Thinking of Buying or Selling? Call us today!

J: (805) 470 1985 ~ M: (805) 458-4925

Market Minute Monday on a Tuesday

↓↓↓click the thumbnail below↓↓↓

Are Big Investors Really Buying Up All the Homes? Here’s the Truth

It’s hard to scroll online lately without seeing some version of this claim:

“Big investors are buying up all the homes.”

And honestly, if you’re a homebuyer who’s lost out on a few offers, that idea probably sounds believable. When homes are expensive and competition is tight, it’s easy to assume giant companies are scooping everything up behind the scenes.

But here’s the thing: what people assume is happening and what the data actually shows aren’t always the same.

Let’s look at what’s really happening with large institutional investors in today’s housing market – because the numbers tell a much different story than the headlines.

The Number Most People Won’t See Online

Let’s start with the most important stat. According to John Burns Research & Consulting (JBREC), large institutional investors – those that own 100 or more homes – made up just 1.2% of all home purchases in Q3 of 2025 (see graph below):

That’s it. Out of every 100 homes sold, only about 1 went to a large institutional investor.

And here’s an important point that often gets missed: that level of investor activity is very much in line with historical norms. It’s not unusually high, and it’s actually well below the recent peak of 3.1% back in 2022 – which itself was still a small share of the overall market.

So, while it can feel like big investors are everywhere, nationally, they’re a very small part of overall home sales.

Why Investor Activity Gets So Much Attention

There are two main reasons this topic gets so much attention:

1. Investor activity isn’t spread evenly. Investors are more active in certain markets, which can make competition feel intense for homebuyers in those areas. As Lance Lambert, Co-Founder of ResiClub, explains: “On a national level, “large investors”—those owning at least 100 single-family homes—only own around 1% of total single-family housing stock. That said, in a handful of regional housing markets, institutional and large single-family landlords have a much larger presence.”
2. Investor is a broad term. Part of what makes the share of purchases bought by investors sound so big is because many headlines lump large Wall Street institutions together with small, local investors (like your neighbor who owns one or two rental homes). But those are very different buyers. In reality, most investors are small, local owners, not massive corporations. And when all investors get grouped together in the headlines as a single stat, it inflates the number and makes it seem like big institutions are dominating the market (even though they’re not).

Yes, big investors exist. Yes, they buy homes. But nationally, they’re responsible for a very small share of total purchases – far smaller than most people assume.

The bigger challenges around affordability have much more to do with supply, demand, and years of underbuilding than with large institutions competing against everyday buyers.

That’s why it’s so important to separate noise from reality, especially if you’re trying to decide if now is the right time to move.

Bottom Line

If you want to talk through what investor activity actually looks like in our local market, and how it impacts your options (or doesn’t), let’s connect.



Sometimes a little context makes all the difference

Interior

Kitchen

Backyard

Single-level 3BD/2BA home on an expansive 11,326 sq. ft. lot in a quiet Atascadero neighborhood. Features a functional layout with a comfortable living area, dining space, and classic kitchen. The large yard offers room for gardening, play, or future improvements. Conveniently located near downtown, schools, shopping, and Hwy 101. A great opportunity to personalize and create your ideal home.

MLS ID: 25276524

1095 Megan Ct Templeton

$869,000

1997 sq. ft.

3 Bedroom

2 Bath

2 Car Attached

New Listing

MLS ID: 26013353

2814 Stardust Orcutt

$789,900

2457 sq. ft.

3 Bedroom

3 Bath

2 Car Attached

New Listing

MLS ID: 26005548

766 S 6th St Grover Beach

$799,000

2340 sq. ft.

3 Bedroom

2 Bath

2 Car Attached

MLS ID: 26001609

1557 Canyon Creek Orcutt

$865,000

2373 sq. ft.

4 Bedroom

3 Bath

2 Car Attached

MLS ID: 25279924

2560 Juniper Morro Bay

$1,655,000

2648 sq. ft.

4 Bedroom

3 Bath

2 Car Attached

MLS ID: 25274123

3942 Berrywood Dr. Orcutt

$680,000

1300 sq. ft.

2 Bedroom

2 Bath

2 Car Attached

Pending

MLS ID: 25281162

1277 Belridge St #6A Oceano

$480,000

1164 sq. ft.

2 Bedroom

2 Bath

1 Car Attached

MLS ID: 25277674

911 E Evergreen Ave Santa Maria

$605,000

1381 sq. ft.

4 Bedroom

2 Bath

2 Car Attached

Pending

MLS ID: 25261449

4470 Cayucos Ave. Atascadero

$675,000

1369 sq. ft.

3 Bedroom

2 Bath

2 Car/Attached

↓↓↓$25,000 Price Improvement↓↓↓

MLS ID: 25275417

2714 Ocotillo Santa Maria

$799,900

2443 sq. ft.

4 Bedroom

2 Bath

3 Car Attached

Active Under Contract

MLS ID: 25274868

781 Koval Santa Maria

$749,900

1975 sq. ft.

3 Bedroom

2 Bath

2 Car/Attached

↓↓↓$15,000 Price Improvement↓↓↓

Active Under Contract

MLS ID: 252262956

2712 Studio Dr. Cayucos

$3,400,000

1200 sq. ft.

3 Bedroom

2 Bath

1 1/2 Car/Attached

MLS ID: 25266701

385 Hassett Ct. Orcutt

List Price/Sold Price

$699,000/$740,000

1830 sq. ft.

3 Bedroom

2 Bath

2 Car Detached

SOLD

12/30

MLS ID: 25207858

187 Via Bandolero Arroyo Grande

List Price/Sold Price

$1,750,000/$1,649,500

4030 sq. ft.

4 Bedroom

3 Bath

3 Car/Attached

SOLD

1/15

MLS ID: 25242204

178 Windward Ave Pismo Beach

$1,125,000

900 sq. ft.

3 Bedroom

1 Bath

↓↓↓$25,000 Price Improvement↓↓↓

MLS ID: 25110241

2743 Rodman Dr Los Osos

$3,299,000

5290 sq. ft.

4 Bedroom

4 Bath

3 Car/Attached

↓↓↓$100,000 Price Improvement↓↓↓

MLS ID: 25046937

5495 Jack Creek Rd. Templeton

$1,300,000

2160 sq. ft.

3 Bedroom

2 Bath

50+ Acres

↓↓↓$975,000 Price Improvement↓↓↓

MLS ID: 24172658

555 Le Point St. Arroyo Grande

$950,000

1833 sq. ft.

4 Bedroom

2 Bath

↓↓↓$225,000 Price Improvement↓↓↓

Big Block LPT Realty

BRE# 02248983

10620 Treena St. S. #230

San Diego CA 92131

CA DRE# 02248983