|
5 Must-Ask Questions for Planting & Restoration Projects
Supporting a tree planting or forest conservation initiative is a popular option for environmentally-minded individuals who want to take action on their concerns about nature, climate change — and even how to offset their own carbon emissions. However, it can be tough to make an informed decision on which programs most deserve your support …Partly because there aren’t a lot of educational resources out there that draw important distinctions among available environmental causes!
This is why, since 2020, Purpose on the Planet has worked to refine a 5-point criteria framework for identifying project locations and programs that are best set up to optimize long-term planting and sequestration success. Which brings us to PLANT! –It’s our acronym for delivering the highest-quality ROI on every donor dollar spent for this most worthy cause:
Planting • Longevity • Affordability • Nature's Numbers • Trees & CO2
| | | PLANTING: Which forestry approach is used in each program? | | |
You may be surprised to learn that forestry projects focused on carbon offsets tend to fall into one of five main categories:
1. Reforestation restores existing forests that have been depleted over time.
2. Afforestation creates new forests in previously unforested areas.
3. Agroforestry purposefully integrates trees into agricultural areas.
4. Improved forest management (IFM) aims at increasing forests’ carbon stores by delaying or avoiding timber conversion.
5. REDD+ (Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation) aims to preserve intact forests by avoiding commercial conversion.
Of the above, only project types 1-3 focus directly on planting and incremental removal of CO2 already existing in the atmosphere. In contrast, types 4-5 involve activities to avoid and reduce emissions without clear accounting of removal.
RED FLAG Any reference to mixing "CO2 removal" with "avoided or reduced" emissions potentially muddies the commitment to tree planting/sequestration, thereby raising the need to look deeper and seek clarification.
| |
GREEN LIGHT: All forms of forestation and agroforestry have the potential to remove atmospheric carbon and support local communities. However, recent studies suggest that the most effective programs normally involve reforestation that focuses on rebuilding diverse ecosystems. Although this strategy is more time consuming, it also delivers the most lasting, effective carbon removal results: When seeds are harvested from native species, plus strategically planted where they’re most likely to thrive, then they stand the greatest chance of vigorous growth and long-lasting life! | | | |
LONGEVITY: How is the durability of the project protected?
| | |
Three central considerations come into play when assessing the durability and permanence of any tree-planting and forest conservation project:
Community-based Conservation - This proven strategy engages communities in the preservation, protection, restoration, and management of their own local ecosystems. Indigenous peoples have long defended against deforestation out of fear that it will compromise their environment and livelihoods. Conversely, involving local communities in program execution from the outset enables them to become empowered guardians of the forests and their long-term welfare.
Legal Title - Secure community ownership rights are essential for sustainable forest management, and they can prompt local communities to participate in planting and conservation efforts. Having legal title empowers them to protect their land and the livelihoods it offers, while minimizing potential deforestation. It can also open the door for future carbon-market revenue streams resulting from its management of emerging forests and continued sequestration.
RED FLAG Restoration projects must have a robust plan for protection from the outset. This should include employing forest guards, implementing fire prevention protocols, and creating an educational program for the community.
| AFFORDABILITY: How can we plant & offset CO2 most economically? | | |
“Trees per $10” – What do you mean? …Well, once the above core foundations have been laid, a very simple way to assess value for money is to determine how many trees can be planted for every $10. As a 2025 guideline, several major providers advise that 5 trees can be planted for $10, or 1 tree for every $2.
But what if you could plant 25 trees for the same $10? That translates into 5 times as many trees for every $1 spent! If you identify the right program and location, it's also feasible to do so without diluting any best practices — bonus!
Nonprofit Efficiency - Simply put, this term refers to how effectively a nonprofit uses its resources to achieve its mission and meet its goals. For example, if a non-profit is 100% "founder-funded" and/or volunteer-run, it can minimize its own operating expenses and dependence on extra, third-party intermediaries. So, the actual cost for planting a tree need not be unduly inflated to support salaries and other overheads that are not directly linked to the planting process. We're living in an increasingly purpose-driven society, and this contemporary nonprofit model can assist in significantly multiplying your philanthropic impact.
| |
GREEN LIGHT - Recent studies tell us that trees planted in tropical or subtropical regions generally sequester more CO2 than those planted in other regions. Why? The trees in this region grow faster than in other places, and also release more biomass into the soil, thus sequestering higher volumes of CO2. Plus, the existing tropical-forest tree cover absorbs solar radiation more effectively, which means it fast-tracks photosynthesis and sequestration. The net gain is this: Not only may you be able to get a lower planting cost per tree in many tropical locations, but you’ll likely also be able to plant a smaller number of trees in the tropics to get CO2 removal results commensurate with other planting regions. | | | | NATURE'S NUMBERS: Are best restoration practices being adopted? | | |
MRV - Measurement, reporting, and verification are the keys to lasting restoration success. Data collection helps boost best practices, increases long-term outcomes, and enhances the overall survival rates at planting locations. …And this process can again be done most efficiently and economically by community-led Forest or Tree Growing Associations. Also, don't be surprised to hear that they leverage modern technology such as drones and satellite imagery to do so!
Survival Rates - Well-established projects often engage local Tree Monitoring Champions from within the community to lift program results. These community members are charged with tree-stand management and data collection, as well as post-planting activities like weeding, watering, pest management, and wildfire protection. For example, at a location in Tanzania, this is a formula that has helped achieve a first-year survival rate in excess of 85%. The latter is a vital metric for assessing project outcomes, and it’s even more relevant for carbon offset purposes, since sequestration levels rise as new trees continue to mature.
| |
GREEN LIGHT - Reputable planting programs value transparency, as evidenced by their consistent report-outs of detailed information on tree-planting progress and annual results. It’s important to seek out organizations that regularly disclose these types of program outcomes — not just planting volume — but also ecosystem progress, and work-and-income benefits created for the indigenous community. | | | | TREES & CO2: Which tree species sequester the most CO2? How many trees need to be planted to offset an average carbon footprint? | | |
CO2 - A reliable per-hectare estimate of carbon sequestration can only be obtained from Permanent Sample Plots — all of them reasonably large and well managed stands of trees. That said, planting projects with a commitment to success metrics and longevity may well have already established CO2 sequestration levels at their site, or conducted their own Quantified Carbon Modeling (QCM) assessment. With this data, it's possible to arrive at the average figure of CO2 sequestered per hectare per year for a particular location and tree species.
| |
GREEN LIGHT - While various factors affect carbon sequestration, studies suggest that mangroves and coastal wetlands may sequester carbon at a rate ten times greater than mature tropical forests. Also, large, old trees — notably oaks and redwoods — store significant amounts of carbon. | | | | |
Targets - US per capita CO2 emissions in 2025 are estimated by Statista to be 13.5 metric tons. For the purposes of this article, we will round this figure up and focus on how many new trees it would take to capture around 14 tons of CO2 during a typical maturation period, using QCM data from Madagascar.
This 2024 reporting was generated at one of our community-based mangrove reforestation projects in Madagascar and, as outlined above, made appropriate adjustment for (a) planting density per hectare; and (b) current survival rates.
The conclusion was that planting 600 mangroves (or 50 trees every month in a year) would remove 14 metric tons of CO2 during a typical maturation period.
| | | | |