|
January 1, 2025 will change the way litigation is conducted in Florida. Clients are warned to be ready as pre-trial deadlines and procedures are about to change drastically. Effective January 1, 2025, most civil cases will be tried within 18 months.
To accomplish this feat, the Florida Supreme Court has rewritten a number of portions of the Rules of Civil Procedure. In this new rigid legal landscape, deadlines in Case Management Orders are “strictly enforced” and trial continuances are “disfavored”, and as a result will be scarcely granted.
The practical effects are jarring. For example, the trial clock will be ticking during the time it takes to obtain a ruling on a motion to dismiss (eroding time for discovery if the motion is not granted). Motions for Summary Judgments filed after deadlines will not be heard until directed verdict motions are made after plaintiff’s case-in-chief. The new rules are inflexible, necessitating strict compliance with little margin for error. There may not be recourse for parties that are added with amended complaints and amendments to pleadings will not delay the trial clock.
RECOMMENDATIONS AND CONCERNS
-
Obtain the CMO early. Defense counsel, clients and claims professionals should diary deadlines from the Case Management Order (CMO) that is issued at filing. Claim professionals should be adept at obtaining CMOs off court dockets/websites and ensure that defense counsel is providing the CMO and its deadlines with initial reports.
-
Collaborate Pre-suit. Clients and claims professionals should view pre-suit demands as an opportunity to collaborate with defense counsel to formulate an approved litigation plan pre-suit, so that the plan can be executed immediately upon filing/service of the complaint.
-
Accept Service? Defense counsel, clients and claims professionals should consider accepting service on complaints (especially newly added parties) to avoid losing crucial time (up to four months or more) while service is to be effectuated. The trial deadline clock used to run from date of filing, not date of service. We suspect some plaintiff’s firms may intentionally delay service in order to shorten the time period for a defendant to engage in necessary discovery. Defense counsel should be prepared to argue that under recently amended rules of judicial administration, trial judges should correct CMO trial deadlines to run from date of service, not date of filing. (see Rule of Judicial Administration 2.250).
-
New Initial Disclosure Requirements. Defense counsel and clients are now required to voluntarily provide discovery and should therefore make such preparations in advance of filing of the suit. See Rule 1.280 below.
-
Early Approval of CMEs and Experts. Clients and claims professionals should be flexible in allowing early retention of experts for compulsory medical examinations (CMEs) as deadlines will not be extended, nor continuances granted. We suspect some plaintiff’s firms will routinely object to CMEs, which will result in delays getting rulings and hearings, while trial deadlines loom.
-
Proportionality Changes to Subpoenas. Defense counsel and clients should be aware that the new discovery rule 1.280 (below) includes a proportionality requirement and provides that parties may obtain discovery regarding any non-privileged matter relevant to any party’s claim or defense, and proportional to the needs of a case. We suspect plaintiff’s counsel may more aggressively make blanket objections to subpoenas for medical records from pre-accident providers or non-treating physicians. This process could substantially delay receipt of critical records, and it is less likely to result in an extension of trial deadlines with the new rule language which disfavors continuances.
-
Get Organized, Get Ready. Everyone must be ready to timely and proactively move their cases. This burden should be shared with defense counsel, clients and claims professionals all working together to meet deadlines. It is recommended that all cases should be scheduled for monthly, recurring status meetings with clients and claims handlers. Teams not prepared for these rule changes will face costly consequences.
The Florida Supreme Court brought about these significant changes in opinions In Re: Amendments to Florida Rules of Civil Procedure, No. SC2023-0962 and In Re: Amendments to Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.510 and New Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.202, No. SC2024-0662. Rules 1.200 (Case Management; Pretrial Procedure), 1.201 (Complex Litigation), 1.202 (Conferral Prior to Filing Motions), 1.280 (General Provisions Governing Discovery), 1.440 (Setting Action for Trial), 1.460 (Motions to Continue Trial), and 1.510 (Summary Judgment) were amended.
