DEMOCRATIC WORLD FEDERALISTS
PEACEFUL | JUST | SUSTAINABLE | WORLD

November 17, 2026

There Is No Muslim Exception to the Constitution

Editor - This is one of the best essays, perhaps a classic, explaining why extreme religious bias in politics is a bad idea. We are reminded that the US Constitution "...does not require Americans to agree about religion. It requires the government to respect their freedom to disagree." Good government requires wisdom, and this essay has plenty of it. Indeed, I would recommend Dr. Rees for the Earth Constitution's House of Counselors which I think of as a House of Wise Ones within the EC's emerging World Parliament. Good governance requires more than knowledge and facts, it requires wisdom. ~ R. Kotila, DWF NEWS

 

November 17, 2026

There Is No Muslim Exception to the Constitution

Robert A. Rees

 

As anti-Islamic rhetoric escalated during the 2026 election, Some American politicians turned religious prejudice into a political weapon.


There was a time when an American politicians who smeared an entire religious community would have faced serious questions about their fitness for office. In the closing days of the 2026 midterm election, however, anti-Muslim rhetoric became a Republican campaign tactic, deployed by President Donald Trump, Senator Ted Cruz, conservative media personalities, and other candidates seeking political advantage through religious prejudice.


The November 3rd, 2026 broadcast of Democracy Now! documents disturbing examples. The targets were not terrorists or foreign adversaries but Muslim Americans, including a candidate for the United States Senate whose apparent offense is his name and faith.


Michigan Senate elect Abdul El-Sayed, a physician and former public health official, endured a barrage of such attacks. Trump mocked El-Sayed's Arabic name, called him a “jihadist,” and portrayed him as sympathetic to terrorists. He even suggested El-Sayed should have to pass through a special metal detector before entering the Senate.


Senator Ted Cruz of Texas joined the assault, calling El-Sayed the “jihadist leprechaun” and repeated allegations that he supports the Muslim Brotherhood. Senator Tim Scott of South Carolina went further, accusing El-Sayed's family of funding Osama bin Laden.


These are not substantive disagreements about public policy. They are attempts to associate a Muslim candidate with terrorism without providing evidence for the accusations.


The broadcast also reports racist remarks by Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., who claimed that Arabs have produced no significant scientific or literary achievements. The assertion is demonstrably false. Its purpose, however, is unmistakable: to portray an entire people as intellectually inferior.


As PBS NewsHour reported November 2, anti-Muslim rhetoric had become increasingly visible in Republican campaign messaging. Cruz declared that “Islamism, likewise, produces murder and oppression” and insisted that “Sharia law has no place in America,” as if it were in danger of becoming so. Other speakers questioned whether Islam shares Christian values and complained about the number of mosques being built.


Legitimate debates about religious extremism, constitutional government, and religious law are necessary. But criticizing particular political movements, candidates, or doctrines is fundamentally different from portraying Muslim Americans as inherently dangerous or unwelcome.


Fox News and Sean Hannity have long influenced conservative debates about Islam, immigration, and national security. Their coverage deserves scrutiny whenever criticism of extremism becomes suspicion of Muslims generally—or of any other religious community, including Jews and Christians. Repeatedly associating Islam with terrorism normalizes prejudice that responsible public discourse should challenge.


Muslims are not a monolith. Like any other group, they are citizens, neighbors, physicians, teachers, business owners, veterans, and public servants. Like Christians and members of other faiths, they hold diverse political views and disagree about religion's proper role in government.


The Constitution does not require Americans to agree about religion. It requires the government to respect their freedom to disagree.


Article VI of the Constitution prohibits religious tests for federal office. The First Amendment prohibits Congress from establishing a national religion or preventing the free exercise of religion. Together, these provisions reject the notion that religious identity should determine eligibility for public service or the protection one receives under the law.


The irony is particularly striking when politicians professing Christianity attack Muslim Americans. The United States was not founded as a Christian theocracy, and the Constitution does not authorize public officials to decide which religions are sufficiently American to deserve representation. Jesus' commandment to love our neighbors as ourselves makes such hostility especially troubling for those who claim to follow him.


A Muslim senator should be no more inherently suspect than a Christian, Jewish, or atheist senator. All are accountable to their constituents and obligated to uphold the Constitution. The prohibition on religious tests exists precisely because confusing religious orthodoxy with political loyalty is so dangerous.


The consequences extend beyond individual candidates. When politicians portray Muslim neighbors as potential enemies, they encourage suspicion in schools, workplaces, and communities. They make Muslim Americans feel their citizenship is conditional, requiring them to prove their loyalty in ways their neighbors of other faiths are not asked to do.


Republican candidates have every right to criticize opponents' policies, challenge their records, and question their judgment. But allegations do not become facts simply because they invoke terrorism or exploit religious fear.


America's founders understood that religious prejudice could become a political instrument. The Constitution was designed, in part, to prevent such prejudice from becoming the foundation of government.


The 2026 election tested whether that principle still commands our allegiance. We can allow fear to determine who belongs, or we can insist that citizenship and constitutional rights do not depend on faith.


The Constitution has no Muslim exception. Neither should American democracy.


Robert A. Rees, Ph.D. is a scholar, humanitarian, and poet living in Marin County, California.


 

                                                          

 


 
Contact: dwfed@dwfed.org
(415) 328-2341
To donate go to: DWFED.ORG
Follow us on social media & Share this Important Information with Others
 
Facebook  Twitter  Instagram  Linkedin  Youtube  
LinkedIn Share This Email