Making the Final Decision For College

Several years ago, my daughters and I saw the musical If/Then, starring Idina Menzel (who played the original Elphaba in Wicked). The show follows Elizabeth or “Liz” and “Beth” in two parallel lives. At first, it is confusing, as we were not sure what was going on, but eventually, we realized that the initial choice she makes in the beginning of the show takes her down a different path, and the audience gets to see what would happen “if” she followed one path or the other.


As the story unfolds, it appears that one of the choices seems like the “right” choice, but ultimately, we see that each path has great joys and great disappointments. It is not necessarily the one path that she takes, but rather, how she responds to the situation that she ultimately faces.


This same lesson can be applied to applying to and attending college. Students often feel as if there is only one path to take them down the road to success. And there are definitely colleges that are a better fit than others, but at some point, you just have to choose. You have to jump off and follow your heart, realizing that each choice will bring ups and downs.


The key to success anywhere is not where you are, but what you do when you are there. You are still that hard-working, resourceful, funny, creative, motivated person who applied to colleges, even if you did not get into your first choice.


As you grapple with your own final decision of where to attend college by May 1st, it may be helpful to think through the following issues.


Identify your needs. It’s easy to get caught up in the rankings, but instead stay focused on your needs, your interests, and which school is the best fit for you.


Focus on the reality of the school. As you revisit schools and speak with current and former students, figure out where you will be able to thrive academically and socially. Put aside your romanticized view of a school, and look at it with an open mind. Many students change their minds either because they did not get into their first choice, or because they realize that a school they initially thought of as a safety school was actually the best fit for them on all counts.


Figure out if you fit in socially. As you walk around campus do you see people with whom you will be friends? Ask students what they do for fun. Does it match your interests? Talk to as many different types of people that you can and gauge how comfortable you feel. Do you feel like you can be you? Do they get your sense of humor? How well do you mesh with the student body?


Review the curriculum. Dig deep into the curriculum and map out the classes you would take in your intended major to make sure you like them. Or if you are undecided, look at the requirements and see if they are things that interest you. If you are planning on majoring in architecture or engineering and you want a hands-on curriculum, see how many of the classes are hands-on versus theoretical.


Run the Numbers. Put together a spreadsheet comparing all of your offers and calculate the full cost of attendance over four years. Make sure you are looking at your net out-of-pocket for each school. Determine how much debt you would have by the end. Graduate with as little debt as possible (we recommend no more than 2/3 of your anticipated first-year income), and you’ll be happy when you don’t have huge student loans hanging over your head!


We interviewed one of our clients who is currently a freshman at Villanova. She did not get into her ED school, which allowed her to think about what she really wanted from a school to make her final decision. You can listen here.


Good luck making your final college decisions!

2025 Acceptances

We are beyond proud of our students and happy to report that everyone has been accepted to a school that is a great fit for them.

 

To our seniors, congratulations for working so hard. We continue to be impressed with your resiliency and accomplishments. We wish you the best of luck and know that you will all be assets to your future colleges! Below is a partial list of colleges to which CBM students were accepted. We are so proud!


*You can click on the picture to view as a larger image.

2025 Admission Trends

What a year! Testing is back--especially at large public universities; applications are up everywhere except slightly down at some Ivies; "New Ivies" are as competitive as ever; colleges are admitting more first-generation students and low-income students; and institutions are looking for applicants who have genuine and distinct interdisciplinary curiosities. Here's a great article from Forbes that details some trends from this year:


Click here to read the article!


And click here to read CommonApp trends from this application season.


What's on Our Minds

The Secret to College Waitlists


Our colleagues at Beasley College Consulting give a great tutorial on Waitlists. Click Here to Read!


And if you are on the waitlist at a school that excites you, we encourage you to be proactive! If you haven't already, please meet with your mentor ASAP to schedule a time to discuss your approach.

What We're Reading

College Admissions Experts Explain the Merits of Not Getting In


Our Podcast

Listen to our latest podcasts!


Our most recent podcasts discuss various pathways for pursuing engineering degrees and teen mental health. You can access our archives here:


Click here to listen!

What's Next

Seniors:
We are proud of you and enjoyed working with you through this process. We are available to meet to help you make your final decision. Please let us know your results.

Juniors: 
If you haven't already, please contact us to schedule a meeting to create resume/activity lists.

Freshmen/Sophomores: 
If we haven't already met, please contact us to develop a plan for the coming year and discuss some potential summer options.  
You bring your friends, we provide the info. If anyone is interested in setting up a free interactive workshop on how to maximize students’ high school years leading up to college, please reach out to stefanie@collegeboundmentor.com
 
Book Now
LEARN ABOUT OUR SERVICES
Email Us