|
Quotes of the Day:
"The lesson which life repeats and constantly enforces is 'look under foot.' You are always nearer the divine and the true sources of your power than you think. The lure of the distant and the difficult is deceptive. The great opportunity is where you are. Do not despise your own place and hour. Every place is under the stars, every place is the center of the world."
- John Burroughs
"Be daring, be different, be impractical; be anything that will assert integrity of purpose and imaginative vision against the play-it-safers, the creatures of the commonplace, the slaves of the ordinary. Routines have their purposes, but the merely routine is the hidden enemy of high art."
- Cecil Beaton
"Man acts as though he were the shaper and master of language, while in fact language remains the master of man."
- Martin Heidegger
1. RUSSIAN OFFENSIVE CAMPAIGN ASSESSMENT, OCTOBER 8 (Putin's War)
2. Ukraine: CDS Daily brief (08.10.22) CDS comments on key events
3. Elon Musk: ‘Aren’t you entertained?’
4. China Hails Elon Musk’s Proposal for Taiwan Unification
5. In Dealing With Putin Threat, Biden Turns to Lessons of Cuban Missile Crisis
6. Ukraine: Russian strikes kill 17 following bridge attack
7. Seven questions with the US Army’s counter-drone boss
8. A Tactical Russian Nuke Wouldn’t Confer Much Battlefield Advantage, Experts Say
9. ‘They Are in a Panic’: Ukraine’s Troops Size Up the Enemy
10. Opinion | What the West is still getting wrong about the rise of Xi Jinping
11. Ukraine claims Russian infighting was behind Crimea bridge blast
12. Taiwan signals its chip firms will follow new U.S. rules on China
13. U.S. Military Teaches Living Off the Land to Feed Future Warriors
14. Russian Divers To Examine Crimea Bridge - The Moscow Times
15. How social media ‘censorship’ became a front line in the culture war
16. The Kerch bridge attack is devastating for Putin
17. How likely is Putin to nuke Ukraine?
18. What Afghans Want the Rest of the World to Know
19. Here’s your first clear look at the next-generation ‘AbramsX’ main battle tank
20. That time the military faked a vampire massacre to fight rebels
1. RUSSIAN OFFENSIVE CAMPAIGN ASSESSMENT, OCTOBER 8 (Putin's War)
Maps/graphics: https://www.understandingwar.org/backgrounder/russian-offensive-campaign-assessment-october-8
Key Takeaways
- A large-scale explosion seriously damaged the Kerch Strait Bridge that links occupied Crimea with Russia.
- The Kremlin named the Russian Commander of the Aerospace Forces, Army General Sergey Surovikin, the new commander of the Russian operation in Ukraine, and this appointment has generated positive feedback within the nationalist community.
- Russian sources claimed that Ukrainian forces continued counteroffensive operations in Kharkiv and Luhansk Oblasts.
- Russian forces continued establishing defensive positions in northern Kherson Oblast.
- Russian forces continued to attack settlements around Bakhmut, Avdiivka, and west of Donetsk City.
- Ukrainian forces reportedly continued to shoot down Iranian-made Shahed-136 drones.
- Russian federal subjects are facing financial challenges in funding mobilization.
- Russian and occupation administration officials continued measures to remove Ukrainian children from their homes in Russian-occupied territories.
RUSSIAN OFFENSIVE CAMPAIGN ASSESSMENT, OCTOBER 8
understandingwar.org
Kateryna Stepanenko, Riley Bailey, Angela Howard, Grace Mappes, and Frederick W. Kagan
October 8, 10:30 pm ET
Click here to see ISW’s interactive map of the Russian invasion of Ukraine. This map is updated daily alongside the static maps present in this report.
A large-scale explosion damaged the Kerch Strait Bridge that links occupied Crimea with Russia on October 8. Maxar satellite imagery shows that the explosion collapsed one lane of the road bridge and damaged the nearby railway track.[1] The Russian Investigative Committee stated that a truck exploded on the bridge and ignited seven fuel tanks on the railroad.[2] A small fraction of Russian milbloggers speculated that Ukrainian saboteurs used a boat to detonate the bridge from the sea, though there is no visible evidence for such a conclusion.[3] The Kremlin refrained from accusing Ukraine of sabotage or attack, echoing similar restraint following the sinking of the cruiser Moskva and the Ukrainian strike on Saky airfield in Crimea.[4] Ukraine did not claim responsibility for the incident, but The New York Times reported that an unnamed senior Ukrainian official stated that Ukrainian intelligence participated in the explosion.[5] Kremlin Spokesperson Dmitry Peskov noted that the Russian President Vladimir Putin ordered a government commission composed of government officials, security services, and the Ministry of Emergency Situations to investigate the ”emergency.”[6]
The explosion will not permanently disrupt critical Russian ground lines of communication (GLOCs) to Crimea, but its aftermath is likely to increase friction in Russian logistics for some time. The road bridge appears at least partially operational, and the railroad bridge did not suffer significant structural damage according to Russian reports that generally seem plausible based on the available video evidence. Russian footage shows people walking on the damaged road bridge and a train moving on the railroad bridge.[7] The Head of occupied Crimea Sergey Aksyonov claimed that the remaining lane of the road bridge opened to cars and buses after a rigorous security check, but that trucks must move by ferry.[8] The collapsed lane of the road bridge will restrict Russian military movements until it is repaired, forcing some Russian forces to rely on the ferry connection for some time. Russian forces will likely still be able to transport heavy military equipment via the railroad. Russian officials will likely intensify security checks on all vehicles crossing the bridge, however, adding delays to the movement of Russian military equipment, personnel, and supplies to Crimea. Putin has already signed a decree strengthening the security protocol on the bridge under the supervision of the Russian Federal Security Service (FSB).[9]
The Kremlin is likely continuing to frame the Russian Ministry of Defense (MoD) as the scapegoat for the Kerch Bridge explosion and other Russian military failures to deflect the blame from Putin. The Russian MoD has not issued an official statement regarding the incident as of this publication.[10] Russian opposition outlet Meduza reported that the Russian Presidential Administration sent out a guide to Russian mass media on the appropriate way to downplay the severity of the damage to the bridge, and it is possible that the Kremlin has ordered the Russian MoD to remain quiet regarding the situation.[11] Russian propagandist Vladimir Solovyov stated that Russia must initiate a strike campaign on critical Ukrainian infrastructure instead of listening to Russian MoD promises.[12]
Some nationalist voices noted that Putin and his close circle are failing to immediately address the attack on a symbolic bridge, voicing direct criticism of Putin for the first time. A milblogger warned that if Putin fails to undertake retaliatory actions it “will be mistaken for the weakness of the president himself.”[13] Another milblogger noted that it is hypocritical for the Kremlin to call on Russians to rally behind Putin if he is unable to comment on significant events such as the Moskva sinking, prisoner exchanges including Azovstal fighters, or the collapse of the Kharkiv frontline.[14] Others criticized the silence of Russian Deputy Chairman of the Security Council Dmitry Medvedev regarding the explosion, given that Medvedev had made several statements defining any attacks on the Kerch Bridge as a violation of Russian ”red lines.”[15] Russian milbloggers and propagandists alike called on the Kremlin to resume strikes on Ukrainian infrastructure and notably did not make any calls for Russia to use tactical nuclear weapons against Ukraine.
Ukrainian and Russian sources claimed that the Kremlin targeted some higher military command figures following the Kerch Bridge explosion, but these reports remain unverified as of this publication. The Ukrainian Main Military Intelligence Directorate (GUR) reported that the Kremlin detained, arrested, and blocked unspecified military officials and ordered the units of the elite Dzerzhinsky Separate Operation Purpose Division to enter Moscow on October 8.[16] Milbloggers who favor the Wagner Group claimed that the Kremlin has replaced Russian Defense Minister Sergey Shoigu and Chief of General Staff Army General Valery Gerasimov supposedly with Tula Governor Alexey Dyumin and the deputy commander-in-chief of the ground forces, Lieutenant General Alexander Matovnikov, respectfully.[17] ISW cannot independently verify either of these reports at this time.
The Kremlin named the Russian Commander of the Aerospace Forces, Army General Sergey Surovikin, the new commander of the Russian operation in Ukraine, and this appointment has generated positive feedback within the nationalist community. Sorovikin previously commanded the “southern” group of forces in Ukraine and was reportedly responsible for the capture of Lysychansk in July.[18] Milbloggers shared their excitement regarding Surovikin’s appointment, noting that Surovikin has the “tough” character necessary to regain the initiative in Ukraine.[19] Wagner financier Yevgeniy Prigozhin extravagantly praised Surovikin because he “got into a tank and rushed to save” the Soviet Union during the 1991 coup attempt in Moscow.[20] Prigozhin’s interview further confirmed reports of a fissure between pro-war and “liberal” factions within the Kremlin, which ISW will consider in more detail in subsequent reports.
Key Takeaways
- A large-scale explosion seriously damaged the Kerch Strait Bridge that links occupied Crimea with Russia.
- The Kremlin named the Russian Commander of the Aerospace Forces, Army General Sergey Surovikin, the new commander of the Russian operation in Ukraine, and this appointment has generated positive feedback within the nationalist community.
- Russian sources claimed that Ukrainian forces continued counteroffensive operations in Kharkiv and Luhansk Oblasts.
- Russian forces continued establishing defensive positions in northern Kherson Oblast.
- Russian forces continued to attack settlements around Bakhmut, Avdiivka, and west of Donetsk City.
- Ukrainian forces reportedly continued to shoot down Iranian-made Shahed-136 drones.
- Russian federal subjects are facing financial challenges in funding mobilization.
- Russian and occupation administration officials continued measures to remove Ukrainian children from their homes in Russian-occupied territories.
We do not report in detail on Russian war crimes because those activities are well-covered in Western media and do not directly affect the military operations we are assessing and forecasting. We will continue to evaluate and report on the effects of these criminal activities on the Ukrainian military and population and specifically on combat in Ukrainian urban areas. We utterly condemn these Russian violations of the laws of armed conflict, Geneva Conventions, and humanity even though we do not describe them in these reports.
- Ukrainian Counteroffensives—Southern and Eastern Ukraine
- Russian Main Effort—Eastern Ukraine (comprised of one subordinate and two supporting efforts);
- Russian Subordinate Main Effort—Capture the entirety of Donetsk Oblast
- Russian Supporting Effort—Southern Axis
- Russian Mobilization and Force Generation Efforts
- Activities in Russian-occupied Areas
Ukrainian Counteroffensives (Ukrainian efforts to liberate Russian-occupied territories)
Eastern Ukraine: (Oskil River-Kreminna Line)
Russian sources claimed that Ukrainian forces continued counteroffensive operations from Kharkiv Oblast in the direction of Svatove on October 8. The Russian Ministry of Defense (MoD) claimed that Russian forces repelled Ukrainian assaults southeast of Kupyansk.[21] The Head of the Kharkiv Oblast administration, Oleg Synehubov, reported that Russian forces continued to shell Kupyansk and surrounding settlements.[22] Russian forces continued routine artillery, air, and missile strikes in eastern Ukraine in the vicinity of Kharkiv City, Bohodukhiv, and near Izyum.[23]
Russian sources also claimed that Ukrainian forces continued counteroffensive operations in the Kreminna direction on October 8. The Russian MoD claimed that Russian forces repelled Ukrainian forces attempting to cross the Zherebets River at an unspecified location.[24] The Donetsk People’s Republic (DNR) People’s Militia claimed that Russian forces maintain full control over the Kreminna-Svatove highway, despite previous reports of Ukrainian forces operating in the area.[25] The Russian MoD also claimed that Russian airstrikes hit two Ukrainian concentrations of manpower south of Kreminna near Siversk and west of Kreminna near Yampilivka.[26] The Russian MoD is increasingly including tactical details about Ukrainian forces in its claims, likely in response to Russian milblogger criticism that they do not report enough on Ukrainian advances. ISW makes no attempt to evaluate the veracity of the details the Russian MoD presents about the sizes, echelons, designations, or types of Ukrainian units and will not present those details in our reports.
Ukrainian sources reported that Russian forces are continuing to suffer personnel losses in Luhansk Oblast. The Ukrainian General Staff reported on October 8 that Russian forces transported 300 wounded personnel to a hospital in Luhansk Oblast.[27]
Southern Ukraine: (Kherson Oblast)
Russian forces continued establishing defensive positions in Kherson Oblast on October 8. Ukraine’s Southern Operational Command reported that Russian forces continued to shell areas along the line of contact to prevent Ukrainian advances and began establishing new defensive lines in the Beryslav and Nova Kakhovka Raions.[28] A Russian source claimed that Ukrainian forces are continuing to consolidate along the front line near Davydiv Brid and Mala Oleksandrivka and are equipping strongholds in Bezimenne, all near the Ukrainian bridgehead over the Inhulets River.[29] ISW does not attempt to validate Russian forecasts of possible Ukrainian operations and offers no comment on their plausibility.
Ukrainian and Russian sources reported ongoing battles north and northwest of Kherson City, near the Ukrainian bridgehead over the Inhulets River, and northeast of Beryslav on October 8. The Ukrainian General Staff reported that Ukrainian forces repelled a Russian ground attack near Ternovy Pody, roughly 20km northwest of Kherson City.[30] Ukraine’s Southern Operational Command reported that Russian forces unsuccessfully attempted to advance in the area of Davydiv Brid and Mala Oleksandrivka near the Ukrainian bridgehead over the Inhulets River.[31] The Russian Ministry of Defense (MoD) claimed that Russian forces repelled Ukrainian attempts to advance near Sukhanove, Pyatikhatki, Sadok, Ishchenka, Burskynske, Shchaslyve, and Mala Seidemynykha on the northern Kherson Oblast frontline.[32] A Russian source claimed that Russian forces retook Pravdyne, 33km northwest of Kherson City.[33] A Russian source claimed that Russian forces repelled a Ukrainian ground attack near Dudchany on the western bank of the Dnipro River.[34] The Donetsk People’s Republic (DNR) claimed that Russian forces maintain positions in Snihurivka, Mykolaiv Oblast, approximately 60km east of Mykolaiv City, and reported ongoing fighting on the outskirts of the settlement.[35]
Ukrainian forces continued their interdiction campaign in Kherson Oblast to support their southern counteroffensive on October 8. Ukraine’s Southern Operational Command reported that Ukrainian forces struck three Russian concentrations of manpower and equipment and a logistics point in Beryslav Raion.[36] Ukraine's Southern Operational Command also reported that Ukrainian aviation struck Russian anti-aircraft systems in Beryslav and Kakhovka Raions.[37] Geolocated images show that Ukrainian forces likely hit five fuel storage facilities near Kyselivka, Bilozerskyi Raion.[38] Ukrainian forces reportedly shot down a Russian Orlan-10 drone in Chervone, Beryslav Raion.[39] The Russian MoD claimed that land and maritime logistics routes are continuously provisioning Russian forces operating in the Mykolaiv-Kryvyi Rih and Zaporizhia directions, however.[40]
Russian Main Effort—Eastern Ukraine
Russian Subordinate Main Effort—Donetsk Oblast (Russian objective: Capture the entirety of Donetsk Oblast, the claimed territory of Russia’s proxies in Donbas)
Russian forces continued conducting ground attacks throughout Donetsk Oblast on October 8. The Ukrainian General Staff reported that Ukrainian forces repelled Russian ground attacks on and around Bakhmut near Vyimka, Bilohorivka, Bakhmutske, and Krasna Hora to the north and Mayorsk, Ozeryanivka, Zaitseve, Odradivka, and Andriivka to the south.[41] A Russian milblogger referred to recent Russian-claimed gains south of Bakhmut of Zaitseve and Vesela Dolyna as a “tactical success.”[42] ISW first reported on Russian ground attacks against Zaitseve and Vesela Dolyna on August 5 and July 13 respectively, noting that Russian forces have taken over two months to be able to claim to have secured two small villages.[43] The Ukrainian General Staff also reported that Ukrainian forces repelled Russian ground assaults around Avdiivka near Pervomaiske, Vesele, Kamianka, and Nevelske, and in western Donetsk Oblast near Pobieda, Krasnohorivka, and Novomykhailivka.[44] The Russian Ministry of Defense (MoD) claimed that Russian forces repelled a Ukrainian counterattack at an unspecified location in the “South Donetsk” direction, possibly referring to the Vuhledar, western Donetsk Oblast area, but there is currently no independent confirmation of the Russian MoD’s definition of this operational direction.[45]
Ukrainian forces likely conducted strikes against railway stations in the Russian rear in Donetsk Oblast on October 8. The DNR claimed that Ukrainian forces struck a railway station in Ilovaisk, Donetsk Oblast, damaging three diesel fuel tanks for trains and a technical area of the station.[46] Russian sources claimed that Ukrainian forces struck the Karan railway station in Andriivka, Donetsk Oblast, roughly 51km north of Mariupol.[47] Geolocated footage shows smoke rising from the station area with audible secondary detonations, likely from ammunition.[48]
Supporting Effort—Southern Axis (Russian objective: Maintain frontline positions and secure rear areas against Ukrainian strikes)
Russian forces continued to conduct routine artillery, air, and missile strikes west of Hulyaipole and in Dnipropetrovsk and Mykolaiv Oblasts on October 8.[49] Ukrainian sources reported that Russian forces attacked Zaporizhzhia City, Mykolaiv City, Ochakiv, and areas of Odesa Oblast with Shahed-136 kamikaze drones but stated that Ukrainian forces successfully shot them down.[50] Russian forces continued artillery fire and drone strikes against infrastructure in Nikopol and Marhanets, Dnipropetrovsk Oblast, on the north bank of the Dnipro River.[51] The Ukrainian General Staff reported that Ukrainian forces shelled Russian manpower and equipment concentrations in the areas of Polohy and Tokmak, Zaporizhia Oblast, and that Russian forces suffered at least 85 casualties.[52]
Russian and Ukrainian sources traded accusations of shelling the Zaporizhzhia Nuclear Power Plant (ZNPP) overnight on October 7-8.[53] Russian and Ukrainian officials and the International Atomic Energy Agency stated that the shelling cut off the external energy supply to the ZNPP after engineers had just restored the external power line on October 7.[54] Ukrainian Enerhodar Mayor Dmytro Orlov later stated that engineers restored power to Enerhodar and the surrounding settlements on October 8.[55] Russian Zaporizhia Oblast occupation official Vladimir Rogov stated that Russian atomic energy agency Rosatom has already started the process of integrating the ZNPP into the Russian power grid.[56]
Mobilization and Force Generation Efforts (Russian objective: Expand combat power without conducting general mobilization)
The financial, logistical, and political challenges of supporting the Russian mobilization process continue to fuel societal division within Russia and criticism of the government. The Kremlin and Russian Ministry of Defense (MOD) risk alienating core supporters including those supportive of mobilization by failing to address inconsistencies and inadequacies in the implementation of mobilization.
The large-scale removal of Russian men of working age (either through mobilization or through their flight) has left holes in the positions they formerly filled. A Russian source reported on October 6 that the Russian Ministry of Natural Resources proposed to exempt garbage collectors and garbage truck drivers from mobilization.[57] Forbes reported on October 6 that Russian sports centers again petitioned authorities for an exemption to mobilization for coaches and instructors, as mobilization applies to 70% of men employed in the industry.[58] Mothers caring for children after the mobilization of their husbands will also face greater non-work demands on their time. A Russian source reported on October 6 that the Liberal Democratic Party drafted a bill authorizing the reduction of work hours for mothers with mobilized husbands to 35 hours a week at prior salaries.[59] Russian authorities appear to have recognized and attempted to address labor shortages caused by mobilization. The Ukrainian General Staff reported on October 8 that local authorities in some Russian districts are attempting to implement mobilization plans drawing on unemployed men of conscription age.[60] However, the economic gaps left by the sudden removal of part of the Russian workforce are likely to continue to create complications.
Funding mobilization poses an economic challenge to Russian regions, as ISW has previously reported.[61] Russian regions balance pressure to deliver on promises to the mobilized while remaining within their means. A local Russian source reported on October 6 that Tartarstan Deputy Finance Minister Gela Gerasimova stated that the budget of Tartarstan cannot finance mobilization. Gerasimova claimed mobilization will draw on the federal budget.[62] Omsk Governor Aleksandr Burkov stated on October 7 that he found an unspecified way to pay each mobilized person 100,000 rubles ($1,603) after previously stating the region's budget could not afford such payments.[63] The costs of mobilization are likely to continue well into 2023, and the long-term viability of such solutions is questionable.
Poor behavior demonstrated by conscripts brought to training grounds has disturbed nearby communities. A Russian source reported on October 7 that residents of Mulino raised complaints that the mobilized sent to Mulino training grounds drank heavily and walked around the village. ISW has previously reported similar complaints in this area.[64] Nizhny Novgorod Governor Gleb Nikitin has therefore banned the sale of alcohol during mobilization in Mulino.[65]
Reports from October 6 and 7 show a series of women across Russia recording video messages asking for help in response to their husbands’ illegal mobilization.[66] ISW has previously reported an ongoing pattern of mobilization of Russians with disqualifying health and personal circumstances.[67] Fontanka Saint Petersburg reported on October 6 that a housewife in Krasnogvardeysky District, Saint Petersburg, received a mobilization notice.[68] This report is the first that ISW has identified detailing the mobilization of a woman without mention of a relevant work background.
