Organizational

Announcement

 

Article 4: ECI Series in Professional Competency, Ethics, and The Evolution of Stormwater Practice (1 PDH Credit)

 

Professional Development Hours (PDHs): As part of ECI’s ongoing effort to improve communication, ECI Certified Professionals may earn one (1) PDH by reviewing this entire announcement. To receive PDHs:


  • Write a summary of your opinion on the article and provide us your thoughts.
  • Fill out a self-certification form and provide an attachment of your summary and opinion. Please email the letter to committees@envirocert.org.
  • You may record the PDHs in your certification profile under Category (Self Study).


The PDH value reflects both the scope and depth of the material presented (approximately one (1) hour of professional content). ECI welcomes feedback on this format and encourages Certified Professionals to share comments or suggestions at wecare@envirocert.org.

 

EnviroCert International, Inc. (ECI) presents this fourth article in its continuing series on professional standards, ethics, competence, and the future of the stormwater and environmental professions.


Stormwater practice has changed dramatically over the past several decades. What was once viewed primarily through the lens of drainage, erosion control, and construction-site compliance has evolved into a broad and technically demanding profession involving water quality, industrial stormwater, municipal programs, inspections, green infrastructure, watershed management, pollutant control, coastal processes, climate resilience, and increasingly sophisticated regulatory requirements.


As the profession has evolved, so too must our understanding of what it means to be professionally competent.


The fundamental principle is straightforward:


Professional competence is not defined by a title, license, certification, number of years in practice, or completion of a training course alone.


Competence is the combination of education, knowledge, experience, judgment, ethics, and demonstrated ability within a defined area of practice.


That principle should guide the future of the stormwater profession.

 

POINT 1: THE PROFESSION HAS BECOME MORE SPECIALIZED


The development of specialized areas of practice is not unique to stormwater. It is a natural and necessary consequence of a profession becoming more sophisticated.


As science advances, regulations become more complex, technologies evolve, and professional responsibilities expand, the body of knowledge necessary to practice competently eventually grows beyond what any one individual can reasonably master. Specialization is the professional response to that growth.


Civil engineering provides a familiar example. Civil engineers may specialize in geotechnical engineering, structural engineering, transportation, land development, hydrology and hydraulics, water resources, environmental engineering, coastal engineering, or other areas. These professionals share a common engineering foundation, but the specialized knowledge, experience, and professional judgment required in their day-to-day practices can be substantially different. The same evolution has occurred in law, medicine, aviation, accounting, information technology, and virtually every other mature profession. As these professions advanced, specialization became necessary because the underlying bodies of knowledge became too extensive and technically demanding for any individual to maintain equivalent expertise across every area of practice.


Specialization does not weaken a profession; in fact, it strengthens it.


It allows professionals to develop greater technical depth, establishes clearer expectations for professional competence, provides employers and the public with greater confidence in an individual's capabilities, and allows professionals to build meaningful areas of expertise throughout their careers.


Stormwater has reached this same stage of professional development.


Modern stormwater practice encompasses erosion and sediment control, stormwater quality, industrial stormwater management, municipal stormwater programs, inspections, green infrastructure, hydrology and hydraulics, pollutant control and treatment, watershed management, coastal processes, climate resilience, and other increasingly technical areas. While these disciplines share important foundational principles, they require different combinations of knowledge, experience, regulatory understanding, and professional judgment. This evolution should be viewed as an accomplishment for the profession, not as fragmentation of it.


Stormwater professionals should take pride in the fact that the field has matured to the point where meaningful areas of specialization have developed. At the same time, specialization places an additional responsibility upon us that we must come to embrace and elevate.


The stormwater profession must recognize the expertise of other professionals and understand that no individual possesses equal competence in every area of practice.


A mature profession does not diminish one specialty to elevate another. It recognizes that different professionals bring different expertise to a common purpose.


That requires greater collaboration among Certified Professionals, Professional Engineers, Professional Geologists, regulators, inspectors, contractors, scientists, educators, and other practitioners. It also requires professionals to support one another, exchange knowledge, respectfully challenge ideas, and recognize when another professional's expertise complements their own.


The stormwater profession will not reach its full potential through competition among specialties or by insisting that one discipline, credential, or professional group can adequately represent every aspect of modern practice.


It will flourish when we recognize specialization as professional advancement, take pride in the increasing sophistication of our profession, respect the expertise of our colleagues, and work collaboratively toward the common goals of protecting water quality, the environment, infrastructure, and the public.

 

POINT 2: BROAD KNOWLEDGE AND SPECIALIZED KNOWLEDGE ARE BOTH NECESSARY


Specialization does not mean professionals should understand only one subject. Stormwater systems are interconnected.


