THE TTALK QUOTES 

On Global Trade & Investment
Published By:
The Global Business Dialogue, Inc.
Washington, DC  Tel: 202-463-5074
 
No. 54 of 2019
TUESDAY, AUGUST 6, 2019

Click HERE for yesterday's Brexit quote Janet Daley.

with thanks to

for sponsoring the event that gave rise to today's quote.

AUTO PARTS AND A NORTH AMERICAN REALITY

 "The industrial capacity of Central Canada, Ontario and Quebec -- except for this little thing called the border -- is essentially part of the U.S. industrial complex."

Flavio Volpe
July 24, 2019
CONTEXT
Geographically, Canada sits at the top of North America’s three-country pillar. At the GBD event on July 24, an event devoted to North American trade,  Flavio Volpe provided the view from Canada. Mr. Volpe is the President of the Automotive Parts Manufacturers Association of Canada. That means that he is part of an industry – the making of cars, trucks, and SUVs – that is vitally dependent on the integration of, and cooperation among, the three North American economies. 

Today’s quote is from comments he made in the Q&A portion of last month’s discussion at GBD. Mr. Volpe acknowledged that Canada has a number of other trade agreements but was quite clear that there really is no comparison between any of those and NAFTA/USMCA, the arrangements with the United States. After noting that 80 percent of the Canadian population lives within 100 miles of the U.S. border, Mr. Volpe said:

"Geography dictates how we do business. You can’t run just-in-time supply chains across two oceans. And so, we’ve always said publicly that the biggest losers [from the loss of] NAFTA or USMCA [would be] Canada right up there with the U.S. The fact of the matter is that the U.S. has got a heck of a lot more industrial capacity to absorb a stupid move like that. We’d be lighting the wick. And however long the wick is, you’re done."

As Mr. Volpe talked about the interplay of geography, politics, and the North American trade agreements – it seemed clear that, if the United States ratifies the agreement, so will Canada. But the timing could be tricky. Parliament is in recess now, and by law a federal election must be held on or before October 31. No one, of course, knows how that election will turn out, but Mr. Volpe did hazard a guess. “I think the current government is going to be re-elected,” he said, “[but] in a minority.” If in fact that is the result, he said, namely a Trudeau-led minority government, “we won’t see the House return until January, as the new government negotiates with other parties on who will support the government, going forward.”

What might those complications mean for the implementation of the USMCA and the all-important rules of origin for automobiles? Mr. Volpe spoke to those issues. He said:

“The three-party agreement says it [USMCA] will come into effect three months after the last country ratifies. And then the automotive rules say the following January is when the new rules come into play.  So, if Canada is the last [to ratify] and it does it in December, January, with a new government or maybe the return government, then we’re seeing the automotive rules of origin starting in January 2021 instead of January 2020.  The automakers will be happy for another year of transition.”
COMMENT
With apologies for the understatement, the U.S.-China commercial relationship is deteriorating at an alarming rate. Those developments also affect U.S.’s North American trading partners, but, for the most part, that is a set of issues for later entries. There is room here for two or three observations, however. The first is from Mr. Volpe’s opening remarks on July 24, when he said,

“The North American economy, the aggregate North American economy, is the strongest economy in the world. Never mind that the main one is the strongest, … the three together is a bloc that can hold off the Chinese surge [and] is a very good hedge against Europe and other rising power[s].”

The second is a development that tends to bolster the above. It is not often that trade data show up as front page headlines, but the front page of last Saturday’s Wall Street Journal carried this one:

Tariff Fight Knocks Off China As Top U.S. Trading Partner. 

China is now number three with Mexico and Canada respectively in first and second place.

Finally, we do not have a good feel for how this August recess is playing out in congressional districts across the country. Our hope is that, at the very least, the roller coaster ride in the rest of U.S. trade policy is reinforcing for Democrats and Republicans alike the urgency of stabilizing North American trade as quickly as possible. The vehicle for doing that is the implementing legislation for U.S.-Mexico-Canada Agreement or USMCA.
SOURCES & LINKS
From the Q&A is a link to the audio recording of the concluding Question-and-Answer session of the GBD event on USMCA that was held in Washington on July 24. This was the source for today’s featured quote.

Flavio Volpe’s Presentation is transcript of Mr. Volpe’s opening remarks at GBD on July 24.

China No Longer No. 1 takes you to the Wall Street Journal article mentioned in the Comment section above.  

TO GET THE TTALK QUOTES IN YOUR INBOX
Or Other GBD Notices, click below.