July 9, 2024

How To Help Young Women Rescue Their Self-Esteem

 

Anna is 18 and graduated from a top-rated public high school with nearly perfect grades. Although attending a great college, she is still ‘haunted’ by not being accepted into her top choice of schools. She is athletic and attractive and has friends who share similar traits. “I think I know the rules to succeed, but I never feel like I’ve done enough or can be OK in the world.”


She constantly compares herself to others she perceives as “doing things better or are prettier. I know it's shallow, but I can't help it” and wonders when she will feel okay. She had been using alcohol to quiet her anxiety and self-doubt until recently when in counseling, she realized how self-critical she has been since late middle school.

 

“I feel like I have been on a treadmill, racing forward, and it’s too risky to slow down or get off,” she said recently “I’m mean to my Mom, and I feel bad, but I see her giving up so much to please me and my Dad and I also do the same things. Help!”

We live in a time where mental health is beginning to be valued and understood to be central to overall functioning in life. At the same time, data is accumulating that our young women are struggling with self-concept and self-esteem at an unprecedented rate and experiencing suicidal ideation and attempts unseen in the history of research on the topic.


Why are teen girls and young women specifically at risk? The roots are complex, but they can be summarized in the simple idea that girls understand that they face many double standards. They are forced to accept 'role strain' in modeling their future goals, knowing extreme demands on them seem to be part of our current social norms. Some are very worried about access to healthcare and privacy about their healthcare. Some feel they have no power to make changes in their lives. They believe they must be smart, hard-working, get perfect grades, be thin, beautiful, and not too threatening to others. Wow, that sounds impossible, doesn't it?


As a society, we must move to help young women understand that their issues are not self-inflicted and, therefore, cannot be fixed by working harder, being thinner, pleasing others more, or any other self-derived solution. In the collective that is our current culture, young women have also observed their mothers and other female role models struggling with the ‘role strain’ of caring for children and elders and performing the majority of housework even when working outside the home and sometimes even when out earning partners in the workforce.

 

They see these encoded double standards as unescapable norms, and they may feel upset, angry, and pushed back at times. However, they are most likely as adolescents to try to model their solutions from peers and female role models in their lives. They try and fix themselves rather than see the problems as systemic. I would say that their mothers see it similarly as well. “Why am I so tired? Why can’t I manage my to-do list?” I hear women of a certain age say, "We are accidentally modeling acceptance of unreasonable norms to the next generation." Awareness is the first step to hopefully changing that.

How can we make even a small dent in adolescent girls and young women’s self-image and esteem?


I am reading, researching, and writing more on this now, as it is a complex task (that clinicians and researchers are intent on understanding); however, a few steps seem like a very promising start.


First, as adults, we as women, men, both parents and teachers, mentors, and Uncles and Aunties can deeply seek out how the young women in our lives are feeling right now. We can validate their sadness and pain and help them see that others hear them and want to be there. We can be honest that our culture is changing, and that change can be scary and make us all feel wobbly, and that is OK. If we are old enough to remember past times when it looked like hopelessness was the norm, shifts occurred, and decent humans ensured that people were fed and cared for and that the right ideals and principles prevailed, we need to share these examples. We need them to hear from US that they are not the problem. Even if they have significant personal obstacles that need to be addressed, they are not the source of all the pain they feel. We can assure them that we are here to help them start to see themselves the way that we do, as competent and intelligent and able to have agency, even as culture insists on a vice grip of oppression on their healthcare and other rights.


We can help men see that they are also hurt by many cultural messages and may, in turn, be part of holding their female loved ones down. I believe most men are not aware at all of the pain that young women feel and would never want to contribute to that pain. Culture can hurt us all.

 

A concrete action that Mothers, Aunties, and assorted female carers can suggest is even a short-term, mutual “detox” from social media with the young women in their lives. At Insight Counseling, we have suggested three to four-day “detoxes” for teens with friends and their Moms and caregivers. Universally, young women see the change in how they feel after just a short time of freedom from constant comparisons with false ideals and, often, false friends.

 

We can model "downtime" time spent in free play activities free of technology by participating in them. Ideas? Hiking, exploring new areas, museums, music types, volunteering, participating in arts and cultural events, and anything young women express interest in! The hard part is generally enforcing regular "screen-free" time for our children in our homes and lives.


Anna recently accepted a four-day phone and social media detox and shared this: " I realized so much of my stress was not there when I was not checking 'likes' and waiting for friends to answer, and comparing herself. "When I got back on (social media), I could feel my anxiety rise right away." She's still figuring out the role of social media and others' expectations of her; however, sharing with her Mom that some daily limit on her screen use is helpful and asks her Mom to enforce this: "Even if I act like a brat when you do it."


I will keep sharing new ideas about what we can all do to help our girls, and I would love to hear your ideas!


Fondly,

Liz

Insight Counseling is accepting new clients.

Please call us at (203) 431-9726 or email us.

CE WEBINAR

How to Help Young Women Rescue Their Self-Esteem

With Liz Jorgensen, CADC​​

Wednesday, July 17th

9:00 am PT/12:00 pm ET

Duration: 1 hour


​​Social media and cultural messages influence young women's self-concept and feelings of autonomy and well-being. In this webinar, we'll explore how these factors influence the rise in anxiety and depression among teen girls and young adult women and look at strategies to help them build resilience and self-esteem.


After attending this webinar, participants will be able to:

  • Discuss and explain current data regarding the impact of culture, the pandemic, and social media on teen girls and young women's self-concept and self-esteem
  • Analyze and compare best practices for helping young women understand the locus of control and external influences on their self-image
  • Learn three interventions to use in working with young women to build self-awareness and resilience and take actionable steps to increase self-esteem


Learn more here or register below! CE credit(s) available.

REGISTER FOR WEBINAR