October 25, 2019            Your source for All Livonia news. All the time. All ways positive. 
     Musings masthead website  
Cinematic Art expands in Livonia with the introduction of Fathom Events 
at the Phoenix Theatre
Manon - The Met Opera Live in HD
October 26 - 12:55pm
October 30 - 1:00pm (Encore)
October 30 - 6:30pm (Encore)
Spirited Away - Studio Ghibli Fest 2019
October 27 - 12:55pm (DUB)
October 28 - 7:00pm (SUB)
Raymonda - The Bolshoi Ballet
October 27 - 12:55pm
Faustina: Love and Mercy
October 28 - 7:00pm
LUZIA - Cirque de Soleil 
October 29 - 7:00pm
Click on this image for all movie times

Vote  November 5



City of Livonia  Mayoral Race
Vote for one candidate in November
Endorsements listed are provided to FridayMusings 
by the candidate or their committee

Maureen Miller Brosnan
FridayMusings
Councilman Jim Jolly,
Livonia Police Officers Association
Police Officers Association of Michigan
Livonia Police Lieutenants and Sergeants Association
Livonia Firefighters Local 1164
Westland Mayor Bill Wild
Congresswoman Haley Stevens
State Senator Dayna Polehanki
County Executive Warren Evans
County Sheriff Benny Napoleon
Sierra Club Michigan Chapter
AFSCME, UAW, Teamsters Local 299 
Michigan Regional Council of Carpenters, 
Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers Local 2
Greater Metropolitan Association of Realtors
Michigan Building and Construction Trades Council
Dan Centers, Livonia School Board Trustee, 
Karen Bradford, Livonia School Board Trustee
Tim Klisz, Zoning Board of Appeals Member 
Gretchen Alaniz, Schoolcraft College Trustee
Brian Broderick, Schoolcraft College Board Chair
Schoolcraft College Treasurer Terry Gilligan
Janice Centers, Zoning Board of Appeals Member
Citizens Roads Advisory Committee Member Brett Gierak
 Former Livonia City Council Members Mike McGee,
 Joe Taylor, and Dale Jurcisin
 https://www.maureenformayor.com/

Laura Toy
Mayor Dennis Wright , 
Former Mayors Jack Kirksey, Jack Engebretson
Councilwomen Kathleen McIntyre and Cathy White 
Councilmen Brian Meakin, Brandon Kritzman
Bruce Tenniswood
Right to Life of Michigan  

City of Livonia Council Race
Vote for up to four candidates in November
Endorsements listed are provided to FridayMusings 
by the candidate or their committee

Scott Bahr  
Mayors Dennis Wright, Jack Engebretson, Jack Kirksey
Council members Laura Toy, Jim Jolly
Brandon Kritzman, Kathleen McIntyre, Cathy White
Brian Meakin
Former Council members Jim McCann, Joe Taylor
John Pastor, Treasurer Lynda Scheel
Commissioner Terry Marecki
Livonia Public School Trustees Mark Johnson
Colleen Burton, Karen Bradford, Crystal Frank
Former LPS Superintendent Randy Liepa
Former Representatives John Walsh, Laura Cox
Former Senator Patrick Colbeck
Former Fire Chief Shadd Whitehead
Livonia Firefighters Union 1164
Schoolcraft Trustee Dillon Breen
ZBA Members Chris Boloven, Joel Turbiak,
Jim Baringhaus
Planning Commissioners Sam Caramagno  Carol Smiley
Greater Metropolitan Association of Realtors
Right to Life of Michigan

Gregory Coppola
Councilmembers Laura Toy,  Brian Meakin,
Brandon M. Kritzman, Kathleen McIntyre
County Commissioner Terry Marecki
Former Councilmen  John Walsh and  John Pastor
Jim McCann and Joe Laura
Zoning Board of Appeals Jim Baringhaus and Tim Kliz
Schoolcraft Trustee Dillon Breen
Right to Life of Michigan

