|
November 15, 2026
Key Developments and What We're Discussing Today:
- Dov Waxman's forthcoming book, The Question of Antisemitism: A Guide for a World Divided by Israel-Palestine, will be released on January 5. I strongly recommend it.
- I interviewed Waxman about his book on Thursday. We covered definitions of antisemitism, the essence of antisemitism, intent vs. impact, slogans sometimes considered antisemitic, when anti-Zionism is antisemitic, and other subjects discussed below.
- For the thousandth time: Determine if a poll of the Jewish vote is methodologically sound before believing it, let alone sharing it. The latest examples are the misapplication of a NORC poll to the Jewish vote in Michigan and a flawed Jewish Majority poll of Michigan Jewish voters. We all want to know how Jews voted in Michigan. Intellectual honesty compels us to conclude that we don't know.
You're on this list because you are smart, good-looking, and generous. Please support my work by chipping in via credit card (you do not need a PayPal account), Zelle (contact me for info), Venmo @Steven-Sheffey (last four digits, 9479), or check.
Friends,
Dov Waxman's forthcoming book, The Question of Antisemitism: A Guide for a World Divided by Israel-Palestine, will be released on January 5. I read an advance copy. I strongly recommend it to anyone who wants to better understand what antisemitism is and isn't, especially as it relates to Israel and Zionism. Unlike many nonfiction books these days, Waxman's book contains no fluff or filler.
Waxman, the Presidential Chair of Modern Jewish Studies at UCLA, writes that instead of asking whether anti-Zionism is antisemitic or whether criticism of Israel is antisemitic or whether pro-Palestinian protests are antisemitic, "we should be asking when criticism of Israel, when anti-Zionism, and when pro-Palestinian protests cross the line into antisemitism. Sometimes they do, but often they do not."
Waxman warns that "making opposition to Israel and Zionism the focus of the fight against antisemitism enables right-wing politicians to shield themselves from accusations of antisemitism by touting their support for Israel."
Instead, noting that Jews cannot effectively fight antisemitism alone and that they need allies, he recommends coalition building and increased solidarity between Jews and other minority groups: Combating antisemitism should," he writes, "be an integral part of the wider fight against all forms of racism, as it once was."
I interviewed Waxman about his book. I tried to ask the questions that you might ask after reading his book. The conversation below has been edited for length and clarity and is no substitute for reading the book, although it will give you a taste of what to expect.
Do you agree with those who argue that we do not need a definition of antisemitism?
I don't reject the value of a definition. When I teach my students, for example, I always emphasize the need to define key terms. The problem is the excessive attention to defining antisemitism, and particularly, the focus on what is antisemitic vis-à-vis Israel and Zionism.
My main criticism is directed at the intense focus that's been given to the IHRA definition, which isn't a very good definition in important respects. The focus on IHRA has ended up becoming a distraction from actually combating antisemitism. For example, many organizations, including universities, come under pressure to adopt the IHRA definition and then feel that the job is done. As long as you've adopted some definition, that's really the main ask and their main activity in terms of combating anti-Semitism. I think we can agree on a lot of things about what is antisemitic without diverting a lot of energy and attention away from actually addressing antisemitism itself.
What about the Nexus Project and the Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism (JDA) definitions?
I think they're both improvements on the IHRA definition [Waxman was involved in the drafting of the Nexus definition]. I think the value of the JDA is the way in which the JDA explicitly links the fight against antisemitism to the wider fight against racism in general. And I do think that's valuable, particularly on the anti-racist left, where the fight against antisemitism is often ignored or relegated to something of secondary importance. So in that respect, if the JDA had more prominence in the United States, it might help to align the fight against antisemitism with the fight against racism.
You seem to view antisemitism as primarily a form of racism. But others see antisemitism as primarily a conspiracy theory. How do you reconcile these different positions?
Conspiracy theories have played a central role in contemporary antisemitism and have done so in the past as well. But I wouldn't reduce antisemitism solely to conspiracy theories. Understanding antisemitism as a distinctive type of racism, as I present it in the book, doesn't exclude the role that antisemitic conspiracy theories play, but it doesn't reduce it solely to that. If we think about antisemitism this way, we can understand how it operates on multiple levels. Conspiracy theories are examples of cultural antisemitism; in other words, how antisemitism manifests in anti-Jewish ideas and anti-Jewish beliefs. But that's not the only way in which antisemitism can manifest.
