Pass Crimson Saguaro on to your friends, family and neighbors! | |
Immigration and the Rule of Law
Without laws, we are not a country.
| | |
Greetings!,
There is a debate raging in this country about reversing the massive influx of illegal aliens into the United States during the Biden Administration.
President Joe Biden (or whoever was in charge) did not enforce our immigration laws letting more than 6.7 million illegal aliens into our country from 2021 to 2025.
Some say many more.
| | | |
Basically, federal immigration Rule of Law under the Biden Administration was non-existent. People from all over the world were invited here and allowed into the country with no vetting, while immigrants seeking to come here legally, waited.
And who wouldn’t come here? We enjoy the greatest country on earth.
Yet, the liberal left erased the border and put America on sale for free.
| | |
The Cost of Illegal Immigration
According to the Heritage Foundation, the number of illegal aliens is now in the US is approximately 17M people at a net cost to taxpayers (taxes paid minus benefits received) of $110B per year.
The liberal media likes to tell us that illegal aliens pay taxes and therefore are a benefit to our country. But not surprisingly, they do not give you the full picture.
| |
| While the media says illegal aliens are not eligible for many welfare and Social Security benefits, the Biden Administration and local governments have implemented many cash giveaways. | | |
The Schumer Shutdown
If illegal aliens are not getting benefits (as the left claims), then why have Democrats shutdown the government to reestablish benefits to illegal aliens totaling ~$200 billion dollars?
The House Ways and Means Committee just put out a report that explains the shutdown is a play to reverse the 2025 “Big Beautiful Bill” provisions that eliminated social benefits for illegals.
So, it has been happening.
The left is willing to shut down government to fund illegals over hard working Americans.
| | | |
The media will not tell you 60 votes are needed to break a filibuster in the US Senate. As of October 28th, there have been 13 failed votes to break the filibuster.
So, let's do the math.
There are 54 Republican votes which is not enough votes to break the 60 vote filibuster. So, it is Senator Chuck Schumer that has the government shut down only to get social benefits for illegal aliens.
It is not because of Donald Trump as the media would have you believe.
So, why not give everyone amnesty as the Biden Administration proposed? Problem solved, right? WRONG. Granting amnesty to all illegal aliens would commit all of us to long-term entitlement liability exceeding $5 trillion dollars.
We cannot go on like this.
| | |
"Lawfully Present Immigrants"
It is interesting to review the new eligibility for “lawfully present immigrants” under the Under the "Big Beautiful Bill" passed in July 2025.
Table 1 below shows you “eligibility” under Biden (tan colored areas) had a wide coverage zone that effectively gave Medicaid, CHIP (Children's Health Insurance Program), ACA Eligibility, and Medicare to approximately 1.4M immigrants (probably many more).
But, what does “Lawfully Present Immigrants” mean?
Read the tan section under “Groups Losing Eligibility”.
| | |
Refugees…asylees…immigrants waiting for deportation…survivors of violence.
All the tan colored eligibility categories are subjective criteria broadly defined to include millions of illegal aliens. These criteria are not objective rules that define those who get help and those who do not.
Now, look at the light blue section ("Groups Maintaining Eligibility"). These are precise and well defined criteria.
The definitions of words matter, and “Lawfully Present Immigrant” was being twisted to convey American social safety net benefits to as many illegal aliens as possible. The new tax law more objectively defines who should get help.
| | |
1.4M immigrants are not losing coverage....
1.4M illegal aliens are being properlyclassified as ineligible for American social benefits.
| | | |
The definitions of words matter.
It is clear this situation is not sustainable. By bringing in millions of illegals to radically alter our country and great American culture, the progressive left has tried hard to destroy us from within.
The Trump Administration knows this and is doing everything possible to reverse this great crime brought upon us under the Biden Administration before it is too late to act.
| | |
Words Shape the Debate
The progressive left insists they engage in “civil debate” yet too often its media allies approach opposing views with rhetorical ambushes using reactions to incorrect use of redefined words to throw you off balance.
That’s not good faith debate. That’s control through confusion.
| | |
A good example how the liberal media deceives is done by repeatedly referring to the United States as a “democracy”.
America is not a democracy. America is a republic.
