|
I have become more and more disturbed as I read and learn about Christian Nationalism. My interest in learning more has not risen from sheer curiosity, but has grown out of deep pastoral concern both for adherents to this ideology and for those who it harms - ALL of whom God has created and loves. I believe Christian Nationalism is a serious threat to both American Democracy and the witness of the Church.
So over the next couple of weeks, I am going to share some comments on the topic broken into two parts. This week I am going to focus on the Founders of our nation, the wisdom of the separation of church and state, and the notion of being a “Christian nation.” Next week, I will then shift to a more full explanation of why Christian Nationalism is antithetical to the ways of Jesus and idolatrous in its pursuit of power.
The Founding Myth
Today people who espouse the ideology of Christian Nationalism often claim that its origin comes directly from the Founders. But as IU Indianapolis Sociology Professor, Dr. Andrew Whitehead, noted in a recent lecture at North UMC in Indianapolis, “Whatever the faith of the Founders was, it was not the same as that of Conservative, Evangelical Christians in America today.” Sadly, some religious and political leaders use the limited historical knowledge held by many Americans to exploit myths about the role of faith in our nation’s founding documents.
In an excellent documentary entitled, “God and Country” (streaming on Peacock & Amazon Prime Video), Constitutional attorney and author of The Founding Myth, Andrew Seidel, notes: “‘When the Pilgrims and the Puritans came over to this land they established their tiny little theocracies, and suffocated everybody’s religious freedom. They imposed theocratic law based on very particular religious views, and were essentially failed societies. So when the Founders got together and were looking at how we were going to create the U.S. Constitution, they looked back at that and said, ‘We don’t want any part of that.’ That is the wrong way to do things.”
When the Founders gathered in Philadelphia for the Constitutional Convention between May and September of 1787, we know that they did not invoke the Bible, turn to religious principles, or seriously discuss being a theocracy. We know this because James Madison’s notes detail very clearly the events of the convention. Andrew Seidel again points out, “It (the U.S. Constitution) is very, very clear. It was secular by design, by choice. It begins, ‘We the People….’ Our Constitution was the first to do that. The first to draw power from the people and not a deity. No other country had done that before. It was the first in the history of the world to ban religious tests for public office. And it did so in language that was very clear and emphatic.” It says in Article VI, Clause 3, of the U.S. Constitution, “No religious tests shall ever be required of any office or public trust under the United States.”
But the Founders wanted to go even further to be crystal clear that we were a nation built on liberty, not tyranny, religious or otherwise. So during the First United States Congress (between 1789-1791) additional protections were added as part of the First Amendment which was ratified on December 15, 1791. There, what is known as the Establishment Clause states, “Congress shall make no law respecting the establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise therof.” This separation of church and state protected true religious liberty, and helped maintain the secular nature of our government. Dr. Brian Kaylor, coauthor of a recent book entitled, Baptizing America: How Mainline Protestants Helped Build Christian Nationalism, shared a helpful and hopeful statement at the end of a recent webinar I attended. He said, “The Separation of Church and State is the antidote to Christian Nationalism,” and it must be continually lifted up to those political and religious leaders who would have us believe no separation should exist.
“A Christian Nation” - The Danger of Imprecise Language
The first General Social Survey (GSS)*, a large, nationally representative survey on the religious affiliations present in the U.S. population was released in 1972. In that survey 90% of those surveyed identified themselves as Christian. About 5% identified as from other religions, and about 5% had no religious affiliation (which are now often commonly referred to as “the Nones”).
So in 1972, we could safely say that the vast majority of Americans identified as Christians, and while that number has dropped to 63% in the most recent GSS, Christians are still the majority religion in the U.S. today. However, here is where the danger of imprecise language becomes evident. Saying that the majority of people who call the United States home identify as Christians is different from saying we are a “Christian nation.” We are not, and have never been a theocracy, but rather a democracy where people of all religions or no religion at all have the right to their particular beliefs or non-beliefs and are welcomed into full participation in civic life. And as we already saw this was by design from the beginning of our nation. So while those who believe in Christian Nationalism want to continuously claim we were established as a Christian nation, this is simply untrue. It is critically important to clearly differentiate between being a nation where the majority of Americans religiously identify as Christian, and being a so-called “Christian nation” used in an attempt to justify privileging one religion over all others.
(*CLICK HERE for a link to Pew Research Report on GSS data)
Christian Nationalism is a Threat to Democracy
Adherents to Christian Nationalism today do not believe in a multicultural, liberal democracy where people are free to make their own decisions about their bodies, their beliefs, who they love, or what they read. Rather, they believe only in imposing their values on everyone else, and if you do not agree, you are now an enemy to be targeted and even violently opposed. Historian and author of White Evangelical Racism, Anthea Butler, asks: “What happens to atheists in this society? What happens to secular people? What happens to the people who don’t believe this stuff?”
Ultimately, Dr. Whitehead notes, “The fruit of Christian Nationalism is not love, but power, fear, and violence.” This ideology is contrary to the way of Christ in the world, and it is not the way forward toward a more compassionate and just society. We, therefore, for the common good of us all, must continue to boldly challenge Christian Nationalism, expose its lies about our nation’s founding principles, and unmask the desire for raw power that motivates this unholy movement.
Love Ridiculously, Pastor Aaron
|