On Friday, September 2nd the man charged with killing Deputy Michael J. Magli pled guilty to three charges and received a 35-year sentence for his crimes - the statutory maximum for those charges. The case might be closed but the wounds to Deputy Magli’s family, the community, and his brothers and sisters in law enforcement will never fully heal.
Robert Holzaepfel pled guilty to one count of third-degree murder for which he received a 15-year sentence, one count of DUI manslaughter for which he received 15 years, and a felony charge of driving with his license suspended or revoked for which he received five years. The sentences must be served consecutively.
The tragedy unfolded on February 17, 2021 when East Lake Fire Rescue received a call about a man passed out behind the wheel of his vehicle at a red light. When the crew broke a window to check his medical condition the man, later identified as Holzaepfel, drove off in a reckless manner that put lives in danger. Deputy Magli positioned himself to throw out stop sticks (a tire deflation device) but Holzaepfel swerved and struck Deputy Magli, killing him. It was the first line of duty death in the history of the Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office (PCSO) and sent the agency and the community into mourning.
But no one has been affected by the loss as much as Deputy Magli’s family. His mother, father, wife, and other family members and supporters were in the courtroom, as were dozens of PCSO members. Deputy Magli’s parents and wife made victim impact statements, expressing how Deputy Magli’s death affected their lives.
Angela Magli-Ramirez, Deputy Magli’s mother, spoke of her love and loss. “My son was my world, from the time he was conceived until the day I take my last breath.” She spoke of Deputy Magli when he was a child: a happy, smart kid who was mature beyond his years and soon became her right-hand man in helping her care for his younger brother and sister. That helpful child grew up to become a kind and loving man, the light of his family’s eyes. “He was an All American in school, he played football since he was seven years old, but he was never the tough guy, never the braggart. He was the guy that everyone liked. But I loved him.”
Above all, Deputy Magli wanted to help people. Joining the PCSO was a natural fit. “When Michael decided to go into law enforcement I of course was not happy, for the reason that something just like this might happen. He said mom, I know what you’re worried about and I’m not stupid. I’m careful. Believe me all I want to do is do my job and get home to my family. I’m not going to try to be a hero, I promise. But that’s just what he was that day.”
“You took a man who saw the best in everyone, who didn’t hold grudges and gave everyone the benefit of the doubt,” said Deputy Magli’s wife Stephanie Magli as she addressed Holzaepfel in her victim impact statement. “And honestly, he’s probably already forgiven you for what you’ve done, because that’s who he was.” Deputy Magli leaves behind two young daughters who were five years old and nine months old when their father was killed. “You took my best friend and the father of my children.” His wife talked about the moments in their daughters’ lives that Deputy Magli will miss. “Michael will always be remembered as the great man he was, and his girls will always know how much their daddy loves them.”
Deputy Magli made a difference to the community he served. “How many people could he have helped and saved, and how much good could he have accomplished in his lifetime if he could have lived it out in its entirety?” his mother wonders. “This is what haunts me every night when I try to go to sleep.”
After the sentencing Sheriff Bob Gualtieri talked about Deputy Magli’s dedication and service, calling him a hero but adding that for a deputy, “It’s not about the heroic acts, it’s about what they do every single day.” Whether it is stopping a drunk driver, helping a lost child, or recovering a stolen wedding ring, deputies do the big and little things that keep our community safe and make people’s lives better. “He did what he signed up to do, but he didn’t sign up to die.”
“The thing is he was always my hero, my little prince,” said Deputy Magli’s mother.
The guilty plea saves the family the additional trauma of a long trial, but for Deputy Magli’s mother the pain will never end. “I will never be free from this grief,” she said. “It is now a solid thing that lives deep inside of me. I didn’t just lose him once, I lose him every time I open my eyes to a new day. Losing someone is a journey. It’s not a one-time thing. There is no end to the loss.”