Mobilized soldiers also continue to face extreme conditions. A Russian news source counted 15 deaths among the mobilized from various regions prior to deployment to Ukraine as of October 7.[69]
Discrepancies in the level of public concern for newly mobilized units as compared to contract soldiers have likely created a rift in Russian society. Ukraine’s Main Military Intelligence Directorate (GUR) published on October 8 a recording of a call between a contract Russian soldier and his mother. The mother complained that mobilized units face preferential treatment over volunteer and contract soldiers who have been fighting for months. The mother argued that Russian contract soldiers purchased their own equipment and faced the same difficulties as newly mobilized soldiers while the Russian public did not care in the same way that they do about the mobilized men. She also noted that contract soldiers faced such difficulties without the 200,000-300,000-ruble ($3,207-4,811) bonus received by the mobilized. The mother directly expressed discontent with the apparent unreachability of Putin on issues related to soldiers’ well-being and questioned whether he “even [knows] where our guys are?”[70] ISW cannot confirm the extent of such dissatisfaction, but the increasing concessions given to mobilized men in response to broad criticism of the mobilization effort could increase such feelings among contract soldiers, volunteer soldiers, and their families.
Deputy Russian Minister of Defense Viktor Goremykin deflected criticism that the Russian Ministry of Defense (MoD) is severely undersupplying soldiers by claiming on October 7 that the Russian Armed Forces “have everything necessary to provide for every servicemember in full.”[71] Widespread reports of Russian mobilized units being forced to purchase their own equipment and clothing, going for days with no food or water, and requesting donations from Russian society contradict Goremykin’s statement.[72] Russian military bloggers publicly mocked Goremykin’s false claim and marveled at the ability of the Russian MoD to continue denying obvious logistical problems. One Russian military blogger claimed that the Russian MoD prioritizes “attempts to create an external gloss” above the lives of soldiers and above the need to win.[73] Another military blogger stated that it is no longer possible to replace reality with beautiful reports.[74] Blatantly false claims decrease general belief in the credibility of the Russian MoD and contribute to the growing narrative of MoD incompetence.
Russian authorities appear to be avoiding prosecution of men avoiding military summonses. Russian lawyer Pavel Chikov posted to Telegram on October 7 that the Penza Prosecutor’s Office canceled the first criminal case for evasion of mobilization under Article 328 of the Russian criminal code after launching the case two days before.[75] Federation Council Committee on Constitutional Legislation and State Building Head Andrey Klishas stated on October 7 that it is unlawful to threaten citizens with criminal liability under Article 328 for refusal to mobilize.[76] Such responses could represent a response to public pressure or challenges in prosecuting all mobilization dodgers. They could also represent the desire to try mobilization dodgers under alternative articles or continue attempts to force dodgers to mobilize rather than sit in prison.
Activity in Russian-occupied Areas (Russian objective: consolidate administrative control of occupied and annexed areas; forcibly integrate Ukrainian civilians into Russian sociocultural, economic, military, and governance systems)
Russian and occupation administration officials continued to increase filtration and law enforcement measures in Russian-occupied territories on October 8. The Ukrainian Resistance Center reported on October 8 that Russian forces continue filtration activities near positions struck by Ukrainian forces to find suspected Ukrainian partisans that they believe to be providing Ukrainian forces with the positions of Russian manpower and equipment concentrations.[77] Russian media reported that Russian forces in Russian-occupied Melitopol have increased street inspections of residents’ documents.[78] The Ukrainian Resistance Center reported that Russian and occupation administration officials launched a Telegram chatbot for reports on the location of Ukrainian partisans in the Russian-occupied territories.[79] The center also reported that Russian Federal Security Service (FSB) personnel increasingly question residents in filtration centers about their participation in the annexation referenda that were held in Russian-occupied territories in late September.[80] Mayor of Melitopol Ivan Fedorov claimed that occupation administration officials are deporting residents with pro-Ukrainian sentiments and transporting them to the Vasylivka border checkpoint, but that Russian forces are still not allowing residents to pass through into Ukrainian-held Zaporizhia Oblast.[81] Russian and occupation administration officials are likely to increase filtration and law enforcement activities as Ukrainian counteroffensives progress.
Russian and occupation administration officials continued measures to remove Ukrainian children from their homes in Russian-occupied territories on October 8. The Head of the Kherson Occupation Administration Vladimir Saldo reported that Russian-occupied Crimea agreed to take over 5,000 children from Kherson Oblast “on vacation” and that 1,500 of those children have already arrived in Crimea.[82] Vladimir Saldo also announced that the governors of Krasnodar Krai and Stavropol Krai stated that their administrations are ready to accept up to 10,000 children from Kherson Oblast. Saldo did not specify a duration for such offers or “vacations.”[83] Vladimir Saldo stated that the children’s parents would be able to join their children in the territories to which they are sent.[84]
Note: ISW does not receive any classified material from any source, uses only publicly available information, and draws extensively on Russian, Ukrainian, and Western reporting and social media as well as commercially available satellite imagery and other geospatial data as the basis for these reports. References to all sources used are provided in the endnotes of each update.
[4] https://www dot interfax.ru/russia/866921; https://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=821458139007933; https://twitter.com/...
[6] https://www dot interfax.ru/russia/866921
[9] https://t.me/boris_rozhin/66452; https://ria dot ru/20221008/putin-1822522699.html; https://t.me/boris_rozhin/66455
[11] https://meduza dot io/news/2022/10/08/ne-razrushen-a-vsego-lish-povrezhden-meduza-uznala-kak-administratsiya-prezidenta-rekomenduet-gosudarstvennymi-smi-pisat-o-vzryve-na-krymskom-mostu
[16] https://gur dot gov.ua/content/v-moskvi-rozpochalys-areshty-viiskovykh.html
[70] https://gur dot gov.ua/content/toho-putyna-ch-ne-znaesh-kak-dela-obstoiat-vse-prekrasno-chto-dazhe-vody-y-khleba-netu.html
[72] https://notes.citeam.org/mobilization-oct-6-7; https://notes.citeam.org... https://gur dot gov.ua/content/toho-putyna-ch-ne-znaesh-kak-dela-obstoiat-vse-prekrasno-chto-dazhe-vody-y-khleba-netu.html
understandingwar.org
2. Ukraine: CDS Daily brief (08.10.22) CDS comments on key events
CDS Daily brief (08.10.22) CDS comments on key events
Humanitarian aspect:
Speaking at the press conference on the occasion of being awarded the Nobel Peace Prize, Oleksandra Matviychuk, head of the Ukrainian "Center for Civil Liberties", emphasized that the Nobel Peace Prize belongs to every Ukrainian and the fact that it was awarded to Russian, Ukrainian and Belarussian human rights defenders together should not be seen as an old Soviet narrative about "brotherly nations". Matviychuk said she was going to use the publicity that comes with the prize for three purposes: 1) to release all Ukrainian military and civilian prisoners,
2) to initiate reform of the international peace and security system that now lies in ruins like Ukrainian Mariupol, and 3) to give a chance for justice to hundreds of thousands of victims of war crimes, create an international tribunal and bring Putin, Lukashenko and other war criminals to justice.
The head of Donetsk Oblast Military Administration, Pavlo Kyrylenko, said that during the past day, the Russian invaders killed 6 civilians in Donetsk Oblast, namely 2 in Zarichne, 2 in Ocheretyne, 1 in Bakhmut, and 1 in Pavlivka. In addition, 9 more civilians killed by the Russians during the occupation were found in the recently liberated communities: 6 in Lyman, 2 in Sviatohirsk, and 1 in Yarova. Another 17 people were injured yesterday. On the morning of October 8, the Russian forces launched a missile attack on Kurakhove. 3 people were injured, and 6 high-rise buildings were damaged, Pavlo Kyrylenko reported.
On the night of October 8, the Russian forces dealt a total of 5 strikes on Kharkiv. A man was injured with shrapnel wounds, Oleg Synehubov, the head of the Kharkiv Oblast Military Administration (OMA), said. The S-300 missiles were launched from Belgorod, Russia. A sports complex and non-residential buildings were damaged, and there were hits in open areas.
During the night, the Russian forces fired almost 80 shells from the Grad MLRS on Dnipropetrovsk Oblast, said the head of the Dnipropetrovsk OMA, Valentyn Reznichenko.
The number of victims of the Russian attack on residential buildings in Zaporizhzhia on October 6 has increased to 17 people, including a child, the press service of the State Emergency Service reported. At about 21:50 on October 8, the Russian occupiers once again hit Zaporizhzhia, the head of the regional military administration Oleksandr Starukh, reported. He called on all the residents to proceed to shelters.
In Sumy Oblast, as of 21:30 on October 8, there were 55 strikes, of which 28 were unguided rockets, Dmytro Zhyvytskyi, head of Sumy Oblast, reports. As a result of an airstrike on one of the villages of the Velikopysarivka community, a man was injured. He was hospitalized.
As of October 7, the Pension Fund of Ukraine has paid out more than 516 million UAH to the residents of Luhansk Oblast, Serhii Gaidai, the head of the Luhansk military administration, said. He noted that this covers 100% of the current need.
Occupied territories
The Russian occupation authorities of Kherson Oblast said they would "gradually invite" women, children, and the elderly from the Kherson Oblast to Crimea, Rostov Region, Krasnodar Territory for a few weeks. The move is reportedly meant for their safety. Krasnodar Krai's governor confirmed that his region is ready to receive up to 10 thousand people. Given the stories of filtration camps, family separations and forced adoption of Ukrainian children in Russia, the intention should be a reason for concern.
Some schools in the occupied parts of Kherson Oblast where, according to the "official" documents of the occupiers, the teaching continues, house Russian military units and equipment. The parents are forced to bring their children to school. Such cases are observed in Hola Prystan, the Center of National Resistance reports.
The Prime Minister of the Russian Federation, Mikhail Mishustin, signed the decree to start a [Russian] federal state unitary enterprise Zaporizhzhia NPP at the Ukrainian nuclear power plant captured by the Russian forces. The decision constitutes an open attempt to steal another Ukraine's state property. The decision was adopted to implement the decree of the President Putin of October 5, 2022. Early Saturday morning, due to shelling by Russian troops, the last power line with the 750kV power system of the ZNPP was damaged and switched off. As a result, Zaporizhzhia NPP was left with no power supply. Diesel generators turned on automatically. They have 10 days worth of diesel fuel available to continue their work.
About 6,000 cars are waiting at the checkpoint in Vasylivka, Zaporizhzhia Oblast, to leave the temporarily Russian-occupied territory for the territory controlled by Ukraine, according to the legally elected mayor of Melitopol, Ivan Fedorov. Vasylivka is the only checkpoint between the Russian-occupied and the free territory of Ukraine. "The enemies mock our people. This morning they let about 100 cars go to the last checkpoint, people were crying with happiness that they could soon be in Zaporizhzhia, but right there, they were turned around and told that Saturday- Sunday is a weekend," Fedorov said.
According to Ivan Fedorov, panic could be observed among the occupiers following the Kerch Strait bridge explosion. A significant movement from the Crimean side to Berdyansk has started because the only remaining route to leave the temporarily occupied territory runs through Melitopol, Berdyansk, Mariupol, and then to the territory of the Russian Federation. "Today, this direction is busy, a large number of cars have left Crimea and are going to the Russian Federation", Fedorov said.
Head of Luhansk OMA, Serhii Haidai, said that Russia pursues coercive policy on the occupied territory in three directions 1) forced mobilization of males; 2) children are forcibly taken somewhere towards Russia, it is not known where; 3) they forcibly take away new and modern equipment from hospitals and schools.
Operational situation
It is the 227th day of the strategic air-ground offensive operation of the Russian Armed Forces against Ukraine (in the official terminology of the Russian Federation – "operation to protect Donbas"). The enemy tries to maintain control over the temporarily captured territories, disrupts the intensive actions of the Ukrainian troops in certain directions, and continues offensive actions in the Bakhmut and Avdiivka directions.
The Russian military shells the positions of the Ukrainian troops along the entire contact line, carries out defense fortification in certain directions, and conducts aerial reconnaissance. The Russian forces continue to violate the norms of international humanitarian law, the laws and customs of war. They strike critical infrastructure. The threat of Russian air and missile strikes persists throughout the entire territory of Ukraine.
Over the past day, the Russian military launched 9 missile strikes and 12 air strikes and carried out more than 80 MLRS attacks.
The Russian forces hit more than 20 Ukrainian towns and villages, including Slavhorod, Bilovody, Vuhledar, Ridkodub, Hulyaipilske, Novoandriivka, Zaporizhzhia and Mykolaiv. Near the state border, the villages of Bleshnya, Hai and Senkivka of Chernihiv Oblast, Starykove of Sumy Oblast, Hlyboke, Udy, Ohirtseve, Strelecha, Kolodyazne, Dvorichne, Neskuchne of Kharkiv Oblast were shelled with Russian mortars and barrel artillery.
Over the past day, the Russian military used seven "Shahed-136" UAVs to attack Ukrainian cities. Three of them were shot down, and four hit targets in the cities of Zaporizhzhia and Mykolaiv.
During the past day, the aviation of the Ukrainian Defense Forces made 30 strikes. Hits on 24 weapons and military equipment concentration areas and 6 Russian anti-aircraft missile systems are confirmed. Ukrainian air defense units shot down two enemy helicopters.
Over the past day, Ukraine's missile forces and artillery hit two enemy command posts, an area of manpower, weapons and military equipment concentration, two areas of artillery firing positions, radar, and an electronic warfare complex.
The morale and psychological state of the personnel of the invasion forces remain low.
The Main Intelligence Directorate of the Ukrainian MOD reported that after Russian Federation announced partial mobilization on September 21, more than 2,000 Russians contacted the Ukrainian hotline "I want to live". A call was intercepted in which a Russian soldier informed his wife that 60 of the 65 mobilized members of his unit had disappeared without a trace on the second day on the front line.
Kharkiv direction
• Zolochiv-Balakleya section: approximate length of combat line - 147 km, number of BTGs of the RF Armed Forces - 10-12, the average width of the combat area of one BTG - 13.3 km;
• Deployed enemy BTGs: 26th, 153rd, and 197th tank regiments, 245th motorized rifle regiment of the 47th tank division, 6th and 239th tank regiments, 228th motorized rifle regiment of the
90th tank division, 1st motorized rifle regiment, 1st tank regiment of the 2nd motorized rifle division, 25th and 138th separate motorized rifle brigades of the 6th Combined Arms Army, 27th separate motorized rifle brigade of the 1st Tank Army, 275th and 280th motorized rifle regiments, 11th tank regiment of the 18th motorized rifle division of the 11 Army Corps, 7th motorized rifle regiment of the 11th Army Corps, 80th separate motorized rifle brigade of the 14th Army Corps, 2nd and 45th separate SOF brigades of the Airborne Forces, 1st Army Corps of so-called DPR, PMCs.
Ukrainian forces repelled the Russian assault on Krasny and continued the counteroffensive on the Kreminna-Svatove highway.
Russian troops repelled the Ukrainian offensive on the villages east and southeast of Kupyansk. Russian reserve units BARS-16 and BARS-13 and units of the 3rd motorized rifle division are getting established in new positions. Up to 1,000 mercenaries of the "Wagner" PMC were redeployed to Lysychansk to prevent a Ukrainian breakthrough in the area after the "fall" of Lyman.
Russian officers left the mobilized servicemen in Kreminna.
Kramatorsk direction
● Balakleya - Siversk section: approximate length of the combat line - 184 km, the number of BTGs of the RF Armed Forces - 17-20, the average width of the combat area of one BTG - 9.6 km;
● 252nd and 752nd motorized rifle regiments of the 3rd motorized rifle division, 1st, 13th, and 12th tank regiments, 423rd motorized rifle regiment of the 4th tank division, 201st military base, 15th, 21st, 30th separate motorized rifle brigades of the 2nd Combined Arms Army, 35th, 55th and 74th separate motorized rifle brigades of the 41st Combined Arms Army, 3rd and 14th separate SOF brigades, 2nd and 4th separate motorized rifle brigades of the 2nd Army Corps, 7th separate motorized rifle brigade of the 1st Army Corps, PMCs.
The Ukrainian Defence Forces' positions in Spirne, Bilohorivka, Verkhnokamyanske, Rozdolivka, Serebryanka, Hryhorivka, Dronivka, Vesele were shelled with enemy artillery of various types.
About three hundred wounded [Russian] prisoners who agreed to fight in Ukraine were sent to the hospital in Novosvitlivka (Luhansk Oblast).
Donetsk direction
● Siversk - Maryinka section: approximate length of the combat line - 235 km, the number of BTGs of the RF Armed Forces - 13-15, the average width of the combat area of one BTG - 17 km;
● Deployed BTGs: 68th and 163rd tank regiments, 102nd and 103rd motorized rifle regiments of the 150 motorized rifle division, 80th tank regiment of the 90th tank division, 35th, 55th, and 74th separate motorized rifle brigades of the 41st Combined Arms Army, 31st separate airborne assault brigade, 61st separate marines brigade of the Joint Strategic Command "Northern Fleet," 336th separate marines brigade, 24th separate SOF brigade, 1st, 3rd, 5th, 15th, and 100th separate motorized rifle brigades, 9th and 11th separate motorized rifle regiment of the 1st Army
Corps of the so-called DPR, 6th motorized rifle regiment of the 2nd Army Corps of the so-called LPR, PMCs.
The Russian military shelled the areas around Yakovlivka, Soledar, Bakhmut, Bakhmutske, Ivanhrad, Opytne, Mayorsk, New York, Vyimka, Rozdolivka, Vesele, Odradivka, Avdiivka, Krasnohorivka, Pervomaiske and Novomykhailivka.
Units of the Ukrainian Defense Forces repelled enemy attacks in the areas around Vyimka, Bakhmutske, Krasna Hora, Bakhmut, Mayorsk, Ozeryanivka, Zaitseve, Odradivka, Andriivka, Pervomaiske, Krasnohorivka, Vesele, Kamianka, Pobyeda, Nevelske, Novomykhailivka.
Russian troops captured Odradivka, Vesela Dolyna and occupied the outskirts of Zaitseve. They are trying to advance on Soledar and Bakhmutske, and made a slight advance to Pervomaiske. Units of the 42nd motorized rifle division of the 58th Army stormed the Ukrainian positions in Maryinka. They are advancing in the direction of Novomykhailivka and Pobeda.
Zaporizhzhia direction
● Maryinka – Vasylivka section: approximate length of the line of combat - 200 km, the number of BTGs of the RF Armed Forces - 17, the average width of the combat area of one BTG - 11.7 km;
● Deployed BTGs: 36th separate motorized rifle brigade of the 29th Combined Arms Army, 38th and 64th separate motorized rifle brigades, 69th separate cover brigade of the 35th Combined Arms Army, 5th separate tank brigade, 37 separate motorized rifle brigade of the 36th Combined Arms Army, 135th, 429th, 503rd and 693rd motorized rifle regiments of the 19th motorized rifle division of the 58th Combined Arms Army, 70th, 71st and 291st motorized rifle regiments of the 42nd motorized rifle division of the 58th Combined Arms Army, 136th separate motorized rifle brigade of the 58 Combined Arms Army, 46th and 49th machine gun artillery regiments of the 18th machine gun artillery division of the 68th Army Corps, 39th separate motorized rifle brigade of the 68th Army Corps, 83th separate airborne assault brigade, 40th and 155th separate marines brigades, 22nd separate SOF brigade, 1st Army Corps of the so-called DPR, and 2nd Army Corps of the so-called LPR, PMCs.
The Russian military did not carry out offensive actions. The Russian fire damaged infrastructure in 16 Ukrainian towns and villages, including Vremivka, Temyrivka, Olhivske, Hulyaipilske, and Zaliznychne.
In the temporarily captured territories of Zaporizhzhia Oblast, Russia is trying to intensify efforts to discredit units of the Ukrainian Armed Forces. Additional special correspondents of the Russian mass media are involved in fake content creation.
Russian units continue to suffer losses. Thus, the enemy lost about 85 people as WIA in the areas around Polohy and Tokmak due to the Ukrainian Defense Forces' shelling of the Russian manpower concentration.
Tavriysk direction
- Vasylivka – Stanislav section: approximate length of the battle line – 296 km, the number of BTGs of the RF Armed Forces - 42, the average width of the combat area of one BTG - 7 km;
- Deployed BTGs: 114th, 143rd, and 394th motorized rifle regiments, 218th tank regiment of the 127th motorized rifle division, 57th and 60th separate motorized rifle brigades of the 5th Combined Arms Army, 37th separate motorized rifle brigade of the 36th Combined Arms Army, 429th motorized rifle regiment of the 19th motorized rifle division, 33rd and 255th motorized rifle regiments of the 20th motorized rifle division, 34th and 205th separate motorized rifle brigades of the 49th Combined Arms Army, 70th, 71st and 291st motorized rifle regiments of the 42nd motorized rifle division, 10th, 16th, 346th separate SOF brigades, 239th air assault regiment of the 76th Air assault division, 217th and 331st parachute airborne regiments of the 98th airborne division, 108 air assault regiment, 171st separate airborne assault battalion of the 7th Air assault division, 11th and 83rd separate airborne assault brigade, 4th military base of the 58 Combined Arms Army, 7 military base 49 Combined Arms Army, 224th, 237th and 126th separate coastal defence brigades, 127th separate ranger brigade, 1st and 3rd Army Corps, PMCs.
