|
The key take-aways from the above chart are:
- During the course of any given year, the S&P 500 Index of large-company US stocks falls, on average, by 14.2% (red dots show intra-year declines)
- Going back to 1980, annual stock market returns have been positive in 35 of 46 years, or three-quarters of the time
- The average annual return for large-company US stocks over the past 46 years has been 10.7% (grey bars show full-year returns)
Dealing With Dissonance
Many of us are feeling a degree of dissonance today—an uncomfortable gap between what we sense in the world around us and what we know we should do with our long‑term financial plans.
Some clients have expressed a version of the following sentiment: "I'm worried about where the country is heading. Maybe we should reduce risk until things settle down.”
This reaction isn’t irrational. It’s human. When the social or political climate feels tense, uncertain, or discouraging, it’s natural to want to create stability somewhere—and the easiest lever to reach for is the investment portfolio. Wanting safety when everything feels unsafe is an understandable impulse.
But as understandable as it is, history tells us that making portfolio decisions based on fear, dismay, or frustration with the state of affairs has consistently been a poor long‑term strategy. Not because the feelings are wrong, but because they rarely correspond to actual economic fundamentals.
In this article, I want to do three things:
- Acknowledge the emotional reality many people feel today.
- Explain why pessimism and portfolio management don’t mix well.
- Offer a more constructive framework for evaluating your financial future—one grounded in economic resilience, not political anxiety.
Why We Feel Dissonance
When external events feel chaotic or divisive, we instinctively brace ourselves. Our brains have evolved to treat negative information as a call to action. In other words, the more unsettled we feel, the more likely we are to seek swift, protective measures.
In personal finance, this often leads to two common urges:
- The desire to reduce risk (“Let’s lower stock exposure for now.”)
- The urge to protect gains (“The market has done well; maybe we should step aside before things turn.”)
These feelings do not arise because of portfolio conditions—they arise because of life conditions. And the danger is that we adjust our portfolios based on emotion, rather than based on data and long-term requirements.
This is the core of the dissonance: the world around us can feel worse even while the economy and markets continue to function, adapt, and grow.
Why Acting on Pessimism Is Historically Counterproductive
-
Feelings do not predict financial outcomes. Researchers have repeatedly found that consumer sentiment, political sentiment, and investor mood frequently diverge from actual market performance. At various times in history, Americans have felt deeply pessimistic about the nation’s direction—even during periods of strong corporate earnings, rising GDP, and resilient labor markets. Markets care about productivity, innovation, interest rates, earnings, global demand, cash flow, corporate reinvestment, and labor efficiency—not the daily emotional climate of society.
-
Major market gains often occur during times of maximum discouragement. Some of the strongest market performance has happened in years when public confidence was especially low. Market behavior is forward‑looking, and investors who wait for “things to feel better” often end up missing out on significant positive returns.
-
The long‑term track record of disciplined investors tends to be strong. Over any extended timeframe—20, 30, 40 years—the U.S. stock market has shown remarkable resilience. It has grown through wars, recessions, inflationary cycles, political polarization, technological disruption, global crises, and periods of profound national division.
What Actually Deserves Your Attention Right Now
-
The broader health of the U.S. economy. Even in times when the social mood is sour and politics are polarized, economic fundamentals can remain robust. Employment, consumer spending, corporate investment, productivity growth, innovation, and global demand all play central roles in shaping market performance. Today, many of these fundamental economic indicators are trending in a positive direction.
-
The resilience and adaptability of companies. Most successful companies are not fragile—they are adaptive organisms. They evolve in response to changing consumer preferences, technological shifts, supply chain challenges, and cost pressures. And the stock funds selected for your portfolio tend to emphasize large, well-managed, profitable companies.
-
Your personal financial plan—not the news cycle. Your investment strategy is built to support your retirement timeline, spending needs, risk tolerance, tax situation, and estate planning goals. Adjustments should be made in the context of these factors, and not in reaction to political developments.
How to Navigate the Dissonance Productively
-
Acknowledge the emotion without acting on it. It’s OK to feel unsettled. The goal is not to eliminate the feeling—just to prevent it from dictating your financial decisions.
- Use data, not moods, as decision inputs.
-
Reaffirm your long‑term purpose. Your portfolio is designed to support your life for decades, including years when the world feels off‑kilter.
