Weekly Roundup
COVID-19 Vaccine Development, Policy, and Public Perception in the United States
|
|
CommuniVax Corner
Our local teams continue supporting vaccination efforts in their communities:
- The team in San Diego has connected with a local food pantry to support rollout efforts. The team is also coordinating with a local School Garden Education Program manager to develop activities for specific target populations. Finally, the team has an upcoming meeting with the Roman Catholic Diocese of San Diego to conduct outreach with several churches in the area. Some of the team's work has recently been described in the New York Times.
- The team in Idaho has been invited to work alongside the Southeast Idaho Public Health team doing outreach and education among local Hispanic and rural white communities, and identifying ways to couple vaccine information with an ongoing reproductive health program targeting young women.
- The team in Prince George's County partnered with Luminus Health to sponsor a vaccine clinic in one of their HAIR barbershops, where 35 people received the J&J vaccine. The team is also planning for another HAIR salon clinic that might focus on vaccine-eligible children.
|
|
People, Perceptions, and Polls
|
|
RESEARCH
Communicating With Vaccine-Hesitant Parents: A Narrative Review. The communication that occurs between a provider and parent with regards to vaccination is critical in reducing concerns and nudging parents toward vaccine acceptance. We focus on promising approaches related to patient-provider communication within the context of vaccination. We found empirical evidence that the use of a presumptive format to recommend vaccines, motivational interviewing, and tailoring information to increase message salience are approaches that can positively affect vaccine acceptance . (Academic Pediatrics, 5/21)
See also:
|
|
NEWS
Anti-vaccine movements shift their target to the vaccinated. While variations of such false claims have been part of misinformation campaigns around the COVID-19 vaccines, there has recently been a shift from demonizing the vaccine itself to villainizing those who are vaccinated. It's a peculiar repositioning for the anti-vaccination conspiracy movement — and as the false claim evolves into more extreme iterations, it has caught the attention of people who study and advocate against vaccine misinformation. . (Salon, 5/26/21)
|
|
NEWS
Resistance to vaccine mandates is building. A powerful network is helping. At stake in this latest contest is whether hospitals, law enforcement agencies and others can require employees to take a vaccine that was made available in an expedited process permitted during a public health emergency — and, likewise, whether schools may require the shots for students, faculty and staff members in the same way many require familiar vaccines for measles and chickenpox. There is little case law on the matter, with only one vaccine, for anthrax exposure, previously cleared in a similar way . (Washington Post, 5/26/21)
|
|
NEWS
‘It’s a minefield’: COVID vaccine safety poses unique communication challenge. Public-health specialists must always strike a careful balance when communicating about vaccine safety, but the enormous scale of the COVID-19 vaccine roll-out means that safety data are evolving fast — so researchers are scrambling to share developments transparently and clearly with the public. And they worry that with the rise of anti-vaccination movements, their messages might be used or interpreted to fuel misinformation campaigns. (Nature, 5/21/21)
|
|
NEWS
The Vaccine Class Gap. Working-class members of every group are less likely to have received a vaccine and more likely to be skeptical. “No matter which of these groups we looked at, we see an education divide,” Mollyann Brodie, who oversees the Kaiser surveys, told me. In some cases, different racial groups with the same education levels — like Black and white college graduates — look remarkably similar . (New York Times, 5/24/21)
|
|
NEWS
Faced with anti-vaccination parents, teens are helping one another get Covid shots. Kelly Danielpour, who runs VaxTeen, said that among the dozen or so queries she gets every day, many are from teenagers contending with parents opposed to them getting vaccinated against Covid-19. The first step, she said, is arming the teenagers with information and resources they can use when talking to their parents — and in some cases that has worked. But if that doesn’t sway parents’ opinions, she said, she tries to get the teenagers information about “minor self-consent.” (NBC, 5/23/21)
|
|
WEBINAR
Tackling Gender-Relation Barriers to Equitable COVID-19 Vaccine Deployment. This webinar will 1) Present the gender and vaccines guidance note and checklist for tackling gender-related barriers to equitable COVID-19 vaccine deployment; 2) Discuss recommendations and challenges to address gender-related barriers and inequities in the field of vaccine delivery and uptake in the Global South; and 3) Explore strategies implemented by selected countries related to equitable vaccine deployment. It will take place on June 3, 2021, 9-10 AM EDT . (United Nations University, 5/21)