Over 27 towns and villages near the contact line were shelled by enemy tanks, mortars, and barrel and rocket artillery.
Units of the Ukrainian Defense Forces repulsed three enemy attacks on Ternovi Pody from the Zeleny Hay area. They attacked Maksymivka and continued to keep Russian logistics facilities and their supply routes under fire control. The Ukrainian forces struck the area where Russian troops were concentrated in Borozenske, killing 10 servicemen and wounding 20. They hit three Russian ammunition depots north of Kherson and southeast of Mykolaiv Oblasts. The Ukrainian forces shot down a Russian Ka-52 helicopter and struck Russian positions in Chornobayivka. Over the past day, one more enemy pontoon crossing was destroyed. Information about the destruction of enemy ammunition depots on October 5 near Kinsky Rozdory has been confirmed.
Ukrainian troops unsuccessfully tried to advance on Russian positions in Pyatykhatki, Sadki, Ishchenka and Bezymenna.
Russian forces constantly shell Ukrainian units in Pravdyne, Soldatske and along the E58 (M14) route. Russian troops strengthen their positions northwest of Kherson by involving the 127th regiment of the so-called DPR in digging trenches in Kyselivka. Russian troops build defensive positions along the Sukhy Stavok - Borozenske - Sukhanov - Mylove line. They urgently redeployed troops from Nova Kakhovka to Beryslav.
Azov-Black Sea Maritime Operational Area:
The forces of the Russian Black Sea Fleet continue to project force on the coast and the continental part of Ukraine and control the northwestern part of the Black Sea. The ultimate goal is to deprive Ukraine of access to the Black Sea and to maintain control over the captured territories.
On October 8, eleven enemy warships and boats were on a mission in the Black Sea, conducting reconnaissance and controlling navigation in the Black Sea waters. There are 24 Kalibr missiles ready for a volley on four carriers: two surface and two underwater (one frigate 1135.6, one
"Buyan-M" missile corvette and two submarines of project 636.3). In general, the current activity of the maritime groups of the Russian Federation is characterized by low intensity. The rocket threat to [the territory of] Ukraine remains high.
The Russian military continues shelling Ukrainian ports and coastal areas. On the night of October 8, the Russian forces attacked Odesa and Mykolayiv with "Shahid 136" and other kamikaze drones. Some of the drones were shot down by air defense.
Today, October 8, a powerful explosion occurred on the Kerch bridge. The explosion went off around 6:00 a.m., and a rail tank car caught fire. The fire lasted for several hours, making it impossible for the Russian side to establish the extent of the destruction for a long time. "At 6:05, the equipment showed a false "busy" signal on the railway tracks on the railway part of the Kerch Strait transport crossing. A rail tank car caught fire in the tail of a freight train. The locomotive with part of the wagons was taken to the Kerch station. "Emergency operation is underway," the Crimean Railway said in a statement. The anti-terrorist committee of the Russian Federation announced its version that a truck was blown up on the Crimean bridge. This caused seven railway fuel tanks to catch fire. Two automobile spans of the roadway of the bridge have partially collapsed. The Crimean occupying authorities accuse the Ukrainian side of sabotage.
Russian special services are currently investigating how a truck with explosives drove onto the Crimean bridge. Inspection and maintenance radio technical complexes ST-6035, which are supposed to detect suspicious cargo, did not go off, and the traffic police inspectors let the truck go.
Later it became apparent that it was impossible to establish a fast ferry crossing due to weather conditions. In Crimea, there was a frantic demand for automobile fuel, and huge queues arose at gas stations. Navigation through the Crimean Strait was closed, and a vast number of ships accumulated on both sides of the strait in the Black and Azov Seas. The damage to the Crimean bridge made it difficult for the occupiers to supply food, fuel, and weapons to their military group in the temporarily occupied peninsula and Kherson Oblast.
"Grain Initiative": 7 ships with 172.6 thousand tons of agricultural products are heading from the ports of Greater Odesa to the countries of Asia and Europe.
The bulk carrier CORNELIA M with 60,000 tons of Ukrainian wheat left for Vietnam from the Pivdenny port. The ships SHAMAN WISDOM, LADY EVA, and ORIS SOFI left the berths of the Odesa port. Bulk carriers LAURUS, ENEIDA and tanker CHEM HERO left from the port of Chornomorsk. Since the departure of the first ship with Ukrainian food, 6.6 million tons of agricultural products have been exported. A total of 292 ships with food for the countries of Asia, Europe and Africa left Ukrainian ports.
UN Secretary-General António Guterres and his team are working on expanding and extending the UN-brokered agreement for a year, allowing the export of Ukrainian grain from the Black Sea region, which may expire at the end of November.
UN humanitarian chief Martin Griffiths and senior UN trade representative Rebecca Greenspan will travel to Moscow in about a week to discuss both issues with senior Russian officials. Facilitating the supply of food and fertilizer from Russia is the central aspect of the package deal brokered by the United Nations and Turkey on July 22, which also restored the supply of grain and fertilizer from the Black Sea.
Russian operational losses from 24.02 to 08.10
Personnel - almost 62,060 people (+380);
Tanks 2,472 (+6);
Armored combat vehicles – 5,111 (+18);
Artillery systems – 1,459 (+4);
Multiple rocket launchers (MLRS) - 345 (+1); Anti-aircraft warfare systems - 180 (+3); Vehicles and fuel tanks – 3,875 (+13); Aircraft - 266 (0);
Helicopters – 234 (+1);
UAV operational and tactical level – 1,079 (+12); Intercepted cruise missiles - 246 (0);
Boats / ships - 15 (0).
Ukraine, general news
Based on the results of the first three quarters of 2022, the Ministry of Economy estimates a drop in Ukraine's GDP at the level of 30%, the press service of the Ministry of Economy reports. The Ministry considers the improvement of the transportation dynamics as a positive factor of economic growth, including both the increase in the export of agricultural products by sea and the increase in the transportation of goods by railway. In the past month, the volume of Ukrainian exports in monetary terms increased by more than 23% compared to August of this year and is a record value since the beginning of the full-scale invasion of the Russian Federation.
In response to the Kerch Strait bridge explosion, the Ukrainian National Security Council Secretary Oleksiy Danilov published a video with the burning Crimean Bridge and the song "Happy Birthday, Mr President". Other Ukrainian officials also joked on this occasion.
International diplomatic aspect
Zaporizhzhia Nuclear Power Plant has lost its last external power source due to renewed shelling and is now dependent on emergency diesel generators. The EU has "condemned in the strongest possible terms the decree of Russian President Putin on the illegal seizure of the Zaporizhzhia Nuclear Power Plant and the establishment of a government enterprise to that matter." "A nuclear safety and security protection zone must be established immediately, without prejudice to Ukraine's sovereignty and territorial integrity," High Representative Josep Borrell demanded. However, no sanctions were imposed on Rosatom, a Russian entity involved in the criminal and dangerous hijacking of the ZNPP.
IMF has approved an additional $1.3 billion in emergency funds for Ukraine to "close a financing gap from shortfalls in grain exports" caused by the aggressive Russian war. "More than seven months after the start of Russia's invasion of Ukraine, the humanitarian and economic toll remains massive, resulting in large and urgent fiscal and external financing needs," the IMF said. Earlier last week, the World Bank forecasted the Ukrainian economy would plunge 35% this year and at least $349 billion, 1.5 times the size of Ukraine's prewar economy, needed to rebuild the economy. However, the WB has upgraded its June forecast of 45.1% freefall.
While for Russians, the most notable events of August were the war in Ukraine (34%), natural disasters (7%), and the death of Darya Dugina, a daughter of a Russian fascist-philosopher (7%), in September appeared a new hot topic. Almost half of Russians (47%) were watching the Kremlin's mobilization efforts, a third (35%) were still following the war, and illegal Russian referenda drew the attention of 9%, according to the Levada Centre poll. Though attention to the war is one of the top-rated events, it's still not significant enough [in public polls] given the fact that it is Russia's war, not a foreign one. Furthermore, the invasion of Ukraine did not change Russians' support of Vladimir Putin; his actions are supported by 82-83% from March through August. However, in September, the backing of his actions decreased to 77%, while disapproval rose from 15% in August to 21% in September. So, it's Putin's war to the same degree as almost of all Russians, and they start to worry when they face the possibility of getting to the trenches of pointless war.
Russia, relevant news
Arrests of Russian military servicemen began in Moscow, the Main Intelligence Directorate of the Ukrainian Ministry of Defense reported. According to the agency, downtown Moscow is blocked off, and units of the Dzerzhinsky operational division, considered the "elite" of the National Guard, entered the city. "They are moving to the center together with police units. Numerous arrests, detentions and blocking of the military servicemen are known," the Ukrainian intelligence reports.
Centre for Information Resilience (CIR) has published an investigative report confirming that April 8, 2022, missile strike on the Kramatorsk train station originated from the territory controlled by the Russian Federation. "Six months on from the attack, the open-source evidence collected and verified by CIR investigators points toward Russia being the perpetrator of the missile strike that killed 59 civilians at the Kramatorsk train station," CIR said.
Russian media reported that the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation had appointed Serhiy Surovikin as the commander of the joint group of troops in Ukraine. Surovikin has been the Commander-in-Chief of the Air and Space Forces since October 31, 2017. He also participated in the armed conflict in Tajikistan, the Second Chechen War and the military operation in Syria.
We publish this brief daily. If you would like to subscribe, please send us an email to cds.dailybrief@gmail.com
Please note, that we subscribe only verified persons and can decline or cancel the subscription at our own discretion
We are independent, non-government, non-partisan and non-profit organisation. More at www.defence.org.ua
Our Twitter (in English) - https://twitter.com/defence_centre
Our Facebook (in Ukrainian) - https://www.facebook.com/cds.UA
Our brief is for information only and we verify our information to the best possible extent
3. Elon Musk: ‘Aren’t you entertained?’
A long article with a lot of chaff. I am forwarding this for Musk's comments on Taiwan and Ukraine.
Here are the key excerpts:
There are some topics that amuse Musk, eliciting prolonged laughter, and other questions that are met with deliberate silence before he speaks. The longest silence follows my question about China and the risk to Tesla’s Shanghai factory, which produces between 30 per cent and 50 per cent of Tesla’s total production. Musk has been an admirer of as well as an investor in China. But he is not immune to the gathering US-China tensions or the risk of a Chinese takeover of Taiwan. Musk says Beijing has made clear its disapproval of his recent rollout of Starlink, SpaceX’s satellite communications system, in Ukraine to help the military circumvent Russia’s cut-off of the internet. He says Beijing sought assurances that he would not sell Starlink in China.
Musk reckons that conflict over Taiwan is inevitable but he is quick to point out that he won’t be alone in suffering the consequences. Tesla will be caught up in any conflict, he says, though, curiously, he seems to assume that the Shanghai factory will still be able to supply to customers in China, but not anywhere else. “Apple would be in very deep trouble, that’s for sure . . . ” he adds, not to mention the global economy, which he estimates, with precision, will take a 30 per cent hit.
It may be Musk’s realisation that business decisions can no longer be made without regard to security and geopolitics — or perhaps it’s simply an arrogant belief that he has all the answers — that now leads him to offer his own solutions to the world’s most complex geopolitical problems. “My recommendation . . . would be to figure out a special administrative zone for Taiwan that is reasonably palatable, probably won’t make everyone happy. And it’s possible, and I think probably, in fact, that they could have an arrangement that’s more lenient than Hong Kong.” I doubt his proposal will be taken up.
On Ukraine too, he has advocated a compromise with Russia that has earned him ridicule in Kyiv, where Starlink had made him a hero until now. He launched his peace plan in a poll on Twitter and suggested that Crimea, which Russia invaded in 2014 and later annexed, should simply be given away to Russia. Volodymyr Zelenskyy, the Ukrainian president, shot back with his own Twitter poll: which Elon Musk do you like more, he asked, the one who supports Ukraine or the one who supports Russia?
Elon Musk: ‘Aren’t you entertained?’
The Tesla chief talks to Roula Khalaf about moving to Mars, saving free speech via Twitter — and why ageing is one ‘problem’ that should not be solved
Financial Times · by Roula Khalaf · October 7, 2022
Dinner with Elon Musk begins with a drive in a Tesla. I am seated in the back, next to X, the billionaire’s two-and-a-half-year-old son. It’s around 7pm in Austin, and X is, as one would expect, cranky. We had set off to Fonda San Miguel, Musk’s favourite Mexican restaurant, after a visit with an FT colleague to the Tesla Gigafactory on the banks of the Colorado river. In this massive site Musk is producing the Y electric SUVs, the latest model in the Tesla collection that has catapulted him to the top of the world’s rich list (net worth: $232bn). Musk, with X perched on his shoulders, had proudly shown off the factory floor as he periodically raged against sluggish investment in lithium refining, which is desperately needed to ease battery shortages around the world.
Musk’s security chief, the designated driver, comes to the rescue with a milk bottle that soothes X to sleep by the time we reach the restaurant. For the next couple of hours, I am better acquainted with the curious character of Elon Musk, the engineer and the visionary, the billionaire and the disrupter, the agitator and the troublemaker. Defying armies of sceptics, including myself (full disclosure: until my family rebelled against me and bought a Tesla Model 3 and I started driving it, I was convinced the company would go bankrupt), Musk has built Tesla into a more than $700bn market cap business and forced the car industry to speed up the shift to electric vehicles. Not prone to modesty, Musk estimates he may have accelerated the “advent of sustainable energy” by “10, maybe even 20 years”.
In just over a decade, he has also transformed the commercial space industry and the economics of space, racing ahead of rivals in building a reusable rocket that can carry passengers. Nasa has picked his Starship to land astronauts on the moon over the next few years. It is now worth around $125bn. One day, or so Musk is convinced, it will be used to colonise Mars.
Musk is a maverick too, a serial tweeter to his more than 100mn followers who flouts convention, revels in outrageous outbursts, fights with regulators and staff, and taunts competitors. He has regular run-ins with the Securities and Exchange Commission: he was fined and forced to give up his chairmanship of Tesla over 2018 tweets in which he claimed to have secured funding to take Tesla private, statements that a US judge later described as having been made “recklessly”. A recent lawsuit accuses Musk of running a pyramid scheme to prop up dogecoin, a cryptocurrency that is, literally, based on a joke — an internet meme of a Japanese dog. Dogecoin has predictably crashed but Musk’s enthusiasm has not: he twins his black jeans with a black T-shirt featuring an image of the dog.
Elon Musk addresses the media in front of the SpaceX Falcon rocket at Nasa’s Kennedy Space Center in Florida, 2018 © New York Times/Redux/eyevine
Why does a serious guy with serious ideas indulge in silly Twitter games that could also cost his followers dearly? “Aren’t you entertained?” Musk roars with laughter. “I play the fool on Twitter and often shoot myself in the foot and cause myself all sorts of trouble . . . I don’t know, I find it vaguely therapeutic to express myself on Twitter. It’s a way to get messages out to the public.”
It is fair to say that Musk is obsessed with Twitter, so much so that he’s been embroiled in an epic on/off buyout of the platform that has captivated Wall Street and the tech industry for months. Twitter sued Musk (and he sued back) after he backed out of a $44bn acquisition deal he made in April, accusing the social media company of under-reporting the number of bots on the platform. This week, and just before his scheduled deposition, Musk changed his mind. He now says he wants to buy Twitter again.
I had asked over dinner whether his original offer had been a bad joke. “Twitter is certainly an invitation to increase your pain level,” he says. “I guess I must be a masochist . . . ” But he makes no secret that his interest in the company has never been primarily financial: “I’m not doing Twitter for the money. It’s not like I’m trying to buy some yacht and I can’t afford it. I don’t own any boats. But I think it’s important that people have a maximally trusted and inclusive means of exchanging ideas and that it should be as trusted and transparent as possible.” The alternative, he says, is a splintering of debate into different social-media bubbles, as evidenced by Donald Trump’s Truth Social network. “It [Truth Social] is essentially a rightwing echo chamber. It might as well be called Trumpet.”
Musk doesn’t eat lunch, possibly because an unflattering picture in a swimsuit taken on a yacht in Mykonos went viral over the summer. Since then, he has been on a diet. At Fonda San Miguel, a teeming Mexican restaurant that promises a regional culinary experience, he is a familiar dinner customer. He orders a frozen margarita (he calls it a slushy with alcohol) and I order a beer. Musk looks around. “There’s a good buzz in this restaurant,” he says approvingly, and suggests to the waiter that they serve us some of their specialities. Musk is telling me that companies are like children when the first plates land on the table: the lamb chops in a pepper sauce, and shrimp with cheese and jalapeños. The food is “epic”, Musk gasps.
Musk is capricious, but he sees himself as a problem solver, and the problem is everything from the potential end of life on Earth to climate change and even traffic (his Boring company is building tunnels). Recently, he has dreamt up his own (rather unhelpful) peace plan for ending Russia’s war in Ukraine. Born and raised in South Africa in a well-to-do family, he landed in California after studying economics and physics in Canada and Pennsylvania. One of his first big ideas was well ahead of its time: he wanted to revolutionise banking. He merged an online payments business he co-founded with another company in what became PayPal. When PayPal was sold to eBay, he used the money to start SpaceX and invest in Tesla.
Ageing strikes me as the only threat to humans that he is not attempting to resolve, though another company he founded, Neuralink, is designing chips that will be implanted in the brain to restore sensory and motor function. Musk is very exercised about population decline, and claims to be doing his part to populate Earth by having 10 children (from various partners), including, it was recently reported, twins with an executive at Neuralink.
He scoffs when I inquire if there are other children he has fathered — “I’m pretty sure there are no other babies looming” — and he dismisses the wild rumours that he has bought a fertility clinic to support his production of babies. Some friends, he reveals, have indeed suggested he should have 500 kids, but that would be a “bit weird”. Referring to himself, aged 51, as an “autumn chicken”, he says he may have more children, but only to the extent that he can be a good father to them. Nonetheless, he predicts that “the current trend for most countries is that civilisation will not die with a bang, it will die with a whimper in adult diapers”. But he says ageing should not be solved. “It’s important that people die. How long would you have liked Stalin to live?” That is a good point.
Musk, with his son X, when he was named Time Person of the Year in December 2021 © Getty Images for Time
Musk’s bigger worry is the preservation of life beyond Earth. His solution is to populate Mars. “Something will happen to Earth eventually, it’s just a question of time. Eventually the sun will expand and destroy all life on Earth, so we do need to move at some point, or at least be a multi-planet species,” he says. “You have to ask the question: do we want to be a space-flying civilisation and a multi-planet species or not?” I’m not sure what I think but Musk is emphatic. “It’s a question of what percentage of resources should we devote to such an endeavour? I think if you say 1 per cent of resources, that’s probably a reasonable amount.”
Would Musk himself join the pioneering colony on Mars? “Especially if I’m getting old, I’ll do it. Why not?” he says. But how useful would he be to Mars if he’s too old? “I think there’s some non-trivial chance of dying, so I’d prefer to take that chance when I’m a bit older, and see my kids grow up. Rather than right now, where little X is only two-and-a-half. I think he’d miss me.”
The table is too small for the large plates we are sharing as a second course: a slow-cooked lamb that melts in the mouth, chillies in a walnut-based sauce and shrimp in creamy chipotle sauce. Musk is right: it is the best Mexican food I’ve ever had.
We turn to his views on government and politics and the Twitter Musk appears, the more emotional, unrestrained persona that comes across in his frenetic posts. He is lauding billionaires as the most efficient stewards of capital, best placed to decide on the allocation of social benefits. “If the alternative steward of capital is the government, that is actually not going to be to the benefit of the people,” says Musk.
Menu
Fonda San Miguel
2330 W N Loop Blvd, Austin, Texas 78756
House frozen margarita $10
Modelo Especial beer $6
House rocks margarita $10
Spicy sauce $0.50
Angels on horseback (shrimp with cheese) $18.95
Cordero lamb chops $24.95
Mixiote slow-cooked lamb $38.95
Chile en nogada (chillies in a walnut sauce) $38.95
Camarones crema chipotle (shrimp in a spicy chipotle sauce) $34.95
Total inc tax $198.37
He is railing against Joe Biden for being in thrall to the unions but also daring to snub him. “He [Biden] had an electric vehicle summit at the White House and deliberately didn’t invite Tesla last year. Then to follow it up, to add insult to injury, at a big event he said that GM was leading the electric car revolution, in the same quarter that GM shipped 26 electric cars and we shipped 300,000. Does that seem fair to you?”
Until recently Musk voted Democrat, although he is now more on the Republican side, or perhaps floating somewhere in between. He says he is considering setting up “the Super Moderate Super Pac” to support candidates with moderate views. He makes a point of telling me that he doesn’t hate Trump, even if he has clashed with him, and insists Biden is simply too old to run for a second term in office. “You don’t want to be too far from the average age of the population because it’s going to be very difficult to stay in touch . . . Maybe one generation away from the average age is OK, but two generations? At the point where you’ve got great-grandchildren, I don’t know, how in touch with the people are you? Is it even possible to be?”
