nhsManagers.net 

25th May 2012 

Live Health News  |  Weather  |  Archive

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

 
Where's public health? 

News and Comment from Roy Lilley
-------------------------------------------------------------
Just down the road from here is the scene of murders, deceit, corruption, vice, blasphemy, theft and deception.  Stabbings and wounds, a hell hole.  But, very elegant; built in 1869, the Viennese State Opera House.  If you ever get a whiff of a ticket, snatch it and go.  Stunning experience.  
 

I am in Vienna for wounds, suffering and it turns out;  incompetence and dissembling.  The kind of wounds old ladies (and gentlemen) get on their legs and seem beyond the wit of healthcare to clear up.  I heard tale of a (soon to come) study for the DH that followed 500 patients for 6 months.  The clear-up rate was 9% and the infection rate 60%.  Tell me that is great practice.

 

I listened to an erudite speaker reflect on 25yrs of wound care experience.   A teenager kicked by a horse who carried the wound for 67 years.  Another who spent 4yrs in bed with and ulcerated leg.  How, before the 90's ulcers were given a low priority and their aetiology hardly understood at all.  Patients were advised to urinate on their legs as a form of treatment.  1992, Doppler and duplex testing and compression bandages.

 

 Given the misery this condition wreaks it is a pitiful history.  A history of neglect, desertion and inattention.  We have NICE guidelines, Scottish guidelines, European guidelines and for all the good they do, probably intergalactic guidelines.  It is a shambles.  Why, in some places these wretched things, at 12 weeks are 20% healed and in others the figure is 95% defies intelligent explanation.  Why is it 20% of sufferers can't walk?  Why it is the casualties are left to social isolation, pain, depression, sleep deprivation and emotional torment?

 

And then there is the money.  The cost is huge.  In fact, beyond huge it is enormous, gigantic, mammoth.  In plain every day terms; half the community nursing budget and often over half their time.  Not just in the NHS; world-wide.  There are billions thrown at this horrible chronic problem.  Probably more than £400 million a year in the UK alone.  Speaker after speaker from every part of the world told the conference the same sorry tale.  In the end I wa annealed to the cost, deaf to the suffering and blind  to the pictures of the most awful, ugly, horrendous, harrowing, pitiful wounds. 

 

This is a fat industry.  The conference was made possible by a huge exhibition of lavish stands; chrome, graphics, samples, goody-bags and flat-screen tellies.  Companies are obese with the profits from products that don't work, scrambling for space in a lookey-likey, me-too market of the ineffective. 

  

The solution, it seems, is simple; compression dressings.  The problem; they are horribly uncomfortable for the victim, making compliance poor and the variations in nursing competence make their use and application, with the required gradient of pressure, a lottery.

 

 This is a mess of an industry and an embarrassment to health services world-wide.  Millions are spent on poorly arranged trials with tiny sample sizes and handpicked patients.  Careers have been built on failing therapies, houses paid for and kids put through school on the proceeds of ineffectiveness.  There is a poor understanding about when healing occurs and health economics seems to ignore the cost of the whole care pathway.  Support for the patient; rising services, meals on wheels, bathing, chiropody, shopping and cleaning.

  

 There has to be a solution to this disarray.  Get this right and in one go you could probably solve the NHS savings conundrum and settle the nation debts of some decent sized countries.  It's simple; stop people getting the shameful things in the first place.  Regard their appearance as a failure.  I am told there is a shed-load of indicators, predictors and heads-up on the patients most likely to be at risk of venous leg ulcers. 

 

 Give them all three sets of support stockings; one set on, one set in the wash and one set ready in the drawer.  Encourage compliance, send a HCA to help put them on if necessary and save enough money to buy Greece and Chelsea a replacement for Drogba.

 

 If we can put all middle aged blokes on a statin, fluoride in the water and screen for breast cancer - we can do this.  Where's public health when you need it?

----------------------------------------------------------------

Feel like having a rant?

Please, use this e-mail address

 

roy.lilley@nhsmanagers.net 

Know something we don't - email me in confidence.

Leaving the NHS, changing jobs - you don't have to say goodbye to us! 
You can change your email details here and we'll keep mailing.

Medicine for Managers
MaM Logo
Dr Paul Lambden
Why do I need a Spleen?
New series from our most popular columnist.
We'll make a doctor of you yet!
-------------------
News and Stuff
News boy
-----------------
--------------
secret 
Gossip
This is what I'm hearing.  
Unless you know better.
  Tell me
>>  I'm hearing some specialist services contracted for by PCTs are not backed with proper paperwork or contracts and are being sidelined by CCGs refusing to take them on.  I'd dismiss it as a local difficulty but it is popping up all over.
>>  CLCH Trust were fined £90k for data foul-ups.  They are to appeal on a 'matter of law'.  Well, they either did it or they didn't.  Why waste money on lawyers? More here.  
>>  Row at Derriford - ex-copper appointed as chair and the other directors are not happy! Here's an outline of the story that's been making the wires buzz.
>>  Tim Kelsey, co-founder of Dr Foster will be appointed head-honcho patient information and palaver.  Good luck.  If he does it right he could change the NHS single handed.
>>  Lot's of chat about acutes running into deficit.  HSJ exclusive here back it up.
-------------------
-----------
MAC logo
Public Involvement People
----------------