Learn21's Weekly EdTech Update

July 23, 2026

The EdTech Index and the Case Against Starting from Zero 

By Joseph South, Chief Innovation Officer, ISTE+ASCD

Every year, thousands of district teams sit down to evaluate the same products. They pull up the same privacy policies, read the same vendor one-pagers, and ask the same questions to the same sales reps. Across the country, educators are duplicating work that has already been done, sometimes by the district one town over.


This isn't a knock on due diligence. Evaluating EdTech thoughtfully is genuinely important work. But when a district in Ohio spends three weeks vetting a reading app for data privacy, and a district in North Carolina spends three weeks vetting the same app for the same reason, something has gone wrong. Not with their process, but with the infrastructure supporting it.


That's the problem the EdTech Index was built to solve. Outside of being free to use, the most immediate benefit is time. Rather than spending weeks researching each product individually, you can see at a glance which tools have already been vetted for quality, safety, and effectiveness. For district teams managing formal procurement, that head start adds up fast. 


A Shared Starting Point

One of the questions our team kept returning to was: how do we make the work of edtech evaluation less redundant and more useful for the people actually doing it? Educators and district leaders aren't short on frameworks or guidance. What they're short on is time, and a reliable place to start.


The EdTech Index aggregates vetting already completed by organizations that specialize in it, including the ISTE Seal, Digital Promise, 1EdTech, Project Unicorn, and more. Rather than requiring every district to independently surface and interpret this work, the platform brings it together in one place, mapped to a common set of quality indicators: Safe, Evidence-Based, Inclusive, Usable, and Interoperable.


Safe: Protects student and educator data privacy and security.

Evidence-Based: Has a research foundation and demonstrated learning impact.

Inclusive: Designed for all learners, including those with divergent needs.

Usable: Intuitive experience for both students and educators.

Interoperable: Integrates with existing school or district systems.


The goal isn't to make the decision for you. It's to make sure your evaluation starts where everyone else left off, not from zero.


What This Looks Like in Practice

The five quality indicators aren't meant to be exhaustive. They're meant to highlight the most important considerations: the elements that, if you get them right, give a product a real chance of working in your context. For example, a product that is safe but not usable won't get adopted. A product that is usable but not evidence-based won't produce outcomes. The indicators are designed to work together, giving evaluators a complete picture rather than a narrow slice.


Over 2,000 products are currently listed on the EdTech Index, with third-party validations visible directly on each product profile. Whether you're a classroom teacher looking for tools that fit your subject area, or a district team managing a formal procurement process, the EdTech Index is built for both. You can:

  • Search by grade level, subject area, or product type.
  • Filter by which quality indicators have been earned. 
  • Access detailed information on pricing, implementation requirements, and integration capabilities.


Our goal is to save every district 1,000 hours of review time while actually increasing their overall satisfaction with their choices. That’s 1,000 hours that can be invested right back into directly helping youth learn, grow, and thrive. 


The Work Still Ahead

Aggregating existing validation data is a starting point, not an endpoint. We are on the constant hunt for additional data points that will help educators make high quality decisions. 


One area we're actively working on involves creating pathways for educators themselves to contribute structured, verified reviews, building a layer of peer knowledge on top of the institutional vetting that already exists. The research is clear that educators trust their peers. The question is how to capture that trust in a way that's rigorous enough to be useful and accessible enough that people actually use it. We are working hard to find the sweet spot that will unlock this powerful additional context.


The EdTech Index doesn't replace the need to evaluate the fit of a particular solution for your specific context. Every district's needs are different, and no platform can make that judgment for you. But it gives every team a head start, and right now most teams aren't getting one.


If you're evaluating EdTech right now, the Index is ready to use today. Start at edtechindex.org.

Media Literacy Minute

The UK’s Answer to Doomscrolling Teens: A Social Media Curfew

The UK government has unveiled plans to block 16- and 17-year-olds from social media between midnight and 6 a.m. by default, while also requiring breaks during chatbot use and cracking down on AI tools that give unsafe mental health advice. This Yahoo Finance UK report notes that media literacy teaching will be strengthened in schools starting this September, alongside new guidance for families on safe AI use. It’s a useful signal for U.S. educators watching how other countries pair platform regulation with classroom digital literacy instruction.


Kids Are Already Using AI — Are We Teaching Them How?

A new UNICEF study found that AI is already used by nearly half of 12- to 14-year-olds and more than half of 15- to 17-year-olds, making AI literacy impossible to treat as an add-on. This UNICEF piece argues that young people need explicit instruction in distinguishing fact from AI-generated fiction, checking whether AI answers are accurate, and understanding how these tools affect their learning, privacy, and safety.


