May 4, 2023
2023 Session, Week 9
The regular session of the Florida Legislature is scheduled to adjourn tomorrow at noon, and what a session it has been.
As of now, an avalanche of bills are bouncing back and forth between the two Chambers in the attempt to get them in a final, agreeable and passable form. If these bills are not resolved by close of business today, it is unlikely they will pass. Look for our last weekly update next Thursday, when the dust has settled, for a final accounting.
CS/CS/HB 3 -- Government and Corporate Activism -- Signed into law this week, this bill revises state banking practices, eliminating the consideration of environmental and social governance (ESG) for Florida’s retirement and investments.

CS/CS/HB 269 -- Public Nuisances -- This bill makes it a crime to distribute materials onto private property with the intent to intimidate or threaten the owner, resident or invitee and makes it a crime to project images onto a building, structure or property without permission.

HB 1297 -- Capital Sexual Battery This law provides for death sentences for certain child sexual offenders.

HB 1359 -- Offenses Involving Fentanyl or Fentanyl Analogs – This law provides criminal penalties and mandatory minimum term of imprisonment for Fentanyl. 

SB 1550 -- Prescription Drugs -- This law requires drug manufacturers by April 1 of each year to notify the Department of Business and Professional Regulation of any “reportable drug price increase” in the 12 months leading up to said review.

SB 1552 -- Public Records/Pharmacy Benefit Managers – The law provides an exemption from public records' requirements for examination and investigation reports and work papers relating to pharmacy benefit managers. 

HB 1627 -- Pretrial Release and Detention – This law requires the Florida Supreme Court to set up a statewide bond schedule, which preempts local bond schedules. In addition, it adds crimes eligible for pre-trail detention, including fentanyl trafficking, DUI and written threats to kill. 
  
CS/CS/SB 450 -- Death Penalty --signed into law by Governor DeSantis last week, this new law modifies the death penalty statute in Florida. It reduces the number of jurors required to recommend a death sentence from 12 to 8, the lowest threshold compared to any state that actively carries out the death penalty.

SB 360 -- Causes of Action Based on Improvements to Real Property --
The governor signed this bill on April 13th, revising the time in which action founded on design, planning or construction of improvement to real property must be commenced (changes the 4-year window commencement from the actual date of possession by the owner to the date of the temporary certificate of completion or the date of abandonment, whichever is earliest); revising date on which statute of limitations period begins (reducing from 10 years to 7 years); providing for calculation of statute of limitations period for multi-dwelling buildings; and defining "material violation."

SB 300 -- Pregnancy and Parenting Support -- was signed by the governor on April 13th and bans abortions after six weeks of pregnancy with an exception for victims of rape and/or incest. This bill is a reduction from last session’s signed-into-law, 15-week ban that does not include any exceptions.

CS/HB 543 -- Public Safety -- On April 3rd, Governor DeSantis signed into law "permit-less carry." Florida becomes the 26th state to pass some version of this into law. The bill was co-sponsored by Rep. Chuck Brannon, and will allow residents to carry concealed weapons without a permit. It is not what some gun-rights activists call "open carry." The new law will go into effect July 1st.

HB 837 -- Civil Remedies (One-Way Legal Fees) -- On March 24th, Governor DeSantis signed this bill into law, limiting insurance companies’ responsibility for claimants’ legal fees in the event of a lawsuit. In most lawsuits, each party pays for their own lawyers, but in the past, a policyholder who successfully sued an insurance company for denying a claim could also sue to recover attorneys’ fees. Supporters felt the previous system was a deterrent for insurance companies acting in bad faith; opponents felt it was an area rife with excessive litigation, which drove up costs.

HB 1Education (Universal School Choice) -- On March 27th, Governor DeSantis signed HB 1 into law. This law is a significant expansion of school choice in Florida and gives every K-12 student access to a voucher to attend private school by eliminating eligibility restrictions and expanding scholarships.

In addition, the law removes the requirement that students complete at least 1 credit through a virtual course.

SB 102 -- Housing (Live Local Act)-- a top priority of Senate President Passidomo, this bill was signed by the governor on March 29th. The new law budgets $711 million for affordable housing for state employees, creates property tax exemptions for housing developers and prohibits rent control. The bill takes effect July 1.
Local Delegation Bills

These bills have passed both Chambers and are awaiting action by the governor.

