McGraw Teaching and Learning in the Era of Generative AI

March 17, 2026

Dear colleagues,


A basic functional understanding of generative AI is useful for all educators. In Your Students Need an AI-Aware Professor (Chronicle of Higher Education, May 5, 2025), Mark Watkins offers a compelling reason for why instructors should care about their own functional AI literacy: without it, students are left to navigate this technology on their own in the absence of practical guidance from their teachers. Even if you do not permit the use of AI in your class, functional AI literacy might make you better equipped to develop realistic and fair policies surrounding the use of generative AI and articulate them in a way that is clear to students.


Taking inspiration from Stanford’s AI literacy framework, we offer ideas below for how to develop your own and your students’ AI literacy in four domains: functional, informational, ethical, and educational.


We conclude with an interview of Jeffrey Smith, who—with Jamie Caldwell—taught ENV221: AI for Global Good in the fall. Their course is fascinating for multiple reasons, including how carefully they balanced teaching each of these four domains of AI literacy.


Sincerely,


Jessica Del Vecchio, Mona Fixdal,

Alex Hollinghead, and Colleen Richardson

 

Functional AI Literacy

 

Functional AI literacy is the understanding of the technology itself; how it works, how to use it, and what it is capable of.

Key components of this kind of literacy include:

  • Understanding the set of technologies that constitutes artificial intelligence, including predictive, generative, and agentic.
  • Understanding how generative AI works. This includes basic vocabulary and mental models of AI, as well as more advanced technical expertise.
  • Recognizing what different generative AI tools are capable of.
  • The ability to identify when generative AI tools have been incorporated into existing teaching, research, or productivity tools.
  • Knowing how to make effective use of generative AI tools, for instance, with prompting techniques.

We recognize that—given the rapidly changing landscape of artificial intelligence—it can be difficult to keep track of new developments and tools. Mark Watkins suggests that instructors set aside ninety minutes per week to explore, read, and reflect on AI. His Substack Rhetorica offers useful articles on AI developments for higher education. A deeper examination of AI is offered by Arvind Narayanan and Sayash Kapoor in their book AI Snake Oil (Princeton University Press, 2024). Their Substack AI as Normal Technology is also a valuable resource.


If you would like to explore AI in community with colleagues at Princeton, please join one of the McGraw Center’s AI related sessions. We’ve highlighted some of our events at the bottom of this newsletter as well.

 
 

Informational AI Literacy

 

Informational AI literacy is a subset of information literacy. The Association of College and Research Libraries has defined information literacy as “the set of integrated abilities encompassing the reflective discovery of information, the understanding of how information is produced and valued, and the use of information in creating new knowledge and participating ethically in communities of learning.”

You are likely already teaching some aspects of information literacy in your classes. You might, for example, be assigning students a research paper in which they need to gather and vet sources, or encouraging the analysis of the audience for whom a particular article is written, or facilitating a discussion of the creation processes of different publications. As AI becomes more ubiquitous, you might consider including AI information literacy as part of your course as well.


Some activities you might try include:

  • Ask students to use an AI tool to generate a list of sources on a particular topic. Then, ask them to use the library databases to do the same kind of search and compile the sources. Have them analyze the different bibliographies, being sure to check the veracity of the AI-provided sources. Finally, ask students to reflect on the different processes and how each supported (or did not) the goal of learning more about the topic.
  • In discussions about the way new knowledge contributes to your field, talk to students about the challenges AI poses to citation. Have them generate a response to a prompt using AI, then have them fact check the response. For accurate information, ask students to find (and vet) sources that show it is correct.
  • Ask students to prompt AI and reflect on how different prompts change the output they receive. What does the exercise reveal about the way the AI functions?


It can be challenging to give up valuable class time to AI literacy, so choosing the right scale of activity or assignment is crucial. The more you can relate the exercises to your course content and the skills you are helping students to develop, the better. We are happy to consult with you as you develop activities or assignments. Please reach out to Jessica Del Vecchio.

 
 

Ethical AI literacy

 
Academic Integrity

As a cluster of technologies, artificial intelligence is not unique in raising moral questions; one might point to any number of concerns with other software and hardware we use in teaching and learning too. However, the ethical challenges associated with generative AI seem particularly significant and complex.

Ethical AI literacy includes:

  • Understanding the ethical implications of how AI models are built and trained. That includes, for instance, appreciating how biased data and biased algorithms can affect AI outputs.
  • Recognizing some of the environmental impacts AI technologies have, especially high consumption of electricity and water resources, and the production of electronic waste.
  • Understanding when the use of AI is in violation of scholarly integrity norms.
  • Being able to identify when the use of AI might be in violation of copyright and intellectual property laws.
  • Awareness of the impact AI might have on different groups of people, especially marginalized communities.
  • An appreciation of some of the privacy and security issues related to the use of AI.