AI Slop Is Everywhere. Here’s How to Spot It.

Ohio University AI faculty experts examine “AI slop,” the flood of low-quality, high-volume AI-generated content named Merriam-Webster’s 2025 word of the year, and what it means for how students and families consume information. This Ohio University explainer finds that while slop isn’t drowning out real news by volume, faculty are more worried about irresponsible or misleading AI use, underscoring why AI literacy belongs alongside traditional media literacy skills.

Why the EdTech Index Matters: A Trusted Resource for K-12 Technology Decision-Making 

By Five Star Technology

At Five Star, we understand that K-12 technology leaders face increasingly complex decisions. From infrastructure and cybersecurity to instructional technology and operational systems, school districts are tasked with identifying solutions that not only meet their immediate needs but also support long-term educational outcomes. Finding the right partners to help navigate those decisions is critical.


That’s why we’re proud to be included on the EdTech Index.


The EdTech Index has become a valuable resource for school districts seeking trusted, vetted partners within the education technology ecosystem. Rather than sorting through countless vendors and solutions, district leaders can use the Index to identify organizations that have demonstrated a commitment to serving K-12 education and understand the unique challenges schools face.


At Five Star, we believe that transparency and accessibility are essential in helping districts make informed decisions. Our inclusion in the EdTech Index provides districts with another avenue to learn who we are, explore our areas of expertise, and determine whether our approach aligns with their goals and priorities.


For districts, the benefits of referencing the EdTech Index extend beyond simply finding vendors. The platform creates a more informed and efficient evaluation process. Technology leaders can explore solutions, compare providers, and identify partners with specialized experience in education. This helps reduce the time and uncertainty often associated with researching potential technology investments, allowing district teams to focus on strategic planning and implementation.


As a company dedicated exclusively to K-12 education for over 20 years, we appreciate resources that empower district leaders to make confident, well-informed decisions. Every organization is unique, and there is no one-size-fits-all approach to educational technology. Having access to a trusted directory of partners encourages thoughtful conversations around needs, priorities, and desired outcomes.


The EdTech Index also fosters stronger connections between districts and solution providers. By making information more accessible, the platform creates opportunities for meaningful partnerships rooted in trust and shared goals. These relationships are essential because successful technology initiatives are built on more than just products and services; they are built on trust.


At Five Star, we are honored to be part of the EdTech Index alongside organizations committed to advancing education through innovation and service. As districts continue to navigate an ever-evolving technology landscape, resources like the EdTech Index play an important role in helping leaders identify partners who can support their vision. We are proud to be part of that community and remain committed to helping schools leverage technology to positively impact students, educators, and their unique communities.  

Big Ideas

Big ideas image

Chimps, Crystals, and 780,000 Years of "Ooh, Shiny"

Ever wonder why our ancient relatives lugged crystals home even though they never used them as tools or jewelry? A new study offers a clue: researchers gave quartz crystals to chimpanzees at a Spanish sanctuary, and the chimps went full rockhound. One carried a crystal back to his room and held onto it for days, and caretakers only got it back by trading bananas and yogurt. In a second test, the chimps picked crystals out of a pile of 20 ordinary pebbles within seconds, even when the crystal types varied in shape and shine.


So the next time a student is distracted by the latest “shiny” thing, take note: it’s just a 6-million-year-old evolutionary response. Turns out it’s not a distraction, it’s a primate birthright. 


Microsoft's 2026 Report: AI Homework Is Basically Everyone's Homework Now

Microsoft's third annual AI in Education Report is out, and the top number is hard to miss: 92% of students and education leaders, and 88% of educators, have already used AI for school. The bigger story, though, is the gap it surfaces: most students and over half of educators say they haven't gotten formal AI training yet, even though a strong majority want it monthly or quarterly. Microsoft's answer is a batch of new free tools (Copilot Notebooks for students, an "AI Guidelines" feature for teachers to set expectations, live-monitored "Learning Zone" lessons) plus a no-cost AI literacy credential built with ISTE and the OECD's AI framework.


Whether it's a chimp puzzling over a quartz crystal or a classroom of students onboarding a new AI notebook, curiosity looks the same at any evolutionary distance. The trick is building the guardrails and guidance so that curiosity turns into real understanding, not just novelty that fades.

X Share on X
LinkedIn Share on LinkedIn

www.learn21.org

LinkedIn        X        YouTube        Instagram