View as Webpage | Visit our Website | Give to BPI | December 2021

Screen Shot 2021-12-03 at 3.34.51 PM.png

This morning, the BPI Debate Union returned to official action. 


Hosting its first in-person debate since 2019, the team faced off against Morehouse College. In an exciting and close contest, the home team won.


Resolved: The celebration of Malcolm X as an autodidact does more harm than good.

The teams debated the legacy of Malcolm X who enrolled in college and participated in competitive debate while he was incarcerated. The debate touched on mass incarceration, contemporary systemic racism, philosophies of education, the meaning of college-in-prison, and the history of the Black freedom struggle. The topic was inspired in large part by the writing and research of Jed Tucker, longtime member of the BPI faculty and leadership, and also was attended by an award-winning biographer of Malcolm X.

Screen Shot 2021-12-03 at 3.35.51 PM.png

We were honored to be joined today by author Tamara Payne who, alongside her late father, co-authored the Pulitzer-Prize winning Malcolm X biography The Dead Are Arising: The Life of Malcolm X. After the debate, Payne offered remarks, reflected on the historical significance of the event, and described the debate as a “very special way to honor the memory of Malcolm X.”

Back in-person with the BPI Debate Union

This is the second time the Morehouse College debate team has visited Eastern Correctional Facility. The first debate in 2017 was also incredibly close. The team’s full record can be found on the BPI Blog here. 


Today’s topic came out of conversations between BPI students, Debate Union Coach David Register, and Director of Reentry Jed Tucker about Jed’s 2017 article "Malcolm X, the Prison Years: The Relentless Pursuit of Formal Education," published in the Journal of African American History, which uncovered evidence that challenges the notion that Malcolm X lacked formal education or was necessarily opposed to it. Tucker’s research draws on archival materials never seen before 2010 that reframes what we knew about Malcolm’s time in prison; it derives, primarily, from Malcolm’s own handwritten letters to his siblings, interviews with some of Malcolm’s contemporaries, and the writings of the superintendent where he did time. The new story reveals the untold tale of Malcolm’s tireless drive for formal education during his time inside and challenges how the world has come to think of Malcolm X. 


In the coming days, the BPI Debate Union at Fishkill will faceoff on the same topic with the Bard Annandale debate team for a public debate where judging will be done by the whole audience and later, Tucker will engage in a conversation on these same themes with BPI alumnus and BPI Debate Union member Reginald Chatman. Stay tuned for more about those events!


Sharing the stage with Morehouse for live, in-person debate has been an extraordinary way to end an unprecedented year. Please join us in sending our deepest thanks to men of Morehouse College, to Tamara Payne, to the Annandale Debate Union, coach David Register, and a huge congratulations to the BPI Debate Union! 


DebateUnion_Eblast_Dec_01.gif
Make a Gift 

Follow BPI for the Latest News:

Facebook  Instagram  Twitter

Learn More on our Website


bpi.bard.edu