CS has written extensively explaining why the United States is a constitutional republic — where Freedom, Liberty, the Rule of Law, and individual rights guard against the tyranny of majority mob rule. The progressive left deliberately manipulates this language to erode public understanding.
| |
| |
When people finally forget we are a constitutional republic, they stop defending what makes it possible: accountability, integrity, restraint, and the Rule of Law.
One of the left’s favorite linguistic tricks is use of the phrase “undocumented immigrant”.
It sounds humane, but this isn’t an honest characterization of the issue.
| | |
"Illegal Alien", not "Undocumented Immigrant"
In U.S. federal law (see 18 U.S. Code § 611 or 8 U.S. Code § 1325), the correct legal term for anyone who is not a citizen or national of the United States is defined as an "alien".
Those who enter the US legally are "documented". Those who don’t are "illegal aliens".
| | |
The term “undocumented immigrant” appears nowhere in federal law.
It’s a rhetorical invention of the left, used to blur the line between a legal and illegal presence and evoke an emotional response to the immigration issue.
This distortion is used to distract us from the isssue at hand.
Words define reality - and when words lose their meaning, so does truth.
| | | |
Word deceptions like this are used to confuse the immigration issue. To solve the immigration problem, we must address the debate truthfully calling it what it really is.
"Illegal aliens" is the immigration issue our country must deal with.
| | |
Liberals Suddenly Love the Rule of Law
Now that DHS is actively deporting illegals, the Rule of Law suddenly matters to the left.
Never mind they all looked the other way while the Biden Administration ignored US immigration law letting in millions of unvetted illegals.
If we have no Rule of Law, we have no country.
But, now their rhetoric has changed. They scream, “Due process! Due process! Where is the due process for these deportees?!”
| | |
Who could forget the love affair liberals had with MS-13 gang member, Kilmar Abrego Garcia?
He trafficked children but portrayed himself as a family man while being a hardcore MS-13 criminal in the US illegally.
The facts prove it was right to deport him without delay.
| | | |
There should be no debate on this one. But the left argued he deserved constitutional due process protections.
Under the US Constitution, he is indeed afforded due process. But what does that mean? Is it a full courtroom criminal proceeding with a jury and appeals as would be afforded a US citizen or a process appropriate for the situation?
As a practical matter, if every deportation were to be adjudicated as a criminal proceeding through a US court complete with appeals and procedures, it would take decades to resolve millions of illegal immigration cases. The left knows this and is using a dishonest interpretation of “Due Process” to delay the game until Trump is gone.
Fortunately, some very smart people have weighed in.
The Supreme Court has ruled the president’s constitutional executive powers must be maintained and has effectively reaffirmed constitutional Due Process shall be appropriate for the situation.
| | |
Due Process
As with other debates outlined above, the definitions of words matter.
The 5th Amendment to US Constitution says,
“… No person shall be… deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law…”
| | | |
The left likes to define “due process” as meaning endless criminal court proceedings and appeals - no doubt with the goal of slowing deportations to “never”.
However, the Supreme Court has established that “due process” refers to a fair and just process of adjudicating a person’s right to “life, liberty, or property”.
If you are here illegally, is it not a fair and just due process to simply enforce the law?
Indeed, we are a nation of legal immigrants. You are welcome to come to our country through the legal immigration process. However, an illegal alien is not a citizen of the United States in the eyes of US law.
Likewise, the Supreme Court has said simple administrative enforcement of the law in these cases is an appropriate application of constitutional due process. Since immigration cases are civil issues, administrative application of due process has been deemed a reasonable adjudication of Due Process under the US Constitution.
Sorry lefties, you won’t get the endless courtroom traffic jam you had hoped for.
| | |
This is a complex area of law that Hans von Spakovsky of the Heritage Foundation explains well.
To make a long story short, illegal aliens are processed in an Administrative Due Process under direction of the DOJ.
This process is defined in federal law using civil law rules for adjudication which involves an administrative court judge, but not jury trials and endless appeals.
| | | |
As mentioned above, and the Supreme Court has affirmed this process qualifies as appropriate due process under the US Constitution for these cases.
The bottom line is federal law provides for fairly and legally exiting illegal aliens from the United States.