Senator Keith Perry

SB 404 -- Public Records/Photograph or Video or Audio Recording of the Killing of a Minor/Autopsy Reports of Minors -- referred to as the “Rex and Brody bill”, this bi-partisan effort passed all committees and both chambers unanimously.

SB 478 -- Early Childhood Music Education Incentive Program -- This bill also passed both chambers unanimously in another bi-partisan effort. 

CS/SB 1154 -- Labor Pool Act -- This bill amends the Labor Pool Act, a Florida law, that regulates labor pools, businesses that provide workers to other businesses on a temporary basis.

Senator Jennifer Bradley

SB 384  -- Violent Offenses Committed Against Criminal Defense Attorneys -- Amends Florida law to reclassify certain offenses committed against criminal defense attorneys as felonies of the first degree.

SB 770 -- Residential Loan Alternative Agreements -- This bill amends Florida law to prohibit residential loan alternative agreements from authorizing a person to place a lien on or otherwise encumber any residential real property.

SB 978 -- Secured Transactions -- This bill amends FS 679.1081. 

SB 1418 -- Emergency Communications -- This bill creates a new Office of Emergency Communications within the Department of Management Services to oversee improvements to public safety answering points (PSAPs) for all 911 calls.

Representative Chuck Clemons

HB 1645 -- City of Gainesville, Alachua County -- The bill provides for a 5-member governing authority to be appointed by Florida's governor. The new government board would have the ability to amend and set utility rates, fees, assessments, charges, rules, regulations, and policies governing the sale and use of services provided by the utilities.



CS/SB 254 --Treatments for Sex Reassignment -- co-sponsored by Sen. Perry, passed the Senate and is now set for its 3rd reading in the House.

Appropriations

The budget was finalized with a smoothness rarely observed in Tallahassee, and the official “cooling-off period” has begun. The conferences finalized their bills on Tuesday morning.  

Florida’s proposed budget is a record $116 billion, $6 billion more than last year’s budget of $110 billion. The budget is $1 billion more than what Governor DeSantis requested, and it’s $3 billion more than the House’s proposed $113 billion and the Senate’s starting point of $113.7 billion.
 
Budget highlights:
  • $75 million for the University of Florida to break ground on a 15-acre campus expected to handle about 10,000 grad students, with a focus on health care business, engineering and artificial intelligence.
  • $5 million in recurring funds for the Hamilton Center for Classical and Civic Education at the University of Florida.
  • $24 million for the Florida School for Competitive Academics, Senator Perry’s statewide magnet school to be located in Alachua County (SB 1386).
  • $389 million for a 5% pay raise for 97,000 state workers, and $108 million to recruit new employees to fill 16,000 vacancies.
  • $382.5 million for Everglades restoration, $850 million for a wildlife corridor, $300 million for environmentally sensitive lands and $300 million to combat sea level rise.
  • $2.5 billion of the $4 billion requested by Governor DeSantis to speed up road building projects, with the remaining $1.5 billion to be released later in the year.
  • $5 million for raises and increased security protection for the governor and his family.
  • A six-fold increase to $6 million for the governor to spend on litigation and related legal costs.
  • And approximately 100 spending items worth more than $300 million requested by individual lawmakers, which will need to survive the governor's veto pen.



The budget is set for a vote tomorrow morning.

Charter Schools

CS/CS/SB 1328 -- Charter School Capital Outlay Funding -- The House has passed a bill that the Senate now must act on. The bill modifies the way charter schools are funded in Florida and could potentially transfer millions of dollars from traditional schools to charter schools. If the bill becomes law, charter schools would receive the money according to student enrollment by creating a new funding formula that takes into account the demographics of a school's student body. The bill also provides additional funding for charter schools that serve students from low-income families or students with disabilities.

SB 1386 -- Florida School for Competitive Academics -- sponsored by Sen. Perry would create the first statewide charter school, billed as the "IMG of academic academies," to be located in Alachua County. The bill has moved to the Appropriations Committee on Education.

