Centre for Civil and Political Rights
ICCPR Implementation: Latest Overview of the Follow-Up Procedure

Argentina - Austria - Burkina Faso - Denmark - Ecuador - Kuwait - Namibia - South Africa - Sweden - Turkmenistan

Adopted during the  125th and 126th  session (March and July 2019 )


This newsletter presents the latest assessments adopted by the Human Rights Committee (HR Committee) on follow-up to Concluding Observations.
 
The measures taken by 10 countries were assessed and graded during the 125th and 126th session (March and July 2019). The links to the reports are available below.  

Overall, the Human Rights Committee observed some progress in the 10 reviewed States. None of them received a D-grade, meaning that all of them submitted a follow-up report to the Committee. 4 out of 10 States received an A-grade, meaning that the recommendation was implemented. However, two States also took measures going against the recommendations of the HR Committee, leading to E-grades. 

In Argentina  , some progress was observed with regards to detention conditions and in assuring reparations to victims of torture. Argentina also fully complied with one recommendation concerning the case of a woman criminalized for abortion against international standards. No compliance was found on matters of sexual and reproductive rights and the investigation into cases of torture.
In Austria , progress was observed regarding racial profiling by police and torture and ill-treatment. Recommendations on detention pending deportation, were not implemented. 
Burkina Faso 's recommendations primarily focused on women and children. Progress was observed in the area of female genital mutilation, but work remains to be done on the abolition of polygamy, the minimum age for marriage and the exploitation of children. 
Denmark fully implemented the recommendations on domestic violence, but several other issues still have to be tackled: the use of solitary confinement and recommendations related to asylum seekers and refugees. 
Ecuador  advanced in complying with all of the recommendations issued by the Committee. Yet, further information was required on the investigation of human rights violations identified by the Truth Commission, on excessive use of force against peaceful assemblies and on complaints of use of force within detention facilities.
From these ten countries, Kuwait has the worst track record: a refusal to implement the recommendations on citizenship of Bidoon people and little progress on the implementation of the recommendations regarding the freedom of assembly and association.
The Committee observed some progress in Namibia , where a draft law criminalising torture was being discussed. Some issues remained unaddressed, including discrimination of several vulnerable groups.  
South Africa partially implemented all key recommendations but one, on the eradication of racism and xenophobia. Other recommendations were about the Truth and Reconciliation Commission and detention conditions, all of which were partially implemented. 
Sweden fully implemented the recommendations related to racism and xenophobia, but took no measures to implement those on the detention of asylum seekers and migrants. Some progress was achieved regarding their guarantees and safeguards. 
Lastly, the main sources of concern in Turkmenistan were related to detention: secret detention, torture and ill-treatment, detention conditions and enforced disappearances. Virtually no progress was made.  
 
For a comprehensive overview of the current follow-up status of countries recently reviewed by the Committee, see here.

In This Issue
Assessment of State replies according to the HR Committee
Reply/Action Satisfactory
A
Reply/Action largely Satisfactory
 
Reply/Action Partially Satisfactory
B
Additional information or action remains necessary
 
Reply/ Action not satisfactory
C
Actions/informations inexistant or irrelevant 
 
No Cooperation with the Committee
D
No follow-up received after reminder(s)
 
The Measures Taken go Against the Recommendations
E
The actions of the State go against the recommendation(s)
 
 

Admissible Assessments
Argentina 
 
The Committee noted that there was a lack of information on the measures taken to revise the  abortion legislation and to remove obstacles that led women to seek clandestine abortions. It further requested information on trainings held on the use of contraceptives and sexual and reproductive health (C). On the other hand, Argentina released Belén, a woman arbitrarily criminalized for abortion, complying with the Committee's recommendation on her case (A).

The Committee required more information on the measures adopted by Argentina to  investigate cases of torture. It required information on assuring that complaints on torture or ill-treatment were quickly, completely and independently investigated and prosecuted; on the implementation of a unified registry of torture cases; and on the measures adopted to guarantee that the National Mechanism of Prevention is established in all of Argentina's regions (C). 

The Committee recognized the creation of the Coordination Unit for Attention and Assistance to Victims of Torture, as well as the permanent training given to the Legal Medicine Division. However, it requested more information on the measures adopted to guarantee full reparation to the victims, as well as on the other trainings adopted in compliance with the Committee's recommendations (B).

Finally, some progress was observed on detention conditions. The Committee noted that Argentina provided information on measures taken to reduce prison overcrowding, broadening infrastructure, and the use of electronic monitoring equipment as a substitute for detention. However, information was required on the increase of the detainee population, and on the specific conditions of the maximum security facilities in Rawson, Chaco and Neuquén (B). 