Erosion affects sediment transport and receiving-water quality. Industrial discharges may enter municipal storm sewer systems. Municipal programs regulate construction activities, post-construction controls, illicit discharges, and long-term water-quality requirements. Green infrastructure affects hydrology, pollutant removal, maintenance, groundwater interaction, and community resilience. Professionals therefore need a broad understanding of how these systems interact.


But broad understanding is not the same as specialized competence. A professional may understand the general principles of industrial stormwater without possessing the technical experience required to manage an industrial stormwater program. An inspector may understand basic hydrology without being qualified to perform advanced hydrologic modeling. A municipal program manager may understand erosion and sediment control requirements without possessing the expertise necessary to prepare complex erosion-control designs.


This distinction is important. Professional maturity requires both an appreciation for the broader system and an understanding of where specialized expertise is required.

 

POINT 3: PROFESSIONAL INTEGRITY BEGINS WITH RECOGNIZING THE LIMITS OF COMPETENCE


One of the most important ethical obligations of any professional is recognizing the limits of his or her own knowledge and experience.


The most capable professional is not necessarily the person who claims to know the most. Often, it is the person who understands when additional expertise is needed.


Professional integrity requires individuals to ask:


  • Do I have sufficient education in this area?
  • Have I performed this type of work before?
  • Do I understand the applicable technical standards and regulatory requirements?
  • Am I qualified to make this decision independently?
  • Should I seek additional training, mentoring, peer review, or specialized assistance?


There should be no stigma associated with answering the last question affirmatively.


Seeking expertise is not an admission of professional weakness. It is evidence of professional judgment. The stormwater community should encourage this attitude.

 

POINT 4: EXPERIENCE IS ESSENTIAL, BUT EXPERIENCE MUST BE RELEVANT


Experience remains one of the most important components of professional competence.


Field experience develops judgment in ways that cannot be replicated entirely through textbooks, training courses, or examinations. Professionals learn how BMPs perform during actual storms, how construction sequencing influences erosion, how maintenance affects long-term performance, and how regulatory requirements interact with real-world conditions.


However, experience should not be measured solely by the passage of time. Twenty years of experience can represent twenty years of professional growth and increasingly complex responsibility. It can also represent repetition of a relatively narrow range of tasks. The important question is whether the experience is relevant to the work being performed.


Competence therefore develops through the interaction of education, experience, continuing learning, and professional judgment. No single component is sufficient by itself.

 

POINT 5: CONTINUING EDUCATION IS A PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY


Stormwater science and regulation do not remain static. 


  • Materials change.
  • Monitoring technologies improve.
  • Pollutants of concern evolve.
  • Climate conditions change.
  • Regulatory requirements are revised.
  • Modeling methods improve.
  • New treatment systems and green infrastructure practices emerge.


Professionals who stop learning eventually become professionals practicing from outdated knowledge. Continuing education should therefore not be viewed merely as a renewal requirement or an administrative obligation. It is an ethical responsibility. 


While we are all too busy, Professional Development Hours (PDHs) should be a tool that you use to help yourself become a better professional. PDHs, technical conferences, peer review, mentoring, independent study, research, and specialized training all provide opportunities to maintain and expand professional competence. The objective should never be simply to accumulate hours. The objective is to become a better professional.

 

POINT 6: PROFESSIONAL LICENSURE AND SPECIALIZED COMPETENCE SHOULD NOT BE CONFUSED


Professional licensure and specialized professional competence serve different, but complementary, purposes.


Professional Engineers and Professional Geologists undergo extensive education, qualifying experience, examination, and regulatory oversight. Licensure establishes important legal authority and carries significant professional, ethical, and public-safety responsibilities. These qualifications should be recognized and respected throughout the stormwater profession.


At the same time, no professional license establishes expertise in every possible area of practice.


A civil engineer who has spent a career designing drainage systems would not automatically be competent to design a complex suspension bridge. A geotechnical engineer would not necessarily possess expertise in traffic engineering, and a structural engineer would not automatically be qualified to manage an industrial stormwater compliance program. The professional license may establish the legal framework within which an individual practices, but actual competence remains dependent upon relevant education, training, and experience.


Professional engineering and geology codes of professional conduct recognize this fundamental principle by requiring licensed professionals to undertake assignments only when qualified by education or experience in the specific technical fields involved.


For this reason, the argument that a Professional Engineer should automatically be "grandfathered" into specialized stormwater practice solely by virtue of holding a PE license is difficult to support from a professional competency standpoint. Engineering licensure is an important qualification, but it should not be treated as automatic evidence of specialized stormwater expertise.


