Eco-News

Quarterly Newsletter

Volume 7 October 2024


Welcome to Eco-News

To inform and inspire ecological community action

Subscription questions? Please email annahaight@stcolumbasinverness.org.

Father Vincent Pizzuto, Vicar of St. Columba's Church and Retreat House, Inverness CA, welcomes you to our inclusive contemplative community of Celtic Christian spirituality.


Father Vincent Pizzuto, PhD began his appointment as Vicar of St. Columba's on January 1, 2017. Since his arrival he has brought to our community a vibrant spirit of openness and hospitality along with considerable academic breadth and theological depth. Read more...

Editorial

Climate Defense is National Defense


A guest editorial by Ivan Light Ph.D.


I started to write Climate Defenders in October 2023. The precipitating cause was my reading of Is Science Enough? by Aviva Chomsky. Chomsky argues that science alone cannot mobilize the political will needed to prevent climate catastrophe. She urges us to broaden the environmental coalition to include more people. It struck me then that scientists and engineers predicting doom and political radicals indicting capitalism had built a left-wing environmental movement but had failed to elicit co-sponsorship from the center and center-right, even though climate catastrophes injure us all regardless of our politics.


As a retired sociologist, I was aware that appealing to values one’s antagonists already hold is a powerful way to change opinion on any issue. What values do center and center-right voters cherish to which environmentalists might appeal? The flag, patriotism, national defense, and national security came to mind. These were conservative values to which a left-wing environmental movement was not appealing, but to which, I concluded, it was easy to connect the cause of climate protection. Here’s the syllogism I invented to express this idea: climate defense is national defense; national defense is national security; therefore, climate defense is national security! Climate defense is patriotic. Proclaiming that message has been the persistent focus of the bi-weekly blogs I have subsequently produced on Substack. The complete list of Climate Defenders blogs is available free on https://ivanlight.substack.com/archive.


Writing the blogs has been a continuing education for me. I still believe that Climate Defenders can appeal to many conservative voters on grounds of patriotism and national security. Of late, however, I have become increasingly aware of the implied competition for taxpayer dollars between a fully funded environmental project and a fully funded military budget. In point of fact, the conservative value of national security has an institutional base in the military-industrial-Congressional complex. If so, opposition to environmental protection derives from more than just the fossil fuel industries. Opposition also derives from interest coalitions that thrive on big military budgets and the belligerent foreign policy that justifies them.


Ivan Light Ph.D.


Ivan Light, Ph.D. received a doctor’s degree in sociology from the University of California, Berkeley in 1969 and settled into a career of research and teaching at UCLA. His research specialty was the economic sociology of immigration. In his words, "This specialty gave me no substantive background in environmental science, but plenty of background on social movements and political change. I retired from UCLA in 2008 and bought a house in Inverness in 2010. I joined St Columba’s Church then and I have been a congregant ever since."


St. Columba's Solar Panels by Anna Haight

News from a UN global survey


Around the world, awareness of the urgency of the threat posed by climate change is growing, as are calls for climate action. This year, the UN Development Programme surveyed 73,000 people in 77 different countries, one of the largest surveys of its kind.


They found that 80 percent of respondents want their governments to do more to act on climate change. 72 percent said they want a swift transition away from fossil fuels. And 56 percent of those surveyed said they think about climate change “daily or weekly.”


“The survey results – unprecedented in their coverage – reveal a level of consensus that is truly astonishing. We urge leaders and policymakers to take note. This is an issue that almost everyone, everywhere, can agree on,” said UNDP Administrator Achim Steiner. To see your country’s results, click here.


Bill McKibben reports in his recent newsletter


The really big climate news today is the new report from the UN Environment Programme on the “emissions gap”—the distance between the commitments made by countries to cut carbon, and the amount that scientists say is required. The news is not good—of all the countries on earth, only Madagascar is meeting the challenge, and we’re still set to see the planet warm an impossible three degrees.


The world is yet to turn the tide on rising CO2 emissions, with the amount of greenhouse gases released into the atmosphere climbing 1.3% last year, UNEP said. The landmark Paris Agreement in 2015 set a goal to limit global warming to well below 2C above pre-industrial levels, and ideally to 1.5C. To meet the more ambitious target, countries must collectively commit to cut emissions 42% by the end of the decade and 57% by 2035, compared with 2019 levels.


“We need global mobilization on a scale and pace never seen before — starting right now, before the next round of climate pledges — or the 1.5C goal will soon be dead,” said Inger Andersen, UNEP’s executive director.


But here’s the part that kills me. We could get back on track by spending…about one percent of the world’s GDP each year.


When it comes to finance, UNEP said the cost of the transition is relatively affordable. While funding for mitigation needs to be more focused on developing countries, investment globally must increase between $900 billion and $2.1 trillion per year, roughly 1% of the world’s total economic output, to achieve net zero by 2050. To explain how dumb our delay is, here’s another new study that tries to point out the economic damage that’s beginning to mount, even in rich America.


