|
Last week in San Francisco, as a delegation representing CalAPA walked toward the Bay Area Air Quality Management District headquarters downtown for a meeting, disruption was happing nearby. A driverless electric vehicle glided up to an adjacent office building, a woman walked out and stepped into it, and it silently zoomed off.
In California's Silicon Valley, the word "disruption" is celebrated as central to reinventing moribund industries. You might be reading this newsletter on a device only dreamed of just a few short years ago.
In government circles, however, disruption is a concept that is feared, and in some quarters loathed. Yet every so often demands for "reinventing government" ebb and flow, and and ebb and flow again. They almost always arrive with a flurry of pronouncements and activity, but ultimately have little, if any, lasting impact. As a famous Californian, former President Ronald Reagan, once intoned, "There you go again."
Last week in Washington, a new president, elected on a disruption platform, was sworn in and immediately began signing a stack of sweeping executive orders that challenged existing law, policy, norms and customs. Chaos ensued.
For the asphalt pavement industry, orders that could impact transportation funding, labor availability and air quality regulations attracted the most interest. Yet most of the orders were less policy directives and more statements drawn from campaign speeches, accompanied by rhetoric-embedded press releases. On one issue, Diversity, Equity & Inclusion (DEI), the Trump administration declared it was time to end the "DEI Madness." Many of the announcements can be viewed HERE.
Perhaps the centerpiece of the administration's reform government effort is the creation of a Department of Government Efficiency to come up with cost-saving measures for America's largest employer, the federal government. Tech mogul Elon Musk, himself a disruptor and the face of the effort, has tossed about the potential of cost savings of $1 trillion to $2 trillion. An official White House statement about that effort is HERE.
While some of the orders call for studies to be conducted and reports issued, there are a number of tangible impacts that are already being felt. A federal freeze on hiring, for example, as well as "return to the office" orders are creating great anxiety as workers await guidance from supervisors about the specifics of what the pronouncements may mean in day-to-day operations. A wave of retirements and turnover in government jobs is likely.
An informal Asphalt Insider survey last week of agencies that operate in California found that anxiety and confusion was widespread, and clear guidance lacking. There was concern that federal grants for various environmental-related initiatives may be at risk. The new administration has taken aim at California's air-quality regulations, in particular, so many questions on that front abounded. With regard to transportation, one early casualty may be a $32 million federal grant to California to advance the use and understanding of "low-carbon transportation materials." Information on that federal program is HERE. The notion that complex LCTM software, years in development and on the verge of being widely released, could be scuttled at the 11th hour also is creating agita in some circles.
A press release or speech or presidential order is not the same as a law, or regulation issued in accordance with the law, so most agency personnel were taking a "wait and see" approach. The fact that several executive orders have already been challenged in court will no doubt complicate matters.
With regard to road construction in California, ongoing projects, and funding, is already in place and proceeding per legal and binding contracts, so there should be little disruption in the short term. However, morale among government employees will no doubt be impacted. As the spotlight shines brighter on unpopular government operations and those who cannot make a strong case that their jobs are essential, that anxiety will certainly grow.
California has seen these movements before. Gov. Gray Davis, a Democrat, created a "Reinventing Government" office known formally as the "Innovation in Government" office with many of the same government-efficiency aims, but his botched handling of the state's energy crisis led to his recall in 2003. Republican Arnold Schwarzenegger was swept into office with a sweeping reform mandate, but his "blow up the boxes" declarations and Blue-Ribbon "California Performance Review" initiative, plus a deep economic recession, terminated some of the most ambitious reform ideas.
About a decade ago, when the non-partisan Legislative Analysts Office determined that Caltrans was overstaffed by 1,500 positions, the Brown Administration called for an outside review of the department conducted by the State Smart Transportation Initiative (SSTI) at the University of Wisconsin. The report, released in 2014, contained a number of recommendations and action plans to make progress on those recommendations.
“We asked for an honest assessment because we are committed to modernizing Caltrans and improving transportation for all Californians,” said then-CalSTA Secretary Brian Kelly in a press release. “This report describes significant challenges that built up for decades at Caltrans and we are committed to facing those challenges proactively and taking action to deliver a modern transportation system that Californians deserve.” Translation: these problems didn't happen on our watch, but we're determined to fix them now. The original press release is HERE. The SSTI "Performance Investment and Transparency" report is HERE.
Caltrans used the report and followup actions as proof it was making improvements, and it did in some areas. That message was folded into the campaign for SB1, the $50 billion Road Repair & Improvement Act of 2017. Since then, the department has added thousands of new employees, to more than 22,000 in Gov. Gavin Newsom's most recent budget. At the same time, CalSTA has released bloated "Climate Action Plans" that seem to promote inaction over action. In other words, "efficient" is not often a term used to describe Caltrans these days. The governor's budget summary, by the way, obscures this growth by blending transportation into a larger "Infrastructure" heading.
If history is any guide, the net effect of the latest round of pronouncements is likely to be more pronouncements, task forces, press releases, lawsuits and other performative actions, but in the long run little meaningful progress that can be noticed by the average motorist or taxpayer. After all, Jerry Brown had two terms as governor to "fix" transportation before returning to Sacramento for Brown 2.0. Similarly, Donald Trump had four years in the White House from 2016-20 to make reforms but a pandemic and controversy dogged him. We'll see how much success he has this time around. Voters certainly seem to have grown impatient with the status quo.
Disruption may work in the business world, but everything about our government is designed to resist it. Anyone elected to any office can see that. Now what?
An authoritative story on the history of transportation funding in California that culminated with the passage of SB1 in 2017 appeared in CalAPA's "California Asphalt" magazine and can be found HERE.
|