Public Schools

CS/CS/CS/HB 1537 -- Education -- A significant re-write (115 pages) of the laws surrounding secondary education in Florida is teed up for passage. It includes language that would allow the state of Florida to create a competitor to AP courses and authorize districts to use the Classic Learning Test to rival the SAT and the ACT and be used in determination of Florida’s Bright Futures Scholarship.

In addition, the bill delays raising required test scores for Florida’s seniors to qualify for graduation.

CS/CS/CS/SB 52 -- Student Use of Social Media Platforms -- has passed the Senate Chamber unanimously. This bill will restrict social media use in schools, restricting access to social media on school district networks and district-owned and specifically banning TikTok on district-owned devices and use of the platform to promote school activities.

Teachers are also given the ability to designate an area for wireless communications and prohibit their use during instructional time.

The Senate version amended a House version, so it must be considered by the House again. The Senate amendment requires students in grades six through twelve to learn about the effects of social media.

CS/HB 389 -- Menstrual Hygiene Products in Public Schools -- has been added to the Special Order Calendar. This bill mandates menstrual products be provided free at public schools, including charter schools.

SB 256 -- Employee Organizations Representing Public Employees – has passed the full Senate and awaits action in HB 1445 -- Employee Organizations Representing Public Employees. The bill remakes the rules that unions operate under in Florida, making the standards to organize higher and banning automatic deductions for union dues from paychecks.

HB 891 --Year-round School Pilot Program -- a pilot program to test out year-round schooling has been placed on the Second Reading Calendar.

SB 1320 -- Child Protection in Public Schools – billed as an expansion of Parental Rights in schools, this bill would prohibit an employee, contractor or student of a public school from being required to refer to a person using personal titles or pronouns that do not correspond with that person’s sex, and prohibit classroom instruction by school personnel on sexual orientation or gender identity until grade 9. This bill has been placed on the Second Reading Calendar.

HB 1557 was passed and signed into law last year, reading: "classroom instruction by school personnel or third parties on sexual orientation or gender identity may not occur in kindergarten through grade 3 or in a manner that is not age- or developmentally-appropriate for students in accordance with state standards."

In a rule-making move, not requiring action by the state legislature, the Florida Department of Education is moving to forbid classroom instruction on sexual orientation and gender identity in grades K-12.

Postsecondary Education

CS/CS/SB 846 -- Agreements of Educational Entities with Foreign Entities --
This bill targets China, Cuba, Iran, North Korea, Russia, Syria and Venezuela and bans state schools, their employees and their representatives from soliciting or accepting gifts from those foreign entities. The bill also bars state schools et al from participating in any agreement or partnership with a school or entity based in or controlled by one of those nations. Schools would have until Dec 1, 2023 to comply with the new law’s provisions. The bill has been placed on the Second Reading Calendar.

Sen. Perry's SB 958 -- Postsecondary Educational Institutions -- has moved to the Fiscal Policy Committee. This bill creates an Office of Public Policy Events through the Board of Governors and the State University System that would put a satellite office on each campus. These offices would ensure that speakers representing “multiple, divergent and opposing” viewpoints be presented on each campus.

Several bills have been introduced to tighten control of the higher education system in Florida, including the similar HB 999 and SB 266:
HB 999 -- Public Postsecondary Educational Institutions -- would change the tenure system in Florida’s higher education, allowing the chair of the university board of trustees to review any faculty member’s tenure status, and would prohibit the college system from providing funds for any activities that “espouse the diversity, equity and inclusion of Critical Race Theory rhetoric.” It would also prohibit the teaching of “identity politics, such as Critical Race Theory, or defines American history as contrary to the creation of a new nation based on the universal principles stated in the Declaration of Independence." The bill has been placed on the Education and Employment Committee Calendar.

SB 266 -- Higher Education -- revises the mission of each state university; requires each state university to annually report certain research expenditures of a specified amount; authorizes each state university board of trustees to review any faculty member’s tenure status; authorizes the Board of Trustees of the University of Florida to use funds to establish and fund the Hamilton College for Classical and Civic Education; revises how general education core courses are established; and removes a prohibition against a public postsecondary institution from being accredited by the same accrediting body for multiple consecutive accreditation cycles. The bill has moved to the Appropriations Committee on Education.