Musk has a dystopian view of the left’s influence on America, which helps explain his wild pursuit of Twitter to liberate free speech. He blames the fact that his teenage daughter no longer wants to be associated with him on the supposed takeover of elite schools and universities by neo-Marxists. “It’s full-on communism . . . and a general sentiment that if you’re rich, you’re evil,” says Musk. “It [the relationship] may change, but I have very good relationships with all the others [children]. Can’t win them all.”
He also has a dim view of regulators, whom he sees as bureaucrats justifying their jobs by going after high-profile targets like him. He seems to be in a constant feud with one regulator or another, whether it’s over his own pronouncements or over the treatment of staff. Musk is unabashed about driving his employees hard. He was bullied as a child (and has also spoken of emotional abuse by his father) but is now sometimes accused of bullying others. He shoots back: if anyone is unhappy working for him, they should work elsewhere because “they’re not chained to the company, it’s voluntary”.
Does he ever think he’s above the law? That’s utter nonsense, he tells me: “I’m subject to literally a million laws and regulations and I obey almost 99.99 per cent of them. It’s only when I think the law is contrary to the interest of the people that I have an issue.” I wonder if he means the interest of Elon Musk.
There are some topics that amuse Musk, eliciting prolonged laughter, and other questions that are met with deliberate silence before he speaks. The longest silence follows my question about China and the risk to Tesla’s Shanghai factory, which produces between 30 per cent and 50 per cent of Tesla’s total production. Musk has been an admirer of as well as an investor in China. But he is not immune to the gathering US-China tensions or the risk of a Chinese takeover of Taiwan. Musk says Beijing has made clear its disapproval of his recent rollout of Starlink, SpaceX’s satellite communications system, in Ukraine to help the military circumvent Russia’s cut-off of the internet. He says Beijing sought assurances that he would not sell Starlink in China.
Musk speaks at a Tesla Model 3 launch ceremony in China, 2020 © Xinhua News Agency/eyevine
Musk reckons that conflict over Taiwan is inevitable but he is quick to point out that he won’t be alone in suffering the consequences. Tesla will be caught up in any conflict, he says, though, curiously, he seems to assume that the Shanghai factory will still be able to supply to customers in China, but not anywhere else. “Apple would be in very deep trouble, that’s for sure . . . ” he adds, not to mention the global economy, which he estimates, with precision, will take a 30 per cent hit.
It may be Musk’s realisation that business decisions can no longer be made without regard to security and geopolitics — or perhaps it’s simply an arrogant belief that he has all the answers — that now leads him to offer his own solutions to the world’s most complex geopolitical problems. “My recommendation . . . would be to figure out a special administrative zone for Taiwan that is reasonably palatable, probably won’t make everyone happy. And it’s possible, and I think probably, in fact, that they could have an arrangement that’s more lenient than Hong Kong.” I doubt his proposal will be taken up.
On Ukraine too, he has advocated a compromise with Russia that has earned him ridicule in Kyiv, where Starlink had made him a hero until now. He launched his peace plan in a poll on Twitter and suggested that Crimea, which Russia invaded in 2014 and later annexed, should simply be given away to Russia. Volodymyr Zelenskyy, the Ukrainian president, shot back with his own Twitter poll: which Elon Musk do you like more, he asked, the one who supports Ukraine or the one who supports Russia?
We are over an hour into dinner and Musk is in a hurry, having scheduled a call with his SpaceX team. We skip dessert and I ask for the bill, only to find out it’s already been settled by Musk’s security chief. Musk ignores my protestations that he is flouting Lunch with the FT convention: “You’re indebted to me for life,” he jokes. We head back to the car that is taking him to a private airport to board his jet and he suggests we continue our conversation on the way.
I find X exactly where I left him, in his car seat, but he’s more cheerful after his nap. He is cooing as he watches videos of rockets on his iPad while his dad discusses rockets with his team. Suddenly, I notice that the car is driving itself, as if to dispel the doubts I had expressed about Tesla’s self-driving prospects. “It can get to the airport without intervention,” says Musk. Alarmed, I put my seatbelt on. Musk could be a magician, but he could also be wrong.
Roula Khalaf is editor of the Financial Times
Find out about our latest stories first — follow @ftweekend on Twitter
Financial Times · by Roula Khalaf · October 7, 2022
4. China Hails Elon Musk’s Proposal for Taiwan Unification
The "modern grand strategist " weighs in on Taiwan after proposing the end for Ukraine? Or a useful idiot?
Perhaps he should stick to making Teslas. And do we want him to have the keys to Twitter?
China Hails Elon Musk’s Proposal for Taiwan Unification
- Tesla CEO suggests Taiwan become a special administrative zone
- ‘One country, two systems’ structure lacks support in Taiwan
Bloomberg News
October 9, 2022 at 6:48 AM EDT
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-10-09/china-hails-elon-musk-s-proposal-for-taiwan-unification?sref=hhjZtX76
Sign up for Next China, a weekly email on where the nation stands now and where it's going next.
China heaped praise on Elon Musk’s plan for a Hong Kong-like system for Taiwan, despite declining support for unification on the island as Beijing ramps up military pressure.
Qin Gang, China’s ambassador to the US, thanked Musk for the proposal, saying on Twitter the “one country, two systems” framework is a basic principle for “resolving the Taiwan question.”
Hours later, Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Mao Ning affirmed those remarks.
“Provided that national sovereignty, security and development interests are assured, Taiwan can adopt a high degree of autonomy as a special administrative region,” she told reporters during a regular briefing Sunday.
In a Financial Times profile published Friday, Musk said, “My recommendation...would be to figure out a special administrative zone for Taiwan that is reasonably palatable.” He added that “probably won’t make everyone happy.
Qin Gang 秦刚
@AmbQinGang
China government official
I would like to thank @elonmusk
for his call for peace across the Taiwan Strait and his idea about establishing a special administrative zone for Taiwan. Actually, Peaceful reunification and One Country, Two Systems are our basic principles for resolving the Taiwan question...
Such a proposal faces growing resistance in Taiwan toward any form of integration with Beijing, especially following the Chinese Communist Party’s sweeping crackdown on dissent in Hong Kong.
The dispute over Taiwan’s sovereignty is among the most dangerous variables in China-US ties, with calls growing among American politicians for a commitment to get involved if Beijing takes military action.
More details about President Xi Jinping’s priorities on Taiwan may emerge next week at the upcoming Communist Party Congress, where he is set to secure a norm-defying third term.
— With assistance by Lucille Liu and Jing Li
5. In Dealing With Putin Threat, Biden Turns to Lessons of Cuban Missile Crisis
Excerpts:
So it was a surprise that the first member of the administration to talk openly about how to avoid forcing Mr. Putin’s hand was the president himself, at the New York home of James Murdoch, the son of Rupert Murdoch, executive chairman of News Corp., which owns, among other assets, The Wall Street Journal.
“We’re trying to figure out: What is Putin’s off-ramp?” Mr. Biden said, in a speech that was largely on domestic initiatives, the Supreme Court’s overturning of Roe v. Wade and other issues central to the midterm elections.
“Where, where does he get off? Where does he find a way out? Where does he find himself in a position that he does not — not only lose face, but lose significant power within Russia?”
Mr. Biden did not answer his own questions, which echo those that his aides have been asking. Nor is it at all clear that Mr. Putin is looking for a way out, at least yet. At just about every turning point in the war over the past seven months, he has reacted to failures among his troops with ever more escalation, calling up untrained recruits, conducting more indiscriminate attacks on cities, reducing gas flows and threatening, of course, to use his ultimate weapons.
In Dealing With Putin Threat, Biden Turns to Lessons of Cuban Missile Crisis
nytimes.com · by David E. Sanger · October 7, 2022
President Biden has mused publicly on whether there might be an “off-ramp” for nuclear threats from the Russian leader that invoke Cold War rhetoric.
President Biden said on Thursday the world may be facing “the prospect of Armageddon” if President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia uses a tactical nuclear weapon.Credit...Erin Schaff/The New York Times
President Biden’s declaration on Thursday night that the world may be facing “the prospect of Armageddon” if President Vladimir V. Putin uses a tactical nuclear weapon in Ukraine included a revealing side note: that Mr. Biden has been looking to help the Russian president find an “off-ramp” that might avert the worst outcome.
His logic came right out of the Cuban Missile Crisis, to which Mr. Biden referred twice in his comments at a Democratic fund-raiser in New York, a good indication of what is on his mind. In that famous case — the closest the world came to a full nuclear exchange, 60 years ago this month — President John F. Kennedy struck a secret bargain with Nikita Khrushchev, the Soviet premier, to remove American missiles from Turkey.
With that deal, which came to light only later, a disaster that could have killed tens of millions of Americans and untold numbers of Soviet citizens was averted.
For weeks now, Mr. Biden’s aides have been debating whether there might be an analogous understanding, a way for the wounded Russian leader to find an out. They have offered no details, knowing that secrecy may be the key to seeking any successful exit and avoiding the conditions in which a cornered Mr. Putin reaches for his battlefield nuclear weapons. Karine Jean-Pierre, the White House press secretary, reiterated on Friday that Mr. Biden had no new intelligence about nuclear weapons use and said she “saw no indications” the Russians were “preparing to use them.”
After Mr. Biden’s remarks, some foreign leaders said they would like to go back to the days when nuclear threats were not discussed in public.
“We must speak with prudence when commenting on such matters,” France’s president, Emmanuel Macron, said on Friday in Prague.
But as one senior European diplomat said earlier this week, when the history of this era is written, many will be shocked at how much work was underway to assess the risks of a nuclear detonation — and to think about how to deter it. It is a hard topic to talk about in public for most officials, for fear of inducing public panic or market sell-offs.
So it was a surprise that the first member of the administration to talk openly about how to avoid forcing Mr. Putin’s hand was the president himself, at the New York home of James Murdoch, the son of Rupert Murdoch, executive chairman of News Corp., which owns, among other assets, The Wall Street Journal.
“We’re trying to figure out: What is Putin’s off-ramp?” Mr. Biden said, in a speech that was largely on domestic initiatives, the Supreme Court’s overturning of Roe v. Wade and other issues central to the midterm elections.
“Where, where does he get off? Where does he find a way out? Where does he find himself in a position that he does not — not only lose face, but lose significant power within Russia?”
Mr. Biden did not answer his own questions, which echo those that his aides have been asking. Nor is it at all clear that Mr. Putin is looking for a way out, at least yet. At just about every turning point in the war over the past seven months, he has reacted to failures among his troops with ever more escalation, calling up untrained recruits, conducting more indiscriminate attacks on cities, reducing gas flows and threatening, of course, to use his ultimate weapons.
Mr. Putin’s latest threats came a week ago, when he declared that the United States’ decision to drop atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki in 1945 set a precedent and that if necessary he would follow suit.
Nonetheless, the main message that Mr. Biden seemed to be conveying is that he was heeding one of the central lessons of the Cuban Missile Crisis, which unfolded when Mr. Biden was just a month shy of his 20th birthday. That lesson, in his telling, is that the United States and its allies need to avoid getting Mr. Putin’s back to the wall, forcing him to strike out.
“It’s part of Russian doctrine,’’ he explained to the well-heeled crowd of potential donors to Democratic senatorial campaigns, that “if the motherland is threatened, they’ll use whatever force they need, including nuclear weapons.”
It is hard to translate Mr. Biden’s description of the risks into a strategy that fits the moment. No one in the administration wants to suggest, in public or private, that the government of President Volodymyr Zelensky should avoid chasing Russian troops out of every corner of Ukraine, back to the borders that existed on Feb. 23, the day before the invasion began.
But behind closed doors, some Western diplomats and military officials say, that is exactly the conversation that may have to happen if the goal is to balance winning back territory against preventing Mr. Putin from lashing out. William Burns, the C.I.A. director and the former U.S. ambassador to Moscow during Mr. Putin’s rise, said on CBS this week that the Russian leader can be “quite dangerous and reckless” when he feels cornered or “feels his back against the wall.”
Of course, that is exactly the kind of assessment Mr. Putin is trying to encourage; his ultimate hope, American intelligence officials say, is to fracture Europe over the question of whether to confront Moscow or appease it.
He has plenty of steps remaining on the escalation ladder: He could conduct exercises with his nuclear-ready troops, he could step up cyberattacks outside Ukraine’s borders and he could make use of chemical weapons, as he has done in the past, against dissidents and other targets. Then, of course, there is the possibility of attacks on energy infrastructure — perhaps similar to what happened last week, mysteriously, to the Nord Stream I and II gas pipelines.
But what the administration says it is looking for are incentives for Mr. Putin to de-escalate — a search that appears fraught.
One of Mr. Putin’s periodic demands is that NATO pull back its forces from former Soviet states and not conduct what he calls provocative exercises on its borders. Early this year, he demanded that NATO sign a treaty that would have essentially rolled the alliance back to what it looked like in the late 1990s.
Many Eastern European officials, concerned about Mr. Putin’s next territorial ambition, say they want NATO in their countries more than ever. To them, this is a time to build up defenses, not pull back. But some Western European officials say they could imagine scaling back on exercises or conspicuous reinforcement of troops, even temporarily. Over the summer, the Biden administration also delayed some missile tests, to avoid unnecessary provocations.
All those would be temporary moves, and Mr. Putin is clearly looking for a permanent alteration in NATO’s stance. And he is not likely, many officials insist, to stop invoking the power of his nuclear arsenal as long as his ground troops are struggling.
nytimes.com · by David E. Sanger · October 7, 2022
6. Ukraine: Russian strikes kill 17 following bridge attack
Revenge attacks?
Ukraine: Russian strikes kill 17 following bridge attack
AP · by JUSTIN SPIKE and ADAM SCHRECK · October 9, 2022
ZAPORIZHZHIA, Ukraine (AP) — A Russian missile barrage that crumbled apartment buildings and houses in Ukraine’s city of Zaporizhzhia killed at least 17 people and wounded dozens, Ukrainian officials said Sunday as Moscow strained to enforce its takeover of illegally annexed territory.
The blasts that collapsed at least one high-rise residential building and blew out the windows of others came from six missiles launched in Russian-occupied areas of the Zaporizhzhia region, the Ukrainian air force said. The region is one of four Russia claimed as its own this month, but the regional capital remains under Ukrainian control.
The multiple strikes came after an explosion Saturday caused the partial collapse of a bridge linking the Crimean Peninsula with Russia. The Kerch Bridge attack damaged an important supply route for the Kremlin’s faltering war effort in Ukraine and a towering symbol of Russia’s power in the region.
ADVERTISEMENT
Stunned residents watched from behind police tape as emergency crews tried to reach the upper floors of a building that took a direct hit. The attack collapsed several floors, leaving a smoldering chasm at least 40-feet wide where apartments had stood. Several hours later, the top floors caved in as well.
European champs Italy draw England in Euro 2024 qualifying
Kyrgyzstan cancels Russian-led military drill on its land
UN: Ukraine nuclear power plant loses external power link
Russia adds popular rapper, writer to "foreign agent" list
In an adjacent apartment building, the barrage blew windows and doors out of their frames in a radius of hundreds of feet. At least 20 private homes and 50 apartment buildings in all were damaged, and at least 40 people were hospitalized, city council Secretary Anatoliy Kurtev said.
Zaporizhzhia resident Mucola Markovich, 76, said he and his wife hid under a blanket when they heard incoming rockets and booms from blasts. “There was one explosion, then another one,” he said. Then, in a flash, their fourth-floor apartment was gone, Markovich said, holding back tears.
“When it will be rebuilt, I don’t know,” he said. “I am left without an apartment at the end of my life.”
Russian officials did not immediately comment on the strikes. Following Russian President Vladimir Putin’s annexation of the Zaporizhzhia region last week, Russia has repeatedly bombarded the city of the same name. At least 19 people died in Russian missile strikes on apartment buildings in the city on Thursday.
ADVERTISEMENT
“Again, Zaporizhzhia. Again, merciless attacks on civilians, targeting residential buildings, in the middle of the night,” Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy wrote in a Telegram post.
“Absolute meanness. Absolute evil. … From the one who gave this order, to everyone who carried out this order: they will answer. They must. Before the law and the people,” he added.
Tetyana Lazunko, 73, and her husband, Oleksii, took shelter in the hallway of their top floor apartment after first hearing air raid sirens and then an explosion that shook the building and sent their possessions flying.
Lazunko wept inconsolably as the couple surveyed the damage to their home since 1974, wondering why an area with no military infrastructure in sight was targeted.
“Why are they bombing us. Why?” she said.
ADVERTISEMENT
While Russia targeted Zaporizhzhia before Saturday’s explosion on the Crimea bridge, the attack on the 12-mile-long span was a significant blow to Moscow. Russia annexed Crimea in March 2014 following a hastily called local vote, a move that drew U.S. and European Union sanctions.
Putin personally opened the $3.7 million Kerch Bridge in May 2018 by driving a truck across it in a symbol of Moscow’s claims on Crimea. The bridge, the longest one in Europe, is vital to sustaining Russia’s military operations in southern Ukraine.
The Crimean Peninsula is a popular destination for Russian tourists and home to a Russian naval base. A Russian tourist association estimated that 50,000 tourists were in Crimea on Saturday.
Putin signed a decree late Saturday tightening security for the bridge and for energy infrastructure between Crimea and Russia, and put Russia’s federal security service, the FSB, in charge of the effort.
Some Russian lawmakers called for Putin to declare a “counterterrorism operation,” rather than the term “special military operation” that has downplayed the scope of fighting to ordinary Russians.
ADVERTISEMENT
Hours after the explosion, Russia’s Defense Ministry announced that the air force chief, Gen. Sergei Surovikin, would now command all Russian troops in Ukraine. Surovikin, who this summer was placed in charge of troops in southern Ukraine, had led Russian forces in Syria and was accused of overseeing a bombardment that destroyed much of Aleppo.
No one has claimed responsibility for damaging the bridge. Zelenskyy, in a video address, indirectly acknowledged the bridge attack but did not address its cause.
“Today was not a bad day and mostly sunny on our state’s territory,” he said. “Unfortunately, it was cloudy in Crimea. Although it was also warm.”
Train and automobile traffic over the bridge was temporarily suspended. Automobile traffic resumed Saturday afternoon on one of the two links that remained intact, with the flow alternating in each direction, said Crimea’s Russia-backed leader, Sergey Aksyonov.
ADVERTISEMENT
The Russian transport ministry said on Telegram Sunday that passenger train traffic between Crimea and the Russian mainland resumed overnight “according to schedule.” In a separate Telegram post Sunday, the ministry said car ferries also were working between Crimea and the mainland.
The Institute for the Study of War, a think tank based in Washington, said videos of the bridge indicated the damage from the explosion “is likely to increase friction in Russian logistics for some time” but not cripple Russia’s ability to equip its troops in Ukraine.
“The collapsed lane of the road bridge will restrict Russian military movements until it is repaired, forcing some Russian forces to rely on the ferry connection for some time,” the institute said. “Russian forces will likely still be able to transport heavy military equipment via the railroad.”
While Russia seized areas north of Crimea early in its invasion of Ukraine and built a land corridor to it along the Sea of Azov, Ukraine is pressing a counteroffensive to reclaim that territory and other parts of Ukraine Putin illegally annexed this month.
The Ukrainian military on Sunday morning said that fierce clashes were ongoing around the cities of Bakhmut and Avdiivka in the eastern Donetsk region, where Russian forces have claimed some recent territorial gains.
In its regular social media update, the General Staff of the Armed Forces of Ukraine did not acknowledge any loss of territory but said that “the most tense situation” on the entire territory of Ukraine had been observed around the two cities.
The regional governor of Zaporizhzhia reported that the death toll had risen to 32 after Russia’s missile strike on a civilian convoy making its way out of the city on September 30. In a Telegram post, Oleksandr Starukh that one more person died in the hospital on Friday.
A part of the Zaporizhzhia region currently under Russian control is home to Europe’s largest nuclear power station. Fighting has repeatedly imperiled the the Zaporizhzhia Nuclear Power Plant, and Ukrainian authorities shut down its last operating reactor last month to prevent a radiation disaster.
The International Atomic Energy Agency, the U.N.’s nuclear watchdog, said Saturday that the Zaporizhzhia plant has since lost its last remaining external power source as a result of renewed shelling and is now relying on emergency diesel generators.
___
Schreck reported from Kyiv
AP · by JUSTIN SPIKE and ADAM SCHRECK · October 9, 2022
7. Seven questions with the US Army’s counter-drone boss
Seven questions with the US Army’s counter-drone boss
Defense News · by Catherine Buchaniec · October 7, 2022
WASHINGTON — Thanks to affordable material and the mitigated risk to humans, experts have pointed to drones as the future of conflict. Already, Russia and Ukraine have deployed drones on the battlefield, each seeking to increase its drone arsenal as their war approaches the eight-month mark.
For its part, the U.S. Army created the Joint Counter-Small Unmanned Aircraft Systems Office to address the proliferation of adversarial drones. The JCO came about after then-Defense Secretary Mark Esper in 2019 designated the Army as the executive agent for counter-UAS activities.
Maj. Gen. Sean Gainey serves as director of that office, and he spoke with C4ISRNET in September about what it takes to protect American interests against drones. This interview was edited for length and clarity.
The Army’s Fires Center of Excellence at Fort Sill, Oklahoma, focuses on counter-UAS capabilities. How is that effort going?
