Please plan to attend the Winter Board Town Hall,

Sunday, February 9, following Sunday Worship.

This will be our second discussion in the series of

Town Hall Meetings designed to explore the

options for what to do with the Chelan Property.

Dear BUUF Congregants,


Thank you to everyone who participated in the Fall Board Town Hall held in November. Your BUUF board has listened to your invaluable feedback. As a result, we have streamlined our focus to two final options, #3 and #4, from the original five that were presented.


At our Winter Town Hall, you will hear more information about these two options. along with a presentation about how the proceeds of the sale of all or part of the property would fulfill the requirements of the Endowment and enable us to begin directing these monies towards fulfillment of our mission. 


This announcement contains information about:

  1. Outcomes of the November 3rd Town Hall
  2. Action taken by the Board since

Outcomes of the November 3rd Town Hall


OPTION 1 – Stay the Course, Keep Doing what We're Doing. There was very little if any support for this option. The general consensus appeared to be that we didn’t buy the property to be landlords and although it has been a good investment, the time and energy it takes to manage the property and the coming maintenance expenses make it a poor option.


OPTION 2 – Keep the Land for Future BUUF Use Without Residential Tenants. This option also did not receive much positive response. The main issues appeared to be loss of income, cost of demolition, cost of interim maintenance and capital expense of constructing “something” on the property. There was also concern about a lack of clear vision for what the property might be used for and whether there was an actual need for more land or buildings.


OPTION 3 - Sell the Property. This option had the most favorable reception and received the most votes in the straw poll. The appeal seemed to be the straightforwardness of the idea. That apart from needing to help the tenants relocate*, this option is a relatively easy and clean break with our current obligations. The idea of funding the endowment fund so that it could actually be of benefit appeared to resonate with folks. 


OPTION 4 - Hybrid Option. To subdivide the Chelan lot into two parcels, one to keep, one to sell. This option received mixed responses. Some questioned whether half the property would be attractive to a buyer, while others liked the idea of the potential for different options. While a minister’s residence received a tepid response, other options were not discussed in any length. 


OPTION 5 - Develop the Property for Affordable Housing. In partnership with other community organizations. This option did not seem to receive that much support. People liked the idea of helping provide affordable housing, but they didn’t necessarily like losing the income or value of the land. Some questioned if the money placed in the endowment could have more impact on homelessness if directed in that area. Since a formal neighborhood agreement prohibits widening Chelan, access to any development would need to be through the south parking lot and the playground area. 


Options 3 and 4 emerged as the most desirable paths forward. The Board believes this is due to the potential to unlock financial resources that would benefit our community in numerous ways.


In our ongoing Town Hall series, we will focus on Options 3 and 4, which involve selling the property either in whole or in part. This decision carries significant implications for our community, and it's important to look at how it may impact our future endeavors and financial health. The Town Hall discussion will feature a presentation on the BUUF Endowment Fund and how the proceeds of the sale could open doors to new opportunities for the growth and sustainability of BUUF.

Action taken by the Board since


Following the November Town Hall, the Board took proactive steps to explore innovative ways to utilize the south half of the property, the portion we would retain after the sale of the Chelan-facing portion. Integrating parts of option 5, we could offer the property to a non-profit organization focused on building low- income housing. Board Vice-President Bob Smith, prepared a potential architectural rendering of how the property might be developed for just such a project.  


LEAP Housing, a respected organization in affordable housing development, has expressed interest in this proposal. Despite the challenges posed by zoning restrictions, which currently allow for only three units, LEAP Housing sees potential in this project. However, they would need to secure financing or grants to cover the development costs.


*The Board has sent official notification to the two sets of tenants currently residing on the property, informing them of our intent to sell. Understanding the potential impact of this sale, the Board is committed to offering support and assistance to tenants during this transition. Tenants will be kept up-to-date with any developments and will be given ample notice regarding any changes to their current living arrangements.  

Moving Forward Together


It is essential to navigate these options with careful consideration and collective input. We encourage all community members to participate in discussions and share their perspectives for the benefit of our beloved community. Your insights and feedback are invaluable as we make these pivotal decisions. Together, we can chart a path that paves the way for a vibrant and prosperous future for BUUF.


If you have question or feedback for your BUUF Board concerning this process, you can leave comments here: https://boiseuu.org/chelan-property-discernment/

Click Here for More Info

The final decision will be offered for congregational vote at the Annual Congregational Meeting on May 18, 2025. Your board and staff look forward to your input.

President – Rob Ham

Vice President – Bob Smith

Treasurer – Sue Langley

Secretary – Debra Smith

Past President – Jan Salisbury

Directors – Jonathan Dover, Susie Hardy, Francis Kilkenny, Julia Pope

Boise Unitarian Universalist Fellowship

6200 N Garrett St

Garden City ID 83714

208-658-1710


Lifting Hearts | Broadening Minds | Enacting Justice


Boiseuu.org