Creditor News
A Newsletter for individuals and businesses concerned with Creditor’s Rights

December 2025 | 405th Edition

 

Inside This Issue:

  • Equal Opportunity Credit Act
  • Poor Debtor's Exemption - Objection in a Chapter 13 Plan
  • The Virginia Property Owners’ Association Act – General Provisions
  • Deed in lieu of Foreclosure

Also Featuring:

  • Ted's Tips
  • Law Review: Estate Planning
  • Firm Attorney Biographies
Employee Spotlight:
Creditor's Rights - It's Our Focus!

Creditors hear too much about debtors' rights - creditors need to fight back! Bankruptcy laws are primarily drawn to protect debtors. The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act also protects debtors, and limits creditors' activity. Both laws prescribe punishments for violations.

We believe that creditors deserve due process and consideration. We work hard to protect our clients' rights through collection activities, civil litigation, and bankruptcy practice. To be competitive, we offer retainer plans and several fee options. To be accessible, we promise prompt and consistent communication.

We would greatly appreciate the opportunity to meet with any prospective client to review your needs and services. Please schedule your appointment by calling Eddie at 804-545-6251 or Jennifer at 804-545-6242.

 

Collections: Equal Opportunity Credit Act

Debtors utilize the Equal Opportunity Credit Act, 15 U.S.C. §1691 ("the ECOA" or "the Act"), to avoid adverse action against them on seemingly valid creditor suits. The litigation that has arisen gives good cause to review lending policies for ECOA compliance.

 

The ECOA was enacted in 1974 to prohibit discrimination by lenders on the basis of race, color, national origin, sex, marital status, age, religion and welfare status. The statute was originally aimed at discrimination against married women who were often denied credit unless they could get their husband's signatures. The statute, in many respects, has been taken to many illogical extremes.

 

Lenders who violate the statute can be sued for actual damages, punitive damages up to $10,000, and costs and attorney's fees. Punitive damages can be awarded even if there are no actual damages, and even if the lender did not have a specific intention to discriminate. In practice, this means that the Act could be used in a counterclaim, not just a defense. In regard to a counterclaim, there is a two year statute of limitations for suits under the Act, which will usually have passed by the time a legal action by the creditor has begun. Most courts have ruled that the two year statute of limitations does not apply when the Act is raised as a defense.

 

There are many potential issues that have been raised under the Act; listed below are those which have been cited most frequently.

 

  1. Requiring the signature of a spouse. Under federal regulations, "[A] creditor shall not require the signature of an applicant's spouse ... on any credit instrument if the applicant qualifies under the creditor's standards of creditworthiness for the amount and terms of the credit requested."(12 C.F.R. §202.7(d)(1).). There have been many cases litigated regarding this. The Virginia Supreme Court found that a bank violated the Act when a husband sought a loan for his construction company and the bank required his wife's signature as a guarantor, even though the husband was individually creditworthy, the wife had no interest in the company and was not a joint applicant, and the bank made no inquiry into her credit standing. The Court made these factual findings, but the company, ultimately, did not have assets to cover the debt. When the husband's construction company defaulted on the loan, after the husband died, the bank sought recovery from the wife and the husband's estate. When the Court found that this violated the Act, it ruled that there could be no recovery against the wife, as "Contracts executed in violation of law cannot be enforced....To deny [the wife] the right to use the ECOA violation defensively would be to enforce conduct that is forbidden by the Act." Debtor's attorneys are using this defense in foreclosure proceedings to prevent summary judgment on the foreclosure, stall for time, release a spouse from liability, and force the lender to defend against a complex and expensive federal claim.
  2. Asking for information about a spouse or former spouse, unless the applicant is relying on the spouse's income or lives in a community property state (Virginia is not - it is a Common Law state).
  3. Asking for sources of an applicant's income without saying that the applicant does not have to mention alimony or child support unless he or she wants the lender to consider it when it decides whether to extend credit.
  4.  Taking race, sex or national origin into account when making a credit decision (although a bank can consider immigration status).
  5. Using statistics to judge the reliability of income from alimony, child support, pensions or welfare. Even if child support payments are statistically unreliable, a bank must consider whether the individual applicant has consistently received payments in the past.
  6. Ascribing a negative value to an applicant's age unless it relates to a "pertinent element of creditworthiness," such as the length of time the applicant has until retirement or the adequacy of security where a mortgage term exceeds the applicant's life expectancy.
  7. Requiring certain types of life insurance before issuing a loan.
  8. Basing a credit decision on the area in which the applicant lives, such as the fact that a white applicant lived in a largely black area. 
  9. Changing the terms of a credit account without notifying the borrower within 30 days and including a boiler plate notice concerning the borrower's rights under the ECOA.
  10. Asking about an applicant's intentions to have children.
  11. Asking for the applicant's title (Mr., Mrs., Ms., etc.) without stating that providing this information is optional.