We’re going to transition what we’re doing at Yuma [Proving Ground in Arizona] into Fort Sill, and that process is happening right now. We’re starting to get the classrooms. They’re starting the program of instruction development. We’re working with the joint team across courses to make sure we’re maximizing all the [program of instruction] capability.
Maj. Gen. Sean Gainey
Will the center’s curriculum focus on different types of counter-UAS strategies, such as kinetic options versus electronic warfare options?
The curriculum will cover all of that. You’ll have an “operators’ course” that will really introduce operators to the spectrum of counter-UAS capabilities that are out there, really focus in on the systems the Army’s currently fielding at divisions and the other services are fielding at their sites or locations.
We’re really excited for our “planners’ course” because, right now, we really don’t have the planning or understanding of how to employ counter-UAS capability from a planner perspective, and that’s going to be a critical piece. That’s probably the course that’s going to be stood up first because, right now, as we’re putting capability out in our installation site, one of the biggest challenges is installation commanders having a planner that they can look at to do the employment of the capability and then lay out all the planning factors with it.
You recently talked about the need for more widespread knowledge across the force on counter-UAS systems. What is the JCO doing to facilitate that dissemination of training and knowledge across the entire force?
The first thing we did was put out a strategy. The strategy was really the first document that we put out that framed the problem for the entire enterprise. Then we put out a handbook based off what we’re doing forward in U.S. Central Command’s area of responsibility, capturing all the lessons learned. We not only provided that for the CENTCOM area of responsibility, but globally to all the combatant commands.
Right now, we’re on our fourth JKO [Joint Knowledge Online] module. If you go to JKO online, there are four modules there that span from operator-level familiarization all the way through policy implementations of employing counter-UAS capability. They’re actually really good modules, and we’re seeing a lot of interest out there.
RELATED
Pentagon tests high-power microwave systems against drones
The Joint Counter-Small Unmanned Aircraft Systems Office has completed its third demonstration to look at capability that could fill identified gaps to defeat the growing drone threat around the world.
Are those modules a requirement?
It hasn’t been updated as a requirement, but my assumptions are, as we continue to move forward and continue to mature, the counter-UAS training requirements will become a requirement in the future. Right now, it’s available, and we’ll find that with soldiers who are preparing for preemployment training, most are more likely to leverage it.
One of the most recent rounds of U.S. assistance for Ukraine included the Vampire system made by L3Harris Technologies. The Pentagon called it a counter-drone system, but L3Harris didn’t advertise it as such. What’s the working definition of counter-drone at the moment?
If you look at some of our capabilities that we’re having a lot of success with in theater now, they weren’t put over there for that purpose. We’ve essentially maximized the capability in that system to give it a dual role, whether it’s taking down rockets or mortars; they now can take down drones. That’s just a natural evolution in the capability because the threat is so prevalent and so large.
You can’t have just a c-UAS capability everywhere. You’ve got to be able to leverage whatever capability you have. So yes, I would tell you that anything that has the ability to take down a drone may not be classified [as c-UAS], but will be utilized in our system-layered approach.
What safeguards are used for autonomous technologies?
At least right now, the human-in-the-loop piece is going to be there until there’s continuing comfort in the ability of a system. But you can start building autonomy without actually having somebody push the button. You can get to the point where it detects, and then the operator does the final push, the effects piece. At some point, that’ll be a strategic decision: When do you want to fully autonomize the ability to let this system shoot? Especially in the future you have things like swarms and other types of threats coming in at you and need to be able to rapidly respond to some of the capabilities.
Some of the autonomy will more than likely have to be built in here, but [the question is]: How far do you go with the autonomy? I don’t think right now anyone is suggesting that we walk away from the system and just let the system do it itself from a defeat perspective, but we’re still looking to leverage technology that can get us there. Eventually, we’ll start having those policy discussions on how we move forward with the autonomous defeat.
How have lessons from the war in Ukraine shaped — or are currently impacting — decisions within your command?
What we’re seeing is what we’ve expected. We’re seeing that the EW capability we’re using works well. We see the kinetic ability working well. What it’s reemphasized is the threat’s ability to leverage drones and UASs to their advantage. If you don’t have a robust capability inside of your force, integrated air and missile defense system, a layered integrated approach with the common [command and control], you’re going to have challenges against these threats; and having it all the way down to the operator level to be able to respond at the operator level.
We’re seeing all of those types of trends employed and reinforcing what we need in order to ensure we’re doing [the right thing] as we continue to move forward and shape our forces.
About Catherine Buchaniec
Catherine Buchaniec is a reporter at C4ISRNET, where she covers artificial intelligence, cyber warfare and uncrewed technologies.
8. A Tactical Russian Nuke Wouldn’t Confer Much Battlefield Advantage, Experts Say
It seems to me that we (and the Russiasns and the Chinese and other advanced military powers, e.g., South Korea and Japan) have conventional weapons that could do as much damage as "tactical" nuclear weapons. Why would you use a tactical nuclear weapon if you have equivalent conventional capabilities to achieve the same battle damage and effects? These are not rhetorical questions. I would like to hear from the nuclear weapons experts, especially if my questions are off base.
A Tactical Russian Nuke Wouldn’t Confer Much Battlefield Advantage, Experts Say
But the environmental and health effects would be enormous and long-lasting.
defenseone.com · by Patrick Tucker
As Russian officials up their nuclear saber-rattling and the Pentagon games out what might happen if Russia were to use one of its 2,000 or so lower-yield nuclear weapons, experts caution that even a relatively small nuclear blast would have far-reaching political and environmental effects. But it would not help Russia win the war.
You might be used to thinking about nuclear weapons in terms of the civilization-destroying half-megaton-class warheads atop intercontinental ballistic missiles. But both the United States and the Soviet Union had a number of smaller nuclear weapons in the one- to 50-kiloton range throughout the Cold War. These are sometimes referred to as “tactical” nuclear weapons, which technically refers to the delivery system but also speaks to their likely use as part of a conventional conflict rather than to deter one. U.S. inventories of these peaked in 1967 and fell afterward, especially when the Cold War ended.
Russia chose a different path, according to this 2017 Johns Hopkins Applied Physics Lab paper. “Recognizing that nuclear weapons were the only affordable means to offset the superior conventional weaponry of NATO, Russia continued to invest in a robust research and development program focused on low-yield nuclear weapons,” its authors wrote.
How much damage could one of these do? The answer depends greatly on where it was used. The online tool NukeMap suggests that a 20-kiloton attack on Kyiv would kill more than 31,000 people and injure another 65,000 within 24 hours. Even those numbers may be a big underestimation.
Michael Frankel, one of the 2017 paper’s authors and a former fellow at the Johns Hopkins Applied Physics Lab, told Defense One via email, “The immediate (prompt) effects would be pretty horrific if you were caught unprotected within a few kilometers, and the military application would presumably be intended to annihilate local concentrations of enemy troops (if they were stupid enough to concentrate in a way that provided such a target), or perhaps important supply depots and such like.”
But Frankel said such a weapon, used on the actual Ukrainian battlefield against military forces, wouldn’t yield a big advantage for Russia. “It is still hard to think of many targets that might be ‘worthy’ of use of nuclear weapons as just another battlefield explosive, albeit a big one,” he wrote.
A lot of that has to do with the enormous size of the battlefield. The total amount of land still occupied by Russia is almost the size of Portugal and the Ukrainians are fighting on multiple fronts, not in the sort of concentrations that would lend themselves to targeting by such a weapon.
“A five-kiloton nuclear explosion will be an effective killer - but only over a relatively short distance, probably less than 1 or 1.5 km. Chances of surviving such a blast (along with any heavy equipment) are pretty good once you get beyond that distance, and beyond two kilometers even better. So to use a nuke to halt or throw back a twenty or thirty kilometer long front advance does not seem feasible,” Frankel wrote.
For Russia, he wrote, “A nuke might be just the thing to create a punch-through corridor against a defensive line (if you were to ignore the nicety of driving your troops directly across a radiation contaminated battleground) for your counter-attack, but that hardly seems to conform to current reality, where Russia would need sufficient troops poised to aggressively pursue such a strategy.”
Nuclear fallout and secondary environmental, radiological effects are part of the point of strategic weapons, which are meant to be maximally destructive. Fallout is much more of a bug than a feature with tactical weapons—and one that isn’t easily gotten rid of, the Johns Hopkins authors wrote.
“Pure fusion, without the use of any fission trigger, remains the gold standard for a ‘usable’ nuclear weapon in the sense that such a weapon would be fallout free. Additionally, the resulting blast environment would be reduced, whereas the prompt radiation footprint would be increased—a particularly effective combination if such weapons are to be used against enemy ground forces on friendly territory. However, pure fusion, at yields sufficient for warfighting applications, would be extremely difficult to achieve,” they wrote..
That means that any weapon that Russia used in Ukraine would poison a much larger area than its specific target. And there aren’t any good means to predict just how far that pollution and contamination might reach. Edward Geist, a policy researcher at the RAND Corporation, recently argued on Twitter that the studies that the United States’s Cold-War studies of the effects of tactical nuclear weapons “were mostly derived from simplified physical/computational models and validated where possible from the available test data, *not* derived from first principles. As a consequence, these models could potentially be extremely misleading and fail to predict catastrophic collateral effects. One such effect is rainout/washout from a nuclear explosion, which could result from the use of low-yield nuclear weapons such as those possessed by Russia.”
Said Frankel: “The biggest uncertainty and likely most consequential result of such use is likely political, which I think dwarfs the purely physical uncertainty of the results of a nuclear explosion.”
U.S. officials have not spelled out how they would respond to Russian nuclear weapons use, only that the response would be “catastrophic” for the Putin regime.
defenseone.com · by Patrick Tucker
9. ‘They Are in a Panic’: Ukraine’s Troops Size Up the Enemy
The last paragraph sums up the challenge for the Ukrainian military and all of Ukraine. Winter is coming.
Excerpts:
The Ukrainian Army is growing stronger, but it is not yet where it needs to be, Swat said. “For all these small victories, it was a very, very tough time,” he said of the last seven months of the war. “Slowly we recover, but we are not there yet. And Russia has a lot of power, and it is unlimited in its weapons.”
In the village of Stavky, some 10 miles from the front line, the sounds of the Russian bombardment of recently recaptured settlements to the east were loud enough for soldiers and civilians to stop talking and listen.
But commanders and soldiers seemed to agree that Ukrainian troops should keep pushing before the Russian side could regroup.
“We have only one month to do this right now, because right now they are in panic,” Swat said. And winter was closing in. “Now we need to get winter clothes, and we are going to have mud.”
‘They Are in a Panic’: Ukraine’s Troops Size Up the Enemy
Ukrainian soldiers are exulting in their smashing of Russian lines in the northeast. They engaged enemy troops up close, and gained confidence from it.
By Carlotta GallPhotographs by Ivor Prickett
Oct. 7, 2022
nytimes.com · by Carlotta Gall Ivor Prickett · October 7, 2022
Fighters with the Carpathian Sich battalion searching houses used by Russian soldiers in the recently recaptured village of Stavky.
STAVKY, Ukraine — Racing down a road with his men in pursuit of retreating Russian soldiers, a battalion commander came across an abandoned Russian armored vehicle, its engine still running. Inside there was a sniper rifle, rocket propelled grenades, helmets and belongings. The men were gone.
“They dropped everything: personal care, helmets,” said the commander, who uses the code name Swat. “I think it was a special unit, but they were panicking. It was raining very hard, the road was bad and they drop everything and move.”
After months of static fighting and holding the line under withering Russian artillery barrages, Ukrainian soldiers are exulting over their smashing of Russian lines in the northeast three weeks ago, and their recapturing of swaths of territory seized by Russian troops earlier this year. They have almost retaken the whole of Kharkiv Province, as well as territory in each of the four regions that President Vladimir V. Putin claims to have annexed for Russia.
There has been little time for reflection for the Ukrainians as they press their counterattack, focused on keeping the pressure on the retreating Russian army to prevent it from regrouping. Yet after months in the trenches never seeing the faces of the enemy, Ukrainian soldiers and commanders have now engaged the Russians up close and gotten a chance to size up their opponent.
Members of the volunteer battalion preparing to move toward a new position near the town of Lyman.
A 58-year-old career soldier, Swat came out of retirement to join the Carpathian Sich, a volunteer battalion, taking over command after his predecessor was killed in battle near Izium in June. He oversees all the companies in the battalion and in an interview recounted its actions during the counteroffensive, providing detail that was corroborated by half a dozen other soldiers.
The battalion has been in the forefront of the fighting, providing flanking support in battles for the strategically important cities of Izium and Lyman in recent weeks. Four days ago the battalion seized another town further east, helping secure a series of dams and the last settlements of northern Donetsk Province for Ukraine.
The battles have been fast moving, and in the flight from Izium, produced a great deal of panic on the Russian side. After the capture of Izium, Swat said, his unit pursued Russian troops for 15 miles down the road in one day. A few more days and Ukrainian troops were at the gates of Lyman, 30 miles south of Izium; Swat’s group moved east to block any attempt by the Russian army to send reinforcements.
The day Lyman fell, his battalion was attacking another town further east. He asked for security reasons not to disclose the location. His units captured the town in a day, without losses, although nine soldiers were wounded. By the third day they had searched and secured the town and handed it over to another group so they could pull back and recharge.
The State of the War
Then after three weeks of sweeping success and minimal losses, the battalion lost five men in a Russian missile strike and Swat lost a close friend when their car hit a mine. Swat was driving but survived with a concussion.
Tearing up when he talked of his friend in an interview, he asked that a reporter not sugarcoat events of the war with only success stories.
In the battle for Izium, Swat was preparing his assault when he saw Russian troops suddenly falling back, he said. Ukrainian brigades attacking from the north had taken a main highway, cutting Russian troops’ supply lines, his deputy commander said.
They moved up the timing of their assault and the unit raced in from the south and seized a high point in the city.
Russian armored vehicles were defending, firing machines guns, Swat said. “But people were so excited, no one stopped,” he said. “I was running with a pistol. It’s like a small feeling of victory. It’s unbelievable, you feel it inside, you are happy.”
“We get this hill,” he said, “It was happiness, everyone jumping, shooting, hugging each other.”
The men were firing off their weapons, not listening when he ordered them to cease fire, he said. It was just a minor firefight, given that the Russians were already withdrawing, but the capture of Izium gave them a huge boost of confidence. It was vindication, he said, for three months of grueling fighting defending positions under Russian artillery and airstrikes that cost them many lives, he said.
As they raced down the road south from Izium after retreating Russian troops, they captured some enemy soldiers who were sleeping off lunch in a camp in the forest. “They were surprised, seven of them,” he said. “No one expected that after lunch we would advance on a forest line.”
Some of the Russians, demotivated and scared, and some hungry, were ready to give themselves up, he said. But some kept fighting, believing Russian indoctrination that the Ukrainians would torture and kill them if they allowed themselves to be captured.
On one occasion a Russian soldier pulled the pin of a grenade and killed himself, saying he would never let himself be taken prisoner, Swat said. “We jumped to him but we were too late,” he said. “So they are also brave soldiers, and they are afraid.”
His battalion has taken more than 30 Russians prisoner in seven months of fighting, 23 of them in the counterattack, he said. “We just get information from them, give them water, food, warm clothes and send them to a higher level,” he said.
It has been a steep learning curve for his men, not only in survival but in humanity. A 27-year-old American platoon commander from his battalion, who uses the code name Boris, said one of his most intense moments of the war came when he held a cup of water for a Russian prisoner to drink.
But the fighting units had little time to chase deserters.
In some places local residents told them they were sheltering Russian soldiers who had either fled their posts or been left behind, but Swat said he did not have time to stop. And in the past few days, he said, Ukrainian air reconnaissance tracked Russian units pulling out on foot through the forests using good military tactics — spreading out, moving slowly — but again his units were too tied up to pursue them.
The platoon commander named Boris said their units had carried out several assaults on Izium from the southwest in the weeks before the counterattack, luring the Russians into reinforcing in that direction. When the full force of the counterattack came from the north, they were not expecting it, he said.
That does not mean there was not resistance.
The Russians were often set up in well dug-in machine gun nests, several Ukrainian commanders and soldiers said. And once Russian troops pull back, there can be heavy bombardment from Russian planes, artillery, and long-range missiles. A powerful missile strike demolished a former Russian command post in the town they seized recently, killing five of his men, he said.
“It was like a cold water shower,” Swat said. Referring to the five who died, he said: “For two days I was like, crazy. They were young guys.”
For all the recent defeats, he said, he does not think the Russian army is by any means broken. “They will fight, they continue to fight,” he said. “It’s the Slavic mentality: to fight for your friends. They also have friends who died.”
He and his men all voiced concern about the mobilization in Russia, and the new strength it would bring to the Russian side.
The Ukrainian Army is growing stronger, but it is not yet where it needs to be, Swat said. “For all these small victories, it was a very, very tough time,” he said of the last seven months of the war. “Slowly we recover, but we are not there yet. And Russia has a lot of power, and it is unlimited in its weapons.”
In the village of Stavky, some 10 miles from the front line, the sounds of the Russian bombardment of recently recaptured settlements to the east were loud enough for soldiers and civilians to stop talking and listen.
But commanders and soldiers seemed to agree that Ukrainian troops should keep pushing before the Russian side could regroup.
“We have only one month to do this right now, because right now they are in panic,” Swat said. And winter was closing in. “Now we need to get winter clothes, and we are going to have mud.”
Oleksandr Chubko and Borys Shelahurov contributed reporting.
nytimes.com · by Carlotta Gall Ivor Prickett · October 7, 2022
10. Opinion | What the West is still getting wrong about the rise of Xi Jinping
Zakaria's answer to the headline question is not what we (or at least I) expected.
Excerpt:
The real question to ask is why China’s response to the changes unleashed by its market opening has been so successful. Why has Xi Jinping’s campaign of repression worked where other East Asian ones did not? The answer lies in a brilliant 2021 essay by China scholar Minxin Pei. Pei points out that China is almost unique in the world today. Nearly every country with a per capita income higher than China’s is either a democracy of some sort or an oil and gas dictatorship. (Petrostates enable a country to get rich without having to modernize its economy or society, because all it has to do is dig in the ground for natural wealth.) Why is China the great exception?
...
The problem for Xi is that he is steering China on a very dangerous path. The state is now dominating the economy again and growth has slowed considerably. Enterprising Chinese businessmen are moving to Singapore and elsewhere. Areas of Chinese society that were once lively and innovative are closing down. Meanwhile, international hostility toward Xi’s expansionism is growing. Pei points out that the neo-Stalinist model bottles up all the forces of change, leaving only one door open — revolution.
As Pei notes, by 2035, China will have about 300 million college graduates. Will they be content to live quietly under Xi’s reign of repression?
Opinion | What the West is still getting wrong about the rise of Xi Jinping
The Washington Post · by Fareed Zakaria · October 6, 2022
One of the few issues on which there is a consensus in Washington these days is that U.S. policy toward China was built on an intellectual error. Liberals and conservatives alike believed that Beijing’s embrace of free markets and its integration with the global economy would fundamentally change China. But they didn’t, and (so the consensus goes) we should recognize that this was a naive belief in the power of markets and trade.
In fact, viewing China on the eve of the pivotal 20th Party Congress, I am struck by how little that line of analysis captures what has actually happened in China over the past decades. China has gone through profound economic and social changes. Its per capita GDP has gone up almost thirtyfold since the start of economic liberalization in 1978. Mass education and urbanization have changed the face of the country. Hundreds of millions Chinese are now middle class, use the most cutting-edge tools of the information revolution and have considerable freedom to own property, start businesses and change their places of residence, all previously forbidden.
It is precisely in response to these massive changes that Xi Jinping has launched his program of repression and centralization. When Xi came to power in 2012, he determined that economic liberalization was actually transforming China profoundly — in a bad way. He believed that the Communist Party was on the verge of becoming irrelevant in a society dominated by capitalism and consumerism. So he cracked down in every sphere imaginable — attacking the private sector, humiliating billionaires, reviving Communist ideology, purging the party of corrupt officials and ramping up nationalism (mostly anti-Western) in both word and deed.
In this regard, Xi follows a familiar pattern. In dictatorships where liberalization and growth have produced a middle class, the regime’s first response is to maintain its hold on power. In the era when South Korea and Taiwan were still autocracies, economic liberalization there gradually led to a growing middle class and calls for greater political freedom — prompting the regimes to crack down, often violently. Yet repression did not work and eventually gave way to democracy.
Follow Fareed Zakaria's opinionsFollow
The real question to ask is why China’s response to the changes unleashed by its market opening has been so successful. Why has Xi Jinping’s campaign of repression worked where other East Asian ones did not? The answer lies in a brilliant 2021 essay by China scholar Minxin Pei. Pei points out that China is almost unique in the world today. Nearly every country with a per capita income higher than China’s is either a democracy of some sort or an oil and gas dictatorship. (Petrostates enable a country to get rich without having to modernize its economy or society, because all it has to do is dig in the ground for natural wealth.) Why is China the great exception?
Pei revives an old distinction between authoritarian and totalitarian regimes. In the former, government is repressive but not all-encompassing. In the latter, such as China and the Soviet Union, the state dominates all spheres of life and does not allow an independent civil society to develop. The Chinese Communist Party dominates everything in China. When a social movement rises outside of the party, such as the Falun Gong, the party views it as a mortal threat and shuts it down.
