Majority of Council appear poised to defeat the proposed Civil Rights
Non-Discrimination Ordinance
At the October 26, 2022 City Council Committee of the Whole Meeting, one of the agenda items was the proposed Civil Rights Non-Discrimination Ordinance.
The room was full as many spoke opposing the ordinance, which is currently in effect in over 60 communities in Michigan.
State Representative Laurie Pohutsky shared her thoughts on the meeting and the NDO in a posting on her Facebook page:
"With this year's Michigan Supreme Court opinion in Rouch World, this (Livonia) NDO is essentially creating a local option to make it simpler and less expensive to handle cases of discrimination rather than having to navigate state or federal systems. To put it simply, this helps small businesses because it provides them with a local avenue to address what is already a state and federal policy. By not adopting an NDO, Livonia is leaving businesses only more expensive and complicated options.
"Livonia's discrimination ordinance hasn't been updated since 1982. The unwillingness of some council members to update an ordinance that hasn't been examined since before I was born does not help to make the case that Livonia is a welcoming community. In fact, it's out of step with the majority of what our community wants.
"To hear a council member tell residents that if they don't like the way Livonia is "then they should leave" represents a failure by the city's elected government and a total unwillingness to continue moving Livonia forward. It's the antithesis of the welcoming community.
"It's also worth noting that some of those folks WILL leave, and the city will be worse off for it.
"It is unacceptable and I stand with our community members who are fighting to get this NDO passed as it is. I also want to thank Councilman McCullough for doing the difficult but right thing consistently on this issue. As a colleague and a resident, I'm grateful for him.
"Nights like last night can be discouraging, but it's imperative that we keep going. It's also crucial that when someone shows us who they are, we believe them. Many people showed us last night."
One particularly articulate presentation was made by PFLAG Livonia board member, Debbie Yates, who read the following statement on behalf of PFLAG Livonia.
"PFLAG is the first and largest organization dedicated to supporting, educating, and advocating for LGBTQ+ people and their families.
"The PFLAG vision is an equitable, inclusive world where every LGBTQ+ person is safe, celebrated, empowered, and loved.
"We know from the personal and sometimes devastating stories shared in our group, we still have a lot of work to do to make Livonia the safe and empowering world envisioned by PFLAG.
"The proposed non-discrimination ordinance would be a step in the right direction.
"The July ruling of the Michigan Supreme Court regarding the Elliott-Larsen Civil Rights Act provided much needed clarity about the interpretation of language surrounding the protection of people based on sexual orientation and gender identity. However, a local ordinance could provide a more efficient and cost-effective process for addressing instances of discrimination in our city.
"Additionally, passing the non-discrimination ordinance would demonstrate that the city government stands firmly against the discrimination of anyone in Livonia, but especially the previously unprotected and vulnerable LGBTQ+ community."
At the end of the meeting, Councilman Scott Morgan made a motion to deny the resolution, in effect killing any changes in the Livonia NDO.
Councilman Brandon McCullough made a motion to approve the resolution, with a request to have the legal department add language that clearly states the consequence for filing a false claim of discrimination.
From all appearances, the motion to deny the resolution, if a vote were held this week would be defeated 5-2 with only Jim Jolly and Brandon McCullough supporting the passage.
|