|
Full Details
We hope this message finds you well. As you may be aware, CFA Institute has proposed a bylaw amendment titled “Amend Bylaws Article 9 – Nominating Process and Election.” After careful review and thoughtful discussion, the CFALA Board of Governors unanimously recommends that our members vote “No” on this proposed change.
We share this recommendation not as an act of opposition, but as a commitment to upholding the principles of transparent, inclusive, and representative governance that define the CFA community.
Why We Recommend Voting “No”
1. The Proposal Eliminates Member Representation in CFA Institute Board Nominations
The amendment removes Presidents Council Representatives (PCRs) as voting members of the Nominating Committee—the only individuals elected by member societies who have historically provided the membership’s direct voice in selecting CFA Institute’s global leadership. This change would centralize board nominations within a smaller group of current board members, with no voting input from the broader membership.
2. The Rationale Provided Is Not Supported by the Facts
CFA Institute has stated that PCRs have “limited, if any, exposure” to the Board of Governors and the Institute’s strategy. We respectfully disagree. PCRs regularly engage with the Board, participate in strategic discussions, and are intimately familiar with the organization’s operations and long-term goals. They offer valuable insight—grounded in member experience and local society leadership—that strengthens the quality and diversity of board nominations.
3. The Proposed Candidate Advisory Council Is Not a Substitute
While the proposal introduces a Candidate Advisory Council, this body would be non-voting, advisory-only, and composed of individuals appointed by or affiliated with existing committees—not elected by the membership. In contrast to the existing nominations committee, these participants would hold no formal power to shape or approve the board slate. The structure lacks the transparency and authority necessary to meaningfully represent the member voice.
4. This Shift Is a Step Away from Inclusive Governance
CFA Institute is a global membership organization, not a private corporation. Member-elected PCRs bring balance and accountability to board nominations, ensuring our leadership reflects not only strategic alignment but also member relevance and trust. Removing this direct representation risks undermining member engagement, weakening transparency, and concentrating power.
Moreover, having PCRs as voting members on the Nominating Committee provides a critical safeguard against insularity—especially at a time when the CFA Institute is facing mounting global challenges and is being called to adapt to the evolving needs of a shifting investment profession. Eliminating this structural channel for broader input would weaken the Institute’s responsiveness and long-term resilience.
5. Many Peer Organizations Uphold Member Representation
Numerous leading membership organizations—including the Financial Planning Association, PMI, AICPA, and IMA—continue to include non-board, member-elected representatives in their nominations processes. These practices demonstrate that governance structures can remain strategic while honoring democratic input.
What You Can Do
We urge you to carefully review the proposed amendment and consider the long-term implications for member representation and governance. If you share our concern that this change reduces transparency and member input, we encourage you to join us in voting “No” on the proposed amendment to Article 9.
How to Vote:
Select the "Against" option to vote NO on this proposal
If you have already voted your proxy and wish to change your vote, you may do so up to the deadline of July 21, 2025 by logging back into the voting site (link below). You will need your election validation number from the original email and your CFAI ID number.
|