We encourage you to discuss the ethics of AI with your students. You might, for instance, ask them to consider whether uploading articles or notes to a Large Language Model (LLM) is in violation of copyright laws, or how sharing their own work with an LLM might compromise their own intellectual property. Princeton University Library’s AI and copyright, which provides an overview of major debates and court cases, can be a useful starting point. For a discussion of academic integrity, Princeton University’s Scholarly Integrity website provides resources and strategies that help integrate policies into teaching. Princeton’s Center for Information Technology Policy has events and resources for students, staff, and faculty on a range of topics related to technology ethics.

 
 

Educational AI literacy

 
Student reflection

Educational AI literacy concerns how the use of AI interacts with the learning process. That, in turn, requires an understanding of how students learn, and considerations of which skills and competencies you want your students to master.

Generative AI can undermine the cultivation of knowledge and skills. As the McGraw Center resource on evidence-based learning suggests, students learn by actively engaging with course material and assignments, for instance, when they summarize a reading, draft an outline, work through a problem, and develop their own argument. By taking over those tasks, AI can short-circuit learning and off-load the cognitive processes that learning requires. AI can also create illusions of understanding (see, for instance, Artificial intelligence and illusions of understanding in scientific research by Lisa Messeri and Molly Crockett, Nature, 2024).


There seems to be a disconnection between how students perceive the usefulness of AI and the negative impact instructors maintain that it has. According to a survey by AAC&U in collaboration with Elon University, a large majority of faculty observe that the use of AI diminishes students' critical thinking skills and decreases their attention spans. On the other hand, while some students see the dangers of AI, many students report that AI can be useful in academic work (see, for instance, How is Princeton’s youngest class using AI? in The Daily Princetonian, October 22, 2025).


While we acknowledge the negative impacts AI can have on learning, we also recognize that for many instructors teaching AI is an important curricular goal. AI can also offer opportunities for creativity and innovation in support of other course goals. In the interview below, Jeffrey Smith explains that it was not necessary for their students to learn how to code an AI tool from scratch. Rather, by allowing students to use AI, it was possible for them to achieve the more important course goal of developing AI prototypes for their community partners.


We encourage you to raise the risks and opportunities AI poses for learning directly with your students. You might ask them, for instance, what skills or cognitive processes they are off-loading if they ask AI to summarize a reading for them. Or, if they ask an AI tool to take notes, make flash-cards, or draft writing assignments, what steps in the learning process are they missing out on? You can find a number of other questions you can encourage your students to reflect on in Considerations for Using GAI for Engagement, Learning, Studying and Exam Prep at the McGraw Center’s website.

 
 

Interview with Jeffrey Smith

Jeffrey Smith is an Associate Research Scholar in the High Meadows Environmental Institute. His research focuses on understanding the present-day patterns of biodiversity and developing models to forecast the potential future of species in a changing world. This past fall, he co-taught ENV 221: AI for Global Good, with Jamie Caldwell, Research and Teaching Laboratory Manager at the High Meadows Environmental Institute.  Jeffrey kindly agreed to talk to McGraw’s Mona Fixdal (MF) about the course.

MF: What motivated you and Jamie to develop this course?

JS: Jamie and I are working at the intersection of biodiversity conservation, climate change, infectious diseases, and sustainable development. We’ve often worked with fairly advanced statistical analyses, geospatial modeling techniques etc. and wanted to look at the potential of AI to contribute to helping address global good or the sustainable development goals. 


We were cognizant of the fact that AI also comes with a lot of trade-offs. There might be some potential for it to help address global good—to help alleviate poverty, alleviate hunger, address climate change, secure clean drinking water, and access to clean air. But, at the same time it can contribute to issues around climate change, create more demand for electricity, more demand for water, more demand for data centers, it can propagate biases that might reinforce issues of inequity across racial, gender, and socioeconomic lines. That tension is interesting, particularly because so much of the public discourse has been so polarized: either AI is portrayed inherently as the best thing that’s ever happened for humanity, or as something that’s going to doom us all.


When we were developing the course, we both thought that there are lots of cases where it is quite useful, and also probably lots of cases where it isn’t. So we wanted to ask: How can we think critically about where and how to apply AI in a way that’s advancing global good rather than hindering us from meeting that abstract goal?


MF: Would you say that the course was an effort to teach AI literacy?

JS: It definitely was. The students had a combination of technical skills development and information about the present day landscape of sustainable development. We split the lectures into those that were focused on how to build a chatbot, how to use image recognition software and audio recognition software, and how to use AI to make an automation type of workflow. The other lectures asked how we can apply that knowledge to specific sustainable development goals. 


MF: What were the main goals of the class? What did you want your students to walk away with? 

