|
California North Coast CCL
invites you to their monthly meeting,
Saturday, November 14 at 9 AM PT here.
We'll discuss what we might expect in light of the midterm results, the current intense permitting reform debate, next week's virtual lobbying efforts, and this month's actions.
CCL endorsed the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026 (BAAJA) shortly after it was introduced in September. Now that everyone has had a chance to read its almost 500 pages...(or have AI produce the Cliff Notes), fierce debate has erupted, as expected, over an issue so important and divisive. And on Monday, November 9, the Senate voted to proceed with that debate.
CCL staff have poured a great deal of thought and effort into studying the legislation and favor early passage before the next Congress resets the agenda, arguing that the current deal is the best we can get.
Our esteemed MoC, Jared Huffman, soon to become the powerful Chair of the House Natural Resources Committee, is vocally skeptical and wants to hold out for a better deal once Dems are in control of both houses.
Many other organizations have weighed in with their own modeling, concerns, support or opposition. For example, both Bill McKibben and Al Gore are a "No," as are numerous environmental justice groups, but some "moderate" house Democrats want to move swiftly ahead.
What is certain is that a great deal is riding on the outcome. Compromise will be necessary, and nobody is going to wind up totally happy, which is usually a good thing in such negotiations.
You can find relevant CCL resources on Community. Here's their detailed training.
If you haven't been following this, here's an AI summary (Claude) of pro's and con's, with links to resources:
BAAJA is the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026 (S. 5653). It’s a big Senate permitting and transmission reform bill introduced September 30, 2026 by Sens. Capito, Heinrich, Lee, and Whitehouse. It needs 60 votes, and the House hasn’t introduced its own version yet.
Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA) of 2026: Summary of All Sections - EveryCRSR (Congressional Research Service) report.com +2
The case for it
-
Faster, more predictable permits. The bill sets one-year deadlines for environmental assessments and two-year deadlines for environmental impact statements. Analysts at Columbia describe it as mainly a speed-and-certainty bill: it changes how quickly infrastructure gets approved, not what gets built. akingumpcolumbia
-
More transmission. It would require utilities and grid operators to plan interregional lines and would let private developers build lines if utilities fall short. It also gives federal siting authority over regionally selected lines when states deny them. gristifp
-
Lower bills and protection from data center costs. It requires new data centers of 20 MW or more to pay the full incremental cost of the infrastructure built for them. Rhodium Group estimates residential bills would fall by $50 to $78 a year by 2040. bipartisanpolicybipartisanpolicy
-
Protection from political interference. Supporters say the federal government could no longer revoke lawfully issued permits or stall whole categories of energy projects. thirdway
-
Grid resilience and domestic minerals. It could expand the transmission capacity regions use to share power during extreme weather and lowers permitting barriers for domestic mining. columbia
The case against it
-
Weaker environmental review. Critics say it greatly expands NEPA categorical exclusions, which removes scrutiny and public comment for excluded projects, and requires courts to give “substantial deference” to agency NEPA findings. therevelator
-
Less judicial oversight. It sets a 150-day statute of limitations and requires most plaintiffs to have taken part in the administrative process. It also limits courts’ ability to vacate permits while problems are being fixed. akingumpakingump
-
Benefits to fossil fuels. The Union of Concerned Scientists argues the bill is tilted toward fossil fuels and would harm communities and the environment. For interstate gas pipelines, the maximum review period drops to nine months. ucsakingump
-
Endangered species and water protections. Wildlife advocates warn it would shift authority to states, limit scientific review, and exempt some projects from key consultations. Other changes include treating a state’s failure to act in time as a waiver of its Clean Water Act certification right. commondreamsifp
-
Effects on Tribes. The Native American Rights Fund says the bill significantly limits Tribal Nations’ ability to participate in permitting decisions affecting their land, water, and cultural interests. narf
-
Mining waste. It would let mines on public lands dump waste rock on adjacent land. grist
Points both sides acknowledge
Even supporters say it isn’t climate legislation, though it could lower emissions by enabling more clean energy and transmission. Even critics credit it with restoring some Council on Environmental Quality authority that courts had curtailed. Major groups such as NRDC and the Sierra Club still haven’t endorsed it, and the sponsors are considering technical changes through a managers’ amendment.
Sources:
Then, at 10 AM PT, join National's monthly meeting here.
Hear from someone who's been in the trenches of crafting energy policy,
including the permitting bill now being debated.
|