At the heart of Xi Jinping’s worldview is his fear regarding the demise of Soviet communism. Xi expressed the view that this happened because the party leaders there lost faith in their ideology and their movement. He sees Mikhail Gorbachev as a foolish reformer who opened up the political system only to see the whole country collapse. The lesson: double down on Leninist party control.
In the conditions of a totalitarian state, Pei points out, the changes produced by economic growth lead to the need for more and more repression — producing, in China (and I would add Russia), a reversion to neo-Stalinism. Vladimir Putin and Xi are similar in recognizing that too much contact and commerce with the West can undermine their rule, inspiring them to search for ways to make their countries less dependent on the West and to consolidate their personalized rule.
The problem for Xi is that he is steering China on a very dangerous path. The state is now dominating the economy again and growth has slowed considerably. Enterprising Chinese businessmen are moving to Singapore and elsewhere. Areas of Chinese society that were once lively and innovative are closing down. Meanwhile, international hostility toward Xi’s expansionism is growing. Pei points out that the neo-Stalinist model bottles up all the forces of change, leaving only one door open — revolution.
As Pei notes, by 2035, China will have about 300 million college graduates. Will they be content to live quietly under Xi’s reign of repression?
The Washington Post · by Fareed Zakaria · October 6, 2022
11. Ukraine claims Russian infighting was behind Crimea bridge blast
Interesting speculation. This could be good PSYOP from Ukraine.
Ukraine claims Russian infighting was behind Crimea bridge blast
Was Crimea bridge explosion ordered by one of Putin's OWN commanders? Ukraine claims warring leaders of Russia's security factions were behind blast - as Western sources suggest it was plot by Moscow establishment to weaken Putin and trigger toppling
- Zelensky's presidential adviser alleged Russia was behind the bridge explosion
- He said it was a symptom of the infighting between FSB and defence ministry
- Russia has not yet assigned blame, claiming that a truck bomb caused damage
- But footage seemingly showed a mysterious wave moments before explosion
- It is thought a bomb-laden Ukrainian boat or drone could've caused the blast
By DAVID AVERRE and WILL STEWART FOR MAILONLINE
PUBLISHED: 07:00 EDT, 9 October 2022 | UPDATED: 07:48 EDT, 9 October 2022
Daily Mail · by David Averre · October 9, 2022
A leading Ukrainian presidential aide claimed this morning that the explosion which damaged a key bridge in Crimea may have been ordered by one of Vladimir Putin's warring commanders.
The 12 mile crossing over the Kerch strait links Crimea to the Russian mainland and is a major artery for Putin's forces that control most of southern Ukraine's Kherson region and for the Russian naval port of Sevastopol.
It was damaged in an explosion early Saturday morning which saw chunks of the bridge fall into the sea and a large fire break out.
The incident prompted gleeful messages from Ukrainian officials - though no claim of responsibility - and video footage of the bridge appeared to show a mysterious wave crest underneath the structure moments before the blast, prompting speculation that a Ukrainian-piloted boat or drone was likely behind it.
But Zelensky's presidential adviser Mykhailo Podolyak today alleged that the explosion was of Russian origin.
Russia's FSB secret service and private military organisations are at loggerheads with the defence ministry and are trying to undermine one another's credibility in bitter dogfight over the botched war, he alleged.
'FSB/PMC try to eliminate leadership of Defense Ministry/GHQ...Isn't it obvious who made an explosion? Truck arrived from RF [Russian Federation],' Podolyak said in a post on Twitter.
A Western diplomatic source added that the bridge attack could have been commissioned from inside the Russian establishment to fatally weaken Putin and trigger his toppling.
'It might be the SBU [Ukrainian secret service] but it also could be the first major sign of a bid from within Russia to incapacitate the Kremlin tsar,' the source said.
A key bridge linking Crimea to the Russian mainland over the Kerch strait is seen damaged and on fire following an explosion on Saturday morning
The 12 mile crossing over the Kerch strait links Crimea to the Russian mainland and is a major artery for Putin's forces that control most of southern Ukraine's Kherson region and for the Russian naval port of Sevastopol
Mykhailo Podolyak, a political adviser to Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelensky, claimed the explosion which damaged a key bridge linking Crimea to Russian mainland was likely an inside job
'FSB/PMC try to eliminate leadership of Defense Ministry/GHQ...Isn't it obvious who made an explosion? Truck arrived from RF [Russian Federation],' Podolyak said in a post on Twitter
Ukrainian president and ex-comedian Volodymyr Zelensky rediscovered his comic chops in a tongue-in-cheek weather report following yesterday's explosion at the bridge.
The Kyiv leader poked fun at the humiliating attack on Putin's supply line, making the audacious comments in his nightly video address posted on Telegram.
Zelensky said: 'Today was a good and mostly sunny day in our country. Over most of the territory, it was about 20 degrees Celsius and sunny.
'Unfortunately, it was cloudy in Crimea, although it was still warm. But however the clouds are, Ukrainians know what to do, and they know that our future is sunny.
'This is the future without invaders, on all our territory, in particular in Crimea.'
The explosion took place just hours after Putin's 70th birthday, with another of Zelensky's aides joking: 'Happy birthday, Mr President'.
The Kremlin had claimed the bridge, which was opened personally by Putin in 2018 to much fanfare in Russian-state media, was being protected by a maximum security operation.
Russia furiously claimed a truck bomb caused the blast and avoided apportioning blame.
Officials identified Samir Yusubov, 25, from the Krasnodar region in Russia, as the alleged owner of the red-coloured International Prostar truck thought to have exploded. They are still investigating who was driving the truck.
Images appear to show movement in the water under the bridge a split second before the explosion which brought down the road bridge and set fire to oil tankers
Russian law enforcement identified Samir Yusubov, 25, from the Krasnodar region in Russia, as the alleged owner of the red-coloured International Prostar truck, which, according to investigators, exploded on the Crimean Bridge
Russian Deputy Prime Minister Marat Khusnullin dispatched a team of divers to examine the bridge underwater
Russian divers are now examining the damage left by Saturday's blast on the Kerch bridge to Crimea.
Russian Deputy Prime Minister Marat Khusnullin said the divers would start work in the morning, with a more detailed survey above the waterline expected to be complete by day's end, Russian news agencies reported.
The team will inspect the bridge's foundations for structural integrity and will search for further evidence in relation to the blast, which killed three people.
'The situation is manageable - it's unpleasant, but not fatal,' Crimea's Russian governor Sergei Aksyonov assured reporters before threatening to retaliate over the blast.
'Of course, emotions have been triggered and there is a healthy desire to seek revenge,' he said.
It was not yet clear if the blast was a deliberate attack, but the damage to such a high-profile structure came amid battlefield defeats for Russia and could further cloud Kremlin reassurances that the conflict is going to plan.
On Saturday, Putin signed a decree for tighter security for the bridge, as well as the infrastructure supplying electricity and natural gas to Crimea, and ordered an investigation.
Daily Mail · by David Averre · October 9, 2022
12. Taiwan signals its chip firms will follow new U.S. rules on China
Taiwan signals its chip firms will follow new U.S. rules on China
Reuters · by Reuters
TAIPEI, Oct 8 (Reuters) - Taiwanese semiconductor companies attach "great importance" to complying with the law, the island's government said on Saturday, signalling they would comply with new U.S. export controls that aim to hobble China's chip industry.
The rules announced Friday by President Joe Biden's administration include a measure to cut China off from certain chips made anywhere in the world with U.S. equipment, vastly expanding its reach in its bid to slow Beijing's technological and military advances.
Taiwan, a major chip producer, is home to Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC) (2330.TW), the world's largest contract chipmaker and a major supplier to companies including Apple Inc (AAPL.O).
In a statement in response to the U.S. announcement, Taiwan's Economy Ministry said Taiwanese firms were law-abiding.
"Taiwan's semiconductor industry has long served global customers and attaches great importance to compliance with laws," it said.
"In addition to complying with domestic laws and regulations, it will also cooperate with the needs of international customers who place orders and the norms of customers in their countries."
Taiwan's semiconductor industry is a technological leader and continues to "maintain an advantage in the competition for international orders", the ministry said.
The government continues to maintain close contact with manufacturers and supports them in investing in factory expansion and supplying products to the world for technological development, the ministry said.
TSMC declined to comment on the U.S. rules, saying it was in its quiet period ahead of quarterly earnings next week. Smaller competitor United Microelectronics Corp (2303.TW) also declined comment ahead of its earnings release later this month.
Taiwan has its own concerns about China, especially efforts by Chinese companies to poach chip talent and technical know-how. The government tightly restricts Taiwanese chip investment in China, the island's largest trading partner.
Taiwan's worries have gained pace as China mounts regular military drills near the island in an attempt to force it into accepting Beijing's sovereignty.
The United States is Taiwan's most important international supporter and arms supplier, despite the absence of formal diplomatic ties.
Taiwan Economy Minister Wang Mei-hua will visit the United States next week to respond to what her office called "concerns" about supply chains and geopolitical issues. She will visit U.S. tech firms that are major customers of Taiwanese semiconductor companies.
Reporting by Ben Blanchard; Editing by William Mallard
Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles.
Reuters · by Reuters
13. U.S. Military Teaches Living Off the Land to Feed Future Warriors
Time to dust off all of our SERE doctrine and notes. Please go to the link for proper formatting and to view the photos.
U.S. Military Teaches Living Off the Land to Feed Future Warriors
Military leaders know they can’t rely on long supply chains in future wars, so they are teaching the lost art of foraging
https://www.wsj.com/articles/u-s-military-teaches-living-off-the-land-to-feed-future-warriors-11665234380?utm_source=pocket_mylist
By Ben KeslingFollow
| Photographs by Rachel Woolf for The Wall Street Journal
Oct. 8, 2022 9:10 am ET
CRIPPLE CREEK, Colo.—On the first day of training in the mountain forest on a recent fall day, Army Spc. Jennifer Evans struggled to properly sharpen a butcher’s knife. Two days later, she was expertly slicing roasts and steaks off a cow carcass and had learned to boil down the bones to make broth.
Spc. Evans was with a handful of military cooks being trained to butcher and prepare meat in austere conditions, skills that have the potential to make the U.S. military more nimble and combat-effective in the event of major conflict. The training, which began a few years ago as a pilot program for Green Beret cooks, recently expanded to include conventional units.
During two decades of conflict in Iraq and Afghanistan, the U.S. military has largely come to rely on bulky truck convoys or air resupply to provide soldiers not only bullets and fuel, but also every morsel of food, even at remote combat outposts.
Military leaders say such lengthy supply chains may not be workable in a potential future large-scale conflict and are preparing troops to be more able to live off the land. They are rolling out lessons on how to source all sorts of food, including meat, through local means.
Pvt. DeMarco Taylor, an Army culinary specialist, watches fellow troops skin a goat during an austere-butchering course.
The shift to foraging, the military term for sustaining a unit using local agricultural products and supplies, means military cooks like Spc. Evans need to know more than how to reheat prepackaged food. They need to know how to find and prepare meals for soldiers in remote locations who need protein-rich nutrition. And in a remote Colorado camp near Pikes Peak, she moved on from boiling beef bones to learning how to slice a fresh pork chop from a pig that had been butchered the day before.
Cooks can be considered afterthoughts in the military, she said. “But it’s not just opening a bag of rice and boiling water.”
The first field-butchering class came about in 2014 because the Green Berets were repeatedly getting bouts of diarrhea, according to Master Sgt. Myron Billingsley, a senior culinary specialist assigned to the Green Berets.
Special Forces often work in small teams in remote locations, where getting resupplied can be difficult. And the American gut sometimes isn’t prepared for local hygiene practices. Leaders realized they could bypass resupply headaches—and troops lost to dysentery—by teaching their cooks how to identify and purchase healthy livestock from local farmers, and then ethically slaughter and expertly butcher them. When those meats were combined with locally sourced items like rice and beans, Green Beret teams could be fed on the local economy.
Master Sgt. Myron Billingsley, a senior culinary specialist assigned to the Green Berets, helped devise a crash course in butchering skills for Special Forces cooks.
So Master Sgt. Billingsley decided to resurrect specialized training for their cooks, a skill that hadn’t been taught for at least a generation. At the time, he was stationed at nearby Fort Carson, Colo., when he sat down at a local restaurant with a local civilian butcher, Jason Nauert, and helped devise a weeklong crash course for cooks attached to Special Forces units to teach them butchering skills.
“That’s a lost art,” said Master Sgt. Billingsley. “If I’m in the middle of nowhere and someone brings me an animal, I can break it down.”
Since then, hundreds of troops have come through the course, including teams from the Air Force and Marine Corps.
On a recent day in the mountains of Colorado, Spc. Evans and the other Army cooks gathered around Mr. Nauert.
“Are you going to teach us how to use every part of the animal?” asked Sgt. Brenden Leal, a cook with the Fourth Infantry Division, a conventional Army unit that has recently begun training its cooks.
“Uh, yes,” Mr. Nauert replied to the group, most of whom said they had never learned how to cut a steak off a carcass.
Master Sgt. Billingsley said it wasn’t uncommon for Green Berets to leave cooks behind when they deployed, lacking respect for what a skilled chef can do. But in the years since he helped launch the field-butchering course, units often now ask for cooks who can leverage local sources of food and prepare healthy, protein-rich meals for the elite troops.
Instructor Jason Nauert shows troops how to butcher a cow in austere conditions.
Sgt. Brenden Leal, an Army culinary specialist, sharpens his knife.
Army culinary specialists skin and gut goats during their austere-butchering course.
Some Marines have also taken Mr. Nauert’s course. Lt. Col. Julian Tsukano, who until recently was in charge of the school that trained Marine cooks, said reliance on contractor-run chow halls—which were the norm in Iraq and Afghanistan—could leave a huge gap in readiness if there is another global conflict.
“We used to have butchers and bakers in the Marine Corps but they’ve gone away as we’ve gone to an industrial model of logistics,” he said.
It is a model where just about every bite for troops in Iraq or Afghanistan was trucked or flown into big bases. “We could build bases where we owned lines of communications and our supremacy was unquestioned,” he said.
But even in those countries, deployed troops darkly joked about the absurdity of driving convoys of supply trucks on bomb-laced roads so chow halls could have crab legs and ice cream.
Freshly butchered steaks cook over a fire during the austere-butchering course in the wilderness near Cripple Creek, Colo.
Jason Nauert, lead instructor of the austere-butchering course.
In other conflicts, like a potential war in the Pacific, Marines might be spread over thousands of miles and just as many islands and can’t depend on regular convoys to deliver ice cream, or even Meal, Ready-to-Eat rations, known as MREs, Lt. Col. Tsukano said.
“This is kind of back-to-the-future,” he said. “Open up the old books.”
SHARE YOUR THOUGHTS
What skills should be part of basic training for U.S. soldiers? Join the conversation below.
Bret Devereaux, a research affiliate at the University of North Carolina who studies ancient militaries, said that the current war in Ukraine gives important lessons about taking supplies from local populations, referencing stories of Russian troops’ looting and mistreating people in occupied areas.
“The Russian method of ‘foraging’ is what foraging usually looks like,” he said. “For a lot of armies, that’s not a big deal, but for the U.S. Marines, you don’t want them stealing washing machines.”
Marines teach ethical foraging, in part, because it is the right thing to do and, in part, because a cooperative local populace can be a help on the battlefield.
“If you mistreat the locals, then God help you,” said Dr. Devereaux. “They’re going to tell the enemy where you are.”
Army culinary specialists gather around a fire in the woods near Cripple Creek, Colo.
Write to Ben Kesling at ben.kesling@wsj.com
14. Russian Divers To Examine Crimea Bridge - The Moscow Times
Russian Divers To Examine Crimea Bridge - The Moscow Times
The Moscow Times · by AFP · October 9, 2022
Divers were to inspect the waters beneath the Crimea bridge on Sunday a day after a huge blast damaged Russia's key road and rail link to the annexed peninsula, killing three people.
"We are ordering the examination by divers, they will start work from six in the morning," Russia's Deputy Prime Minister Marat Khusnullin told state media late Saturday after the early morning explosion.
He also said the "first results" of Russia's inspection of the bridge were due Sunday.
Authorities in Russia and Crimea have tried to reassure the population and downplayed the attack on the bridge, which has major symbolic importance for the Kremlin.
Officals said car and train traffic had resumed over the bridge, with Moscow's transport ministry saying Sunday that long-distance passenger trains from Crimea to Russia were "moving according to the standard schedule."
The Russian-installed leader of Crimea, Sergei Aksyonov, said late Saturday that authorities were assessing whether it is safe to let busses through.
He said people who want to get back to Russia could take a car or a ferry to cities such as Krasnodar and Anapa.
Moscow said a truck bomb exploded setting off a massive blaze, but has stopped short of blaming Ukraine.
Some officials, mainly in Crimea and Russian-occupied areas of Ukraine, have nonetheless called for retaliation.
Aksyonov urged Crimeans to remain "calm" and said the "situation is under control."
But he added: "Of course, there are emotions and there is a healthy desire to seek revenge."
The Moscow Times · by AFP · October 9, 2022
15. How social media ‘censorship’ became a front line in the culture war
Some good background and useful historical overview in this article.
How social media ‘censorship’ became a front line in the culture war
By Will Oremus
October 9, 2022 at 7:00 a.m. EDT
The Washington Post · by Will Oremus · October 9, 2022
Technology
Online content moderation wasn’t always a partisan issue. That began to change in 2016.
By
October 9, 2022 at 7:00 a.m. EDT
Early last year, amid mounting criticism that social media was spreading disinformation about covid-19, Facebook expanded an unprecedented campaign to police falsehoods by banning what it called “debunked claims” about the virus. Among them: The claim that covid was “man-made” and had leaked from a lab in Wuhan, China.
To the Biden administration and the scientific establishment, Facebook’s efforts to rein in misinformation were too little, too late, given how its network had helped false and damaging claims to go viral in the first place. But others complained that the crackdowns squelched legitimate debate about the frustrating performance of public health authorities — a view that was partly vindicated when China’s lack of transparency prompted prominent scientists to declare the lab-leak theory “viable” and demand further investigation.
In May 2021, barely three months after it imposed the ban, Facebook backtracked: “In light of ongoing investigations into the origin of Covid-19 and in consultation with public health experts,” the company said, “we will no longer remove the claim that Covid-19 is man-made from our apps.”
What people can and can’t say online — and the role of Big Tech in making those calls — has emerged as a critical fault line in American politics. The left cries for content moderation to tamp down disinformation, racism and misogyny. The right decries that as censorship and demands the right to free speech.
In recent months, several flash points have brought this battle to the fore. Last week, the Supreme Court agreed to hear a case that accuses YouTube of abetting terrorism by recommending content from the Islamic State. Last month, a federal court upheld a Texas law that would prevent social media platforms from removing or limiting posts on the basis of political viewpoint.
Meanwhile, the world’s richest man, Elon Musk, is pushing to close a deal that would give him sole control of Twitter, whose decision to ban President Donald Trump after the attack on the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021, has reverberated as perhaps the single most divisive act of content moderation in internet history. Musk has said he would reinstate Trump.
“We’re approaching a pivotal moment for online speech,” said Daphne Keller, who directs the Program on Platform Regulation at Stanford University’s Cyber Policy Center. “The political pressures on content moderation have increased tremendously.”
How online forums set and enforce rules for what users can post wasn’t always so divisive. When the consumer internet was born in the mid-1990s, lawmakers in both parties shared a desire to see American tech firms thrive. That consensus survived early battles over pornography, copyright infringement, breastfeeding photos and terrorist propaganda.
But as in so many realms of American society, the 2016 election marked the beginning of the end of that bipartisan comity.
Christopher Cox, a former Republican congressman from California, now serves on the board of Netchoice, a tech industry lobbying group that is fighting the Texas law. Cox said he can understand conservatives’ frustration with some of the platforms’ decisions, which he called an “abuse of power.”
But the remedy is not to give more power over speech to the state, he argued, “Politicians exercising control over the political speech of others is a very dangerous recipe.”
Protecting ‘the little guy’
In 1995, Cox helped craft the provision that paved the legal path for today’s internet giants to moderate online speech. At the time, the political stakes seemed so low that the national media barely noticed.
The consumer internet was just blossoming, with millions of Americans beginning to log on to services such as CompuServe, Prodigy, and AOL. To the extent most lawmakers considered online speech at all, their chief concern was limiting the availability of pornography to minors.
Cox and Rep. Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) had a different concern. Earlier that year, a libel judgment against Prodigy held that its attempt to police its forums made it responsible for users’ content. Cox and Wyden worried the judgment would stifle the fledgling internet.
So they hashed out a statute that gave online service providers broad latitude to host, distribute and moderate content posted by users without being held liable when they posted something illegal. Part of a broader bill called the Communications Decency Act, it came to be known simply by its location: Section 230.
In a recent interview with The Washington Post, Wyden, now a senator, recalled that he saw the internet companies as “the little guy,” and wanted to give them leeway to develop their innovative technologies without being squashed by heavy-handed regulations. He thought empowering them to moderate their own sites would lead to a cleaner, safer internet without the need for government censorship of online speech.
