"Children Learning, Parents Earning, Communities Growing"
December 7, 2020 | Issue #49
California Alternative Payment Programs (APPs)- Lifting up families and children

Since 1976, community based Alternative Payment Programs (APPs) have been supporting working families with access to child care, early education and supportive services. For over 40 years, APPs connected income eligible working families with resources to lift families up towards self-sufficiency and help break free from the cycle of poverty for themselves and for their children. Today, these programs have evolved in their supports for the most fragile of families by linking them not only to child care and early learning programs but also to food programs, mental health, domestic violence intervention, housing, transportation and health care to name a few.
 
For each month in 2020, an agency was profiled to showcase their work and services being delivered within their respective county and/ or community. Review of those profiled highlighted ways that individual agencies and the case managers were working to support the needs of families in a 24 hour/seven days per week economy, to meet the unique cultural and linguistic needs of families with outreach and materials in understandable languages and to serve as a reliable place families could turn to in any time of need.
 
During these unprecedented and challenging times, our agencies not only continued to be the reliable place for families to turn, but increased their supports to include access to emergency child care, diapers, collected clothing for the entire family, housing and food. As communities continue to recover, the agencies continue to serve. Lifting families and children up is the North Star that is our compass for the work that we do. 
 
Here are the unique CAPPA Member Agencies profiled in 2020. Click on each of them to learn more!
Governor Newsom Releases the Master Plan for Early Learning and Care: California for All Kids

Aspirational but Fails to Meet the Here and Now

Observations from CAPPA's CEO: As reported last week, the Master Plan was released on December 1, 2020. The 113 page document has much in it to like. However, it simply fails to address the immediate needs of the child care and early learning delivery system.

Currently, our system of child care and early learning is grossly underfunded. Over the last ten years, this system had only received a token amount of real investment in terms of building up access for working families and meeting the real needs of our earliest learners beginning at birth. Family child care providers and centers that support our poorest of families with access to child care to meet their needs make on average between $3.00 per hour and $7.50 per hour. And the rates reimbursed to those family child care providers to care for the most fragile of children are based on 2015 reimbursement data.

During this pandemic, over 400 child care centers and 5,700 family child care homes have closed down. However, the demand for access by our essential workers on the frontlines of this pandemic and our poorest of families has grown.

The Master Plan for Early Learning and Care fails to meet or even address in a real way the crisis that currently exists. And by failing to address the immediate crisis in a real and thoughtful way the current subsidized child care system will simply crumble and have to be rebuilt from scratch at a much higher cost.

The Master Plan espouses expansion of transitional kindergarten for all 4-year-olds and greater access to qualified 3-year-olds in the state to public preschool. Sounds great. However, there is absolutely no way to reach those goals if the existing child care workforce goes out of business.

For community based partners that support our poorest of working families, this plan does not take into account their working needs. Those needs being that child care must be provided in a real way that meets the real working needs of families in California's 24-hour/seven days per week economy.

So for conversation sake, and the focus of the plan to expand preschool and transitional kindergarten, where is the investment to support wraparound supports for working families. For instance, most families cannot leave their job after three and a half hours, the time of a preschool or part-day kindergarten program. These families would need to secure transportation from one program to another.

Additionally, many of the families that rely on subsidized child care to work, need after 6:00 pm evening care or weekend. The Master Plan does not meet the real needs of our poorest families or the true working needs of most families.

Finally, the master plan creates more fractures within the existing system. Essentially the plan says that three and four year old children will be supported; however families with infants and toddlers are left out.

California's child care system is poised for total collapse. The time is now to set a priority of funding family child care providers and centers. Stabilize what capacity currently exists. It is then, and only then that it be appropriate to revisit the goals of the Master Plan.

The Master Plan for Early Learning and Care can be read here. Click here to see past meeting materials & information.
California unveiled a blueprint for the future of early education. Critics say it’s built on shaky ground

(Excerpt) “We’re sounding the alarm, because the system is on the verge of collapse,” said Max Arias, chairman of the Child Care Providers Union, which represents thousands of workers. “Who knows how the sector will look when it’s time to start implementing this plan? We need to address this crisis, because if not, there won’t be any child-care providers left.”

Indeed, the pandemic has further destabilized an industry that was already in decline when Gov. Gavin Newsom campaigned on early-education reform in 2018, and when experts began work on the plan last fall. Echoing the Master Plan for Higher Education, the Master Plan for Early Learning and Care was envisioned as a 10-year guidebook for new legislation, investment and reform. Its main goals include uniform standards for early education, better training for child-care workers, easier access to subsidized care for low-income families and universal transitional kindergarten for all California 4-year-olds.

“The goals they lay out are great, but where’s the roadmap for actually getting this done?” asked Ted Lempert, a former state assemblyman who is president of the research and advocacy organization Children Now. “COVID has made this system so fragile and so essential. Now we’re in code red.”

Click here to read full article.