|
In this section we re-visit last week's meeting, providing:
- an AI summary (YouTube transcript analyzed by Claude's Sonnet 4.5)
- links to the Community 7 video
- draft minutes produced by city staff (if available)
We'll revise and edit when necessary for clarity, brevity, and to avoid inaccuracies, which are sure to happen on occasion. And, considering the difficulty Council has had with audio feeds, it's likely that some comments or segments of the meeting will be missed in the video transcript.
BILLINGS CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION - OCTOBER 20, 2025
Overview
The Billings City Council held a work session on October 20, 2025, to discuss two major agenda items: a state proposal for an Eastern Montana Forensic Mental Health Facility and potential residency requirements for city department heads. The meeting began with updates on city construction projects and the announcement of the newly opened short-term holding facility. The forensic mental health facility discussion dominated the meeting, with council members expressing significant concerns about the state's accelerated timeline (applications due November 10th, decision by Thanksgiving 2025) and the lack of detailed information about impacts on the community, workforce, and release planning. Council unanimously agreed to have Mayor Cole draft a letter to the state expressing support for the facility's need while requesting more information and partnership rather than submitting a formal application. On the second agenda item, Council Member Kennedy proposed requiring department-level employees to reside within Billings city limits, modeled after a Helena resolution, which was moved forward to a future business meeting for formal consideration.
ACTIONS TAKEN & VOTES
Short-Term Holding Facility Announcement (9:14-10:03)
Council Member Owen announced that the short-term holding facility opened that day (October 20, 2025) and had already begun accepting arrestees awaiting judicial proceedings.
No formal action taken; informational update only.
Eastern Montana Forensic Mental Health Facility Discussion (23:12-1:28:23)
MOTION (1:24:52-1:28:02): Council Member Shaw moved that Mayor Cole draft a letter to the state (governor, DPHHS, Board of Investment) expressing appreciation for the facility, understanding the need, but requesting more information about community impacts before proceeding with an application.
VOTE: Unanimously approved by all council members present (Mayor Cole, Council Members Shaw, Neese, Owen, Rogers, Kennedy, Aspenlieder, Tidswell, Rupsis, Boyett) (1:27:56-1:28:02).
Residency Requirements for Department Heads (1:28:30-end)
MOTION (1:35:26-1:38:01): Council Member Kennedy moved to place a resolution on a future business agenda requiring director-level employees to reside within Billings city limits, modeled after Helena's resolution (which includes waiver provisions). Seconded by Council Member Rogers.
Discussion indicated the motion will move forward for formal consideration at a future business meeting, with Council Member Kennedy agreeing to draft the resolution himself without using staff time.
COUNCILMEMBER NOTABLE QUOTABLES
Council Member Owen on Short-Term Holding Facility (9:25-9:56):
"Just super excited to share tonight that the short-term holding facility opened today... This is the start of, I think, a very important turn in our community. It is not the end. We need to be working now with our public health partners on those diversion and prevention programs that keep those beds turning over so our officers continue to have the ability to arrest people."
Mayor Cole on Forensic Mental Health Facility Timeline (26:05-26:20):
"Those applications from local government bodies are due on November 10th with the goal of the state making a decision by Thanksgiving. And yes, that is Thanksgiving of 2025, not 2026."
Council Member Owen on Criminal Justice Focus (34:44-35:47):
"It is truly a criminal justice facility, not a general mental health facility. And I think that's the right lens for the analysis... if it's going to be in Yellowstone County, we have to address its location... We must address workforce now... And we have to address release planning."
Council Member Rupsis on State Timeline (38:22-38:46):
"I was sitting there Friday looking at this thing and I just kept thinking about this Seinfeld episode where Elaine is invited to a wedding in India that's going to take place in like two or three weeks from now. And it's absolutely not a serious invitation... so it was a non-vite, a non-invite, and I got the sense that that's what this was."
Council Member Aspenlieder on State Partnership (1:07:00-1:10:44):
"This isn't a referendum on the legislature trying to fix a problem. It's a referendum on how this process is trying to be implemented in a very clunky and non-partnership fashion. This is once again Helena telling us what they're going to do in our community without collaborating with us from the get-go."
Council Member Shaw on Residency Restrictions (1:37:32-1:37:55):
"My first thought is, you know, if you come to Montana and want to own a horse, you can't live in the city. That seems like a really kind of mean line to draw in my opinion for a director... that would be a very valid reason to live in the county yet work for the city."
PUBLIC COMMENT HIGHLIGHTS
Doug Osborne (10:32-14:34):
Osborne, a longtime Billings resident and attorney, offered mixed feedback on the council and city leadership. He expressed that he feels safer in Billings than 18 months ago when he previously addressed the council about crime concerns. However, he criticized Mayor Cole's eight-year tenure, saying "I don't feel safer."
Jim Ronquilo (14:43-18:58):
Ronquilo reported attending a Big Sky Future economic summit with over 300 people where Council Member Kennedy represented Billings. Ronquilo enthusiastically recounted Kennedy's pitch to potential businesses: "Billings, the city of Billings is open. We're open for business. Anybody want to come there? We welcome you with open arms. We have a affordable housing project just going on online in the Heights. We have a new electrical generating outfit out in Laurel that's burning clear air clean air. We're ready for you."
MEETING STATISTICS
Duration: Approximately 1 hour and 57 minutes
Attendance:
-
Council Members Present: Mayor Cole, Kendra Shaw, Roy Neese (online), Jennifer Owen, TJ Rogers, Bill Kennedy, Scott Aspenlieder, Daniel Tidswell, Tom Rupsis, Mike Boyett
-
Excused: Ed Gulick
-
Guests: Senator Mike Yakawich ("Southside Mike"), Jon Forte (Yellowstone County City-County Health Department/Riverstone Health), Commissioner Waters (Yellowstone County)
Process and Tone:
The meeting reflected significant frustration with state government processes, particularly the compressed timeline and perceived lack of partnership from DPHHS. However, legislators present (Senator Yakawich) and health officials (Jon Forte) were treated collegially, with council members distinguishing between legislative efforts and executive branch implementation. The residency requirements discussion was more philosophical and less contentious, with council members expressing various perspectives on balancing recruitment flexibility with community investment.
|