Most undergraduate engineering programs provide valuable education in mathematics, physics, chemistry, fluid mechanics, hydrology, hydraulics, soils, environmental engineering, and other subjects directly relevant to stormwater practice. That educational foundation can provide engineers with significant advantages when entering the stormwater profession. However, college coursework alone typically does not provide the breadth of applied training and experience necessary to demonstrate competence across the increasingly specialized areas of modern stormwater practice.


Conversely, the stormwater profession should recognize and respect the substantial technical foundation that Professional Engineers bring to the industry. Engineering education and professional practice frequently provide sophisticated knowledge of hydrology and hydraulics, soil mechanics, geotechnical behavior, drainage systems, modeling, infrastructure design, construction, risk assessment, and other disciplines that can be extremely valuable to stormwater management.


The appropriate position, therefore, should not be that engineering licensure automatically establishes stormwater expertise, nor should it be that professional certification somehow diminishes the significance of a PE license. The two qualifications serve different purposes and can substantially strengthen one another.


A Professional Engineer entering or expanding into a specialized area of stormwater practice should be encouraged to build upon that engineering foundation through relevant experience, mentoring, continuing education, specialized training, and, where appropriate, professional certification. Likewise, Certified Professionals should recognize when an issue requires engineering analysis, design, or other expertise beyond their own qualifications and collaborate with appropriately qualified licensed professionals.


Professional certifications, continuing education, specialized training, mentoring, and practical experience can all help professionals develop, expand, and demonstrate additional expertise. These mechanisms are not substitutes for professional licensure where licensure is required, nor should they be viewed as competing with it. Rather, they provide complementary pathways through which professionals can develop and demonstrate specialized competence beyond their foundational qualifications.


This is precisely how a mature profession should operate: recognize the value of foundational qualifications, require demonstrated competence for specialized practice, understand the limits of individual expertise, and bring the appropriate professionals together to solve complex problems.


Professional licensure and professional certification should complement one another, not compete with one another. Ultimately, the objective should not be to defend titles or credentials, but to ensure that the individual performing the work possesses the knowledge, skills, experience, and professional judgment necessary to perform that work competently.


POINT 7: REGIONAL DIFFERENCES REQUIRE PROFESSIONAL JUDGMENT


An important part of professional maturity is recognizing that technically defensible practices may differ among regions without the underlying science being fundamentally different.


The issue of regional practice continues to perplex municipalities, regulators, and practitioners. Differences in accepted practices from one jurisdiction or geographic area to another can create the impression that the stormwater profession lacks consistency regarding appropriate methods and standards. In many cases, however, these differences are considerably narrower than they initially appear.


Sound stormwater practice should begin with overarching scientific and technical principles. Fundamental concepts involving erosion processes, sediment transport, rainfall-runoff relationships, soil behavior, pollutant transport, hydraulics, stabilization, treatment, and maintenance do not change simply because a jurisdictional or state boundary has been crossed.


What changes are the conditions under which those principles must be applied. Stormwater practice is influenced by climate, rainfall characteristics, hydrology, geography, geology, soil conditions, vegetation, receiving waters, construction methods, available materials, regulatory requirements, and local experience. These variables can substantially influence which practices are appropriate and how they should be designed, implemented, and maintained.


For example, an erosion-control practice commonly used in one region may be inappropriate in another. Cover-management values used in erosion modeling may vary based on vegetation, climate, and accepted regional practices. A stabilization technique that performs successfully in a humid environment may perform very differently under arid or semi-arid conditions. Even relatively simple practices, such as the use of straw on disturbed slopes, may be discouraged in one jurisdiction while remaining a practical, effective, and economical control measure in another.


Accordingly, consistency in professional practice should not be confused with uniformity of solutions.


The objective should not be to require every municipality, regulator, or practitioner to use precisely the same BMP, material, design value, or methodology. Rather, professionals should begin with generally accepted scientific and technical principles and then apply informed professional judgment to develop solutions appropriate for the specific site and regional conditions.


When viewed through this framework, many apparent regional disagreements become differences in application rather than fundamental differences in science or professional principles.


ECI develops its certification examinations and professional guidance around generally accepted principles that can be applied across the United States and internationally. Those principles establish the technical foundation; they are not intended to dictate a single solution for every location or circumstance. Their application ultimately requires professional judgment. There is rarely only one acceptable solution to a stormwater problem.


For this reason, professionals should be cautious about declaring a practice incorrect merely because it differs from what they commonly use in their own region. A more appropriate professional inquiry is whether the practice is:


  • Based upon technically sound general principles;
  • Appropriate for the site's geography, geology, soils, climate, and hydrology;
  • Responsive to local construction practices and available materials;
  • Consistent with applicable regulatory requirements; and
  • Capable of achieving the intended environmental and performance objectives.


