Barry M. Wayne
Coral Gables
Marco T. Paredes, Jr.
Director of Government Affairs, Tallahassee
Special thanks to Christopher Perrigan who assisted in the drafting of this alert. Christopher is a second year Juris Doctor Candidate at Florida State University College of Law.
|
|
|
Has Permanent Alimony Met its Demise
in Florida? Stay Tuned...
|
While the world of marital law invokes all kinds of reactions from those who find themselves engaged in the process, no concept causes a stir quite like "permanent alimony." To those who are recipient candidates, it may mean the cavalry is on its way, creating a sense that their financial future includes long-term stability. To those exposed to pay, dread.
Permanent alimony, while not always "permanent," is designed to provide for the necessities of life as established during marriage for a party lacking financial ability to meet such needs on their own. Although permanent alimony is most often applied to long-term marriages (currently defined as 17 years or more), it can be applicable in shorter marriages as well. While modifiable under certain circumstances, permanent alimony could result in long-term support payments, that is until death of either party, or the recipient's remarriage, whichever occurs first. Prior attempts to reform Florida's alimony laws through the legislative process have failed. This year could be different.
At present, Florida recognizes multiple forms of alimony: temporary, bridge-the-gap, rehabilitative, durational, and permanent. The Court's discretion in determining the form of alimony awarded is "broad." Currently, the Florida Legislature is once again considering bills to limit discretion via alimony reform through House Bill 1559 (HB 1559) and its companion, Senate Bill 1922 (SB 1922). HB 1559 prohibits permanent alimony absent an express agreement between the parties (we can refer to that as the "fat chance provision") and, similarly, SB 1922 eliminates permanent alimony.
This would effectively end the prospect of permanent alimony by court determination. That would be a big change. The effective demise of permanent alimony raises the question, if not permanent, then under the proposed legislation, what "duration" replaces permanent? The current answer likely lies within the surviving alimony categories.
While other forms of alimony survive, these bills would impose new limitations. For example, rehabilitative and durational alimony would be subject to new rules. Rehabilitative alimony is intended to provide support during a defined time period, and in accordance with a specific "rehabilitative plan" designed to enable a spouse to obtain or reestablish their ability to provide for their own support. Under current law, the rehabilitative term does not have a firm "cap" on duration. If passed, the bills would impose a five-year limitation on rehabilitative alimony, but the rehabilitative time period could be shorter if it exceeds the term limitations of durational alimony. Durational alimony under these bills shall not exceed one-half the length of the marriage. Thus, in a marriage of eight years, the maximum alimony term would be four years.
These bills are lengthy and, in certain respects, complex. While the elimination of permanent alimony has received a majority of the attention, it is the bills' provisions related to children that have become most controversial. Both bills include a child time-sharing (formally referred to as "visitation") presumption. Specifically, these bills would create the presumption that equal time-sharing (50% to each parent) is in the best interests of minor children. Injecting this child-related presumption has caused hesitation among some legislators in their support of these bills during the committee process.
While HB 1559 has been reported favorably out of its referenced committees and is currently on the House floor awaiting final action, SB 1922 is in its last committee stop, Senate Rules. The Family Law Section of the Florida Bar, for its part, opposes HB 1559, stating, "The legislation, which would institute an automatic 50/50 presumption of timesharing and dramatically alter the current system of alimony in the state, would negatively impact Florida families, especially children." Family Law Section of the Florida Bar Press Release, April 6, 2021.
The 2021 Legislative Session adjourns on April 30th. Should either of these bills survive and pass the House and Senate, they would next have to await the action of Governor Ron DeSantis, who has 15 days from the date of presentation to sign the bill into law. Similar legislation has been passed twice in recent years, but were ultimately vetoed by then Governor Rick Scott.
Permanent alimony (and alimony in general) has weathered legislative reform in the past. This is not a done deal. Stearns Weaver Miller's Marital & Family Law group and Government Affairs team is keeping a close eye on this proposed legislation. For more information, please contact us.
|
|
|