April 28, 2020

Dear Rostered Ministers and Leaders,
 
The realities of the COVID-19 pandemic continue to shape our daily life. Some of us are starting to look forward to what worship and congregational life might look like as we are able to physically gather together again. I wanted to write today to provide you with some resources and a framework for thinking and conversation.
 
First, I want to say: Thank you! I am so proud of the ways you are faithfully and creatively living into your call as pastors, deacons and leaders. You are a competent, caring, courageous group of leaders. I know the challenges of this time can feel overwhelming. I know there is a unique kind of vulnerability that often accompanies putting worship on YouTube, Facebook Live and all kinds of formats. I know most of us did not anticipate this is what pastoral ministry would look like in 2020. And yet, here we are. You are leading with grace and courage and faithfulness and curiosity. You have been called for such a time as this. I have no doubt.
 
As we near the end of Governor Walz’s extended stay at home order (due to expire on May 4) some of us are beginning to think about what congregational life might look like as some kinds of physical gatherings can begin to happen again. I want to say a few things and share some great resources with you.
 
At the time of my writing the governor has not yet given further direction on his stay at home order. Nor has Governor Walz yet given specific guidance about what kinds of gatherings, if any, are recommended.
 
I want to emphasize that any decisions you make regarding physical gatherings should be informed by Governor Walz, the MN Department of Health, the CDC and the federal government’s guidance regarding a three-phase reopening. Direct links to the MN Department of Health and CDC remain on the synod website. The federal document, Opening Up America Again can be found here .
 
At this time, it is still my strong recommendation that congregations continue to suspend in person worship gatherings. We have not yet seen the steady decline in cases used as a benchmark in federal guidelines. It is also my recommendation that you begin to think about how you will start to foster congregational life and corporate worship as groups of people are able to gather. It is wise to anticipate that the number of people able to gather will change incrementally and may move up and down for the foreseeable future.
 
Pastors, deacons, church professionals and leadership teams should begin thinking through plans and logistics. As you think through how and when you might gather again, I commend to you the document, Returning to Church from the Wisconsin Council of Churches. In addition, I’ve included an addendum to this letter with some practical guidance offered by three ELCA bishops serving in Texas and Louisiana. For those of you considering outdoor worship services please refer to the MN Department of Health document here dated April 10 and note the safest option is for everyone to stay home.
 
I hope these resources will be useful as you engage in conversations with your colleagues and congregation’s leaders. As you have conversation and make decisions please keep in mind the following:
 
Remember your neighbors. This includes your neighboring congregations and colleagues. Consider how the choices you make impact the faith communities around you. Work toward the good of all. Further, consider the implications for small group gatherings (if 50 people can safely gather in a space what happens when person 51 arrives?) and the needs of those who must be present (building staff, etc.) to make those gatherings a reality.
 
Remember you are one body with many parts and every part has a role to play. As you make decisions, do your best to consider the various needs of the members and participants in the life of your congregation. What works for vulnerable adults might not work well for young children. What meets the needs of some might inhibit others. There is not going to be a one size fits all response. Harness the creativity you’ve shown over the last weeks and continue to think creatively about church. A reopening does not mean a returning to what was.
 
Remember the 8th commandment. Apply it to others and yourself. This is hard and we are learning as we go. There will be fumbles and mistakes. We will act on decisions and realize we could have done something differently. Some people will question us. Some people may feel forgotten. Be quick to ask for forgiveness when necessary. Remain rooted in grace and extend that grace freely (to others and yourself!).
 
Pay attention to the gifts digital worship brings us. Several of you have told me members of your congregation and/or wider community are participating in worship for the first time in years…or ever! Perhaps ministry in your context will continue to rely heavily on digital means. Maybe some kind of hybrid will emerge. We don’t yet know exactly how everything will work. Experimentation will continue.  

Ask for help. Please. Your colleagues, your Bishop, your synod staff - we’re here for you.
 
It’s okay to be different. What works for your congregation might be different than what works for another. Let’s all care for our neighbors and work toward mutual good while we bring our various gifts to the table for the sake of God’s church in the world.
 
Remember who you are . Above all remember who you are: called and claimed by God to love and serve in this time and place. If you have trouble remembering (as we all do from time to time) then give me a call. I promise to remind you, you are indeed a child of God.
 
May the peace of God sustain you in the days ahead.