|
|
NEWS
Rand Paul says he won't get a Covid vaccination. Republicans remain perhaps the most a vaccination-resistant demographic. A recent PBS/NPR/Marist poll found that more than 4 in 10 Republicans say they have no plans to get vaccinated. Paul has said for months that his natural immunity means getting vaccinated is unnecessary, even though scientists say the evidence about long-lasting natural immunity is murky . (NBC, 5/23/21)
|
|
NEWS
As the US Unmasks, the Pressure Is on for Vaccine Passports. The natural way to create a vaccine passport is to make it a federal function, as Israel and countries in Europe are doing, because national governments have the most comprehensive data about their citizens’ health status. Or, well, they ought to have. In fact, a decision made during the Trump administration renders it practically impossible for a federal vaccine passport to be created. (Wired, 5/25/21)
|
|
NEWS
States Are One-Upping Each Other with Vaccine Rewards — But Will It Work? Offering people rewards for getting vaccinated isn’t something new. Large retail chains like CVS, Target, and Walgreens have offered perks like this for years — usually in the form of a gift card or coupon for customers who get a flu shot. Other businesses have gotten in on the giveaways during the Covid-19 vaccine rollout, offering everything from free doughnuts and beer to weed and amusement park tickets, with proof of vaccination . (Rolling Stone, 5/18/21)
See also:
|
|
NEWS
They Haven’t Gone for a Shot. So Shots Are Coming to Them. Across the country, nurses, technicians, emergency medical workers and community partners are rolling up to the doorsteps, streets and churches of people who are homeless, who live in areas without reliable transportation or who have no internet access. Their goal: to reach the unvaccinated stragglers in overlooked neighborhoods, plugging a vulnerable gap in the nationwide effort to outmaneuver death . (New York Times, 5/20/21)
|
|
NEWS
The Struggle to Improve Vaccination Rates Among Latinos in New York. In interviews, three dozen Latinos living in New York City expressed skepticism about how the vaccines were developed, but the primary reason they cited for not getting a shot was a lack of access. When the vaccine was first offered, some people didn’t know where to make an appointment or whom to ask for help. And those who did complained about the hurdles they faced: most of them worked more than one job and didn’t have time to search for a slot; others didn’t have a reliable Internet connection at home or were hesitant to call the vaccination hotline, owing to their limited command of English. . (New Yorker, 5/22/21)
|
|
NEWS
US COVID-19 vaccination pace is down by nearly half in the last month. These states slow to vaccinate may struggle this summer, expert warns. The eight states with the fewest vaccine doses administered per capita are Mississippi, Alabama, Louisiana, Arkansas, Wyoming, Idaho, Georgia and Tennessee, according to the CDC. The states with the most administered per capita are Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, Hawaii, Maine, Rhode Island, New Mexico and New Jersey. Washington, DC has a rate of vaccination that would qualify in the top eight if it were a state, according to the CDC . (Philadelphia Tribune, 5/21/21)
|
|
NEWS
Unmasked and Unequal. A Kaiser Health News analysis of CDC vaccination data this week found that only 22 percent of Black Americans have gotten vaccinated, and in most states the rate of Black people who’ve been vaccinated lags behind that of white residents. This is a flagrant failure in the vaccine rollout, especially considering that Black folks experienced some of the worst COVID-19 outcomes—a matter fueled by systemic racism and compounded by being more likely to work an essential job and less likely to have access to quality health care . (Slate, 5/21/21)
See also:
|
|
RESEARCH
Indirect Protection by Reducing Transmission: Ending the Pandemic with SARS-CoV-2 Vaccination. The direct protection against disease measured by the clinical trials is important, but whether and to what extent the vaccines provide indirect protection by reducing transmission is also of great consequence in controlling and eventually ending the pandemic. Therefore, understanding the effects of vaccines on transmission is key to deploying evidence-based population vaccination plans, recommendations for the public, and policies for use of nonpharmaceutical interventions with varying degrees of effectiveness in this next stage of the pandemic . (Open Forum Infectious Diseases, 5/21)
|
|
Law, Policy, and Politics
|
|
OPINION