Professional differences should therefore be evaluated through technical evidence, site-specific conditions, applicable requirements, demonstrated performance, and professional dialogue, not assumption or familiarity alone.


This distinction is particularly important for Certified Professionals who work across jurisdictions or review the work of other practitioners. Different does not necessarily mean wrong. Likewise, a practice that has historically been accepted locally should not be presumed technically appropriate if the underlying science, site conditions, or performance do not support it.


Professional competency requires both an understanding of generally accepted principles and the judgment necessary to appropriately adapt those principles to local conditions.


When professionals begin from a common technical foundation and then evaluate differences through geography, geology, climate, hydrology, soils, vegetation, regulatory requirements, and other relevant conditions, many of the perceived regional conflicts narrow considerably.


Sound professional practice is grounded in consistent scientific principles, but their application must reflect regional and site-specific conditions. Differences in application are not necessarily inconsistencies; they are often evidence of informed professional judgment.

 

POINT 8: DISAGREEMENT SHOULD ADVANCE THE PROFESSION, NOT DIVIDE IT


Stormwater professionals will disagree. Disagreement challenges us to elevate our knowledge and understanding. Technical disagreement encourages research, discussion, innovation, and improvement. Personal disagreements allow an opportunity to better understand the opposing position.


But there is an important distinction between professional disagreement and professional disparagement. Too often, individuals within technical professions rush to criticize another professional simply because that individual approaches a problem differently. 


This behavior damages the profession. It undermines public confidence, discourages collaboration, and creates divisions among individuals who ultimately share the same objectives.


There have also been unnecessary tensions between Certified Professionals, Professional Engineers, Professional Geologists, regulators, contractors, inspectors, and other practitioners. While a certain difference in perspective is understandable, each group brings different education, experience, responsibilities, and perspectives to the industry.


The profession should benefit from those differences rather than fight over them.


A Professional Engineer may provide engineering analysis and design authority. A Certified Professional may possess extensive specialized knowledge of erosion control, industrial compliance, municipal stormwater management, inspections, or water quality. A regulator may bring a different understanding of permit implementation and enforcement. A contractor may possess field knowledge that significantly improves constructability and BMP performance. 


The strongest solutions frequently come from combining those perspectives. Professional collaboration should therefore be viewed as a strength rather than a threat.

 

POINT 9: SPECIALIZATION IS A SIGN OF A MATURING PROFESSION


Some individuals view specialization as unnecessary fragmentation. ECI sees it differently.


Specialization develops when the body of knowledge within a profession becomes too extensive for one person to maintain equal expertise across every area.


That evolution should be welcomed. It means: 


  • the profession is growing;
  • its technical knowledge is expanding;
  • professionals are developing deeper expertise; and,
  • employers, regulators, and the public can increasingly identify individuals whose education and demonstrated competence align with the responsibilities they are being asked to perform.


No one certification at ECI can address the needs of the respective sector. The knowledge and skillsets for the management and planning required for the MS4 community is different from the highly specialized demands of the industrial stormwater sector


The objective is not to create professional silos and unnecessary initials after a person’s name. The objective is to develop professionals who possess a sound foundational understanding while developing greater expertise in the areas in which they practice.

 

POINT 10: THE STANDARD SHOULD BE COMPETENCE … NOT CONVENIENCE


The stormwater profession will continue to face pressure to make qualifications faster, easier, and less expensive. Accessibility matters. Workforce development matters. Creating meaningful opportunities for individuals to enter, develop, and advance within the profession matters.


But accessibility and competence are not mutually exclusive. 


The appropriate response is to create better career pathways, expand education and mentoring, provide financial assistance where appropriate, encourage meaningful continuing education, and create opportunities for individuals to progressively develop the knowledge and experience necessary for professional advancement. The answer should not be to redefine competence simply because achieving professional competence requires time, education, experience, and effort.


Standards have value precisely because they require something of the individuals who meet them. Professionals who have invested years developing their knowledge and expertise deserve a system that recognizes the value of that achievement. More importantly, employers, regulators, municipalities, and the public should be able to rely upon professional qualifications as meaningful evidence of competence—not simply evidence that an individual completed the quickest available pathway.


The consequences extend well beyond the interests of individual professionals. Stormwater practitioners are entrusted with protecting water quality, receiving waters, aquatic habitat, public infrastructure, and other environmental resources. Decisions concerning professional qualifications must therefore be evaluated against those public responsibilities.


