|
As many California employers know, courts in this state tend to interpret employment laws broadly, often in ways that favor employees. However, two recent decisions favored employers.
In Doe v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A., the Second District Court of Appeal held that an employer is not strictly liable for harassment allegedly committed by a supervisor who did not supervise the employee who brought the complaint.
And in Villasenor v. Schneiter, the same appellate district held that the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) does not change the common law presumption that a corporation is separate from its owner. As a result, a plaintiff seeking to hold an owner personally liable as the company’s “alter ego must overcome that presumption.
Doe v. Wells Fargo Bank
Under FEHA, an employer is generally strictly liable for harassment by a supervisor, even if the employer did everything right. For harassment by a coworker, however, the employer is liable only if it knew or should have known of the conduct and failed to take immediate and appropriate corrective action.
The plaintiff, a Wells Fargo wealth advisor, alleged that a high-performing investment strategist with a “managing director” title sexually assaulted her during a 2020 business trip. She conceded he was not her supervisor but argued the bank was liable because he supervised other employees. Wells Fargo sought summary judgment, arguing it could not be strictly liable because the strategist never supervised the plaintiff.
The Court of Appeal affirmed. It held that where the alleged harasser is not the plaintiff’s supervisor and only supervises other employees, strict liability does not apply. Strict liability exists because harassment by one’s own supervisor carries a power imbalance and a risk of retaliation. If the harasser does not supervise the complainant, the alleged harasser is simply a coworker.
The court also noted that the plaintiff’s rule would produce odd results, such as making an employer strictly liable if a shop foreman harassed an executive.
Additionally, the court cautioned that strict liability is not limited to an employee’s direct or immediate supervisor. Under FEHA’s broad definition of “supervisor,” other employees can also qualify as the employee’s supervisor. But where, as in this matter, the alleged harasser is not the plaintiff’s supervisor, strict liability does not apply.
Villasenor v. Schneiter
In Villasenor, a restaurant hostess won a jury verdict against her corporate employers for sexual harassment and other FEHA violations. She then sought to hold the company’s owner personally liable as her employer’s alter ego.
Under the alter ego doctrine, a court may disregard a corporation’s separate identity and pierce the “corporate veil” when misuse of the corporate form justifies holding the owner liable for the corporation’s actions.
To do so, a plaintiff must show (1) such a unity of interest and ownership that the company and owner are not truly separate, and (2) an inequitable result if the company alone is held responsible.
Courts presume that a company exists separately from its owner, and the plaintiff bears the burden of overcoming that presumption.
Villasenor argued that FEHA’s purpose requires courts to reverse that presumption in FEHA cases. The Court of Appeal disagreed, holding that FEHA does not alter the presumption of corporate separateness. The court explained that the presumption is consistent with FEHA’s goal of providing effective remedies: A plaintiff who cannot collect from a corporate defendant can still seek recovery from the owner by overcoming the presumption.
The Bottom Line for Employers
Prompt and impartial investigations are key.
Although strict liability may not apply in every case, an employer may still be liable if it fails to respond to a harassment complaint. Wells Fargo prevailed in part because it promptly investigated, placed the alleged harasser on leave, and disciplined him afterward.
Train managers to report informal complaints. An earlier complaint at Wells Fargo was never reported or investigated. In another case, a similar incident could help establish that an employer “knew or should have known” About harassment. Investigate every complaint, formal or informal, rather than assume it will go away.
Respect the corporate form.
Under Villasenor, owners are not automatically liable for FEHA judgments against their companies. That protection is strongest when the business operates as a genuinely separate entity, with its own finances, records, and corporate formalities.
|