|
A study published in the International Journal of Child Care and Education Policy examined long-term impacts of pre-K in New Mexico. Researchers accessed archival student data for those who had participated in the state’s pre-K program (NMPK) to assess whether participation in the program improved outcomes on state exams in both ELA and math, and to evaluate whether NMPK participation increased the odds of high school graduation. They used propensity score matching, a statistical technique enabling a quasi-experimental design by constructing an artificial “control” group and treatment group. Researchers created matched sets of control and treatment subjects — who are as close to similar as possible on indicators available — and compared them with respect to exam scores and high school graduation.
The researchers found that NMPK participants significantly outperformed their matched nonparticipants in both ELA and math in third, sixth and eighth grade, but not 11th grade — suggesting potential fadeout effects. Additionally, there were significant associations between NMPK participation and the probability of high school graduation. The study authors note that researchers and policymakers should use caution in generalizing results from studies such as this, and that “The study of the effects of quality, program design and other program inputs in future studies is essential for understanding why some programs like NMPK see significant long-term gains, whereas other programs, such as Tennessee’s Prekindergarten program, do not.”
|