 

There are also many potential defenses that have been raised by lenders; listed below are those which have been cited most frequently.

 

  1. Voluntary signatures are okay. Although a spouse cannot be required to co-sign a note, voluntary signatures are okay. Thus, the lender can win if it can show that the spouse's signature was voluntary.
  2. One spouse was not enough. A lender can argue that the applicant's spouse did not satisfy it's credit criteria all alone, and the other spouse's assets figured into his loan decision, which is why the other spouse's signature was required.
  3. 3. Both spouses are principals. If both spouses are principals in a business, the lender can argue that it required both of their signatures because of their business relationship rather than their marital status.
  4. Pre-1986 guarantors. ECOA regulations were expanded to include guarantors as of October 1, 1986. Courts have been split as to whether they apply to guarantors if a bank violated the Act before that date but renewed the note after it.
  5. Good Faith. A lender is not liable if it acted in good faith compliance with the Federal Reserve Board's "official staff interpretation" of the ECOA, which can be found at 12 C.F.R. §202.

 

The City of Richmond Circuit Court denied an ECOA defense pled by a wife who had signed a broad release when the loan was refinanced. The case was Richmond Lotco L.P. v. Perrowville Dev. Corp.

 

In Perrowville the lender obtained a guaranty and general release of claims from four directors of a real estate development company and their wives. The release was included in the modification of an existing loan that the lender had purchased from the Resolution Trust Corp. after the original lender, a bank, went into receivership. The release stated that the borrowers and guarantors would release the note holders "from any and all claims, losses, liabilities, causes of action of any king whatsoever, if any, whether existing or contingent, known or unknown, matured or unmatured, that the borrowers or guarantors may now have or have had in whatever capacity against the noteholder...".

 

When the successor lender brought a collection suit under the modification, the wives claimed that they were not involved in the business and that their guaranties had been required solely as a result of their marital status, in violation of the ECOA. The wives argued that the ECOA gave them both a defense to the collection action and a counterclaim against the lender. The lender argued that the release was part of the consideration that the lender received for continuing to finance the development project under the modification. The Court ruled in favor of the lender, stating that the modification agreement did not constitute a violation of the ECOA and that therefore the wives could not pursue either a defense or a counterclaim.

 

The litigation that has arisen gives good cause to review lending policies for ECOA compliance. Please call us if you have any questions.

Ted's Tips

Email addresses can be used to find a debtor’s online accounts. Facebook accounts can be especially exciting and rewarding.

 

Bankruptcy: Poor Debtor's Exemption - Objection in a Chapter 13 Plan

In the case of In re Bonner, Judge Tice of the United States Bankruptcy Court, Eastern District of Virginia, Richmond Division, ruled that a credit union, which did not perfect its lien on a car the debtor purchased with a credit union loan, could not prevent confirmation of the debtor's Chapter 13 plan. The Court did, however, sustain the credit union's objection to the debtor's claim of a $2,000 "poor debtor's exemption" in the car under Virginia Code §34-5.

 

In Bonner the credit union maintained that its purchase money security interest, though not perfected as to third parties, could be enforced in a Chapter 13 case notwithstanding Bankruptcy Code §544(a). The Court ruled, though, that the avoidance powers under §544 extend to trustees in Chapter 13. The Court cited the case of In re Freeman, where another court had held that a Chapter 13 debtor shares the trustee's status as a hypothetical lien creditor under §544. Accordingly, the Court ruled that since either the debtor or trustee is deemed to have exercised the hypothetical lien creditor's rights at the time of filing, the transfer of the security interest by the debtor to the credit union had been nullified. The claim filed by the credit union was therefore unsecured, and the debtor had properly provided for it under the plan.

 

Nevertheless, the Court ruled that pursuant to Virginia Code §34-5, the poor debtor's exemption could not be claimed against a debt for the purchase of such property or any part thereof. Unlike the exception included in Virginia Code §34-26(8), which provides only a valid purchase money security interest with priority over the exemption, the restriction in §34-5 is not conditioned on the creditor possessing an enforceable lien. Therefore, the Court reasoned that the credit union's failure to perfect its security interest simply had no bearing. Accordingly, the Court sustained the credit union's objection to the poor debtor's exemption.

Law Review of the Month: Estate Planning

The firm has extensive experience in estate planning. We welcome the opportunity to discuss wills, trusts, living wills (Declarations for Natural Death) and other planning matters.