“I think the cost of climate [change] is increasingly a threat to our already very fragile fiscal outlook,” said Mark Zandi, chief economist of Moody’s Analytics. Factoring in the prospect that the government must spend “tens of billions or hundreds of billions more each year to help mitigate the fallout of climate events,” he added, “the outlook looks even darker.”


One percent of GDP would be the savviest financial planning in the history of the earth.



In a time of ongoing social and ecological upheaval, the St. .Columba’s Council for Ecological Discipleship seeks to address the spiritual roots of our ecological crisis, grounded in the scriptural, theological, and spiritual wisdom of the Christian contemplative tradition. 



About the Council for Ecological Discipleship


Council Member Bios

Letter from the Editor


Dear Reader,


You might be wondering what happened to our planned Eco-Retreat for the first weekend in October. After we had scheduled it we learned that same weekend St. Columba’s would be hosting the new Episcopal Bishop and his wife for his first official Triannual Visitation to St. Columba’s. It also coincided with the Blessing of the Animals, traditional on the Sunday closest to St. Francis’s Feast Day October 4.


Combined with the fact of low enrollment, when we attempted to reschedule the retreat for the Spring 2025 our presenters could not confirm availability.


This has prompted CED to ask the question, perhaps it is not only the distraction of the Fall election, but the theme and retreat program was not a draw. So we are coming back to you our readers to ask for some quick feedback on what eco- topics you would like to see more of or less, in our Eco-News and for those who might attend an in person eco-retreat, what are your main interests? What topics you would like to engage in with talks, discussions and walks in the beautiful wildlife environment of the Point Reyes National Seashore?


Please click this link for the survey. It will take 3 minutes.


Thank you so much for your time


Penny Washbourn

CED Member


Penny's Bio

Eco-News Reader Survey

Click for Survey Form

PROGRAMS

FILM DISCUSSION


Common Ground : Saving the Planet one Acre at a time

January 15, 4-5pm PT


Common Ground is the highly anticipated sequel to the juggernaut success documentary, Kiss the Ground, which touched over 1 billion people globally and inspired the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) to put $20 billion toward soil health. By fusing journalistic expose’ with deeply personal stories from those on the front lines of the food movement, Common Ground unveils a dark web of money, power, and politics behind our broken food system. The film reveals how unjust practices forged our current farm system in which farmers of all colors are literally dying to feed us. The film profiles a hopeful and uplifting movement of white, black, and indigenous farmers who are using alternative “regenerative” models of agriculture that could balance the climate, save our health, and stabilize America’s economy – before it’s too late.


Starring actors Woody Harrelson, Laura Dern and regenerative framer Gabe Brown, the documentary was directed and produced by Josh Tickell and Rebecca Tickell. Josh is the author of 2017 book Kiss the Ground: How the Food You Eat can Reverse Climate Change. Since the film’s release in early 2024 it has received multiple awards.


In Spring 2024 CED hosted a Zoom interview with Ryland Engelhart, the Co-founder and Chief Mission Officer of the Kiss the Ground movement and producer of Common Ground.


Film Discussions

We will be providing opportunities to discuss the most important documentaries concerning the impact of climate change as well as progress being made across the globe to address those effects. Participants watch films on their own time and register for an online discussion, moderated by a Council member.



2025 Upcoming films and dates:


Common Ground : Saving the Planet one Acre at a time

January 15, 4-5pm PT


Deep Rising March 19, 4-5pm PST


Out There: A National Parks Journey:

June 25, 4-5pm PST


Cooked: Survival by Zipcode :

November 19, 4-5pm PT




Check Online Offerings for registration information a month prior to the discussion to receive the Zoom link.

Book Study


Throughout the year the Council will provide a "slow" read and online discussion of foundational and new texts that address the spiritual crisis of our human relationship to the earth. Each book study meets three times over a six week period to allow for careful reading and reflection. Sessions moderated by Council members.




2024 Upcoming books and dates:

Times: all Pacific



The Great Work by Thomas Berry

November Tuesday 19, 4-5:30pm

December Tuesday 3, 4-5:30pm

December Tuesday 17, 4-5:30pm



2025 Upcoming books and dates

Times all Pacific


Life After Doom : Wisdom and Courage for a World Falling Apart by Brian D. McLaren



February 19, 4-5:30pm PT

March 12,4-5:30pm PST

March 26, 4-5:30pm PST


The Light Eaters: How the Unseen World of Plant Intelligence Offers a New Understanding of Life on Earth

Zoe Schlanger


May 7, 4-5:30pm

May 21, 4-5:30pm

June 4, 4-5:30pm


Saving Us: A Climate Scientist's

case for Hope and Healing in a Divided World by Katharine Hayhoe


July 16, 4-5:30pm

July 30,4-5:30pm

August 13, 4-5:30pm


The Heartbeat of the Wild: Dispatches from Landscapes of Wonder, Peril and Hope

by David Quammen


September 24, 4-5:30pm

October 8, 4-5:30pm

October 22, 4-5:30pm



Check Online Offerings for registration information a month prior to the first discussion to receive the Zoom link.