Temporary Teacher Certificates

Rep. Yvonne Hinson has introduced a bill to allow certain paraprofessionals to be issued temporary teaching certificates, valid for 5 years while being mentored.
The Chambers have released their tax packages: in the Senate -- SB 7062 -- and in the House – HB 7063.

Both versions contain some mix of tax holidays, including two different back-to-school tax holidays (August and January). In addition, tax holidays are presented for gas stoves, hurricane supplies, recreational supplies and public events.

Both would permanently eliminate sales tax on diapers and adult incontinence products, baby supplies (strollers, cribs, baby wipes, etc.) and oral hygiene products like toothpaste and mouthwash.

Both would exempt energy-efficient household appliances from sales tax for the second consecutive year.

Both will expand property tax breaks for disabled veterans and surviving spouse members of the military and law enforcement killed in the line of duty.

Both versions have sales tax breaks for companies that produce methane-based fuels that come from sources like sewage plants, landfill gas that is at times referred to as “renewable natural gas.”

Both versions contain tax breaks for those that install “gray water” water-recycling systems, but they differ on the details, such as length and caps.
The House proposes a significant tax break for businesses that rent. The rate is scheduled to fall from 5.5 to 2 percent in two years, but this tax bill cuts the tax from 5.5 to 4.5 next year.   The Senate bill does not contain this reduction.
Governor DeSantis has expressed support for a package of bills that are being touted as “the toughest crackdown on undocumented immigration by any state” in more than a decade.

CS/SB 1718 -- Immigration -- and HB 1617 -- Unlawful Immigration -- will change the landscape surrounding undocumented immigrants.

Included in the two bills are provisions that: make it a third-degree felony to transport, shelter or harbor undocumented immigrants; invalidates non-Florida state ID cards; requires hospitals to collect immigration status of patients; prevents scholarships for DACA recipients; and increases penalties for hiring undocumented workers.

Noting that these policies are explicitly supported by Governor DeSantis, some version of these two bills is almost certain to pass a Legislature that has super-majorities in both chambers. CS/SB 1718 has moved to Rules and HB 1617 to the Commerce Committee.

SB 264 -- Interests of Foreign Countries -- would restrict ownership of land and property by seven "countries of concern," including China, Cuba, Venezuela and Russia. The bills would prohibit anyone living in those countries from acquiring land or buildings in Florida if they're not a U.S. citizen or permanent resident. Foreigners from China, Russia, Iran, North Korea, Cuba, Venezuela and Syria would be prohibited from buying property within 1 mile (amended from 20 miles) of a military installation or critical infrastructure (i.e., a seaport or wastewater treatment plant). Foreigners from China would be prohibited from owning any property statewide, including homes.

This bill passed through committees and the Senate, but awaits further action.
Permitting and Licensing Issues

CS/SB 1604 -- Land Use and Development Regulations -- now has an amendment tacked on to it that attempts to further Tallahassee’s engagement with Disney.
The amendment attempts to "retroactively" require any special district’s newly appointed board to review any development agreements and other agreements within four months of taking office.

A bill emerging from the House, HB 949 -- Operation of a Golf Cart -- would essentially ban young drivers of golf carts by requiring a drivers' license or learners' permit to drive one. The House version of the bill is working its way through committees.

HB 235/SB 350 --  Alternative Mobility Funding Systems -- This bill will affect local governments by specifying criteria that must or may be included in a mobility plan and mobility fee for transportation. A mobility plan identifies multimodal projects necessary to permit redevelopment, infill and development. A mobility fee is a one-time fee paid by the developer.

The bill would prohibit a transportation impact fee or fee that is not a mobility-based fee from being imposed within the area that is within a mobility plan. The bill would require mobility fees to be updated every five years. The bill also dictates the comprehensive requirements a local government must follow in implementing the mobility plan and fee.

The legislature also passed a limit to the increases of impact fees a local government may enact, with one exception / process. This bill would eliminates this exception.
HJR 31 -- Partisan Election of Members of District School Board -- has moved to a 3rd Reading. This bill would place a constitutional amendment on the 2024 ballot allowing voters to decide whether or not school board races should be explicitly partisan.

