|
While it will take time for the educational world to understand fully the impact of the trauma of the past two years, there are some clear lessons that have already emerged. The most important lesson is one we already knew, but it is one that we must re-learn every few years: computers are not teachers.
While some students – estimates range between ten and twenty percent – thrived in a distance learning environment, many students floundered. Secondary schools experienced failure rates as high as 50% and many students – especially those who had not been accustomed to working with computers for academic work – simply disengaged. Many classes proceeded on the myth that when the cameras were on, teachers would deliver instruction and then, during “asynchronous instruction,” students were to be disciplined and diligent enough to complete homework assignments and turn them in. It didn’t happen, and the single greatest cause of student failure during the pandemic is the same cause that persists today: missing homework. Even today, after students have been relying on computers for 18 months, many do not know how to keyboard and type, slowly and inaccurately, with a single finger. It's as if we gave every student in American a nice car, but forgot to give them the keys and teach them how to drive.
The false assumptions of computer-based instruction were even worse for students in the primary grades, as six and seven year old’s were expected to stare at a screen and listen to teachers, but within minutes, the headphones slipped down around their necks and, if the students remained on their computers at all, it was to play games rather than engage in classwork.
We should be careful not to cast blame solely on the pandemic for this state of affairs. In the years before March of 2020, I observed classrooms in which students were plugged in and the classroom was silent – but the most casual observation revealed that some of the headphones were not plugged into the computer but into their pockets where their phones were concealed. The crisis of engagement was made worse by the pandemic, but the pandemic was not the cause of it.
I’m fully aware that there are shining exceptions in which distance learning worked well and teachers and administrators did heroic work to deliver technology and connectivity to students. But the evidence of lower reading levels, poor behavior, and rampant disengagement cannot be ignored.
Schools are heading for a funding cliff as federal relief funds dry up and student populations decline in many places. In the past two years, billions of dollars were spent on programs and products. If the pandemic has taught us anything, it is that the most important investments in the future will be on people and practices. It is, in brief, not what we buy that matters most, but what we do.
|