Cox, in a separate interview, added: “The question is who’s in charge. There are going to be decisions made about what content is on these websites. Should the government be in charge of it? There are all sorts of reasons that would be a bad idea. It’s subject to all sorts of abuse.”
Early court decisions went on to interpret Section 230 even more broadly than Cox and Wyden had anticipated, establishing sweeping immunity for user-posted content. That set the stage for the rise of sites like Yahoo, Google, MSN. Later came YouTube, which is owned by Google, and Facebook. They could host, aggregate, and organize vast pools of user content without having to worry too much, from a legal standpoint, about whether it might be false, hurtful, or even dangerous.
The result was a potent business model that, compared with traditional media, dispensed with paid content creators in favor of unpaid ordinary users, and replaced paid editors with software algorithms designed to surface the most relevant, engaging or tantalizing content.
Yet the consumer internet was never an unfettered free-speech zone. The most successful online platforms discovered early that they had to make and enforce basic rules or they’d be overrun by pornography, spam, scams, harassment and hate speech — and that would be bad for business.
Even when an internet forum starts with a goal of allowing freewheeling discourse, “they quickly run into the inevitable fact that you have to moderate in order to have a commercially viable and user-friendly product,” said Evelyn Douek, a Stanford law professor who researches online speech regulations.
The need to screen and review millions of posts per day on sites like YouTube and Facebook gave rise to a shadow industry of commercial content moderation involving huge teams of workers spending their days making rapid-fire calls about whether to take down posts that users have flagged as offensive or obscene. To preserve the illusion of a “free-speech zone,” tech companies tend to distance themselves from that work, often outsourcing it to poorly compensated contractors in far-flung locales, said Sarah T. Roberts, author of “Behind the Screen: Content Moderation in the Shadows of Social Media.”
Even so, some decisions proved too thorny or consequential for tech companies to sweep under the rug.
Everything in moderation: Key moments in the battle over online speech
February 1996: Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act immunizes websites from liability for content their users post
December 2008: Facebook develops its first formal rulebook for content moderation after mothers protest its removal of breastfeeding photos
August 2014: The antifeminist Gamergate movement blurs the line between online speech and real-world harm
May 2016: Facebook is shaken by allegations of anti-conservative bias; Russian trolls use social media to sow division ahead of the U.S. election
August 2017: Tech companies crack down on right-wing groups that used social media to organize the deadly Charlottesville rally, but exempt Trump from their rules
April 2018: Congress amends Section 230 to hold websites liable for online sex trafficking
March 2020: Platforms ban misinformation about Covid-19 even as their algorithms amplify it
May 2020: Trump threatens to revoke Section 230 after Twitter fact-checks his tweet equating online voting to fraud
October 2020: Twitter and Facebook suppress a New York Post story about Hunter Biden’s laptop ahead of the election
January 2021: Major platforms suspend or ban Trump after Jan. 6 Capitol riot
May and September 2021: Florida and Texas pass laws banning social media “censorship” of political speech
April 2022: Elon Musk offers to buy Twitter and take it private, promising to restore “free speech” policies
October 2022: Supreme Court agrees to hear two cases that call for a reconsideration of Section 230
1/13
End of carousel
In 2006, a shocking video appeared on the then-new YouTube: Grainy and shaky, the amateur footage showed deposed Iraqi president Saddam Hussein being hanged by members of the new Iraqi government, some of whom shouted insults in his final moments. The hanging had been closed to the media; the video exposed a vengeful and undignified execution at odds with official reports.
The decision of whether to leave the video up or take it down fell to Google’s deputy general counsel, a young lawyer named Nicole Wong. “What we ended up deciding was that the video of the execution was actually a historic moment, and it was actually important that it be shared and seen,” Wong said in a 2018 conference.
Two years later, an angry group of moms protested outside the Palo Alto offices of the three-year-old social media site Facebook, which had been taking down breastfeeding photos for violating its rule against nudity. The furor spurred Facebook to develop its first internal rule book for what users could and couldn’t post, drawing fine-grained, if somewhat arbitrary, distinctions to delineate between wholesome and prurient images, among other things.
Previous content policies had amounted to, “If it makes you feel bad, take it down,” former safety lead Charlotte Willner said. She recalled that one of the guiding motivations amid the lack of regulation of online content was executives’ desire not to run afoul of powerful people, especially public officials who might try to sue or regulate them.
Despite the occasional flare-ups, the big platforms cultivated an image as guardians of free speech abroad — one Twitter official boasted in 2012 that his firm was “the free-speech wing of the free-speech party” — while maintaining a studied political neutrality at home.
But as social media’s influence on politics and social mores has grown, it has become clearer that free speech for some users could mean real harm for others.
In 2014, large subcultures of angry, mostly male, gamers targeted a handful of women in the video-game industry and media with vicious, coordinated online threats, which at times spilled into real-world attacks. That movement, known as GamerGate, challenged tech companies’ claims to neutrality, because it pitted the free-speech claims of one group of users against the privacy and safety of others, said Tarleton Gillespie, a principal researcher at Microsoft and author of the book “Custodians of the Internet.” Neutrality, in this case, meant allowing the harassment to continue.
The illusion of social media’s neutrality with respect to partisan politics began to crumble two years later, with effects that are still reverberating.
Fake news and real anger
In May 2016, the tech blog Gizmodo ran a story alleging that liberal Facebook employees were secretly suppressing news stories from right-leaning outlets in the social network’s influential “Trending” news section. While prioritizing mainstream news sources over overtly partisan outlets might seem reasonable to some, conservatives saw it as a “gotcha” moment that proved Silicon Valley tech giants were imposing their liberal values on their users.
Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg embarked on a high-profile apology tour, meeting personally with top conservative politicians and pundits, ordering bias training for his employees, and laying off the journalists in charge of the Trending section.
While the company’s leader was busy doing damage control, however, his platform was being exploited in troubling new ways in the run-up to the November 2016 U.S. presidential election.
A cottage industry of fake news sites, some run by teenagers in Macedonia, was booming on Facebook as its fabricated articles — which often had a pro-Trump bent — sometimes received more likes and clicks than factual news reports.
It emerged after Trump’s election that profit wasn’t the only motive for the flood of manipulative political content on Facebook. Russian operatives had also been using fake accounts, groups and pages on the social network to spread polarizing content aimed at turning Americans against one another.
Attempts by Facebook employees to address both the fake news problem and Russian information operations were undermined, The Post later reported, by its leaders’ fear of further angering conservatives.
By 2017, many on the left had come to blame Facebook and social media for helping to elect Trump, pressuring tech companies to take tougher stands against not only fake news but the president’s own frequent falsehoods and racial provocations.
In response, tech companies that once prided themselves on their lean workforces, tacitly accepting some ugliness as the cost of doing business, began spending heavily on human content moderators. They developed software to help automate the process of flagging posts that might violate their increasingly complex rule books.
While their efforts swept up inflammatory posts by Trump’s more fervent supporters, Facebook and Twitter were loath to take action against Trump himself. Instead, they concocted various ad hoc exemptions to allow him to remain on the platform.
Social media also shared blame for the rise of a more vocal and visible white supremacist movement, which used online forums to radicalize, recruit, and organize events such as the deadly “Unite the Right” rally in Charlottesville in 2017. To liberals, that reinforced the link between online speech and real-world violence, making content moderation literally a matter of life and death. That link would be driven home in 2018 as hate speech and lies about Muslims that spread on Facebook helped fuel a genocide in Myanmar against the country’s Rohingya minority.
At the same time, the right became increasingly suspicious of tech companies’ efforts to tackle those problems domestically, viewing them as censorial and politically motivated. The platforms’ actions against right-wing accounts and groups involved in the Charlottesville violence galvanized the far right to begin setting up its own “free speech” social networks, such as Andrew Torba’s Gab.
In what has since become a common rallying cry on the right, Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Tex.) criticized “large tech companies putting their thumb on the scales and skewing political and public discourse.”
By the end of 2017, an industry that had previously enjoyed widespread trust and popularity among Americans — the same industry Wyden had seen as “the little guy” in need of protection two decades earlier — had come to be known by left and right alike as “Big Tech.” The epithet, an echo of past crusades against Big Business, Big Banks, Big Tobacco and Big Pharma, conjured not only power but corruption, a force that needed to be reined in.
The first blow to Section 230 came in 2018, when Congress passed and Trump signed a bipartisan bill to fight online sex trafficking by removing the liability shield for sites that facilitated it, whether knowingly or not. Sites that hosted adult “personals” ads shut down altogether rather than face lawsuits, a change that many sex workers said made them less safe. No longer able to advertise and screen clients online, they returned to streetwalking to drum up business.
Since then, Congress has struggled to find a path forward. In 2018, Republicans held hearings investigating Facebook’s alleged suppression of pro-Trump influencers Diamond and Silk, while the left railed at social media’s role in the rise of conspiracy theorist Alex Jones. A month after Facebook said that banning Jones would run “contrary to the basic principles of free speech,” it did just that, responding to mounting pressure that also led Apple, Spotify, YouTube and, eventually, Twitter to ban him over his false statements that the Newtown, Conn., school shooting in 2012 was a hoax.
By that point, nobody believed that tech company policies were being enforced consistently — or objectively. So Facebook came up with a novel solution: a semi-independent, nonprofit review panel, called the Oversight Board, staffed with experts on freedom of expression and human rights from around the world.
By 2019, Trump allies such as Sen. Josh Hawley (R-Mo.) were calling for changes to Section 230 that would require platforms to be politically neutral to receive legal protections. “Google and Facebook should not be a law unto themselves,” Hawley said. “They should not be able to discriminate against conservatives.”
The outbreak of covid-19 in 2020 brought new tests for the platforms. Large swaths of the right, including Trump, rejected scientific guidance on how to stop the spread.
Again, the companies managed to infuriate both left and right. Their algorithms rewarded enticing yet unsubstantiated conspiracy theories, such as a viral video titled “Plandemic” that advanced a slew of conspiratorial claims about the virus’s origins, how it spreads, and the safety of masks and vaccines. At the same time, their moderation systems — by now partly automated, with human moderators sent home because of covid restrictions — scrambled to remove such content under new policies prohibiting misinformation about the virus.
Meanwhile, the platforms were slowly getting tougher on Trump as he began to predict a “rigged election” and deride mail-in ballots as “fraudulent,” laying the groundwork for his attempt to dispute the results of the coming presidential election. The tech companies’ reluctance to penalize a sitting president was colliding with their policies against election misinformation — one of the few, narrow categories of falsehoods, along with covid-19 and vaccine misinformation, that they had vowed to police.
In May 2020, Twitter hid a Trump tweet behind a fact-checking label for the first time. The White House retaliated with an executive order directing the Federal Trade Commission to reinterpret Section 230 to weaken or remove tech platforms’ liability shield. (It didn’t.) Seven months later, Trump threatened to veto a bipartisan defense spending bill unless Congress first repealed Section 230. (It didn’t, and Congress later overrode his veto.)
A galvanizing moment for the right came in October 2020, just weeks before the election in which Democrat Joe Biden unseated Trump.
The New York Post, a right-leaning tabloid, published a story about illicit materials found on a laptop that had reportedly belonged to Biden’s son Hunter. Facebook and Twitter later said they had been warned just days earlier by federal authorities to be on the alert for foreign influence operations related to the election, including possible “hack-and-leak” maneuvers. Both reacted swiftly and aggressively, with Facebook using its algorithms to limit sharing of the Post’s story on its network. Twitter banned all links to the article and suspended the Post’s account.
The moves drew outrage from the right, whose leaders saw Silicon Valley tech companies wielding their power to bury a journalistic report from a major newspaper in what smelled like an attempt to help the Democratic candidate in the upcoming election. Even some critics from the left wondered if the platforms had overstepped by substituting their judgment for the editorial judgment of an established news organization — albeit a tabloid with some infamous missteps on its record.
While questions remain about the laptop story, a later investigation by The Washington Post appeared to validate at least part of the New York Post’s reporting. Twitter’s then-CEO, Jack Dorsey, eventually apologized for what he described as an honest mistake, while Facebook’s Mark Zuckerberg recently acknowledged his company got it wrong as well.
Content moderation in the crosshairs
The platforms finally suspended Trump after the Jan. 6, 2021, attack on the U.S. Capitol, on the grounds that his continued posts disputing the election risked inciting further violence. Twitter banned him permanently, and Facebook and YouTube issued indefinite suspensions.
The moves, which came only after Trump had lost his grip on power, reinforced the sense among critics on both sides that the tech companies were making up the rules as they went, with one finger held to the political winds and one eye on their rivals as each jostled to avoid sticking its neck out alone.
Between the Hunter Biden story and the Trump ban, some conservative leaders had seen enough. They were ready for the government to take back some of the power it had previously entrusted to internet companies.
In May 2021, Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis (R), signed a state law banning large social media platforms from “censoring” posts by elected officials, candidates for office, or major news organizations. Texas followed with a law that went even further, preventing platforms from limiting the online speech of any Texan — not just politicians or news outlets — on the basis of political viewpoint. Both laws also required online platforms to be more transparent about their rules and the justification behind their moderation decisions.
Numerous other states have drawn up similar bills, which could take effect if the Texas and Florida laws survive their ongoing legal challenges.
In a ruling that swept aside decades of precedent, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit in September upheld Texas’s social media law, setting the stage for courts to reinterpret the First Amendment for the digital age.
The Washington Post · by Will Oremus · October 9, 2022
16. The Kerch bridge attack is devastating for Putin
The Kerch bridge attack is devastating for Putin | The Spectator
The bridge was vital for supplying Russia's war effort in Ukraine
8 October 2022, 6:08am
The Spectator · by Lisa Haseldine & Svitlana Morenets
It’s hard to overstate the impact of the bombing of the Kerch bridge. Opened four years ago to great fanfare, the 12-mile long bridge came to embody Vladimir Putin's claim on conquered Crimea. It symbolised his ability to protect and supply the area and reunify the ‘Russian world’ (Russkiy mir).
At about 6am local time, just after Putin celebrated his 70th birthday, CCTV footage shows a huge explosion ripping through both the rail and road bridge. Parts of the road bridge have collapsed into the sea, destroying two of its four lanes. It has since reopened to some passenger traffic and plans to reopen to trains, but not to trucks - which suggests its substructure has been damaged too much to allow military use.
Russian state media is reporting that a supposedly explosive-filled truck filmed driving towards the blast on CCTV is responsible – the TASS news agency has said that the owner of the truck has been traced to the Russian region of Kuban'. It added that the explosion was all the worse because the truck "set fire to seven fuel tanks from the train that was on the railway part of the train." Some Western analysts have, however, suggested that the force of the explosion indicates something more powerful was used.
️ Another video of the explosion on the Crimean bridge.
Follow @Flash_news_ua pic.twitter.com/CCgFnsfxxK
— FLASH (@Flash_news_ua) October 8, 2022
Ukraine has yet to come out and claim it – its secret service has published a taunting Tweet but so far there has been nothing from Zelensky. This leaves open the possibility that this was a self-inflicted strike by Russia, a so-called ‘false flag’ attack to facilitate an escalation of the conflict. Strikingly, the Kremlin and the Russian state media have so far refrained from blaming Kyiv, simply calling it an ‘act of terrorism’. This runs contrary to almost every other incident in the war so far, with the Kremlin using every opportunity to twist the narrative away from itself as the aggressor.
But then again, Ukraine usually delays its announcements – it claimed the responsibility for major explosions in Russian military bases in Crimea weeks after they happened. The same was true with the destruction of Moskva, the Russian warship bombed earlier this year.
That the Russian state media has chosen to report on this incident at all demonstrates how significant it is. In recent weeks, the media has more openly been reporting and commenting on Russian war losses, hinting at the frustration felt domestically by the disastrous course of Putin’s war. It suggests that to ignore the Kerch bridge explosion would have caused further damage. Nevertheless, independent Russian news site Meduza has claimed that the Kremlin has issued instructions to state outlets to downplay the incident: the bridge has been ‘damaged’ not ‘destroyed’.
Closer look at the collapsed road span of the Crimean bridge pic.twitter.com/ZW1OOAKdns
— OSINTtechnical (@Osinttechnical) October 8, 2022
The Russian war effort has been severely impacted by the loss of the Kerch bridge. It had become one of just two railroads transporting supplies and troops to the Ukrainian front. With it now destroyed, and against the background of an increasing number of Russia territorial losses, the pressure is on Putin’s army to keep control of Melitopol and the railway that runs through it to keep supply routes to the Front open.
Alongside this railway, the logistics of the Russian army's entire southern group depends on keeping control of the M14 road running from Mariupol on the Russian border, through Melitopol, to Kherson. There are no other routes left open to them. The clincher, of course, is that Melitopol itself is already within range of Ukrainian attacks.
Ukraine had, for the past few months, made its intention clear to strike the bridge if given the chance. Russia had assumed the Kerch bridge was beyond their reach but threatened reprisals if it was hit.
This attack now raises the obvious question about how Putin will respond and whether this is the event that could trigger the deployment of his nuclear arsenal. The State Duma has just declared the attack a ‘declaration of a war without rules’, while military politicians and commentators are already demanding a solid response from the Kremlin – to not do so ‘would conclusively prove we are weak’. Pro-Putin Duma politician Sergei Mironov called for an end of the 'special military operation': 'It's time to FIGHT!'
In a statement, Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov said that there was currently no timeline for when the bridge would be restored and fully reopened. While the road bridge has now partially reopened (one lane was undamaged), all trains to Crimea are currently suspended and a ferry service between Russia and Crimea is being set up instead. The absence of a Stakhanovite declaration to rebuild the bridge as soon as possible hasn’t gone unnoticed. Crimean officials have also confirmed they are working on opening a land corridor to the territory through the ‘new region’ of Kherson, illegally annexed to Russia just last week.
Putin has reportedly set up an investigation committee to find out what happened, and a criminal investigation has been launched. After initially denying that there had been any casualties in the explosion, the investigation committee has now announced three bodies have been found, presumably, they say, passengers travelling on the bridge when the blast occurred.
The response from the Kremlin so far has been surprisingly muted: Putin himself is yet to release a statement; there has been little rhetoric from officials baying for Ukrainian blood in retaliation. By contrast, it seems the mood in Crimea is one of panic. The Crimean authorities have moved to reassure residents that the peninsula has 55-days worth of supplies (the Kerch bridge also brought in commercial foodstock). They have also had to squash excitable rumours that rationing in supermarkets might be introduced. Tourists who want to leave have been promised that they will be ferried back to Russia by boat, and queues several miles long have begun to form at petrol pumps.
It is tempting to see the Kremlin's reaction as a tacit recognition by Russia that it is losing the war with Ukraine, but with Putin, one shouldn’t be so sure. The calls by pro-war commentators within Russia to turn the 'special military operation' into a full-blown war indicates that Putin will find himself under pressure to respond in a way that satisfies any potential dissent. That this incident isn’t, or won’t be, used by Russia to escalate the conflict cannot be ruled out.
WRITTEN BY
Lisa Haseldine & Svitlana Morenets
Lisa Haseldine is The Spectator's assistant online editor. Svitlana Morenets is a Ukrainian journalist currently at The Spectator and writes Ukraine in Focus, a weekly email with the latest updates on the war.
17. How likely is Putin to nuke Ukraine?
Excerpts:
Even in conventional warfare, the Russian military finds itself unable to attack now due to the lack of manpower and organization. In nuclear warfare environment, apart from questionable morale, the Russians would fall short of proper training, equipment, and protection.
In other words, for Putin, going nuclear in Russia’s failing war means creating more irreversible issues with little to no desired effect.
“Putin is attempting to force Kyiv to the negotiating table by annexing Russian-occupied territory and threatening nuclear use,” the ISW said.
"Putin’s call for negotiations and implicit nuclear threats are aimed at both Ukraine and the West; he likely incorrectly assesses that his nuclear brinksmanship will lead the United States and its allies to pressure Ukraine to negotiate.”
How likely is Putin to nuke Ukraine?
kyivindependent.com · by Illia Ponomarenko · October 7, 2022
When Russia’s Vladimir Putin is in trouble, he threatens to start a global nuclear holocaust.
The Russian president has a long history of nuclear brinksmanship, always implicit in his rhetoric yet never manifesting in reality.
And now, as his war of conquest in Ukraine is failing, Putin is again trying to use the nuclear card against Ukraine and the West – and he is reassuring the world that this is not a bluff.
During his Sept. 30 speech in which he declared the illegal annexation of four Ukrainian oblasts, Putin again said he would employ “all means” available to defend so-called “Russian lands.”
Putin’s pseudo-historic conspiracy theories, defiant tone, and aggressive allusions are trying to send a message: Do not mess with the trigger-happy man with the bomb.
His demand is simple: Kyiv must stop its counteroffensive, and the West must stop supporting Ukraine and reach a deal with the Kremlin.
But how likely is Putin to walk the walk?
Nukes on the battlefield
As Russia’s positions on the battlefield deteriorate, the likelihood of Putin nuking Ukraine depends on the price it would have to pay for its actions, namely if the West confirms its readiness to inflict a devastating response.
“The more confident Putin is that nuclear use will not achieve decisive effects but will draw direct Western conventional military intervention in the conflict, the less likely he is to conduct a nuclear attack,” wrote the U.S. think tank Institute for the Study of War (ISW).
