|
I wish I’d been wrong…
… there’s no satisfaction in predicting that someone’s mother will still be waiting for a new hip, neither…
… pleasure in finding that something you have been writing about for months has finally become a headline.
I wish I’d been wrong.
From the beginning of this government, my argument was straightforward. If Labour wanted to restore NHS waiting times, it would need a ruthless focus on delivery… from day one.
Every decision would have to pass one test…
Does this help patients
get diagnosed
and treated sooner?
There is no wriggling out of it… Labour’s promise was clear. Restore;
’…92% of patients waiting no longer
than 18 weeks, by March 2029.’
An enormous undertaking. Requiring;
- capacity,
- capital,
- people,
- reliable diagnostic pathways and…
…managers with the time and authority to make the whole journey work.
Above all, it requires concentration. No spare time for settling institutional scores, and...
... no spare capacity for absorbing disruption of our own making.
Now NHS leaders are telling ministers the promise is...
‘not going to happen’
… really… where have they been?
The Health Foundation’s latest analysis has prompted fresh warnings that the arithmetic has caught up with the rhetoric.
Streeting understood the dangers in September 2024, he told Parliament;
‘… we will not repeat the mistakes
of top-down reorganisation.’
He promised evolution rather than another revolution.
At that point he was either a fool or a liar, because…
… six months later, he announced the abolition of NHS England.
Of course, a minister may change their mind, but …
… when they do, they owe us an explanation of the consequences, the costs, impact and risks.
What did the upheaval contribute to the waiting-time promise?
How much management attention did it consume?
When were the benefits supposed to arrive?
Whilst patients waited for appointments, staff waited to find out if they still had a job.
Whilst services needed coordination, organisations faced new structures, reporting lines and redundancy plans.
Management attention, proclaimed in the Darzi report as scarce (Chapter 10), is a finite resource. Spend it on reorganising the people responsible for delivery and you'll have less of it available for delivery, itself.
The organisation sees a restructure.
The survivors see empty desks.
Then came the doctors’ dispute.
Streeting called the BMA ‘moaning minnies’ and accused it of 'juvenile delinquency’. If industrial disputes are a bonfire, Streeting threw petrol on the flames.
I struggle to see how it helped a hospital manager find a workable rota or a patient get an operation.
The BMA has responsibilities, too, but…
…. a secretary of state’s job is to secure an agreement, maintain services and protect patients. Name-calling is a curious negotiating tactic.
Meanwhile, the NHS endured a punishing summer. Heat brought additional illness, uncomfortable wards and difficult working conditions.
Streeting kicked social care, into the long-grass... with another report.
Summer can no longer be relied upon to provide breathing space before winter. A recovery plan needs resilience throughout the year.
What about the organisations sounding the alarm, now?
It would be unfair to say the Health Foundation think-tank has only just started thinking. It questioned the plan’s realism in early 2025 and subsequently projected a miss.
The warnings were available. What changed because of them? Nothing.
The NHS Alliance exists to represent the service and influence government. Its bluntness is welcome, but...
... as it is funded (eventually) by ~£20m of taxpayers’ money, patients are entitled to ask where were they?
I can’t prove that a different minister would have delivered the target. Streeting inherited an exhausted service, damaged infrastructure and formidable demand. The Treasury, the unions and NHS leaders have responsibilities, but …
Streeting chose the priorities… on his watch.
Streeting knew the risk of reorganisation.
Streeting promised to avoid it, then...
Streeting introduced it whilst accepting a deadline that demanded sustained concentration.
Yes, Streeting is a very Silly-Boy.
My concern was never that the NHS needed no reform. It was that the government would confuse reforming its architecture with improving its performance.
That distinction now matters, it matters desperately.
I would happily have been proved wrong. Patients cannot afford another round of political excuses.
They deserve Cooper; to role up her sleeves and get on with an honest, funded recovery-plan, protected from distraction.
Humility requires admitting what we cannot know.
Accountability requires naming the decisions we can.
It was political arrogance, individual hubris and leadership’s weakness that has plunged the NHS back to where it was in the pre-election summer of 2024.
NHS people will bear the workload, families will bear the pain and suffering and the idiot responsible for it all has moved on…
… may your god help the Ministry of Defense.
Have the best weekend you can.
|