logo-wide2.png
 

Beach Update # 16

Dear Karen

Happy May! What a joy it is to see the community come to life again these past few weeks. Our spring meeting at Whyte Hall is less than two weeks away, and I wanted to bring you up to speed on the beach.


The pieces continue to fall into place for the Army Corps of Engineers to commence a major beach restoration. The agency has secured funding, scoped the beaches to determine engineering requirements, interviewed five dredging companies, and met regularly with federal, state, and county stakeholders.



The Corps has yet to award a contract, and there are still some remaining moving pieces to be resolved. But officials are increasingly discussing a late summer/early fall project launch. I will keep you updated as we learn more.

In an effort to ensure the project stays on course, FIPPOA board member Andrew Kirtzman and I traveled to Washington D.C. recently with the leaders of the Fire Island Association and Seaview. We met with Senators Chuck Schumer and Kirsten Gillibrand, Congressman Andrew Garbarino, and officials of the Corps.



The fact that our representatives were so generous with their time was a testament to their commitment to our cause. Last year, when the odds were stacked against us in our fight for this beach, Senators Schumer and Gillibrand stood up and made our fight their own. Congressman Garbarino wasn’t far behind. We will never forget them for coming through for us. 

Late last month, Colonel Alexander Young, who is leading the Army Corps effort and is quickly becoming one of our favorite people, decided to visit the Pines with his colleagues and state officials. We hosted them at my house, along with Suzy Goldhirsch, president of the FIA, and the leaders of several other east end communities.



A year ago, we were caught in a seemingly unbreakable cycle of applications for help and rejections from the Corps. But once the agency dropped its opposition to the project following a months-long battle, our relationship changed. Over the past few months, we have become true partners.  

Plans are meanwhile underway for the Pines Party on August 10th, which will be the 25th anniversary of this extraordinary community event. I’d like to describe some of the steps we take to ensure the party does not harm the beach, as some have asked me about it in the context of the replenishment.

Photo: Krys Fox

Because Fire Island is a national seashore, the party is a heavily-regulated event; numerous government agencies have requirements that we are obligated to meet. We have met, and in some cases exceeded, them each year.


We have a 10-year permit from the NY State Department of Environmental Conservation to hold the party on the beach subject to certain requirements. While the DEC permit allows us to scrape the beach north of the mean high tide line, in 2023 we voluntarily chose to discontinue the process of scraping to create a protective berm. Instead, we employed water filled K-rails to secure protection of the party site.


Last year the Fire Island National Seashore made additional recommendations that we adopted, including securing the stage and other structures with water filled cubes so that we no longer dig anywhere into the sand. For the first time, FINS employees attended our party to ensure compliance, and told us they were completely satisfied that we acted as good stewards of the beach.


I’ve been asked if the vehicles that bring equipment to and from the party damage the beach. The answer is that the trips are a tiny fraction of the vehicular traffic that traverses the beach throughout the year, as anyone who has watched utility trucks, police, FINS, and, during the winter, contractors travel back and forth regularly. FINS is in fact currently looking to expand the number of permits to allow driving from the mainland onto Fire Island’s beaches.


The bottom line, as explained to us by the Army Corps, is that the erosion of our beach was caused not by vehicular traffic or anything man-made, but by an unusual number of back-to-back storms since Elliott in December, 2022, and the lack of the usual south and southwest winds that naturally replenish the sand on the beach.



One of the qualities of the Pines Party that I have always found magical is that a day or two after the sun rises on it you can barely tell it was ever there. It is the result of a tremendous amount of planning and care that goes into protecting our beach.

I look forward to seeing you at the May 18th meeting at Whyte Hall (refreshments at 10AM; meeting starts promptly at 10:30AM). 


Best,

Henry

Henry_headshot_small.jpg
 

Click here to renew or join FIPPOA Today!

Screen Shot 2022-02-10 at 4.27.54 PM.png
 
 

Henry Robin, President

Allan Baum, Vice President

Alan Brodherson, Secretary

Eric Sawyer, Treasurer

 

Gary Clinton, Greg Henniger, Bill Hildebrandt, Andrew Kirtzman,

Chris Mai, Charles Montorio-Archer, Anthony Pietrangolare, Nate Pinsley, Leland Rechis, Russell Saray, and Ed Schulhafer

 

Building our community together.