According to a 2022 report by the Federation of American Scientists, Russia remains the world’s leading nuclear power, with a total inventory of 5,977 warheads at its disposal.
But employing its strategic nuclear triad to incite a full-fledged thermonuclear war is the scenario in which the Kremlin is least likely to achieve a guaranteed end.
Concerning Russia’s war in Ukraine, it makes more sense to consider the use of Moscow’s tactical nuclear weapons.
Strategic nuclear weapons have large yields and are intended to inflict devastating damage far from the battlefield on anything from cities to critical infrastructure, thus undermining the target's ability to wage war.
Low-yield tactical nukes are designed to have a less significant impact and to be used on battlefields in military situations. Typically, tactical nuclear weapons include missiles, gravity bombs, artillery shells, or equipped torpedos with the explosive power of a couple of kilotons.
A mushroom cloud raises up in the sky from the Grable nuclear artillery shell detonation carried out by the U.S. military on May 25, 1953 (CORBIS)
By contrast, the atomic bomb used on Hiroshima in 1945 was around 15 kilotons. The RS-24 Yars, one of Russia’s main strategic intercontinental missiles, can bear warheads with a couple of hundred kilotons each.
Critically, tactical nuclear weapons have never been used in combat.
It’s impossible to say precisely how many tactical warheads Russia currently has in its arsenal. A 2021 U.S. Congressional Research Service study estimated the Russian stockpile at between 1,000 to 2,000 warheads.
Point of no return
Moscow is currently facing the urgent task of trying to stop Ukraine’s counteroffensive, which has already retaken large swathes of the country’s eastern and southern regions.
The Kremlin has tried to rectify the situation in two ways.
The first is the announcement of “partial mobilization” in Russia. However, the conscription of thousands of barely trained, poorly organized, and unmotivated men is unlikely to reinforce Russia’s depleted military units or help Moscow reverse its downward course in 2022 or 2023.
The second is the ongoing pressure on Europe via natural gas supplies. The Kremlin openly pushes the narrative that Europe will freeze to death in winter unless it ceases to support Ukraine’s war effort. Despite this, NATO and most European states continue to provide Ukraine assistance and are actively finding ways to compensate for curtailed Russian gas exports.
Tactical nuclear weapons may be a logical Plan C for Russia.
However, a single tactical nuke will not bring Russia its desired results on the battlefield in Ukraine. Ukraine’s military remains relatively unconcentrated, and one tactical nuke is not going to inflict critical damage on Ukraine’s war effort along the 1,000-some-kilometer front line.
The Kremlin would inevitably have to use multiple strikes to derail Ukrainian offensives.
Even a single nuclear strike would spell the end of the Non-Proliferation Agreement, escalating the war and sparking outrage not only from NATO and the West but also India and China, which have already voiced their dissatisfaction with Russia’s war.
Russia's use of nuclear weapons would also risk direct retaliation by NATO. In a statement on Sept. 25, U.S. National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan warned that Russia would face “catastrophic consequences” in the event of a nuclear strike against Ukraine.
The grave political and military consequences of such a step would greatly outweigh Russia’s potential gains.
Moreover, a swift response from the West following the use of a single tactical nuke would preclude Russia from inflicting subsequent strikes.
The Kremlin may also resort to nuclear terror by targeting strikes at Ukrainian cities or critical infrastructure or undertake demonstration strikes to incite fear.
However, the ISW suggests that “such attacks would be highly unlikely to force Ukraine or the West to surrender.”
The U.S. think tank did note that “there would be tremendous gambles of the sort that Putin has historically refused to take.
"Ukraine’s government and people have repeatedly demonstrated their will to continue fighting. And the West would find it very challenging simply to surrender in the face of such horrific acts because of the precedent such surrender would set.”
In this regard, Western intelligence can monitor Russian nuclear facilities and sound the alarm bells should Russia start to make the necessary preparations. The world will not be unprepared should Russia decide to use tactical nukes in combat and will thus have the opportunity to respond.
The question also arises as to whether Russia’s military in Ukraine is ready to operate in an environment of nuclear warfare.
Conventional warfare has already created grave issues with morale among Russian troops in Ukraine. Such problems have precipitated the phenomenon of “the 500th,” the Russian military members that refuse to participate in hostilities, as well as harsh criminal punishment by the Kremlin for "the refuseniks.”
It is an open quest whether Russia’s unmotivated, barely trained, and coerced military would operate effectively after seeing mushroom clouds on the battlefield. Using low-yield nuclear weapons in combat implies that they will be close to friendly forces.
The rules for the effective use of tactical nuclear weapons mean the blasts would be to create gaps in Ukrainian defenses. And Russian mechanized units would have to immediately rush through those holes deep into the Ukrainian rear, straight through just-targeted areas.
Even in conventional warfare, the Russian military finds itself unable to attack now due to the lack of manpower and organization. In nuclear warfare environment, apart from questionable morale, the Russians would fall short of proper training, equipment, and protection.
In other words, for Putin, going nuclear in Russia’s failing war means creating more irreversible issues with little to no desired effect.
“Putin is attempting to force Kyiv to the negotiating table by annexing Russian-occupied territory and threatening nuclear use,” the ISW said.
"Putin’s call for negotiations and implicit nuclear threats are aimed at both Ukraine and the West; he likely incorrectly assesses that his nuclear brinksmanship will lead the United States and its allies to pressure Ukraine to negotiate.”
_______________________________________________________
Note from the author:
Hello! My name is Illia Ponomarenko, the guy who wrote this piece for you.
I hope you found it useful and interesting. I work day and night to bring you quality stories from Ukraine, where Russia is waging the biggest war in Europe since WWII. My little homeland, Donbas, is now the site of the worst fighting. We are helping to keep the world informed about Russian aggression. But I also need help from every one of you — to support Ukrainian wartime journalism by donating to The Kyiv Independent and becoming our patron.
Together, we can help bring peace to Ukraine.
kyivindependent.com · by Illia Ponomarenko · October 7, 2022
18. What Afghans Want the Rest of the World to Know
Conclusion:
Afghanistan is not far from becoming the country we were in the Taliban’s first regime. But some things are different now. Few in rural communities have access to the internet, but those who do can organize and resist in new ways. In secret, behind closed doors, Afghanistan is still breathing.
Hajera told me there was no hope. I want to believe that there is a little.
What Afghans Want the Rest of the World to Know
The country is, once again, the worst place in the world to be a woman.
OCTOBER 9, 2022, 7 AM ET
SHARE
The Atlantic · by Bushra Seddique · October 9, 2022
Hajera gave birth to her daughter, Sarah, in Kabul two weeks after the Taliban took over Afghanistan last summer. Hajera is 35 and worked as a government economist. She and her husband already had two sons and were happy to be welcoming a daughter. But they soon lost their jobs, and the Taliban erased the rights women had gained over the previous two decades.
An Afghan women’s-rights activist had connected me with Hajera, who was too afraid to share her last name. “We had a job,” she told me. “We had money. We had a home. We had a country. We had a family.” Now, she said, “we have nothing.”
Afghanistan is, once again, the worst place in the world to be a woman.
I asked her: What did she hope would happen now? “Hich omid nist,” she said. There is no hope.
I was born in 1999, two years before the September 11 attacks and the subsequent invasion of my country. For Afghan women, the overthrow of the Taliban marked the beginning of a luckier time. Schools were opened to girls. Women were no longer imprisoned at home—they were allowed to work, and would no longer be beaten if they chose not to wear the burqa.
Freedom came too late for my mother and her generation. They had prayed and protested for these rights. But many were married off as children. My mother was married at 16. Our mothers and grandmothers refer to these times as the “unblessed years.”
Now that the time of unblessing has returned, it has become clear that as we grew up, my generation was witnessing not the beginning of a new future, but an anomalous moment in our country’s sad history. We had been enthusiastic, energetic, happy, and hopeful. On August 15, 2021, Afghanistan returned to zero. Or even less than zero, because the path to freedom feels even longer and more dangerous now, and Afghan women are so very tired.
Bushra Seddique: My Escape from Afghanistan
I am a refugee in the United States now, but I have been talking with my family and friends, with former teachers and colleagues, to understand what they have been going through and what they want the rest of the world to know.
Girls studying in a secret school in Afghanistan (Daniel Leal / AFP / Getty)
Faryal is a 14-year-old girl in Kabul. As with many of the women I spoke with for this story, I’m using only her first name to protect her privacy. She should be in ninth grade this year at Hussain Khail High School, where she loved her classes, even though the students had no chairs or tables and studied in hot, overcrowded tents. She used to wake up every morning and leave for school with her 12-year-old brother, but now she watches from the window as he boards the bus. She stays home all day, doing nothing, looking at her old books.
Soon after returning to power last year, the Taliban banned secondary school for girls. The Ministry of Education indicated that these schools would reopen once the Taliban settled on a dress code for female students and teachers “in accordance with Islamic law and Afghan culture and traditions.” But everyone knows it was a lie.
Faryal told me she misses her friends and the playground, where they would braid one another’s hair. She asked me with a crying voice questions I couldn’t answer. Why have they only closed our schools, not the boys’ schools? Are the Taliban at war with women?
Not everyone is waiting for the Taliban to open the schools. Some people are running secret schools for girls out of their homes. One person told me that she knew of at least two such schools in Kabul and three or four elsewhere in the country, but there may be many more.
Recently, I spoke with a teacher at one of these secret schools. Ayesha Farhat Safi, 22, teaches roughly 80 teenage girls in the basement of her family’s house in Kabul. She doesn’t make any money doing it, and she could be arrested or beaten. She told me, “A lot of students are reaching out to us, but we don’t have enough space to have them all participate, and it hurts me.”
NPR and other news organizations have reported on female students’ attempts to get around the ban. Some schools that teach young girls legally are secretly instructing teenagers as well. When Taliban inspectors visit the schools, the older girls scatter and hide.
None of these secret schools is close enough to where Faryal lives for her to attend. But she knows of them, and dreams about going to one someday. She told me she doesn’t care if the Taliban catch her.
Taliban guards fired into the air to disperse women protesting outside the Ministry of Education in August. (Nava Jamshidi / Getty)
I spoke with a 26-year-old woman who, until the government fell, had worked for the Ministry of Education, analyzing national enrollment data. She loved her job and the difference she was making in the country. Now she has no job, and many of the schools she watched open have been closed. She told me she feels small and weak, an “observer of the miseries of women.”
Her former colleagues at the ministry have told her that many teachers who taught in girls’ schools have been reassigned to teach boys. Others have left the country. She has had many opportunities to leave, but she doesn’t want to go. She teaches English classes for girls and women, as well as classes in computer coding and other technical skills. Some are streamed online, but others are in person. She told me that her girls gather in a secret location where they pretend to be studying the Quran and Sharia. She believes that the only way we can help Afghan women is to empower them through education. She told me, “I want to stay until it becomes impossible for me to stay.”
Saira Saba, 42, is a former teacher too. She helped organize a protest in August in front of the Ministry of Education, in Kabul, and held a sign reading Bread, Work, Freedom. News reports said about 40 women participated in the protest, though Saba told me there were even more: mothers and daughters, women who’d never learned to read and women who’d worked as professors at universities.
Saba participated despite knowing that the Taliban were arresting and beating female protesters. She said, “We want a country where we have our rights. We want a country where we will be able to work. We want a country where we know who our president is and who our leaders are. And where we have the right to choose our own leaders.”
Women at a United Nations refugee camp on the outskirts of Kabul in July (Wakil Kohsar / AFP / Getty)
Of course, it’s not only women who are suffering in Afghanistan. The Taliban are also targeting religious and ethnic minority groups. The economy is paralyzed; the health-care system has broken down; people are starving.
Recently my mother told me that she was walking back from the bakery with three loaves of bread when she decided to share the food with some beggars she passed by. But there were far more hungry people than there were loaves of bread. She says there are more beggars now than she can ever remember seeing in Kabul, and more kids on the streets than in schools.
We lost our freedom of speech the same day we lost our country. There is no constitution, and Taliban commanders set up their own courts to judge individuals on whatever charges they want, whenever they want. Terrorists are finding a haven in Afghanistan, and deadly bombings of civilians in mosques and markets have increased.
But the fear and oppression are worse for Afghan women, because they can’t fight back; they’ve been systematically removed from society, imprisoned in their homes once again. My conversations with the friends I grew up with get shorter and less cheerful each time we speak. They have stopped planning for their futures—they can see that there is no future. Some of them have accepted the first marriage proposal that came their way, no matter who it came from, because they think their only escape from their current circumstances is to find a husband.
My sister’s closet is filled with colorful clothing. But when she goes out she can only wear black; she says it’s like the whole nation is in mourning, and the people in the streets look like zombies. She used to wear lipstick and eyeliner; she no longer bothers, because she knows no one will look her in the eyes. She says that, covering her face wherever she goes, she has forgotten what she even looks like.
It would be nice to think that, in the privacy of their own homes, women have remained free; that they could turn their back on an oppressive government that doesn’t see them as fully human, and continue, at least in their own personal relationships, to be who they’ve always been. But that’s not the case. By removing women from the public sphere, the government has also reestablished the patriarchy within the home, where men are once again judge and jury.
I want to believe that there’s something to be done—that foreign governments or institutions or refugees like myself could somehow help the women back home. The United Nations has restricted the travel of some Taliban leaders. The United States has imposed sanctions on Afghanistan to pressure the Taliban to create a democratic government in which women and other minorities have equal rights. It has also frozen $7 billion of Afghan money in U.S. banks, and announced that it will use about half of that for a fund to support the Afghan economy, in ways that will help the people without enriching the government.
But human-rights activists are calling for more penalties. The UN could ban all Taliban leaders from traveling; Twitter could cut off access (as Facebook has done already) to the official Taliban accounts as well as those operated by anyone lobbying on the Taliban’s behalf. Additional humanitarian aid could be provided on the condition that women are allowed to work, go to secondary school, and participate in politics. Governments and nonprofit groups could help women’s-rights activists by providing financial support and political backing. They could also set up and fund online education and more secret in-person schools.
Afghanistan is not far from becoming the country we were in the Taliban’s first regime. But some things are different now. Few in rural communities have access to the internet, but those who do can organize and resist in new ways. In secret, behind closed doors, Afghanistan is still breathing.
Hajera told me there was no hope. I want to believe that there is a little.
The Atlantic · by Bushra Seddique · October 9, 2022
19. Here’s your first clear look at the next-generation ‘AbramsX’ main battle tank
Photo and video at the link: https://taskandpurpose.com/tech-tactics/abramsx-main-battle-tank-video/
Here’s your first clear look at the next-generation ‘AbramsX’ main battle tank
Finally.
BY JARED KELLER | PUBLISHED OCT 8, 2022 6:30 PM
taskandpurpose.com · by Jared Keller · October 8, 2022
SHARE
After months of veiled teases, General Dynamics Land Systems has finally revealed its first clear look at its next-generation main battle tank concept.
In a video released Saturday, the defense contractor showed off the so-called “AbramsX” technology demonstrator trundling along at a testing facility, spotlighting the tank concept’s “transformational technology” ahead of the system’s full unveiling at the Association of the U.S. Army’s annual meeting in Washington D.C. next week.
Details on the Abrams X are scant at the moment, but according to GDLS, the new tank concept features “reduced weight for improved mobility and transportability,” allowing for a similar tactical range to the M1A2 Abrams variant currently in service with roughly half the fuel consumption and a significantly smaller crew.
As our colleagues at The War Zone reported when GDLS first started teasing the next-generation tank concept in previous months, the AbramsX will likely feature several new weapons systems and sensors, including a 30mm Kongsberg Protector RS6 Remote Weapon Station mounted on top of its main turret, what looks like an advanced 120 mm main gun, some variant of the Trophy active protection system that’s seen testing on the Army’s current M1 Abrams fleet in recent years and refreshed electro-optical and infrared turrets.
Not only is it deadly, featuring “AI-enabled lethality” based on the company’s Katalyst Next Generation Electronic Architecture for advanced mobility and target acquisition, manned/unmanned teaming (MUM-T), and various autonomous systems, but the AbramsX is silent too — sort of.
“The AbramsX’s hybrid power pack supports the U.S. Army’s climate and electrification strategies, enhances silent watch capability, and even allows for some silent mobility,” according to GDLS, suggesting that the new Abrams concept might achieve some level of relative stealth when moving across the battlefield compared to previous interactions.
Subscribe to Task & Purpose Today. Get the latest military news, entertainment, and gear in your inbox daily.
According to GLDS, the AbramsX will function as a “key node in lethal battlefield networks” and serve as a bridge between the currently-fielded Abrams SEPv3 and the recently-unveiled SEPv4 iteration to some sort of “future tank,” whatever that might look like.
The SEPv3 upgrade to the Abrams “incorporates turret and hull armor upgrades, mine blast improvements, reactive armor tiles, lightweight belly armor, improved countermine equipment, Improvised Explosive Device (IED) jamming equipment, a Total Integrated Engine Revitalization (TIGER) engine, an upgraded transmission, an Auxiliary Power Unit (APU), improved power generation & distribution, Ammunition Data Link (ADL) for smart munitions,” according to Army budget documents.
Meanwhile, the SEPv4 upgrades reportedly include “new laser rangefinder technology, color cameras, integrated on-board networks, new slip-rings, advanced meteorological sensors, ammunition data links, laser warning receivers and a far more lethal, multi-purpose 120mm tank round,” as Army officials told Warrior Maven way back in 2016.
When soldiers can expect to get their hands on the AbramsX remains to be seen: the service only received its first half-dozen initial production versions of the SEPv3 back in October 2017 and started testing the SEPv4 this year.
The latest on Task & Purpose
Want to write for Task & Purpose? Click here. Or check out the latest stories on our homepage.
Jared Keller
Jared Keller is the managing editor of Task & Purpose. His writing has appeared in Aeon, the Los Angeles Review of Books, the New Republic, Pacific Standard, Smithsonian, and The Washington Post, among other publications. Contact the author here.
Tanks
Vehicles
taskandpurpose.com · by Jared Keller · October 8, 2022
20. That time the military faked a vampire massacre to fight rebels
I recall the story of an SF NCO or Warrant Officer doing something similar with chemlights in Haiti- His voodoo was stronger than the local witch doctor's.
That time the military faked a vampire massacre to fight rebels
An Air Force officer needed to do psychological warfare. He turned to the supernatural. Kind of.
BY NICHOLAS SLAYTON | PUBLISHED OCT 9, 2022 9:25 AM
taskandpurpose.com · by Nicholas Slayton · October 9, 2022
The U.S. military has done some strange things in its existence. It created fake armies full of inflatable tanks. It trained soldiers to read minds. It has footage of UFOs. And then there was that time it faked a series of vampire attacks as part of a counterinsurgency strategy.
Seriously.
In the aftermath of World War II, the United States found itself as one end of a reorganized geopolitical fight. The U.S. and its allies were on one end, the Soviet Union’s sphere was the “second world” and then there was the “third world,” the post-colonial states.
In the recently independent Philippines, there was also one of those struggles. The anti-Japanese rebel group the Hukbalahap, also known as the Huks, had been reformed by communists to fight against the central government. And the United States has no interest in letting the Huks’ insurgency take hold, even though they had been on the same side during World War II. And that’s where the then-relatively new Central Intelligence Agency got involved.
Edward G. Lansdale was an Air Force officer who worked with the CIA’s precursor the Office of Strategic Services during World War II. He had served in the Philippines and with the Huks insurgency on the rise, he was called back to help fight it. He and the CIA started to develop a plan to not just fight the Huks, but sway Filipinos from joining them.
The solution Lansdale came up with was vampires. Well, technically an aswang. In the Philippines, an aswang is a kind of catch-all term for various monsters in folklore, such as werewolves and vampires. But for Lansdale, it was clearly the vampiric take on aswang that was the plan.
Subscribe to Task & Purpose Today. Get the latest military news, entertainment, and gear in your inbox daily.
A psychological warfare squad was brought in. The squad went around to villages, spreading rumors that an aswang was in the countryside — actually where the Huks were based. Then they started hunting the Huks. The squad would kidnap the end person of a Huk patrol. Then they killed the person by puncturing the next, hanging the corpses upside down and letting the blood drain. The Huks would come back and think an aswang had got their comrades. And so would the villagers, the CIA figured.
This was paired with other attempts to bring supernatural horror to warfare. Lansdale had his psyops squad paint the “eye of god” on buildings during the night, targeting people assumed to be allied with or aiding the Huks.
And somehow, against all odds, the plan to fake a vampire attack using corpses of kidnapped Filipino rebels sort of worked. Over several months from 1952 to 1954, the Huks lost ground and their rebellion was put down. Lansdale, meanwhile, continued his work there, before CIA Director Alan Dulles had him take his anti-communist counterinsurgency plans to Vietnam in 1954.
The latest on Task & Purpose
Want to write for Task & Purpose? Click here. Or check out the latest stories on our homepage.
taskandpurpose.com · by Nicholas Slayton · October 9, 2022
De Oppresso Liber,
David Maxwell
Senior Fellow, Foundation for Defense of Democracies
Senior Fellow, Global Peace Foundation
Senior Advisor, Center for Asia Pacific Strategy
Editor, Small Wars Journal
Twitter: @davidmaxwell161
Phone: 202-573-8647
email: david.maxwell161@gmail.com
|