Unfortunately, we have already witnessed instances in which professional qualification standards have been reduced in the name of accessibility, workforce availability, cost, or expediency. ECI believes the resulting degradation of professional standards presents a serious concern for the future of the industry, particularly when decisions affecting competency are influenced by organizations or interests that may financially benefit from lowering the barriers to qualification.


There is nothing inherently wrong with economic interests participating in the regulatory process. Contractors, developers, trainers, consultants, municipalities, environmental organizations, and professional associations all have legitimate perspectives that should be heard.


The problem arises when economic convenience or special interests are allowed to outweigh technical competence, environmental protection, and the public interest.


Regulators and municipalities have a particularly important responsibility in this regard. Their obligation is not to establish the easiest qualification standard, nor the standard preferred by the most influential stakeholder. Their responsibility is to establish and maintain requirements reasonably necessary to accomplish the environmental and public-policy objectives entrusted to them.


The Clean Water Act was not enacted for the convenience of the regulated community, certification organizations, training providers, consultants, or any other particular interest. Its fundamental purpose is the protection and restoration of the Nation's waters. Professional qualification standards associated with implementing those responsibilities should reflect that public purpose.


ECI strongly supports expanding opportunity within the stormwater profession. We support workforce development, alternative career pathways, mentoring, education, financial assistance, and programs that help individuals from all backgrounds enter and advance within this industry.


But expanding opportunity should mean helping more people achieve meaningful professional standards, not lowering the standards so that they are easier to achieve.


Those are fundamentally different approaches. The stormwater profession should advocate for the first and resist the second.


Competence must remain the standard, not convenience, expediency, political pressure, or economic self-interest. The public, the profession, and the environmental resources we have been entrusted to protect deserve nothing less. As previously stated, we need to create better career pathways, expand education and mentoring, provide financial assistance, encourage meaningful continuing education, and create opportunities for individuals to progressively develop the knowledge and experience necessary for professional advancement.

 

POINT 11: THE FUTURE WILL REQUIRE MORE EXPERTISE, NOT LESS


The technical demands facing the stormwater profession are likely to increase rather than diminish.


Professionals will be required to address emerging contaminants, advanced monitoring, changing rainfall patterns, climate resilience, green infrastructure, nature-based solutions, watershed-scale planning, water reuse, increasingly sophisticated modeling, and evolving regulatory requirements. No individual will master every one of these subjects. Nor should that be expected.


The future of the profession will depend upon professionals who possess strong foundational knowledge, develop specialized expertise, recognize the limits of their competence, continue learning throughout their careers, and collaborate effectively with others. That is how mature professions function.


The stormwater community should not expect any less out of the industry professionals.

 

POINT 12: A CALL FOR PROFESSIONAL MATURITY


ECI encourages every member of the stormwater and environmental community to embrace several fundamental principles:


  1. Professional competence must be demonstrated and maintained.
  2. Professionals should practice within the limits of their education, experience, and expertise.
  3. Continuing education should be treated as an investment in professional capability, not simply a renewal requirement.
  4. Specialization should be viewed as professional advancement rather than fragmentation.
  5. Regional differences and legitimate professional judgment should be respected.
  6. Technical disagreements should be addressed through evidence and professional dialogue rather than personal criticism.
  7. Licensed professionals, Certified Professionals, regulators, contractors, inspectors, educators, and other practitioners should work collaboratively rather than competitively.
  8. Most importantly, professionals should never place pride, convenience, or economic interest ahead of public protection and environmental stewardship.

 

CONCLUSION


Stormwater management has evolved into a sophisticated environmental profession. With that evolution comes certain responsibilities. 


The profession can no longer reasonably expect one person, one discipline, or one credential to represent mastery of every aspect of modern stormwater practice. Nor should it.


A strong profession is not one in which everyone claims expertise in everything. A strong profession is one in which individuals possess sound foundational knowledge, develop meaningful expertise, understand the limits of their competence, continue learning throughout their careers, and respect the expertise of others.


Specialization does not divide a profession when it is accompanied by collaboration. It elevates it.


Professional standards do not restrict opportunity when they are reasonably and fairly established. They protect the credibility of the profession.


And recognizing the limits of one's knowledge does not diminish professional standing. It demonstrates professional integrity.


As stormwater practice continues to evolve, these principles will become increasingly important. ECI believes they provide the foundation upon which a more technically capable, collaborative, ethical, and respected stormwater profession can be built.


Article 5 will continue this discussion by examining why ECI developed specialized professional certifications and how those certifications correspond to the increasingly distinct technical and regulatory areas within modern stormwater practice.

 
Facebook  Instagram  LinkedIn  Twitter

EnviroCert International, Inc. | 9 September 2026