            
Robert Donovic
Bruce Tenniswood
Livonia Police Officers Association 
Livonia Fire Fighters Local 1164
 Police  Officers Association of Michigan
 Park Commissioner Paul Condon
Schoolcraft Trustees Gretchen Alaniz, Dillon Breen, 
Mayor Dennis Wright, 
Councilwoman Laura Toy, Councilman Brian Meakin, 
Former Livonia School Trustee Steve King
Greater Metropolitan Association of Realtors, 
County Commissioner Diane Webb,
State Representative Jewell Jones, 
Right to Life of Michigan

Brian Duggan
Laura Toy, Joe Laura, Jim McCann
Livonia Police Officers Association
 
B randon McCullough
FridayMusings
Greater Metropolitan Association of Realtors
Livonia Police Officers Association
Police Officers Association of Michigan
Livonia Police Lieutenants and Sergeants Association
Livonia Firefighters Local 1164
Mayor Dennis Wright, 
Wayne County Commissioners Glenn Anderson & Diane Webb
Former City Councilwoman Maureen Miller Brosnan    Councilmen Jim Jolly, Brandon Kritzman, 
Great Detroit Building & Construction Trades Council,  Sheet Metal Workers' Local 80,
 Bricklayers & Allied Craftworkers, 
   
Eileen McDonnell
FridayMusiings
Sierra Club Michigan Chapter
County Commissioners  Glenn Anderson &  Diane Webb
former LPS School Board  Dianne Laura
former Livonia City Council member Joe Laura, 
Schoolcraft Trusteew  Gretchen Alaniz and Joan Gebhardt

Kathleen McIntyre 
FridayMusings
Mayor Dennis Wright,  Former Mayors Jack Kirksey, Jack Engebretson,  John Grzebik, Greenleaf Commission,      
Zoning Board of Appeals Tim Klisz and  Jim Baringhaus
Arts Commissioner Lindsay Spence
Recreation Commissioner Katie Jolly
Livonia Police Officers Association
Police Officers Association of Michigan
Livonia Firefighters Local 1164
Treasurer Lynda Scheel,  Council members Laura Toy, Jim Jolly,Brian Meakin,  Cathy White, Brandon Kritzman
 Wayne County Commissioner Terry Marecki, 
Schoolcraft Trustee Gretchen Alaniz
Click on the image below to instantly be transported to the Seedlings Braille Books for Children bid site. Look over the items now and get ready for when the bidding starts November 1st.
ONE WEEK REMAINING BEFORE THIS 
LINK IS OPEN FOR BIDDING,

Send your calendar notices to  [email protected]
 
October in Livonia
 Livonia Arts Commission's annual Fine Arts Exhibition is being held the entire month of October in the Fine Arts Gallery in the Bennett Civic Center Library.

October 1 - 30
Wilson Barn Pumpkin Fest Every day in October

October 19 - 31
Pumpkin Place fundraiser for Livonia Cares

October 25
Halloween Walk at Greenmead

October 25 @ 5:30 - 8:00
Free Scary fun at the Livonia YMCA
Games, spooky stories, crafts, and a costume contest 

October 26 @ 7:30 - midnight
Livonia Arts Commission
Triology Band at Burton Manor
Music from the Heart Fall Concert
$20 in advance/$25 at the door
October 26  @ 10:00 - 4:00
Madonna University Music Arts Day
 
October 28 @ 6:00
Madonna University, Fran Building - Suchyta Hall

October 28 @ 5:00 - 7:00
Flemings support for the ARC
People with Disabilities
tickets @  TheARCNW.org
 
October 30 @ 12:00 - 1:30
Livonia Education Foundation Luncheon

November in Livonia
November 1 @8:00, 2 @8:00, 3 @2:00
November 8 @8:00, 9 @8:00, 10 @2:00
Barefoot Productions

