|
This week, Christians and Jews are honoring two of their faiths' most sacred holidays: Holy Week (April 13th to April 20th) and Passover (April 12th to April 20th). Many non-religious people observe Easter for its secular meanings, such as celebrating spring, renewal, and community. But for all people, this is a sacred time of the year.
On April 16, 2025, Dana Point Harbor Partners (DPHP) notified slip tenants of a increase in slip fees in excess of 9%. Click here to read the letter. In our opinion, this was a proverbial raising of the middle finger, showing no respect to boaters or the County. The letter gave no rationale for the rate increase as required by the Master Lease with Orange County. Is this because DPHP feels the draft copy of a 5-year plan proposed last year is acceptable rationale? Also, DPHP is well aware that Orange County authorized an independent market rate survey for slip pricing. We are confident they know the report from the appraiser is due by the end of May. Was the slip rate increase letter sent in advance of the market rate survey because DPHP is fearful of what the report will say? So much for respecting sacredness.
We hope the County holds DPHP to both the letter of their Master Lease with the County, and the obvious intent of the key clause on using a proper market study to establish slip rates at market rate pricing, reasonably determined and consistent with the limitations on pricing as mandated by the Tidelands Grant.
We expect the new appraisal from a professional, independent, qualified, and well-vetted appraiser to have a different result from the farce of a market rate study of a year ago, using only Newport Beach marinas (marinas which were cherry-picked) for a desired result.
And, lastly, the new appraisal should set a Gold Standard for how all future appraisals or market rate surveys should be done, so no more Cherry Picking is involved.
On another note, did you notice on the slip rate increase letter that the marina office is now advertising 15’ slips? We are not sure where these slips are in the marina, but we hope to say more in an upcoming newsletter.
We have stated in previous newsletters that under the Public Trust Doctrine, which regulates the Dana Point Tidelands Grant, Orange County as Grantee, has certain fiduciary responsibilities which cannot be assigned or abdicated.
Under the Public Trust Doctrine, a grantee (e.g., a local government or private entity) holding public trust resources has a fiduciary responsibility to manage those resources for the benefit of the public. This means they must act in good faith, with reasonable care and skill, and avoid self-dealing or conflicts of interest that would harm the public interest.
1. Fiduciary Duties:
The grantee must manage the trust property with reasonable care and skill, ensuring its preservation and proper use for the public's benefit.
The grantee must act solely in the public's best interest, avoiding any actions that could benefit the grantee at the expense of the public.
The grantee must act honestly and fairly, avoiding any actions that would be inconsistent with the trust's purpose.
2. Key Aspects of the Fiduciary Duty:
- Preserving Trust Resources:
The grantee cannot alienate or deplete trust resources, such as submerged lands, for private gain.
The grantee must ensure reasonable public access to and enjoyment of the trust resources, such as beaches, waterways, and parks.
The grantee must balance competing interests when managing the trust, considering both current and future public needs.
- Transparency and Accountability:
The grantee must be transparent about its management of the trust resources and be accountable to the public for its actions.
3. Examples of Potential Violations:
-
Selling trust lands for private development: This would violate the duty to preserve the trust resources for public use.
-
Favoring private interests over public interests: This would violate the duty of loyalty.
-
Engaging in self-dealing or conflicts of interest: This would violate the duty of good faith.
We ask, is Orange County faithful to its fiduciary duties? You decide. We, for one, are tired of hearing the County say they don’t have the power to do anything. If they don’t have the power then they have abdicated their power. Plain and simple!
|