Below are the most important revisions to be aware of:
THE RULE CHANGES SUMMARIZED
RULE 1.200 – CASE MANAGEMENT; PRETRIAL PROCEDURE
Case management tracks will be designated at the outset of new cases with duration to disposition as follows:
-
General: (jury) 18-month time to disposition
- Streamlined: (non-jury/county jury) 12-month time to disposition
- Complex: 30-month time to disposition
For streamlined and general cases, the court must issue a case management order that specifies the projected or actual trial period. Requests for modifications of the actual trial periods are governed by Rule 1.460 (Motions to Continue Trial), discussed below. Importantly, the rule mandates strict enforcement of deadlines in case management orders, unless changed by court order.
RULE 1.201 – COMPLEX LITIGATION
Clerks will not automatically designate a case as complex; parties are required to file a motion, and the court may hold a hearing. Per the rule, a complex case is “one that is likely to involve complicated legal or case management issues and that may require extensive judicial management to expedite the case, keep costs reasonable, or promote judicial efficiency.” Complex cases will be the exception, with most cases falling into the 18-month general track.
RULE 1.202 – CONFERRAL PRIOR TO FILING MOTIONS
Parties have a duty to confer and to file a certificate of conferral prior to filing non-dispositive motions, such as motions to compel. If the movant is unable to confer with the opposing party, then the movant must file a certification that the opposing party was unavailable for a conference and should describe all efforts undertaken to accomplish dialogue prior to filing the motion.
RULE 1.280 – GENERAL PROVISIONS GOVERNING DISCOVERY
In a nod to Federal Court system, the rule now requires parties to submit initial discovery disclosures within 60 days of service of a complaint or joinder, unless the court sets a different time. Such disclosures must include the names and contact information of individuals likely to have discoverable information, a description of documents or tangible objects which may support the parties’ claims or defenses, a computation of damages, and insurance policies. The rule also includes a proportionality requirement and provides that parties may obtain discovery regarding any non-privileged matter relevant to any party’s claim or defense, and proportional to the needs of a case. This is a change from the prior standard, which required that requests must be reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence. Finally, the parties now have a continuous obligation to timely supplement discovery, which may include modifying initial disclosures or other discovery responses upon learning new information.
RULE 1.440 – SETTING ACTION FOR TRIAL
Rule 1.440 Setting Action for Trial eliminates the “at issue” requirement. This means that come January, a court can set a case for trial and the case can be tried, regardless of whether the pleadings are closed.
RULE 1.460 – MOTIONS TO CONTINUE TRIAL
One of the biggest changes is to Rule 1.460, which now expressly provides that “s” Courts are encouraged to use all appropriate methods to address and prevent any delays, such as deposition use and remote courtroom appearances during trial. Also, the court now has discretion to impose sanctions if a continuance is granted because of an attorney or party’s dilatory conduct.
RULE 1.510 –SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Under the new rule, the deadline to respond to a motion for summary judgment is tied to the date of service of the motion rather than the hearing date, and a response must be filed within 60 days after service of the motion.
IN CONCLUSION
While the new rules present a more streamlined process, attorneys, claims professionals and litigants must all adjust now to these procedural requirements and strict deadlines. Moving forward, it is imperative that teams actively manage cases and stay ahead of the curve. Early preparation will be key in navigating these new rules, which will apply to all cases in January. Our law firm has implemented training and procedures to ensure a smooth transition into the new deadlines and rules. We have created a dedicated Pre-Trial Compliance Attorney position, overseen by Nicole Seropian, to train our teams and audit compliance and ensure our litigation teams have the resources they need to proactively and efficiently comply. Should you wish to discuss our firm’s strategy, please feel free to reach out to Daniel Santaniello.
For the full text of the Rules changes, go to:
https://supremecourt.flcourts.gov/content/download/2434944/opinion/Opinion_SC2023-0962.pdf
https://supremecourt.flcourts.gov/content/download/2434947/opinion/Opinion_SC2024-0662.pdf.
More civil rules changes are likely to come from the Florida Supreme Court. All other proposed amendments to the rules can be found here:
https://supremecourt.flcourts.gov/Case-Information/Rules-Cases-Proposed-Amendments
|