Item 12.2
Amended Eminent Domain Resolution for Muller Parkway Completion
The Board discussed Resolution 2025R-043-A, a resolution addressing eminent domain proceedings to acquire from Park Ranch Holdings certain real property or interests in real property along the Muller Parkway right-of-way, including approximately 3.54 acres of real property to increase the size of the right-of-way, and approximately 6.77 acres of non-exclusive drainage easements across properties adversely impacted from increased base flood elevations. This is an amendment to Resolution 2025R-043, which the Board passed on April 17, 2025, updating and clarifying the real property descriptions subject to eminent domain.
County Manager Jenifer Davidson provided an overview of the amended resolution, outlining the background, purpose, and key changes proposed for Board consideration, "Earlier this year in April, the Board authorized the use of eminent domain for a legitimate public purpose, the Muller Parkway Project. Today, we are asking you to amend that prior action...
The right to private property is a fundamental aspect of individual liberty and autonomy. Therefore, the government may not take private property without a legitimate public purpose and just compensation.
Under a 2019 agreement with Park Ranch Holdings, the County is responsible for building two lanes of Muller Parkway... To complete the project as planned, the County needed additional land which was described by staff to the Board in April and we are now asking you to amend today.
The total amount of land that is the subject of the discussion today consists of small portions of land along the road alignment for irrigation, drainage, road design elements, including an elevated road surface and a roundabout, and future construction road maintenance, totaling 3.54 acres...
The County would purchase a non-exclusive drainage easement covering 6.77 acres through this process. The total estimated cost to acquire the property and the associated easements is approximately $635,000 as determined by the appraiser."
Commissioner Tarkanian sought clarification on the legal basis for the County’s definition of adverse impact, asking, "It's a County code that one foot additional water is adverse to the landowner. Is that a state code Is there a federal code? I mean, how do we, how did the County come up with that? And is it a commonly used measure? And then does the County think then that if it's less than that under its code, it's not adversely affecting the land?"
County Engineer Jeremy Hutchings offered technical clarification in response, explaining, "County code defines adverse impact. That's where we're finding that definition. The Federal Code requires FEMA studies when you have 12 inches of impact or more. The County code requires FEMA studies at 6 inches, so we're a little more restrictive on the study requirement. But our code for adverse impact is defined as 12 inches or more."
Following presentations by the County and representatives of Park Ranch Holdings, LLC, and public comment, Commissioner Rice reinforced the action being considered by the Board, saying, “I think there’s a misconception … as to whether or not we’re voting to approve eminent domain. That was done at the last meeting.”
Vice Chairman Gardner further expanded, adding “When this issue went before the judge, he indicated he needed better descriptions of the land…we also felt that our appraisal might need adjustment…(previously approved eminent domain) pieces were not contiguous. There were a few feet here, a few feet there…So in this process, we have corrected that and we feel it is better to just buy those pieces…I agree that this is the only fair thing to do, is to increase our compensation for those inconveniences.”
Chairwoman Hales provided a detailed policy perspective and closing remarks on the item, stating, "Regardless of whether we may or may not agree whether the development agreement should have been entered into, it is now our responsibility to implement it in the best interests of Douglas County residents consistent with the law and with our rights under the agreement.
We have tried very hard to find an alternative to eminent domain. I would love nothing more than to come to peaceful resolution and move forward amicably. Douglas County residents have long insisted to the full extent possible that development pay for itself. Through the terms of this development agreement, we're building a road that provides access to Mr. Park's $100 million property. In other developments, the County has required that the developer build the road to the development.
Regarding this development agreement, I must give the residents the benefit of their bargain and that requires me voting for this eminent domain."
Commissioner Tolbert concluded the discussion by emphasizing fairness, dialogue, and community responsibility, adding, "I want to put it on the record that I've engaged in direct conversations with both Mr. Park and Mr. Anderson with the goal of understanding their perspectives and opening a dialogue between the parties. I've made every effort to encourage communication, compromise, and clarity. So I'll wrap this up. At this point our responsibility is to navigate a complicated situation with honesty, fairness, and a commitment to the greatest good for the greatest number of people.
After much discussion and deliberation, the Board voted unanimously to adopt Resolution 2025R-043-A.
|