November 4, 2025

THE REMBRANDT HEIST 

Anthony Amore

Pegasus Crime

11/4/25

True Crime

Hardcover, 272 pages

“...a dramatic and colorful recounting...an impressively detailed play-by-play of the theft, drawing on his own investigations into the thefts of artworks and his access to Connor and Dotoli, both of whom he’d befriended, and sources in law enforcement and the art world. This captivates.” 
-Publishers Weekly

On April 14, 1975, notorious art thief Myles Connor, in disguise, entered the Boston Museum of Fine Arts with an accomplice. They headed straight to the Dutch Gallery, stole Portrait of Elsbeth van Rijn, and escaped after a brief scuffle—leaving no evidence behind.



Unlike most thieves, Connor wasn’t motivated by money but by freedom. The previous summer, arrested for trying to sell stolen Wyeth paintings while already out on bail, he coolly told an FBI agent, “Just you watch me,” when challenged about his fate.

Again on bail, Connor confided in State Police Major John Regan, who told him, “It’s going to take a Rembrandt to get you out of this one.” Thus began the heist. But intertwined with this caper was the story of Connor’s best friend, music man Al Dotoli, whose own plan depended on the Rembrandt’s return.


The Rembrandt Heist reveals the anatomy of this audacious crime, the genius and contradictions of Myles Connor, and the tangled loyalties of friendship—set against the backdrop of one of history’s most famous paintings.

Dear Reader,


For the past twenty years, I have been investigating, researching, teaching, and writing about art theft. To gain a deeper understanding of those who steal highly valuable art, I set out years ago to interview as many of these individuals as possible. Along the way, I encountered Myles J. Connor.


Meeting Connor made sense: he is the best art thief who has ever lived. Moreover, he hails from Milton, Massachusetts, which is a stone’s throw away from where I work at the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum in Boston. 


I had been on the trail of the thirteen works taken from the Gardner Museum for 10 years before reaching out to Connor. There was a good reason for this delay. First, for many of those years, he was incarcerated in a federal penitentiary (on an art-related charge, naturally). I had also learned a lot about him during those years from the countless people who called me offering information about him, certain that he was behind the Gardner heist.


He was not. Instead, he was serving a federal prison sentence in Illinois. Still, upon his release, it was essential that I finally talk with him. It proved to be the start of a friendship that has lasted over a decade, born of a strange kinship at the intersection of art thievery and art protection. 


My friendship with Myles Connor meant years of unfettered access, including long interviews about not just his crimes but, more interestingly, his motives. It turns out that his heists were based not on money—as is the case with almost every other art theft in history—but in other motives connected to his unique code of honor. And what money he ultimately did make from heists (both from banks and museums) was used to feed his insatiable appetite for Asian antiquities—primarily, samurai swords.


Connor’s heists are the stuff of legend. But it was his biggest score—the 1975 theft of a Rembrandt from the Museum of Fine Arts in Boston—that was the most stunning, in terms of his reasons and the breathtaking return of the painting accomplished by his longtime best friend, Al Dotoli.


Dotoli’s life is a legendary story unto itself, growing a small-town concert sound business into a worldwide endeavor supporting the major musical acts of his time. But it was his undying loyalty to his best friend, Connor, that led this legitimate businessman to risk it all and return the stolen Rembrandt to win his friend’s freedom.


The Rembrandt Heist is more than just a book about theft. It’s a story of fidelity, true friendship, and a curious sense of honor that will force you to keep reminding yourself that it’s all true!


Thank you,


Anthony Amore

Book Club Menu

A Dinner for a true Japanophile


Main Dish: Miso-Glazed Black Cod 

Side Dishes: Steamed Rice and Miso Soup

Beer Pairing: Sapporo (Myles Connor’s favorite)


The subject of The Rembrandt Heist—art thief Myles Connor—is a lover of Japan who spent nearly all of his ill-gotten gains on a world-class collection of samurai swords!


I've had many meals with Myles Connor. In fact, our very first meeting ended with lunch at a Japanese restaurant in Quincy, Massachusetts. It wasn't a surprise that he chose the place--Connor's affinity with all things Japanese is the stuff of legend, beginning with trips to Boston's Museum of Fine Arts with his grandfather, from whom he inherited the passion.

 

The first thing he ordered was a Sapporo beer. Truth be told, I knew that was coming, too.

 

As an avid animal lover, I expected him to eschew meat. He didn't disappoint. He's not exactly a vegetarian, but his preference is sushi and other pescatarian delicacies. So, in honor of this art thieving-samurai-sword-collecting enigma, I offer the following meal.

 

Miso-glazed black cod is iconic in Kyoto-style cuisine and has been made famous globally by chefs like Nobu Matsuhisa. It features buttery, flaky black cod marinated in a sweet-savory miso sauce and broiled to perfection.


Anthony Amore

For Your Book Club

About Anthony Amore

Join Book Club Favorites


Book Giveaways


Say Hello


Register for GalleyMatch


Novel Noshes


Author Recipes

©Copyright 2025 The Book Club Cookbook

Facebook  Twitter  Instagram  Pinterest