EMPOAweb.org

EMPOAonline@gmail.com

Join, signup for newsletters..............Contact Us

View this email in your browser

July 19, 2026

SUFFOLK MUSLIM CEMETERY

Poll Results

In EMPOA’S last newsletter, we asked for everyone’s opinion on whether or not the Town should approve the proposed Suffolk Muslim Cemetery if all the changes offered by Mr. Sarwar and outlined in the newsletter were made part of it. The results were decidedly one-sided. One might say that the community responded with one voice loudly saying “NO!”.


Responses were received from 164 residents and 95% responded “[i]t should not be approved”. 68% of the responders were East Moriches residents.


As a result, EMPOA has advised Mr. Sarwar that it will not support his proposal for any sort of cemetery at the former Spadaro airport site.


Application Filed to Demolish Historic House

The Osborn House

453 Montauk Highway, East Moriches

(next to former ice cream shop)

Almost the oldest house in East Moriches is going to be demolished if the Town grants the owner’s application to do it. The Town’s Historic District Advisory Committee (HDAC) is to review the application. Its next meeting (virtual) is on August 11 at 5 pm.

 

A poll question is at the end of this newsletter so that, after learning more about the house (if necessary), your opinion will be counted. We will report the results, with no identifying information, to the Town.

Osborn House 7/8/2026

Is the house old? Historic maps provide part of the answer:

The first map below is part of the 1797 Hulse map of Brookhaven. There are a few houses in the East Moriches village area, but their owners are not identified.


Roads going north from the Montauk Highway are, left to right, Moriches Middle Island Road, Wading River Road and the Riverhead Road. The streams from the bay (blue) are (left to right) the Forge River, Terrell River and Seatuck Creek.


Click/tapping a map goes to a larger version; download to see detail in it.

From the 1873 Beers Atlas of Long Island:

From the 1909 Atlas of Suffolk County, Vol 1:

From a 1915 Sanborn map:

Maps from 1840 and 1858 show the village and how sparsely settled it still was, but house owners are not identified on those maps.

SUMMARY

____________________________


There is a lot of history below--very interesting--but here's a quick summary.


  • The Osborne House is approximately 300 years old and is one of the oldest residences in the entire Moriches area.
    
  • The house was recognized as historic by the Society for the Preservation of Long Island Antiquities in 1971 and by the New York Division of Historic Preservation in 1982.
    
  • The current owner purchased the property last December for $25,000 less than it sold for in 2005.
    
  • Four months later, his engineer claimed that “the building is structurally compromised beyond repair”, and the owner applied to demolish the house in June.
    
  • It is not publicly known what the owner wants to do with the one-acre property.


  • The Town’s Historic District Advisory Committee (HDAC) will review the demolition application. It will meet virtually on August 11 at 5 PM and monthly after that.
    

Please express your opinion by answering the poll question at the end of this message. EMPOA will provide the Town with the poll results without identifying respondents. 



If you don't see the poll, check and see if your provider "clipped" or truncated the email because it is long and click "view entire email" or a similar option.

OSBORN HOUSE HISTORY

 

The house’s history began in the 1700s and has been reported in several recognized texts on the history of the area.

 

 As reported in Strolling through Old East Moriches (1975):

“The house has two sections and were built about 50 years apart by Theophilus Smith and his wife Glorianna Brewster Smith in the 1700's. It was then used as a tavern for a period of about 30 years. The house was bought and modernized by Henry Parson Osborn for his family of 6 children. In 1831, Henry Osborn freed his 3 slaves. The slave quarters are still up in the attic.”

Slavery was known in the Moriches at the time. In 1827 Henry and at least 2 other East Moriches residents freed their slaves.

 

Henry bought the house in 1815. As reported later, the lot on which the house stood was huge: from Head of the Neck Road to the bay east of Pine Street. He was a farmer and is also reported to have had a store. At that time, it has been said, there were only 6 houses in what we now call East Moriches.

 

Henry Parsons Osborn and family

 

Henry P and his wife Susan raised their 6 children in the house. According to the 1840 census, besides his wife and children, 3 other adults and 2 “free colored persons” lived in the house. Six were engaged in agriculture, 1 in commerce and 1 in a learned profession or engineering.

 

By 1850, according to the census, 5 of Henry’s children remained at home and 5 other adults and one black 10-year old lived there. Henry owned 800 acres valued at $20,000. The same land today would be worth millions, even up to $220 million.

 

He became a prominent citizen of Moriches as was described in Portrait & Biographical Record, p. 668 (1896):

 

“Henry P. Osborn was in no sense of the word a politician, although he creditably acted in the capacity of Justice of the Peace for a period of twenty years. During that time he tried many important cases and his decisions were invariably sustained whenever carried to a higher court of justice. He was also the incumbent of other positions of responsibility and trust, and in whatever office placed, he always tried to carry out the wishes of the people whom he represented. He lived a long and useful life, dying in 1859 when ripe in years.”

 

There are other documented examples of his being recognized as responsible and trustworthy.


  • In 1826, at a celebration by the “Republican Citizens” of the Moriches vicinity of the 50th anniversary of independence, Henry's toast was reported in the newspaper.
  • In 1828 he was chosen as secretary of the County convention friendly to the John Quincy Adams administration to choose delegates for a state convention in Utica.
  • The following year he was appointed chairman of a meeting in Riverhead to nominate New York legislature candidates.
  • In 1829 and 1833, he was named as an administrator for two different estates.
  • In 1831 he was named by the owner as the representative to receive offers on a house in Moriches.

