Living with Wolves
Alert: Section 1709
March 4, 2011


Visit our website

Our Report to Congress


Send us an email



Our hope that the U. S. Congress would move to protect endangered wolves was short-lived, lasting only a few days. As we warned in our last email, bad anti-wolf bills continue to wait their turn, bearing deadly consequences for all wildlife. Once again, we need your best effort to contact Senators who hold the fate of wolves, and the Endangered Species Act, in their hands.


In the final hours of Friday, U.S. Senator Daniel Inouye of Hawaii introduced the Senate version of the Continuing Resolution (CR) to fund the nation's budget. Sadly, this new version carries the same deadly news for wolves that was contained in the House of Representatives budget bill. It appears that this new wolf rider (Section 1709), promoted by Senator Jon Tester of Montana, is the only anti-environmental rider to resurface in the Senate version of the CR. It contains exactly the same sad language as a rider in the House version of the bill, introduced there by Representative Mike Simpson of Idaho. It is important that our Senators be reminded that the wildlife of this nation belongs to each and every citizen, not to individuals in any one state.   

If you believe, as we do, that the protection of wolves should be determined by sound science and biology, and that wolves should not be treated like a political football, please pick up your phone and call as many Senators as you can.


If vulnerable animals, fish and birds can be killed by the whim of anyone who finds them inconvenient, where will this end? Certainly not with wolves, who are in the sad position of being first in line.


Wildlife protection is not a budget priority. A matter of this importance to our nation, overturning a generation of soundly considered protection for wildlife, without adequate discussion, has no place tacked onto a budget bill and being fast-tracked through the Senate.


Will Senators be there over the weekend to receive your call? Some offices may have message services active, or staff on the ground. If you can't get through, please make every effort to call on Monday, as early as possible, since we hear that this bill may move forward in the Senate as early as Tuesday.     


Section 1709 seeks to remove wolves from the protections of the Endangered Species Act (ESA). It calls for the reissuance of the April 2, 2009 decision by Interior Secretary Salazar to delist wolves as an endangered species. That decision was found to not be in compliance with the ESA and was rightfully overruled by a federal court.


Disturbingly, the Section also prohibits any future "judicial review." This proposed legislation actually excludes one of our three branches of government, the judicial branch, from any future involvement. If passed, it cannot be challenged in our federal courts.


Until wolves are ready to be delisted based on the guidelines set by the ESA they should remain protected.


When you call, tell them that it is Section 1709 of the Continuing Resolution that you are concerned about. We are providing below a list of the members the U.S. Senate that may be willing to fight for this issue or that we feel should hear from you.


You can remind them that during the lame duck session in December, Senator Cardin of Maryland rightfully objected to and stopped an effort by Idaho Senators Risch and Crapo to seek a last-minute unanimous consent vote to delist wolves. Senator Cardin called this earlier attempt an effort "to solve politically what should be done by good science," and said that such legislation would undermine the ESA. He was right and those concerns are still as valid today as they were then.


Please take a moment to look over this list and call the office of any or all Senators you can, especially if you live in a state they represent. Give their offices a call and politely state your opinion.  An effort on your part can lead to big results, but if you want to have your position heard, you must do it Monday morning.


Thank you for your on-going support and diligence. Your voice does matter.









Please note there are Senators who are already on our side on this issue and others that should be.


Call Monday morning or leave a message over the weekend or do both.  


If you wish to find a Senator not on this list, you can find them here. 


Barbara Boxer  


Phone: 202/224-3553  


Max Baucus  


Phone: 202/224-2651  


Benjamin Cardin  


Phone: 202/224-4524


Thomas Carper  


Phone: 202/224-2441  


Kirsten Gillibrand  

New York  

Phone: 202/224-4451  


Frank Lautenberg  

New Jersey  

Phone: 202/224-3224


Jeff Merkley  


Phone: 202/224-3753 


Bernard Sanders  


Phone: 202/224-5141  


Tom Udall

New Mexico

Phone: 202/224-6621


Sheldon Whitehouse

Rhode Island

Phone: 202/224-2921


Michael Bennet


Phone: 202/224-5852


Jeff Bingaman

New Mexico

Phone: 202/224-5521


Maria Cantwell


Phone: 202/224-3441


Richard Durbin


Phone: 202/224-2152


Al Franken


Phone: 202/224-5641


Daniel Inouye


Phone: 202/224-3934


Tim Johnson

South Dakota

Phone: 202/224-5842


Mark Kirk


Phone: 202/224-2854


Amy Klobuchar


Phone: 202/224-3244


Mark Pryor


Phone: 202/224-2353


Harry Reid  


Phone: 202/224-3542 


Debbie Stabenow


Phone: 202/224-4822


Mark Warner


Phone: 202/224-2023


Ron Wyden


Phone: 202/224-5244






Section 1709. Before the end of the 60-day period beginning on the date of enactment of this division, the Secretary of the Interior shall reissue the final rule published on April 2, 2009 (74 Fed. Reg. 15123 et seq.) without regard to any other provision of statute or regulation that applies to issuance of such rule. Such reissuance (including this section) shall not be subject to judicial review.