Volume 18, Issue 1

January 2025

Neutral Risk Doctrine 


By Robert Cassio, Esq.


In a recent WCAB decision, a Board Panel denied the defendant’s Petition for Reconsideration on the issue of “arising out of employment,” (AOE), and confirmed compensability for injuries caused by a third-party assault which were perpetrated for unknown motives. In Bustamante v. Community Warriors 4 Peace, 52 CWCR 162, the applicant, who was a former gang member, was sent into a dangerous neighborhood in Los Angeles which was known to be an area active with gang activity. While working, the applicant was shot multiple times by two assailants. The claim was denied noting that the applicant's injuries had not arisen out of his employment and contended that the applicant was the only victim and that he was personally targeted due to his former gang affiliations.


At trial, the applicant testified that he did not recognize the individuals that shot him, he was uncertain as to whether the assailants were gang members and did not why he was shot. The applicant also offered evidence in the form of police reports that the applicant told officers that he had not seen the suspects and did not understand why he was targeted. The police reports also noted details which confirmed the randomness of attack. 


Continue Reading...

Remote QME/AME Evaluations Post COVID-19 Emergency Regulations


By Candace Talbot, Esq.


During the COVID-19 pandemic, emergency regulations were put into place allowing QME and AME evaluations to proceed virtually either by telephone or by videoconferencing. This was seen in Title 8 Section 46.2 of the California Code of Regulations, which has now been repealed, along with many of the other emergency COVID-19 regulations. However, remote medical legal evaluations are still available post COVID-19. Title 8 Section 46.3 of the California Code of Regulations outlines the conditions for a remote medical legal evaluation. This code section states that video conferencing for a medical legal appointment that has both video and audio connection can be utilized if the below conditions are met and a hands-on evaluation is not necessary:


"(A) There is a medical issue in dispute which involves whether or not the injury is AOE/COE (Arising Out of Employment / Course of Employment), or the physician is asked to address the termination of an injured worker's indemnity benefit payments or address a dispute regarding work restrictions; and


(B) There is agreement in writing to the remote health evaluation by the injured worker, the carrier or employer, and the QME.


(C) The remote health evaluation conducted by means of a virtual meeting is consistent with appropriate and ethical medical practices and the AMA Guides 5th edition, as determined by the QME and the relevant medical licensing board; and


(D) The QME attests in writing that the evaluation does not require an in person physical exam” (Title 8 Section 46.3 of the California Code of Regulations.)



Continue Reading...

Recent Panel Decisions on Issues of UR Timeframes and Discontinuance of Care


By Brian Binkley, Esq.


Labor Code Section 4610 outlines the timeframes in which responses to treatment requests are due. Generally, requests for authorization of treatment are allowed a response with 5 business days or within 14 days upon the timely request for additional information for the treatment being requested. For issues involving an imminent or serious threat to life, these decisions must be addressed within 72 hours of the request made. Two recent panel decisions have addressed this subject matter. Please note these panel decisions have not been marked as significant and are not binding precedents but give guidance to the court’s assessment of the subject.

 

In Silvia Correa v. Display Products (2024) 89 Cal.Comp.Cases 1075, the issue was addressed as to who can decide whether a request for treatment involves the imminent or serious threat to life requiring a 72-hour response. In this case, the primary treating physician submitted a request for caregiver assistance, 12 hours per day, seven days a week for six months. The defendant had previously provided care at 4 hours per day under a prior stipulated agreement that was set to expire. The RFA itself did come to the claim’s examiner marked as needing an expedited response. The carrier provided their response within the general 5-day time frame indicating the request itself did not establish the need for review with the expedited time frame required.  


Continue Reading....

Fresno

7112 N Fresno St Ste 300

Fresno CA 93720

Ph: (559) 449-2558

Fax: (559) 449-2564


Bakersfield

1800 30th Street, Suite 320

Bakersfield CA 93301

Ph: (661) 328-2200

Fax : (661) 328-0022

Facebook  Instagram  Web