March 22, 2025 / VOLUME NO. 358

Efficiency Woes


The excitement around artificial intelligence is partly driven by the idea that AI will replace mundane tasks and improve efficiency. In fact, a recent survey by KPMG found that 70% of global bank executives want to use AI to cut costs.


But banks have a hard time improving efficiency. According to a March report from McKinsey & Co., private, nonfarm businesses in the U.S. have seen a compound annual growth rate in labor productivity of 1.3% since 2010. For commercial banks, that figure has declined by 0.02% per year over the same timeframe.


“Banks are acutely aware of their stubborn costs but often struggle to effectively mitigate them due to myriad challenges, including complex operating models, competing risk management initiatives, and patchworks of legacy systems and processes inherited from M&A deals,” McKinsey said. The consulting firm projected risk and compliance budgets will grow 5% annually at global banks through 2028. “These competing priorities have forced banks to focus largely on near-term efficiency solutions, which don’t address the core issues.” 


Christopher Wolfe, the head of North American bank research at Fitch Ratings, has found that the industry’s efficiency ratio, which stood at 58.7% at the end of 2023, hasn’t improved much since 1950, when it was 59.4%. The advent of the mainframe computer, the personal computer, ATMs, the internet — nothing made a lasting impact on the ratio. 


It may be that the efficiency ratio is the wrong way to measure technology advances. Some of the benefits may be flowing to customers and shareholders, for example. Customers don’t have to pay for access to mobile banking, after all. 


So, will the benefits of artificial intelligence flow to customers? Or will AI make banks more efficient in the next decade? “I think that you can't discount the possibility,” Wolfe says. “But if history is any guide, the answer is no.”


Naomi Snyder, editor-in-chief of Bank Director

Banks Have Been Unloading Bonds at a Loss. Is That a Good Thing?

With a roller coaster ride in long-term bonds, banks have a tough decision to make.


“The reality for a long time was that recording big securities losses was a dogmatic no-no.”

— Brian Leibfried, Performance Trust Capital Partners


• Paul Davis, contributing writer for Bank Director 

How To Compete With Ag Fintechs

Fintech startups are gaining ground in agricultural finance with fast approvals and flexible terms. How can midsize banks stay competitive?

How AI Can Empower Retail Banking

Artificial intelligence could help banks to improve customer advice, sales growth and loan decisioning.

Building a High-Performance Sales Culture

By shifting to a customer-centric approach, banks can build long-term loyalty, fueling sustainable growth.

Jackpot! How Banks Can Prevent ATM Attacks

What CEOs and boards should know — and ask — about ATM jackpotting attacks.

About Bank Director

Bank Director provides research, peer-insight and executive and board services to the financial industry. CEOs, CFOs, Chairs and leadership teams at financial institutions, fintechs and financial services firms turn to Bank Director to keep pace with their ever-evolving business landscape.