November 2 @ 4:30 @ 8:00
Tail Waggers @ Woodland Lanes

November 2

November 2
14th Annual Healthy Livonia Turkey Trot
Bicentennial Park
November 5 @ 7:00 am - 8:00 pm
Livonia General Election
Vote
November 5 @ noon - 3:00
Madonna University Music Department

November 8 @ 7:30
November 9 @ 7:30
November 10 @ 2:00
Women in War
Livonia Community Theatre
St. Paul's Presbyterian Church

November 10 @ 10:30

November 16 @ 10:00 - 3:00
Rotary Club invites you to Be a Cancer Kicker
@ Burn Fitness - Livonia

November 23 @ 2:00 - 4:00
Blessings in a Backpack Bowling Outing

November 23 @ 9:00 - 3:00
Historic Greenmead Treasures from Grandma's Attic

December in Livonia
December 7
Livonia Symphony Orchestra
Magical Fantasies
Clarenceville High School
Louis Schmidt Auditorium
December 8 @ 4:00
City of Livonia Christmas Parade
December 15 @ 3:00

Spaghetti Dinner Year Two. Another barn burner success.
Be proud Livonia for the part we are playing in eradicating polio worldwide.
Any thought that the community Spaghetti Dinner raising awareness and funding in the fight to eradicate polio would not be able to surpass the outstanding success of last year would have had it all wrong.

Year two of the joint project put on by our two Rotary Clubs, the AM and Noon Club, saw a full house from start to finish. Spaghetti, conversation, dessert, Rotarians, elected officials, Boy Scouts, High School Interact students, candidates, two and three generation families in attendance.

President Janet Haas, the noon club, and Pat Zucal, the AM Club, chairwomen Tammy Bonifield, Livonia School Trustee, and Barb Lewis, retired Livonia Librarian were all done proud by the hard work of everyone involved. And Livonia was done proud with this quality community gathering.

Mayor Dennis Wright, Clerk Susan Nash, Council President Laura Toy, Councilman Scott Bahr were all of hand. Council candidates Jim Davis, Rob Donovic, Brandon McCullough. Mayoral candidate Maureen Miller Brosnan.

Bob Modes, owner of the Blue Plate was on hand with his parents and aunt. Dennis Nazelli purchased a table of ten. Art Cole, himself a Rotarian, had two tables.

The typewriter had his table with Livonia historian Kathy Bilger and her husband Don. 

The list could go on and on. But from the moment you entered Christ our Savior Lutheran Church you felt welcome. Students opened the door and greeted you with a smile. And when you left the students were saying "thank you for coming tonight." 

This project was done right even with two Rotarians washing dishes, Rotarians cooking up the spaghetti, student Interact members clearing tables, Rotarians greeting everyone and making them feel welcome.

A warm welcome that was the feeling with laughter, conversation, smiles filling the room which was already wall to wall with people.

Rotary has been working to eradicate polio for more than 30 years. Their goal of ridding the world of this disease is closer than ever.

As a founding partner of the  Global Polio Eradication Initiative, Rotary has played a significant role in reducing polio cases by 99.9 percent since their first project to vaccinate children in the Philippines in 1979.

They have helped immunize more than 2.5 billion children in 122 countries. So far, Rotary has contributed more than $1.8 billion toward eradicating the disease worldwide.


Today, polio remains endemic only in Afghanistan, Nigeria, and Pakistan.

 But it's crucial to continue working to keep other countries polio-free. If all eradication efforts stopped today, within 10 years, polio could paralyze as many as 200,000 children each year.

Those attending this community spaghetti dinner are helping make an impact across and around the globe.

 Livonia is playing a significant role in eradicating polio. Rotary AM and Rotary Noon are leading the fight and for that reason all of Livonia says thank you Rotary.
Is the sale of Newburgh Mill a done deal?
Is Livonia actually helping move it along?
On June 6 a dozen intrepid citizens opposed to selling off park land, Hines Park specifically, showed up at the Kirksey Recreation Center to attend a meeting between Livonia and Wayne County officials for the purpose of updating Livonia on the progress or process of the
Early arrivals for the June 6th meeting who were told the meeting was cancelled. It was apparently just moved.
 sale of Newburgh Mill.