 

Real Estate: The Virginia Property Owners’ Association Act – General Provisions

In the last issue of Creditor News we began a review of the Virginia Property Owners’ Act. Under the Act, sellers are required to disclose in their sales contract that the property is located within a development subject to the Act. The Act also requires the seller to retrieve the Disclosure Packet in the Act and provide it to the purchaser. The Disclosure Packet includes the following information: association documents, the name of the association, state of incorporation, register agent’s name and address, any other entity/facility to which the owner may owe fees or charges, budget or summary, income/expenses statement or balance sheet for last fiscal year, statement of balance due of outstanding loans, nature/status of pending lawsuits, unpaid judgments (with material impact on association or members or relating to lot being purchased), insurance coverage provided for lot owners including fidelity bond maintained by association, and much more

 

The purchaser may cancel the contract within three days if delivered by hand or email, or six days if sent by mail, after receiving the Disclosure Packet or being notified that it is “not available” (meaning: a current annual report has not been filed by the Association with either the SCC or the CICB; or the seller has requested in writing that the packet be provided and it is not received within 14 days; or the association has provided written notice that the Disclosure Packet is not available). Additionally, if the Disclosure Packet is not delivered or the association does not indicate that it is not available, the purchaser may cancel the sale any time prior to closing. If the purchaser received the Disclosure Packet, the owner also has the right to request an update. However, the rights to receive and cancel the contract are waived conclusively if not exercised before settlement.

 

Failure to provide a Disclosure Packet after a written request for it has been made results in a waiver of any claim to delinquent assessments or violations of association documents up to that point, and the association will be liable to the seller for actual damages sustained up to $1,000 if the association is managed by a CIC Manager or up to $500 if it is self-managed.

 

In the next two issues of Creditor News, we will discuss the provisions of the Virginia Property Owners’ Association Act that provide a memorandum of lien and foreclosure in the event of an owner’s default.  

 

Foreclosure: Deed in lieu of Foreclosure

In certain cases it may be more practical for the lender to seek or accept from the borrower a deed in lieu of foreclosure rather than incur the expense of foreclosure – this is at the lender’s discretion. If the lender agrees, in return for voluntarily surrendering the property, the borrower will seek either partial or complete satisfaction of the debt.

 

Considerations. Before accepting the deed in lieu of foreclosure, the lender must consider many matters:

  1.  Value of the property vs. the amount of the debt.
  2. Other debts on the property. A deed in lieu of foreclosure does not extinguish prior or junior liens or encumbrances. Thus the lender, in accepting the deed, accepts the property with the liens. It is possible for the lender to structure the deed in lieu of foreclosure so that it does not release the deed of trust so as to preserve a future foreclosure to extinguish subordinate liens.
Looking for more Creditor News articles? Check our our Creditor News Blog!

Lafayette Whitlock Fischer Hughes PLC is a full-service creditor’s rights firm. While many attorneys do “collections”, few attorneys have the trained expertise and staff to represent creditors in all four areas of Creditor’s Rights—Collections, Bankruptcy, Real Estate and Foreclosure. We do, and, we represent credit unions, banks, loan companies, homeowner associations, doctor’s offices, landlords, small businesses and individuals. In Creditor News we will explore all four areas of Creditor’s Rights.

Meet the Attorneys of Lafayette Whitlock Fischer Hughes PLC

Edward S. Whitlock, III, Esq. - Editor

Eddie is a Richmond native with a concentrated law practice in creditor representation. His practice focuses on creditor’s rights (Collection, Bankruptcy, Real Estate, and Foreclosure), but also includes the general practice of law (Business and Will & Estate Planning). Eddie holds a B.A. (1984) in Political Science, and a Juris Doctor (1987) from the University of Richmond. He is the former Chief of Admin/Military Law for the 329th Support Group (Area) in the Virginia Army National Guard. Eddie is the former President of both the Henrico County Bar Association and the Virginia Creditors’ Bar Association. He is the chair of the Virginia State Bar’s Fee Dispute Resolution Program, and a former member of the Virginia State Bar’s Disciplinary Committee. He is the chairman of the Henrico Economic Development Authority. He is the President of Home Loans for KOVAR Corporation. He is also a former director of Henrico CASA, and a former adjunct professor of criminal law at J. Sargeant Reynolds Community College.

Jennifer W. Fischer, Esq. - Editor

Jennifer concentrates her practice in creditor representation (Collection, Bankruptcy, Real Estate, and Foreclosure), but also Business and Will & Estate Planning. Jennifer holds a BS (2011) in business administration from Christopher Newport University, and a Juris Doctorate (2014) from University of Richmond, T.C. Williams School of Law. She was admitted to the Virginia State Bar in October 2014. She is a board member for the Virginia Creditors' Bar association and the Henrico County Bar Association.

CREDITOR NEWS © 2025. This newsletter is prepared and published by Edward S. Whitlock, III, Esquire, and Jennifer W. Fischer, Esquire, and is provided free of charge. The information contained in this newsletter is general in nature. It is intended to be helpful but does not, and is not meant to, replace consultation with an attorney in connection with a legal problem. Readers needing legal advice should retain competent legal counsel.

 

Lafayette Whitlock Fischer Hughes PLC www.lawplc.com

 
Facebook  Twitter  Linkedin