If you’re experiencing dissonance today, you are not alone. Susan, Donna, Alex and I are here to address your concerns and help you stay the course with your investment strategy and your financial plan.
January Reset for College Planning
January is one of the most important months in the college planning process. It is a natural time to take a breath and reset, evaluate where you are and create a clear strategy for the months ahead.
Whether you are a junior gearing up and getting into the nitty gritty of it all, or a senior facing decision points, there are opportunities at this stage in the year to set yourself up for success in both admission outcomes and affordability.
Here are some focus points to help you get the year started on the right track.
1. Financial Aid and FAFSA deadlines
Deadlines are critical for these applications to maximize your financial aid. Also, some schools require the forms for merit scholarships even though they are not need-based.
- Families should be completing the FAFSA and CSS Profile (if required) if they have not already- early submission ensures you do not miss priority windows for university grants
- Check for other college-specific deadlines such as unique scholarship opportunities separate from merit scholarships
2. Review Academic Progress and Mid-Year Grades
Reflect on your academic progress and be sure to have a plan for the second half of the school year.
- Mid-year grades matter- colleges use them to confirm academic consistency, make decisions for students who were deferred in the early action process, and evaluate the academic rigor for juniors
- Check in with teachers if you have any concerns about finishing the year strong to get extra support
3. Evaluate and Focus on Extracurricular Activities and Their Impact
Think ahead about what else you would like to get involved with before college for your own growth and interest and to help with your college applications.
- Reflect and consider what you want to focus on for spring and summer
- Do you want to take on a leadership role? Start an impactful project? Set up an experience for summer that will be meaningful for you and your college application?
4. Make a Standardized Testing Plan (Juniors)
Spring is a common testing window. Start making your plan now for spring.
- Decide on testing or test optional
- If you take tests, which will you take? SAT, ACT, or both?
- What will be your test prep? Also, how many attempts will you make?
5. Plan for Spring College Visits Now
College open houses fill up for February and April breaks.
- Sign up for open houses early and make your hotel reservations early if needed
- Create a spreadsheet or list of items to compare for each college such as costs, student environment, geography, academics, unique features, etc.
6. Refresh Your College List
Your college list will likely evolve, and that is a good thing. It is a good time to re-evaluate based on these items:
- Your academic interests
- Your academic performance
- Information from your research on the college
- Likelihood of a merit scholarship (important affordability factor)
- Geographical location
- A “best fit” both financially and for the student’s overall experience and comfortability
7. Create Your Student and Family Timeline for the Next Six Months
Having an organized plan and roadmap of upcoming deadlines and “to dos” will help the whole family stay on track and reduce stress.
Some Items for Your January to June Timeline:
- Testing dates and prep plan
- Financial aid application deadlines
- Campus visits
- Application items for seniors
- Setting up activities for spring and summer
- College List review of your top criteria and schools
- Family meeting times- set time aside during these busy years to create a calm space for discussing your college plans
- Anything else that needs to be done!
January is a great time to set up expectations and success for the coming year. Thinking about your strategy now and following your own plan and committing to steps will go a long way to being successful in finding the right college fit for the student and the family’s financial situation.
Start your plan NOW knowing you will have a momentous year ahead, approaching the exciting “move-in” day when you see your efforts pay off!
Media for the New Year
The new year can act as a catalyst to expand horizons and vary daily routines. So far in 2026, I’ve expanded my regular news diet to incorporate balanced and diverse points of view from foreign-domicile media sources.
Here are three podcasts that I’ve been tuning into regularly, which you might find helpful:
-
BBC News – Newshour: the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) is the UK’s national public service broadcaster, founded in 1922 and operating as a chartered corporation, independent from government influence. This podcast is “long-form”, with daily episodes running about 45 minutes.
-
Reuters World News: the Reuters news agency was established in London in 1851 and acquired by the Thomson Corporation of Canada in 2008. This podcast is “short-form”, with daily episodes running about 10 minutes.
-
FT News Briefing: The Financial Times (FT) was founded in London in 1888. The British company Pearson, which had owned the FT since 1957, sold it to the Japanese holding company Nikkei a decade ago. This podcast has a financial markets orientation and is “short-form”, with daily episodes running about 10 minutes.
These daily productions can be accessed using a web browser, but you may find following via a podcast app more convenient. My favorite podcast app is Pocket Casts, which can be downloaded to your phone using the Apple App Store or through Google Play.
|