The residents were told that the meeting was cancelled and had no idea on when the meeting might be rescheduled.

But in a letter obtained by FridayMusings the meeting was held on June 6, with citizens not told where the meeting was being held, with an additional meeting on June 20th.

 Attending the June 6th meeting according to a memo sent to the City Council by Mayor Dennis Wright was Wright, Dave Varga, Mark Taormina, Brian Meakin and Ted Davis. The meeting included "interviews arranged by Wayne County with prospective developers" of the " approximately 4,000 square foot historic mill building, as well as a horse stable and outbuilding on about 2 acres of land containing roughly 375 feet of frontage on Newburgh Lake."

The proposals presented to the city of Livonia included a "microbrewery, micro-distillery, restaurant/cafe, dental office and wellness spa."  Four of the five proposals of the Newburgh Mill site, part of Hines Park, relied "on supplemental redevelopment of the balance of the property, including a small retail plaza, apartments, townhouses and a senior living
facility."

Mayor Wright told the members of the Livonia City Council in this memo dated that "the County is seeking guidance from the City as to the preferred uses(s) of the property. It was made very clear to the County that any expression of preference from the advisory committee is non-binding. . ."the County Administration is looking to move quickly through the process of engaging a developer with either a purchase agreement or letter of intent. The County indicated that could take up to three months. The County anticipates that its selected developer would begin the entitlement process with the City (rezoning and site plane/waver use) at the same time the County Commission is weighing the offer."

Mayor Wright in acknowledging that their input was limited to feedback on proposed uses did provide a summary and evaluation of the proposals. There was a consensus of those attending the June 6 meeting that supported the reuse of the existing mill a a microbrewery or distillery or cafe while preserving the historic nature of the mill.

According to Bill Craig, a Livonia resident, Wayne County has a proposal from Richard Cox to purchase the property for $400,000. The County is including a requirement that the purchaser of the Newburgh Mill build Wayne County a horse stable and police station at Cowan Road and Farmington.

This entire process for the Newburgh Mill has been wrapped in secrecy with no opportunity for public input, no chance to hear the proposal. Yes the public will have their two minutes to say something about the proposal at a County Commission hearing in Detroit. Two minutes in public comment after the Commission votes on the proposal to sell Newburgh and Phoenix Mills. 

Livonia had another option had the committee chosen to look at it. That was to oppose the sale of the property by simply
 stating that Livonia would like the property to be maintained as public land. As a result of the finding of the committee Wayne County is now saying that Livonia supports a micro-brewery. That statement shared by Wayne County does not include that "the potential sale of Newburgh Mill is outside the City's jurisdiction."

That last quote is factually correct but once the property is sold there will be limited opportunity by the City to maintain the Mill as public land and as a part of Hines Park.

Wayne County has let this property fall into a state of disrepair despite having received $250 million dollars from the 1/4 mill taxpayers approved years ago. $10 million a year. With this money the County should have and could have kept the building renovated, applied for historic preservation grants, leased the building out themselves while maintaining ownership. 

So now the proposal to purchase is going to the Commission committee and then to the full Board of Commissioners at
 the same time possibly being sent to the City of Livonia to seek rezoning.

Only two County Commissioners are set to vote no. Commissioners Glenn Anderson and Diane Webb. So it is a done deal for Phoenix and Newburgh Mills. All without input from the nearly 13,000 residents who signed petitions asking that they mills be maintained as public land and not sold.

Warren Evans has done a disservice to citizens who wanted to be engaged. 13,000 who wanted to be engaged. Thank you Glenn Anderson and Diane Webb for wanting to open up county government while engaging citizens on the issue of selling off park land. 

A HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE ON THE
 "NEGATIVE" CAMPAIGN FOR MAYOR

There is a lot of commentary on social media regarding the perception by some about negative campaigning in the mayor's race. What is "factual" to one group is "negative" to another group. For the most part, both campaigns have put out mail highlighting their records and positions.

But we have had a comparison of missed votes by the candidates, and Laura skipping the candidate debates. Laura defends that she was taking care of her sick mother, had a car accident, and most recently, a family emergency. Maureen defends that she was recovering from surgery for lung cancer. Maureen has been called "full of it" and a "lier" while Laura has been answering a suggestion that she has promised appointment to her seat on city council if she becomes Mayor.

But none of this is new this year. Nor is it new to Livonia.

In 1969, Mayor Harvey Moelke was on the receiving end of fact based campaign literature put out by supporters of Ed McNamara. There was a picture of the house Moelke lived in and included the assessed value and amount of taxes paid. Next to it was a picture of the house McNamara lived in with the same information. The reader was left to conclude that Mayor Moelke was paying less than his share of taxes compared to candidate McNamara. 

McNamara won. Did this campaign flyer make a difference?

In 1995, Councilman Dale Jurcisin was running neck and neck against Jack Kirksey when a mailer hit the mail boxes the weekend before the election claiming that the Ardmore Psychiatric Hospital on Farmington Road north of 7 Mile was going to be turned into group housing with residents from Detroit, all orchestrated by County Executive McNamara and his lieutenant Jurcisin.

Kirksey won. Did this campaign flyer make a difference?

In 2007, Councilwoman Maureen Miller Brosnan ran against Jack Kirksey and she won the primary election. At the end of the general campaign an anti-Brosnan mailer arrived with a picture of Kwame Kilpatrick leaving an airplane with money flying out of his pockets, suggesting that Livonia and Brosnan would somehow be controlled by Detroit.

Kirksey won. Did this campaign flyer make a difference?

A few years ago in a campaign for re-election to the City Council, Tom Robinson was the recipient of such negative campaign literature that he and his wife, a member of the Livonia Board of Education, moved out of town and have not been heard of since. His crime? He was undergoing a kidney transplant and accepted city health insurance. Without the transplant he surely would have died. But this did not stop the opposition from sending out a letter from Jack Kirksey that was devastating to Robinson, suggesting that somehow he did something improper.

Robinson lost. Did this letter make a difference? 

So, with a view to the past, "negative" campaigning has been with us, and often has been shown to be effective.  The essential question is: are the attacks in the current campaign based on documented fact, or are they unsupported and primarily personal characterizations?

It will be up to the voters to sort all that out, and we'll find out the results on November 5.  

If you love motion pictures then you have gotta love the Film Forum
Please join the typewriter at the Douglas Trumbull Film Forum at Phoenix Theatres Monroe on Star Trek The Motion Picture's 40th Anniversary this December 7th. Turnbull is an American film director, special effects supervisor, and inventor. He contributed to, or was responsible for, the special photographic effects of 2001: A Space Odyssey, Close Encounters of the Third Kind, Star Trek: The Motion Picture, Blade Runner and The Tree of Life, and directed the movies Silent Running and Brainstorm. 

The typewriter was hooked with the mention of Blade Runner. Add to it 2001: Space Odyssey and I am there. Maybe early with popcorn and iced tea. I am all about it.
  
Livonia Lions and Livonia AM Rotary shared in making the
Kids Against Hunger a huge success 
 

Our Livonia Rotary AM Club was out in force at another of their
 community service opportunities.
 
This picture on the left is from Kids Against Hunger with Rotarians helping to package 45,000 meals. Did it take all day? Nope. Two hours. Livonia knows how to volunteer.