Also, it obviously manifests in behavior, in actions such as discrimination and violence that aren't always motivated by conspiracy theories. Sometimes it can be motivated by antisemitic stereotypes on a more emotional level of dislike, discomfort, or even envy. We would recognize all of those as antisemitic even if not motivated by beliefs in Jewish conspiracies.
When we see antisemitic conspiracy theories in circulation, that should ring alarm bells, but I think it's a bit reductive to reduce antisemitism solely to a conspiracy theory.
Many people think that antisemitism is synonymous with Jew-hatred. Do you agree?
One of the things I try to push back on in the book is that very simplistic, very crude understanding of antisemitism. We now have, when it comes to other forms of racism, like anti-Black racism, a much more sophisticated understanding of how anti-Black racism operates. Somebody says, "Oh, I don't hate Black people." But if they're voicing anti-Black stereotypes or engaging in discrimination, we would say clearly it's not just enough to say, "I don't hate Black people" or "I have a Black friend."
But when it comes to Jews, some people still fall back on this idea that it's just about hating Jewish people, and if you don't hate them, that's fine. And many Jews themselves have that very kind of simplistic view. It's incumbent upon us to educate ourselves and have a better, more sophisticated understanding of antisemitism, because if we don't have that, we certainly can't expect other people to have that.
If Jews cannot agree on what antisemitism is or how to define it, how can we expect anyone else to understand what antisemitism is?
I think there is the most disagreement regarding Israel and Zionism. There's no dispute among Jews on other topics, such as Holocaust denial or certain conspiracy theories being antisemitic. Jews disagree among themselves about Israel and Zionism increasingly. And now that has spilled over into a disagreement over what is antisemitic vis-à-vis Israel and Zionism. That does make it harder to then explain to non-Jews what is antisemitic because there is no agreement among Jews. I also think it's hard because Jews themselves often don't really understand what antisemitism is.
How should we respond when people use antisemitic tropes without realizing that they are antisemitic tropes, such as Graham Platner's claim that he did not know his tattoo was antisemitic (looking at it, I would not have known either), or Trump's claim that he did not know that "Shylock" was an antisemitic slur?
Our response should recognize that a person employing an antisemitic trope isn't necessarily an antisemite. These symbols have been circulating in our culture and Western culture for a long time, so it's very easy for people to draw on symbols, stereotypes, tropes, without necessarily themselves harboring animus against Jews. We need to be able to recognize that antisemitism is more widespread than antisemites.
What about impact vs. intent? Someone might not intend a certain statement to be antisemitic and might be motivated by factors other than what we would consider antisemitic, but some Jews might hear it as antisemitic.
We have to consider not just what their intentions were, but what impact it might have upon on a Jewish person. We can't just shrug it off. But at the same time, I don't think we should respond in the same way we should respond to intentional acts of antisemitism.
How does that analysis apply to certain controversial slogans such as "Palestine shall be free from the river to the sea," or "Free Palestine," or "Globalize the Intifada"?
In the book, I distinguish between harm and offense. Something might be offensive, it might upset people, but that doesn't mean that it should be ruled out of bounds or unacceptable. So I would distinguish between "Free Palestine" or even "from the river to the sea" and the call to "globalize the intifada."
Globalize the intifada could be meant as maybe the original Arabic meaning, simply throwing off or trying to challenge the Israeli occupation. But it's not unreasonable, given the second intifada, for many people to fear that it is a call for violence. In that case, the impact isn't simply that we're being offended by this. It leads to a sense of threat and fear.
I would identify that as a harm. It leads Jewish people to be scared and fearful. There's a distinction between being offended by something and being threatened by something.
People need to think about the impact of their statements or their actions on Jews, but that doesn't mean that anytime a Jewish person is offended by a statement, that statement should be censored. It means that all of us should take into account how our words will be heard.
Unfortunately, instead of saying to those who might use slogans that upset us, "What did you mean? This is what we heard," the reaction is simply, " You're an antisemite; you need to stop saying that."