In Christ, 
Bishop Regina Hassanally


Addendum: Guidance for Congregations based on the three phases of the federal document, Opening Up America Again

This addendum relates the three phases for “Opening Up America Again,” as described in the federal document by the same name directly to congregational life. 

The information in this addendum is courtesy of Bishop Sue Briner of the Southwestern Texas Synod, Bishop Erik Gronberg of the Northern Texas-Northern Louisiana Synod and Bishop Michael Rinehart of the Texas-Louisiana Gulf Coast Synod. It is used with permission.

What are the three phases?
A summary of the three phases is spelled out in this article. The 18-page federal document on reopening in phases can be found HERE .

Before proceeding to these phases, the document says the following gating criteria should be met, in order to mitigate against resurgence and protect the most vulnerable.

  • 14-days of declining symptoms
  • 14-days of declining cases
  • Hospitals able to treat all patients without crisis care
  • Robust testing program in place for at-risk healthcare workers, including emerging antibody testing

When all of the above criteria are true for your region, then elected officials and health experts will begin with phase one. In all phases, good hygiene practices like washing hands and wearing masks in public are strongly recommended. People who feel sick should stay at home, not go to work or to school. Social distancing will be important for the foreseeable future. Here are the phases.

Phase 1 – For states and regions with 14 days of declining cases
  • Schools, daycare and organized youth activities stay closed.
  • Bars stay closed.
  • Large venues like churches, movie theaters, ballparks and arenas may reopen, but observing  strict social distancing protocols.
  • Gyms may reopen, with appropriate social distancing.
  • Elective surgeries may resume.
  • Return to work in phases. Close common areas at work where people gather. Encourage telecommuting.
  • Avoid non-essential travel. (The DOD has suspended travel until the end of June.)
  • Hospitals and senior centers remain closed to visitors.

Once a community has seen 14 days of declining cases, and the hospitals are not overloaded, churches may begin to meet in person, though we will need to practice extreme hygiene and social distancing. The fellowship hall/gathering space should remain closed.

Phase 2 – For states and regions with no evidence of a rebound and who satisfy the gating criteria for a second time
  • All vulnerable populations continue to shelter in place.
  • People need to understand that if they return to work, they could be putting vulnerable residents in their household at risk.
  • All people should continue to maximize physical distance in public.
  • Non-essential travel may resume.
  • Employers should continue to encourage telecommuting and keep common areas closed.
  • Schools, daycare, camps and organized youth activities may resume.
  • Bars may reopen with diminished standing room occupancy.
  • Visits to senior care facilities and hospitals remain prohibited.
  • Large venues (sit-down dining, movie theaters, and churches) can operate with moderate social distancing protocols.

Phase 3 – For states and regions with no evidence of a rebound and who satisfy the gating criteria for a third time
  • Vulnerable individuals can resume public interactions but should prescribe physical distancing.
  • Low risk individuals should minimize time in crowded environments.
  • Worksites may now resume without restrictions.
  • Visits to senior care facilities and hospitals may resume, remaining diligent with hygiene. 
  • Large venues (sit-down dining, movie theaters, and churches) can operate with limited social distancing protocols.
  • Bars may resume operation with increased standing room.


How does this apply to our church?

Here is what the three phases mean for congregations:

Phase 1: Once your region has had 14 days of declining cases, you may begin to resume in-person worship, weddings and funerals with strict social distancing protocols (sitting every-other pew, six feet apart, no hand shake, passing of the peace, etc.). Continue to strongly discourage vulnerable individuals from attending. No visits to hospitals or senior care facilities. No schools, daycare or youth activities. Encourage church staff to work from home as much as possible. Fellowship activities are suspended still. Stay in phone contact with seniors and homebound members of your congregation and community.

Phase 2: Once your region has had 28 days of declining cases without resurgence, you may resume in-person worship, weddings and funerals with moderate social distancing protocols. Strongly discourage vulnerable individuals from attending. No visits to hospitals or senior care facilities. Schools, daycare, camps and organized youth activities may resume. Continue to encourage church staff to work from home when possible. Fellowship hour and activities may resume with maximum social distancing. Stay in phone contact with seniors and homebound members of your congregation and community.

Phase 3: Once your region has had 42 days of declining cases without resurgence, you may resume in-person worship, weddings and funerals with limited social distancing protocols. Strongly discourage vulnerable individuals from attending. Visits to hospitals and senior care facilities may resume with great care. Schools, daycare or youth activities may resume. Church staff may work without restrictions. Fellowship may resume with limited social distancing. Resume homebound communion.