Our Livonia Lions Club assisted Kids Coalition Against Hunger and 140 volunteers packing over 45,000 in just over two hours last Saturday at St. Edith Church. Two-thirds of these meals will be distributed in and around Livonia, the remaining will help replenish the 500,000 meals recently sent to the Bahamas for disaster relief. Lion Pride!!  Pictured on the right are Lions Kevin Burke, Al Blanchard and Kohl's Cares volunteers.

Cole, Newton & Duran CPA's show us howTaxpayers Can Compare Eligibility and Benefits of Two Education Credits 
 
There are two education credits that can help taxpayers with higher education costs: the American opportunity tax credit and the lifetime learning credit . There are several differences and some similarities between them. Taxpayers can claim both benefits on the same return, but not for the same student or same qualified expenses.

Here is a comparison of these two credits:

What is the maximum credit or benefit?
  • American opportunity tax credit: Up to $2,5000 credit per eligible student
  • Lifetime learning credit: Up to $2,000 credit per tax return
Is it refundable or non-refundable?
  • American opportunity credit: Refundable for up to 40 percent of credit
  • Lifetime learning credit: Not refundable
Can taxpayers claim the credit if they file with the filing status married filing separately?
  • Both credits: No
What is the limit on maximum adjusted gross income for the other filing statuses?
  • American opportunity credit: Married filing joint: $180,000 Other statuses: $90,000
  • Lifetime learning credit: Married filing joint: $136,000 Other statuses: $68,000
Can a taxpayer claim credit if they be claimed as a dependent on someone else's tax return?
  • Both credits: No
Must the taxpayer or their spouse be a US citizen or resident alien?
  • Both credits: Yes, unless nonresident alien is treated as resident alien for tax purposes
What is the number of tax years for which the credit is available?
  • American opportunity credit: Four tax years per eligible student
  • Lifetime learning credit: Unlimited
What type of program is required?
  • American opportunity credit: Student must be pursuing degree or other recognized education credential 
  • Lifetime learning credit: Student does not need to be pursuing degree or other recognized education credential
What is the number of courses for which the credit is available?
  • American opportunity credit: Must be enrolled at least half time for at least one academic period in 2019
  • Lifetime learning credit: Available for one or more courses
What qualified expenses does the credit cover?
  • American opportunity credit: Tuition, required enrollment fees, course materials
  • Lifetime learning credit: Tuition and fees required for enrollment and attendance
For whom can the taxpayer claim the credit?
  • Both credits: the taxpayer, their spouse, or a student they claim as a dependent on their tax return
Who must pay the qualified expenses?  
  • Both credits: the taxpayer, their spouse, the student, or a third party

About Cole, Newton & Duran CPAs (cndcpa.com)    Cole, Newton & Duran CPAs (CND) has been providing quality, personalized financial guidance to local individuals and businesses for more than 50 years. Our expertise ranges from basic tax management and accounting services to more in-depth services such as audits, financial statements, and financial planning. CND is one of the leading firms in and throughout the area. By combining our expertise, experience, and the team mentality of our staff, we assure that every client receives the close analysis and attention they deserve.
Trunk or Treat this Saturday and Monday.
How can you go wrong in Livonia. You can't.
 

Livonia is a healthy community. 
The Rick Austin Memorial 5K is a wonderful way to remember Rick Austin
Please plan on joining us to honor and remember Churchill's longtime teacher and coach, Rick Austin, at the 3rd annual Rick Austin Memorial 5k to be held at Churchill. Details on the flyer! All proceeds to go the Churchill Athletic department and support student athletes!! 


Have you purchased your raffle ticket yet?
Only 300 tickets available!!

Richard & Geraldine Joyner scholarship for two students either at or planning on attending Schoolcraft College 


Applications for the Richard & Geraldine Joyner Scholarship for those attending or planning to attend Schoolcraft College are now available.

 Simply drop an email to [email protected] and an application will immediately be
forwarded to you. 

In January Bill and Bob Joyner will announce the two winners of the Richard & Geraldine Joyner Scholarship. Each for $600. Applications are due on December 1st, awarded on January 1st.