What about anti-Zionism?
Anti-Zionism can be antisemitic, but not always. Those who oppose Israel's continued existence as a Jewish state need to be clear and explicit about what that's going to mean for Jews currently living in Israel. There are some forms of anti-Zionism that will have antisemitic consequences for Jews.
If it results in a state in which Jews are relegated to second-class citizens or even worse, have their property taken from them and are pushed to emigrate, those would be harmful outcomes for Jews.
But other versions of anti-Zionism don't necessarily involve annulment of Jewish rights in Israel/Palestine. We need to be more nuanced about this instead of lumping all forms of anti-Zionism together and treating them as all the same. Some of them would very likely have antisemitic consequences for Jews, but not all.
Some forms of anti-Zionism, most of all, Jewish forms, are motivated by concern for Jews, the argument being that Zionism and Israel's identification as a Jewish state is harmful for Jews.
Conflating all forms of anti-Zionism, and then saying, for example, they all originated from Soviet anti-Zionism (which is antisemitic), or they're all the same, is a huge overgeneralization that is really unhelpful at a time when anti-Zionism is undoubtedly rising. We need to be able to explain to people when anti-Zionism is antisemitic and when it isn't, and how people can, if they want to oppose Zionism, do so in a way that is not going to be harmful to Jews.
So what is the bottom line and why did you write this book?
It all comes down to we need more nuance. The conversation about antisemitism within the Jewish community, and certainly in the country at large, is really broken, is really becoming unhelpful, and becoming deeply contentious. This isn't good for Jews. It's not good for the fight against antisemitism, and it's not good for having serious, much-needed conversations about Israel/Palestine.
In Case You Missed It:
- Some people claimed that the NORC poll showed that a majority of Jewish voters voted for Rogers over El-Sayed. Seriously? It was a poll of the general voting population that happened to pick up 102 Jewish voters in Michigan. It did not weight by denomination and did not ask the Pew pre-screening questions necessary to determine whether respondents were Jewish. NORC is a reputable polling organization, but they were not trying to poll Jewish voters. That’s why they did not mention the results for Jewish voters in their own reporting about their poll's results.
- A Mercury poll of Jewish voters in Michigan commissioned by something called "the Jewish Majority" failed to weight by denomination and failed to ask the screening questions necessary to determine whether respondents were Jewish. It is not a methodologically sound poll of the Jewish vote.
- Before you believe, let alone share, any poll of Jewish voters, read my explainer on how to evaluate polls of the Jewish vote. I have yet to see a methodologically sound poll of Jewish voters in Michigan. But I've seen a lot of unsound polls of Jewish voters in Michigan. Try to remember that the plural of "bad data" is not "good data."
- The Nexus Project explains that combating antisemitism means combating white nationalism, attacks on immigrants, and efforts to undermine our democracy, and provides examples of how Stephen Miller, Trump's new chief of staff, has made destroying those core values his political purpose, including Miller’s xenophobic, anti-democratic, hate-fueled actions.
- Michael Koplow recommends that Israel address its declining standing in both parties by focusing less on arguing how valuable it is to the U.S., and focusing more on bringing its policies into alignment with American values.
Social Media of the Week. Paul Rudnick,
Video Clip of the Week. Trump reacts to the midterm election results.
Vintage Music Clip of the Week. The joy is infectious: Rod Stewart & Faces-- Pool Hall Richard (1973).
Wondering Why I Did Not Reply to Your Email? Read the fine print.
This is the newsletter even Republicans have to read. If someone forwarded this newsletter to you, your luck continues. You can subscribe and get it in your inbox every Sunday for free. Just click here.
I hope you enjoyed today's newsletter. It takes time to write and costs money to send. You are on this list because you are smart, good-looking, and generous. If you'd like to support my work, click here and fill in the amount of your choice. You don't need a PayPal account. If you see something that says "Save your info and create a PayPal account," click the button to the right and it will go away. Or you can use Zelle, (contact me for info), Venmo @Steven-Sheffey (last four digits, 9479), or send a check.
Unless stated otherwise, my views do not necessarily reflect the views of any candidates or organizations I support or am associated with.
|