|
Good Enough Just Isn't
Casey Cropp, CMEA President
One day, during a particularly intense rehearsal, one of my flute students asked why I kept rehearsing a musical passage over and over. My response was that it wasn’t good enough. Her next statement was so striking that I will never forget it! With a wrinkled expression on her face, she replied, “I think you should just say, Good Enough Just Isn’t.” I’ve often pondered what she said that day as incredibly insightful.
Recently, as I have had the opportunity to be a clinician at festivals, I’ve been told to consider evaluating ensembles that play everything listed on the music well as a level 2 rating. The rationale is that a computer can do that, however it doesn’t address the musicality and emotional impact of an outstanding performance. I believe that to be a very accurate statement as well!
All this has me thinking: do we have an expectation of inspiring our students to go beyond performing just what they see on a page? Isn’t it our goal to develop musicality? Beauty of melodic line? Understanding of our role in harmonic support? In a passage of a Tim Lautzenheiser book that I’m presently re-reading, he writes,
“Humans, by nature, enjoy comfort. In addition to that, we are creatures of habit, and we find ourselves repeating behaviors simply for the sake of fulfilling the requirements of life; in a sense, we do what we do to maintain the status quo or to get to the point of “it’s good enough.”
This “good enough” thought process has seemingly been at the back of my mind forever…
What brought it to my head now was that I just heard someone I respect greatly make the comment, “We as individuals are too easily pleased!” It put that memory from my flute student right back in the front of my brain…
And it made me realize why some performances are okay to good, and others go way beyond expectations.
Could it be that as you begin to wrap up another year - as contests, festivals, final performances, and end-of-year projects are all shaping up, are you holding your students and ensembles to the standards and levels that are going to help them continue their growth for the rest of their lives? Or might you be in the cool-down stage, trying to make it until the end?
I hope the fire continues to burn brightly! Those who look up to you every day deserve all you can give them up to the final bell!! Finish stronger than ever!
Casey
|