All other presidents (not Biden) have followed this process, except this time, Donald Trump is doing it.
Once again, the Trump Administration is simply enforcing existing law on behalf of all US citizens.
The Rule of Law matters. Yet, the leftists have tried to use lawfare to stop deportations at every turn.
| | |
Lawfare - The Left's Weapon of Choice
Since legal immigration is no longer an allowed thought in liberal politics, they want to stop deportation of the “America Last” voting block they have been cultivating.
When the left doesn’t get their way, they resort to lawfare and worse.
Presently, they are trying to create mayhem by keeping government closed to secure social benefits for illegal aliens.
| |
| |
It won’t work as the government shutdown is exposing many illegal aliens and able-bodied Americans who are living off the US taxpayer.
Yes, there will be some individuals who are adversely affected by the shutdown. This will be reconciled once we get back to normal business.
In the meantime, this event is a much-needed house cleaning. It also shows us that the fear tactics used to coerce voting for massive overspending to "keep government open" was hyperbole to manipulate us.
Please consider calling Senator Chuck Schumer to encouraging him to “hold the line”. (sarcasm intended)
| | |
Federal Injunctions
Another way they have implemented lawfare is to get an obscure federal district court judge to declare a nationwide injunction to stop the Trump Administration.
There have been two main Supreme Court rulings in 2025 that show “due process” for this issue is interpreted as a simple enforcement of the law. These cases refer to Trump’s use of the 1798 Alien Enemies Act (AEA) to deport illegals.
| | |
As you can see, the Supreme Court recognizes the constitutional protections under the US Constitution must be preserved with practical limits that are properly administered under federal law. The Court has affirmed the president must be allowed to protect our country without unjustifiable restrictions.
Winning these cases has been very important for our country.
| | |
Birthright Citizenship
As CS published in January, birthright citizenship is a provision of the 14th Amendment that is being used to justify the children of illegal aliens will remain here as US citizens.
Is this fair and just? An illegal alien has a child and then is connected to the child as the parental reason to remain in the country.
How is this reasonable?
| |
| |
The 14th Amendment was intended to reconcile the practical issue that the children of slaves brought to the United States did not have a legal home. To fully reconcile the issue of slavery, the country ratified the 14th Amendment.
This was right to do.
However, birthright citizenship was never intended by the 14th’s authors to be used as a weapon by a political faction to forever change our country.
This aspect of the Constitution is an Achilles’ heel that will change our country forever having profound impact on public entitlements and voter demographics.
The left is banking on a slow deportation process while “anchor babies” are born further complicating reconciliation of the damage the left has done to our country.
The urgency to deport is clear.
Birthright citizenship is a gap in our constitution that must be resolved to reestablish orderly immigration for our country. Unless it is adjusted by the Supreme Court or by a new constitutional amendment, our country will be changed forever.
| | |
We Must Solve this Problem
No doubt illegal immigration is a very difficult and emotional issue to untangle on a human level.
There will be pain and disruption, but the Rule of Law must be preserved else we will not have a country.
Hard, painful choices must be made to resecure our future.
| |
| |
Families, private property loss, children and general life disruptions are all emotional arguments to stop the deportation process. The left knows this and manipulates your emotions and feelings using word deceptions to disrupt the process of restoring orderly, fair and just immigration.
Do not let them sway you from what is truly important for our country.
We are a nation of laws. Without laws, we are not a country.
If we enforce the Rule of Law, the solution is simple. Come here legally, you are welcome to stay and contribute to our Exceptional Country. Come here illegally, you must go back home and return legally.
If we do not solve this problem, the problem will solve itself by eliminating America.
This is why America must be first.
| | Sign up for Crimson Saguaro | | Simply click the button below and copy the page link. Send it to your friends and family asking them to sign up for the 2026 Golden Ticket mailing list. (Once you are on the list, there is no need to sign up again.) | | Sign up information will NEVER be shared or used for anything but this email program. (We hate when the political organizations do this to us.) | | | |
|
We are turning back to America First!
Thank you,
Brad Newman, Charmaine Roth, James Roth, Terry Babb, Jamie Alford and Bob Hathorne
CactusMan@CrimsonSaguaro.org
| | | | |