 

Henry P died of "consumption" at the age of 70 in in 1859.

 

Henry Toppings Osborn and family

 

Henry P’s son, Henry T, followed in the father’s footsteps. Portrait & Biographical Record, p. 668 (1896) described him as follows.

 

“HENRY T. OSBORN, who for many years was a tiller of the soil, is now [1896] retired from the active duties of life, and is in the enjoyment of a competency which his own excellent business qualities and good judgment have won him. He is still residing in East Moriches, in the same house in which he was born January 9, 1826. . ..

 

“As soon as his services could be made use of to advantage, he aided in the work on the home farm. He remained under the parental roof until twenty-five years of age, when he engaged in agricultural pursuits on his own account, and it was not long before he became one of the leading men of this class in the county. His ventures were successful, and he is now [1896] enabled to retire, surrounded by every comfort and convenience which money can purchase.

 

“. . . . Our subject is a popular man in his neighborhood, and this was illustrated when he was elected to the office of Highway Commissioner on the Republican ticket. He has also been Trustee of the Town, serving with satisfaction to all concerned. He is interested at all times in enterprises of a worthy nature, and no laudable movement is allowed to fail for want of support on his part.”

 

By 1860, according to the census, Henry owned 223 acres valued then at $20,000. He raised horses and milk cows, and grew wheat, corn and oats. By 1870, he had 20 “improved” acres and 300 acres of woodland and was growing the same crops. In 1880 he added vegetables according to the census.

 

Henry T "dropped dead in the East Moriches post office" at age 82 in 1909.

 

Later History

 

A 1940 article in the Patchogue Advance adds detail and later history.

 

“Another very interesting old homestead of the Moriches section now coming up for mention in the Tribune's series of articles relating to places that have remained in continual occupancy of one family for a century or more is the Osborn property on Main street, East Moriches.

 

“The house, a frame structure standing on the north side of the street a short distance east of Pine street, and occupied by Mark Osborn [grandson of Henry T], is a fine example of old Long Island architecture.

 

“In 1815, according to the Tribune 's informant, "Esquire Henry P. Osborn" came from East Hampton to what is now East Moriches, then called by the general name of Moriches, and bought from Theophilus Smith a large tract of land extending from the bay to Head of the Neck road.

 

“Later the property was divided between his two sons, Henry T. and George Osborn, the former getting the land north of Main street and east of Pine street and the latter the portion south of Main street and east of Atlantic avenue. The northern tract has remained, partly, in the family, while the southern portion has long ago been broken up and sold to various parties.

 

“Originally the house was a tavern. Its cellar is constructed of stones which were brought from Rock Hill by oxen. One of these stones is so large that it took two teams of oxen to draw it down to the site of construction. The fireplace in the public tap room was the largest of any in this section. It was large enough to burn cordwood in and ' still have room for the slaves to walk in the ends and cook over the fire, The original west wing, which contained the public room, has been removed and a modern one built in its place. [The last sentence needs confirmation.]

 

“Henry T. Osborn was the husband of the late Louisa Jane Osborn, who died several years ago [in 1931] at the age of 100. The house was then, occupied by their son, Edward Osborn, and since his death, by Marc Osborn, her grandson. This makes four generations which have lived in the house.” 2/9/1940 Patchogue Advance, p 9 (“street” and “avenue” are lower case in the original).


After Marc's death in 1964 the house was sold outside the family.

WHAT'S NEXT

 

The Town Code sets forth the procedure to be followed when an application for demolition of a house in an Historic Districts is filed. These steps are described generally in this section and in an article with more specificity here.

 

The application must be reviewed by the HDAC—that's where this application is now—and the Committee makes a recommendation to the Planning Commissioner based on the historic value of the house and the effect demolition would have on the character of the Historic District.

 

The Commissioner then is to consider the physical and economic feasibility of preservation and approves or denies the application. Alternatively, he may work out an arrangement with the owner for preservation.

 

The Commissioner's decision may be appealed by any aggrieved party to the ZBA.

Besides doing the quick poll below, what can you do?


Something simple is to email the HDAC with your views on the demo application. Send your email to Amy Moody in the Town Planning Dep't at amoody@brookhavenny.gov.


And you might let our Councilperson Karen Dunne Kesnig know them as well at kdunnekesnig@brookhavenny.gov.


PLEASE copy us at EMPOAonline@gmail.com



A Note

 

More information is in the documents we collected that could have been included; checking more on the information provided would have been desirable. However, more time was not available.


There's more to learn by looking at the documents collected on EMPOAweb. Everything from them is not in this newsletter. And there are many tidbits not on the Osborne family in the newspaper pages collected. We also know there is more available than we have collected.


YOUR OPINION?


POLL QUESTION 1

Does the Osborn House (described above) have historic value that should be preserved and would its demolition be a loss for the character of the Historic District?

Click/tap a response below

POLL QUESTION 2

Where do you live or have a business?

Click/tap a response below.
To make a difference, STAY involved!
 
SPREAD THE WORD . . . SHARE THIS EMAIL ON SOCIAL MEDIA
X Share This Email
Pinterest Share This Email
LinkedIn Share This Email