Should employers make vaccination mandatory? Yes, here’s why. Some Americans do not want to be vaccinated, with many bristling at the prospect of others telling them what to do. Individual liberty is a foundational American ideal. This underscores the critical importance of addressing directly whether workplace vaccine mandates are defensible. Our answer is: Yes, employers are ethically justified mandating that employees get vaccinated — especially when community transmission rates are high, and a sizable percentage of workers remain unvaccinated . (Baltimore Sun, 5/28/21)
|
|
NEWS
C.D.C. Will Not Investigate Mild Infections in Vaccinated Americans. Critics say the agency is missing important opportunities to learn about the real-world effectiveness of the different vaccines and to gather information that might help identify trends in the pandemic’s trajectory — for example, how long vaccine protection lasts, or how various vaccines compare in preventing infection with variants, or whether certain patients like older people are more susceptible to breakthrough infections . (New York Times, 5/25/21)
|
|
NEWS
The US worried about vaccine tourists. Now it’s encouraging them. Robert Amler, the dean of New York Medical College’s school of health science and practice, says that encouraging travelers to fly to the United States from places with low vaccination rates—and potentially higher levels of infection—may itself be bad for public health. “Any risk of ‘importing’ covid infections will depend on the volume of incoming travelers and the percent of travelers arriving who already have covid infection,” says Amler, a former chief medical officer at the CDC. (MIT Technology Review, 5/26/21)
|
|
Research, Development, and Clinical Practice
|
|
LETTER
SARS-CoV-2 vaccines for all but a single dose for COVID-19 survivors. We believe the best solution is to provide individuals who already had a SARS-CoV-2 infection receive only one (rather than two) shots of the currently authorized mRNA vaccines (BNT162b2/Pfizer; mRNA-1273/Moderna). Emerging real world evidence suggest that the antibody responses to the first vaccine dose in individuals with prior SARS-CoV-2 infection is equal to or exceeds the antibody titers found in naïve individuals after the second dose . (The Lancet, 5/25/21)
|
|
NEWS
Moderna says its Covid-19 shot works in kids as young as 12. The company studied more than 3,700 12- to 17-year-olds. Preliminary findings showed the vaccine triggered the same signs of immune protection in kids as it does in adults, and the same kind of temporary side effects such as sore arms, headache and fatigue. There were no COVID-19 diagnoses in those given two doses of the Moderna vaccine compared with four cases among kids given dummy shots. In a press release, the company also said the vaccine appeared 93% effective two weeks after the first dose. (STAT, 5/25/21)
|
|
NEWS
COVID-19 Vaccine Makers Are Looking Beyond the Spike Protein. In recent months, though, it’s become clear that the coronavirus is a slippery, shape-shifting foe—and spike appears to be one of its most malleable traits. Eventually, our first generation of spike-centric vaccines will likely become obsolete. To get ahead of that inevitability, several companies are already looking to develop new vaccine formulations packed with additional bits of the coronavirus, ushering in an end to our monogamous affair with spike . (The Atlantic, 5/21/21)
|
|
NEWS
How greenlighting Pfizer's new vaccine storage requirements could dramatically improve access. "The ability to store Pfizer vaccine in refrigerators for a period of time is great news as this makes the vaccine more readily available to the public because community clinicians like me are able to get, store and deliver vaccinations to help us reach the last mile, have more flexibility in distribution plans and reach areas where vaccines may be harder to access in a timely manner," said Dr. Jay Bhatt, an internist in Chicago and an ABC News medical contributor. (ABC, 5/22/21)
|
|
NEWS
Can ‘Vaccinated’ Breast Milk Protect Kids? The Science Is Hazy. Despite the limited data, across the country, interest in what some are calling “vaccinated milk,” bought on the black market, has risen in recent months. Some are reportedly advertising it on Craigslist for $3.50 an ounce — more than 10 times the price of gasoline. (This, to be clear, isn’t a great idea: Research has shown that untested milk can have all kinds of bacteria and one small 2015 study found that about 10 percent of samples advertised as human breast milk online contained milk from a cow.) . (Undark, 5/19/21)
|
|
This newsletter supports CommuniVax, a research coalition convened by the
Johns Hopkins Center for Health Security and the Texas State University Department of Anthropology,
with support from the Chan Zuckerberg Initiative and The Rockefeller Foundation.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|