IN THE NEWS

In this section we highlight one organization that is contributing to the health of the planet. Last issue we focused on The Grove Collaborative for reducing the use single use plastics in consumer products . This issue we focus on their partnership with The Nature Conservancy's Emerald Edge program.

The Nature Conservancy announces A Partnership to Help Protect Our Forests


The Nature Conservancy ‘s Emerald Edge program seeks to protect a vast swath of the coastal-rainforest system from the Pacific Northwest to the Tongass, which includes most of Southeast Alaska.


Forests like the Emerald Edge are the Earth's largest above-ground "pools" of carbon, helping keep excess carbon dioxide out of the atmosphere. But the decimation of old-growth trees and other extractive commercial practices are putting these forests—and the climate—at risk.

Tongass Rainforest in Emerald Edge © Chris Crisman

The Nature Conservancy (TNC) and Grove Collaborative are partnering in support of conservation led by Indigenous First Nations, Alaska Natives, and coastal Tribes. These communities have been intimately connected to these lands and waters for millennia and are leading efforts to support sustainable economic and community development and heal the bonds with these lands and waters so they can continue to support life for generations to come.


Two Million Acres Closer to a Sustainable Future Grove is on a mission to transform the products you use at home into a force for good. Over an eight-year partnership (January 1, 2023 - December 31, 2030), Grove will contribute $1,500,000 to the Emerald Edge to support Indigenous-led conservation across 2 million acres of the Tongass Rainforest of Southeast Alaska.


Salmon Southeast Alaska's communities rely on the Tongass' abundant rivers and streams for food security.

© Chris Crisman

The Emerald Edge spans over 100 million acres of lush forest, rivers, islands, and mountain streams in Washington state, Oregon, Alaska, and British Columbia. As the world’s largest coastal temperate rainforest, it sustains thousands of species—including salmon, bears, wolves, whales, and humans—and plays a critical role in regulating the global climate. 


Indigenous Peoples Are Key Leaders in Conservation



Community stewardship of the Tongass National Forest helps maintain the natural wealth of this region. Indigenous communities, whose cultures and livelihoods are deeply intertwined with the ecosystem, have for hundreds of years been shut out of land-use decision-making and the economic benefits of the region’s natural resources by governments and conservation groups alike. TNC and its Canadian affiliate Nature United are working across the region to build trust and support Indigenous Peoples in asserting their rights and authority over their lands and waters so they can protect the integrity of the landscape and sustain the cultural and economic life of their communities.

Wild Women’s Tongass Wilderness Kayak Pilgrimage


By Sylvia Timbers, CED member


Twenty years ago, for a year, we prepared—ten women, bound by the dream of a sacred adventure into the heart of Alaska’s Tongass Wilderness. After months of planning, five floatplane journeys from Petersburg ferried us, two by two, with our kayaks and all the gear that would carry us through the immensity of this untamed land. The final flight left us on an unnamed island, where the horizon stretched endlessly into untouched, wild beauty.


Paddles dipped into the crystalline waters, and we began our ten-day pilgrimage. Beneath our boats, silver salmon surged toward their distant promise, while eagles soared above in watchful arcs, their cries echoing in the vast silence. Each stroke pulled us deeper into the embrace of this ancient land, a place where the weight of mountains met the immensity of the sky humbling us in their presence


The humpbacks came to greet us, their great bodies breaking the surface, close enough to drench us in their breath. Once, we almost capsized when a full breach occurred directly in front of us. On the shore, we glimpsed deer swimming between islands, and moving quietly among the ferns, their forms like whispered secrets in the trees. At night, the wolves sang from unseen corners of the forest, their voices haunting the edge of our firelight.


Just before departing for our next island we encountered three grizzlies, a distance below us at the bottom of a ravine. They stood up to smell us, noses twitching and paws waving. We froze. Then, hearts racing, we ran to our loaded kayaks, jumped in and furiously paddled. It felt as though Mother Nature herself had granted us safe passage. Humbled and grateful, we resumed our journey deeper into her wild arms.



Nights beneath an infinity of stars brought a silence so profound, it became its own kind of music. The wilderness spoke to us not in words, but in the language of wind and water, hymns of stars and solitude. Here, in this place where human footprints had not yet fallen, a new kind of love was born—love for the land, for the creatures who shared it with us, and for the parts of ourselves we discovered in this wild, quiet place. We returned rapturously transformed, knowing we had touched the sacred.


Facebook  Instagram  YouTube

St. Columba's Inverness

12835 Sir Francis Drake Blvd.

PO Box 430

Inverness, CA 94937

415.669.1039

Email Us

Contact Us