|
Financial Impact: How HB 31 Would Shift Costs and Risk
If enacted, HB 31 would create incentives that favor current budgets over the long-term protection of future municipal police officers and would place upward cost pressure on those municipalities that remain in the system.
MPERS carries municipalities’ unfunded liabilities from prior years, when employer contribution rates were calculated using assumptions that proved too optimistic. Employers currently contribute 33.475% of payroll. Only about 9–10% of it pays for benefits being earned today. The remainder pays down municipalities' (including towns and villages) old pension debt through level annual payments, similar to a fixed mortgage.
If key assumptions are met—including continued participation—the scheduled payoff of that debt will cause the employer contribution rate to decline sharply in about eight years. In fact, subject to final approval, the employer contribution rate will decrease from 33.475% for fiscal year 2026 to 29.35% for fiscal year 2027—a reduction of over 4 percentage points. This marks the second decrease of at least 4 percentage points in six years.
In 2014, municipalities' unfunded liabilities were bundled into a 20-year amortization schedule. Municipalities will fully pay off this debt on June 30, 2034—more than halfway through the scheduled payoff. This 2014 debt represents approximately 75% of the system's total unfunded liability. Most of the current employer contribution rate pays down this debt, so its payoff in about eight years should trigger a very substantial rate reduction for all employers. If towns and villages opt out under HB 31, the resulting payroll loss and UAL reallocation would increase rates for remaining employers during the years leading up to that relief.
The employer contribution rate is not extra money that could be reused. Part pays for benefits being earned in the present; most is already committed to municipalities' past unfunded obligations. HB 31 would allow towns and villages to stop enrolling new officers before their share of that old debt is fully paid, while leaving the remaining employers responsible for completing the payments.
HB 31 would not require opting-out towns and villages to replace MPERS retirement, disability, or survivor benefits for future hires. As a result, future officers hired by those towns and villages—and their families if tragedy occurs—would bear the full cost of replacing those protections, without employer-provided lifetime protection.
Replacing MPERS-level protection on an individual basis—without pooling and without employer contributions—would typically require over 45% of a police officer's pay, if such coverage were even available. For most officers, that would not be realistic. The practical result would likely be less protection, not cheaper protection.
As towns and villages opt out, MPERS payrolls would shrink—but their approximately $53 million share of unfunded liability, as currently allocated, would not disappear. It would be reallocated to the employers that remain. Cities and other municipalities that stay in MPERS could be left paying both their own legacy costs and the costs shifted from those that leave. The bill does not specify whether towns and villages that opt out would be required to pay their share of unfunded accrued liability under existing law. By default, it would shift to the remaining municipalities. No council or board vote by the remaining municipalities would be required; the shift would occur automatically under the law.
Internal illustrative estimates (very rough estimates, not actuarial projections) show the potential impact on major cities if all 129 towns and villages opt out:
- New Orleans: Currently $146M; could absorb about another $12M
- Baton Rouge: Currently $88M; could absorb about another $7M
- Shreveport: Currently $60M; could absorb about another $5M
- Lafayette: Currently $38M; could absorb about another $3M
- Bossier City: Currently $20M; could absorb about another $2M
- Monroe: Currently $16M; could absorb about another $1.3M
- West Monroe: Currently $6.8M; could absorb about another $537K
HB 31 would not eliminate pension costs.
It would change who pays them, by operation of law.
|