SJR 1234 and HJR 1157 -- Hunting and Fishing -- would place a constitutional amendment on the 2024 ballot allowing voters to decide whether or not to enshrine a right to hunt and fish in the state constitution. The proposal is advancing in both chambers.
Social Issues

SB 1316 -- Information Dissemination -- also known as the “Blogger Registration” bill, would require bloggers to register with the Office of Legislative Services or the Commission on Ethics if they wrote articles about Legislators or executive branch officials. Since the filing of the bill, Governor DeSantis and Speaker Renner have both publicly stated their objection to the bill. This bill has not moved since March 7, and so appears dead.

A bill to legalize marijuana SB 1576 -- Legalization of Recreational Marijuana -- is likely dead. The bill has not had a Senate hearing nor does it have a House companion bill.

Also Following

CS/SB 7050 -- Elections -- an amendment was filed to the election law rewrite working its way through the legislature that changes the Florida’s Resign to Run law so that it does not apply to “Persons seeking the office of President or Vice President of the United States.”

In addition to this classification, the bill is intended to improve the security of Florida's elections and to make it more difficult for ineligible voters to register to vote.
The bill would increase the fine for knowingly submitting a false voter registration application from $50 to $250 and increase the maximum penalty for impersonating a voter from 60 days in jail to 1 year in jail. The bill would also create new penalties for certain election-related offenses. For example, the bill would make it a felony to knowingly register to vote in more than one election. The bill would also make it a felony to knowingly solicit or collect another person's voter registration information for the purpose of voter fraud.

The bill also changes the procedures for registering voters. Under the current law, voters can register to vote by mail, in person or online. The bill would add a new requirement that voters who register by mail or online must provide a copy of a government-issued photo ID.

The bill requires mandatory, formal, signature-matching training to certain persons, including Supervisors of Elections, canvassing boards and election workers and requires the Department of State to adopt rules that establish standards for formal signature matching in addition to allowing Supervisor of Elections offices to use computer programs to assist in the matching.

The bill also contains several additional smaller administrative changes.

This bill and the House bill -- HB 411 -- have been placed on the Rules Agenda.

HB 991 -- Defamation, False Light and Unauthorized Publication of Name and Likenesses -- The bill remains in the Judiciary Committee. This bill makes it easier to sue media outlets for defamation and, if passed, is likely to be met with court challenges.

This bill directly takes on the US Supreme Court NYT vs Sullivan and lowers the legal threshold for defamation, reducing it from “actual malice” to only proving negligence.
The bill also changes the criteria of who would be exempt, expanding "public official" to include public employees, appointed office holders and influencers (those with a “broad audience” on social media) or those whose fame or notoriety derives from granting media interviews.

CS/SB 1110 --Term Limits -- This bill, limiting County Commissioners and School Board Members to terms of eight years, has moved to Committee Affairs for its First Reading.

SB 1432 -- Communications Services Tax -- a bill that would cut taxes on Florida cellphone, cable and satellite plans remains in Regulated Industries.

HJR 129 -- Requiring Broader Public Support for Constitutional Amendments or Revisions -- This proposed amendment to Florida’s constitution would raise the threshold for constitutional amendments to pass from 60% to 66.67%, except for a repeal of an amendment that would only need to meet the same threshold which was required at the passing. Ironically, it would only need 60% to pass.

HB 5 -- Economic Development -- eliminates Enterprise Florida, Inc., a public-private partnership that promotes Florida as a business destination. The bill transfers the duties and functions of Enterprise Florida to the Department of Commerce. The bill also provides for a transition period and funding for the Department of Commerce. This bill is on today's calendar.

CS/CS/HB 125 -- Utility System Rate Base Values -- This bill has passed both chambers and changes the way the purchase of local water systems is valued, from book value to a higher value and to recover that amount along with investor returns by raising customer water rates. This move makes the privatization of water systems more attractive to investor-owned utilities.  

TELL US WHAT INTERESTS YOU
If you would like us to track a particular issue or bill, just let us know.
Director, Public Policy + Grassroots Engagement