Alaska Public Media Alaska At-Large your news window on Washington DC

March 30, 2023

What Peltola says post-Nashville

Like so many similar massacres, the horror of Monday’s school shooting in Nashville is evolving along two paths: Grief and political response. Or lack of response.


I keep thinking about how two House Democrats reacted this week.


First, Alaska Congresswoman Mary Peltola. She used her five minutes in a hearing on Tuesday — the day after the Nashville shooter killed three adults and three children — to “give a plug for Second Amendment rights and good values.”


“You look at some of the tragedies that are occurring, and those aren’t hunters. Those aren’t kids that have grown up with hunting and the good values that, I think, hunting and hunting families provide,” she said.


It was a painful moment for many Alaska Democrats who voted for her, who want to see her support gun control, particularly a ban on AR-15-style weapons.


By coincidence, Juneau retiree Ben Muse got a letter from Peltola’s office on Monday, laying out her position on guns. It seems to be a form letter that just happened to arrive on the same day as the Nashville shooting. Muse, disappointed, posted the letter on Twitter.

Several Alaskans noted the contrast between Peltola’s response now and what she tweeted last May, before she was elected to Congress: 

The thing is, after the Uvalde school shooting, Congress broke its standstill and enacted the biggest gun control bill in 30 years. It had funds for school security, mental health treatment, red-flag laws and closed the so-called “boyfriend loophole.”


Then, in July, the U.S. House passed an assault weapons ban. It died in the Senate for lack of support. And that was back when Democrats had majorities in both houses of Congress.


Peltola is both a moderate and a pragmatist. It affords her some fluidity on polarizing issues that is sure to drive a large segment of her base to fury several times a month. 


She’s far from the only lawmaker drawing anger from gun control advocates this week. The congressional reaction to this shooting is decidedly muted. 


“I’m a realist,” Senate Judiciary Chair Dick Durbin, D-Ill., said yesterday, when asked about the possibility of passing gun legislation, according to The Washington Post.


One of the most liberal senators, Ed Markey, D-Mass., responded with a bill calling for $250 million to study gun violence.


“We know this is not a panacea,” Markey said, in a remarkable understatement.


Politically speaking, Peltola has nothing to gain by supporting an assault weapon ban now. 


A good number of Alaskans love their guns and are absolutists about the Second Amendment. Peltola, as a subsistence hunter and a gun owner, has some bona fides to avoid alienating them. And the chances that meaningful gun control law could pass this Congress? Nil.


But many Alaskans can’t fathom why it should be so easy to buy an AR-15 to shoot 9-year-olds, and they want their congresswoman to take a stand against the madness.


Which brings me to the second Democratic response to Nashville that I can’t get out of my mind: that of Rep. Jamaal Bowman, D-N.Y. It was really something. Take a look.


“More guns lead to more death!” he shouted outside the House Chamber yesterday. He called Republicans cowards. He refused to be silenced. “Calm down? Children are dying! Nine-year-old children.”


I don’t imagine that Bowman advanced anyone toward a legislative solution. But, given the horror at Covenant School in Nashville and the powerlessness of Congress, maybe screaming into the void is the most appropriate thing he can do.


Sorry to end the newsletter on such a dark note. Maybe I’ll have sunnier topics for you when I’m back in your inbox in two weeks.

- Liz Ruskin

lruskin@alaskapublic.org

Follow me on twitter: @lruskin

Know others who need our Alaska At-Large newsletter? Forward this email so they can subscribe free here.

Peltola speaks of Second Amendment rights, not gun control, following Nashville shooting

Rep. Mary Peltola plugged "Second Amendment rights and good values."

READ MORE 

UAA to house Ted Stevens papers

The collection fills 4,800 boxes, not counting a warehouse full of memorabilia.

READ MORE  

Arctic policy conference brings international leaders to Anchorage. Russia not included.

The Arctic Encounter Symposium runs through tomorrow evening in downtown Anchorage.

READ MORE 

Judge likely to rule next week on halting Willow construction on Alaska’s North Slope

The Legislature and Alaska's congressional delegation have jointly filed an amicus brief urging the judge not to grant an injunction.

READ MORE

DONATE TODAY

Alaska Public Media members help fund our newsroom. If you're enjoying Alaska At-Large, our politics newsletter, please consider donating. 

Click here to give.

Willow protesters dog Biden as he touts his environmental achievements

The protests haven't been huge, but the focus on the Willow project could tarnish Biden's climate legacy.

READ MORE  

New revenue estimate for Willow project presents rosier picture for Alaska treasury

Changed assumptions about tax credits, oil prices and other factors resulted in an estimate of early cash losses over a shorter period.

READ MORE 

Reminder, Alaska: PFD applications are due tomorrow

The state’s online PFD application will be available until 11:59 p.m. on Friday.

READ MORE 

Alaska regulators examine ConocoPhillips’ 2022 Alpine gas leak near Nuiqsut

Conoco says it now monitors well pressure more closely and would use more cement to reinforce its wells if needed.

READ MORE  

Read more news at alaskapublic.org/news.

We want to make sure you are getting the newsletters that matter to you. Manage your preferences, change your subscriptions, sign up for our other newsletters, and update your contact information by clicking Update Profile below.

2017_AKPM_2_color.png
Facebook  Instagram  Twitter  YouTube