JS: The first learning goal was to give students a familiarity with currently available AI tools and how we can apply them. So rather than just using a chatbot, how do we build a chatbot? Or how do we build an automation workflow? Or how do we build something that does image recognition? 


A second learning goal was to give them background information about the Sustainable Development Goals, how to think about them in a critical sense, the history of these goals, how they are structured, and how they have guided international action and international development.


And then the third goal was to think critically about the intersection of AI and the Sustainable Development Goals, particularly with a focus on areas where it could provide benefits or help advance those specific goals or areas. We also asked where it might not enable progress towards meeting those goals, or actually hinder progress towards those goals. 


The last goal was how to assess the accuracy and sustainability of these tools, as well as monitoring any biases that might be coming through. So it was really about both developing skills and then thinking critically about how to use them in the context of sustainable development.


MF: For the final group project, students worked with an external NGO. How did you establish these collaborations and what did the projects look like?

JS: Early in the semester, we paired students with organizations that are working to implement the Sustainable Development Goals. It was a combination of organizations Jamie and I had worked with, like the World Bank and the Natural Capital Project, and local partners that we found through the Program in Community-Engaged Scholarship (ProCES), like New Jersey Future, the Camden Dream Center, Food Bank of South Jersey, and Sustainable Princeton. 


The way we pitched it to the partners was to recognize that they’ve probably had some conversations in their organization about using AI to do a particular thing, but at the same time limited resources to explore and implement their idea. So we asked them, “What’s that project that you’re curious about doing with AI?”


For example, the Food Bank of South Jersey said that they’d often get calls after hours from partners like Costco or Wegmans, trying to deliver food or donate food. They wanted a tool to manage off-hours requests. The students worked to develop a prototype that would take in information from whoever it was, log it in a spreadsheet, and send out confirmation emails. It was an automation and chatbot integrated together.



MF: So, obviously, in this course, AI tools were an integral part of class work and you encouraged students to use it. But you still wrote an AI policy. How did you draw that line between desirable and undesirable uses of AI?

JS: One of the easiest ways to build an AI tool is by asking a different AI tool, “how do I build this tool?” We didn’t care as much if students were learning the code necessary to create their prototype, we just wanted them to make something that works. But we also wanted to design assignments that would be more difficult to have AI write.


In the final project there was a group component, i.e. the AI prototype, a report, and the in-class presentation. And in addition, there was an individual paper component where we asked students to describe what had happened over the course of the semester: what was the initial ask from the partner, what were the obstacles you encountered, how did you address them as a team, how did your team decided to divide up the work amongst different people, and what skills you developed over the course of the semester?


We also asked them to reflect on how the class caused them to rethink their different perceptions on AI. That information would be difficult to generated by AI. We hoped it would cause students to think critically about what they were engaging in, and that it would let us see whether or not they were really engaging with the project. We thought that that structure of the assignment would be less conducive to them just using generative AI.


MF: What did you learn about Princeton students’ ideas about AI by teaching this class?

JS: I think the overwhelming sentiment that the students came into the course with was a skepticism of the utility of AI for global good. At the same time, there was a sense that it’s inevitably going to permeate many dimensions of society. So the initial mindset was, “this is something I want to learn more about because I think it’s inevitable, even if I don’t think it’s a good idea.“


Over the course of the semester the one thing that I think most groups came to realize is that AI as an abstract concept can be quite problematic for global good, or for reaching the sustainable development goals. But AI narrowly defined can be quite good. A lot of the students who worked in these group projects had, like, really clear examples at the end. They often came to the conclusion that they had built a tool that made a positive impact, at least in a local context, or at least in a specific context.


I think there’s still a lot of larger societal concerns for students, for instance about who has control over AI technologies, about persistent biases in AI technologies, about potential risks, and about lacking the proper governance or regulatory structures. I think a lot of students are thinking really critically about who holds the levers of power when it comes to how these technologies are being deployed, in addition to just, like, whether or not the technology is good or bad.

 
 

Events

 

Faculty Discussion: AI Resilient In-Class Activities


Join us for a conversation with Bradley Dickerson, Assistant Professor in Princeton’s Neuroscience Institute, about how he made his course “AI resilient” by adding active learning to his lectures; turning an out-of-class writing assignment into an engaging in-class activity; and using group work to encourage accountability on longer term assignments.

March 18, 2026

12:00 pm – 1:00 pm

Faculty Special Event: Pedagogy, Practice and Policy in the Era of Generative AI


Save the date for a daylong symposium on how AI is reshaping teaching and learning at Princeton and how we might respond.

May 19, 2026

9:00 am – 4:00 pm

Faculty Workshop: Navigating the AI Landscape: An Exploration of Common Tools


In this session, we will provide an overview of commonly available AI tools, and give you an opportunity to critically explore their capabilities for teaching and learning.

June 9, 2026

10:00 am – 11:00 am

 

© The Trustees of Princeton University