Reviewed by the Human Rights Committee in August 2016
State replied on implementation measures: July 2017
Assessment of the State reply by the Human Rights Committee: August 2019
Recommendations
Grade
12.1 El Estado parte debe revisar su legislación sobre el aborto, incluyendo su legislación criminal, en particular mediante la introducción de excepciones adicionales a la prohibición del aborto, inclusive cuando el embarazo es producto de una violación sexual, sin importar la capacidad intelectual o psicosocial de la mujer. El Estado parte debe, asimismo, asegurar que todas las mujeres y niñas puedan acceder a los servicios de salud reproductiva en todas las regiones del país y que las barreras legales, el ejercicio de objeción de conciencia por parte de los trabajadores de la salud y la falta de protocolos médicos no obliguen a las mujeres a recurrir al aborto clandestino que pone su vida y su salud en riesgo [...] Asimismo, el Estado parte debe multiplicar y asegurar la aplicación de programas de educación y sensibilización a nivel formal (escuelas y colegios públicos y privados) e informal (medios de comunicación y otros) sobre la importancia del uso de anticonceptivos y los derechos a la salud sexual y reproductiva.
C
12.2. El Estado debe revisar el "caso de Belén", a la luz de los estándares internacionales en la materia, con miras a su inmediata liberación, y a la luz de este caso, considerar la descriminalización del aborto
A
14.1. Velar por que todas las denuncias de tortura o malos tratos sean investigadas de manera rápida, completa e independiente y que los responsables de esos actos comparezcan ante la justicia; 
C
14.2. Asegurar que las víctimas reciban una reparación adecuada que incluya servicios de salud y de rehabilitación
B
14.3.  Asegurar que los exámenes forenses de los presuntos casos de tortura y malos tratos cometidos por agentes del Estado sean imparciales y exhaustivos, y se lleven a cabo de acuerdo con el Protocolo de Estambul;
B
14.4. Implementar un sistema unificado de registros de hechos y víctimas de tortura, con el fin de establecer políticas específicas para a la prevención de la tortura y los tratos crueles, inhumanos o degradantes, incluso con la implementación de programas sistemáticos de formación en derechos humanos a las fuerzas del orden y de seguridad
C
14.5. Agilizar la adopción de las medidas jurídicas necesarias para asegurar que el mecanismo nacional de prevención sea establecido en todas las regiones del país, según lo previsto en el Protocolo Facultativo de la Convención contra la Tortura y Otros Tratos o Penas Crueles, Inhumanos o Degradantes, y velar por que dicho mecanismo disponga de r ecursos humanos y financieros suficientes para funcionar eficientemente
C
24.  El Estado parte debe adoptar medidas eficaces para mejorar las condiciones materiales de los centros penitenciarios, reducir el hacinamiento existente y responder debidamente a las necesidades fundamentales de todas las personas privadas de libertad, en particular el acceso a la salud, de conformidad con lo dispuesto en el Pacto y en las Reglas Mínimas de las Naciones Unidas para el Tratamiento de los Reclusos (Reglas Nelson Mandela). El Estado parte también debe considerar una aplicación más amplia de las penas sustitutivas de la prisión, como la vigilancia por medios electrónicos, la libertad condicional y los servicios a la comunidad.
B
 
The follow-up report is available here (ES).

The HR Committee regretted the lack of specific information on the measures taken to prohibit  racial profiling by the police , to provide racial sensitivity training and to hold law enforcement personnel accountable for offenses against persons belonging to ethnic minorities (B). The Committee also reiterated its recommendations regarding the competence of the  Austrian Ombudsman Board (B).

Austria also received a B-grade for the recommendations regarding torture and ill-treatment. In particular, the State should provide information on the measures taken to ensure prompt, thorough and impartial investigations into allegations of torture and ill-treatment. The Committee asked the State to address the discrepancy between reported allegations and the number of ensuing criminal convictions, and to provide statistics and make them public. 

Lastly, the recommendations regarding detention pending deportation, were not implemented. More information was required on the length of detention and the detention policy of children above the age of 14 (C).    
 
Reviewed by the Human Rights Committee in November 2015
State replied on implementation measures: December 2016
Assessment of the State reply by the Human Rights Committee: March 2019
Recommendations
Grade
20.1. E nsure that the legislation clearly prohibits racial profiling by the police and prevent investigation, arbitrary detention, searches and interrogation on the basis of physical appearance, colour or ethnic or national origin. Continue to provide all law enforcement personnel with racial sensitivity training in order to curb racial profiling and police misbehaviour towards ethnic minorities. Law enforcement personnel who commit offences against persons belonging to ethnic minorities should be held accountable. 
B
20.2. The Austrian Ombudsman Board should take steps to raise awareness about its new competence to receive complaints and make use of its ex officio powers to open investigations into allegations of racial discrimination and racially motivated misconduct by the police. 
B
22. Undertake an independent investigation into the reasons underlying the discrepancy between the low number of criminal convictions for ill-treatment in police custody and the relatively high number of allegations. Ensure prompt, thorough and impartial investigations and documentation, in accordance with the Manual on the Effective Investigation and Documentation of Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (Istanbul Protocol), into all allegations of torture and ill-treatment. Perpetrators prosecuted and convicted should be subjected to sanctions commensurate with the gravity of their acts, and victims provided with effective remedies. Collect and make public information on the number and nature of reported incidents of torture and ill-treatment of detainees, disaggregated by age, gender and ethnic origin of victims, and on the convictions and types of sentences or sanctions imposed on perpetrators of such acts. 
B
30. Ensure that  detention pending deportation  is applied only after due consideration of less invasive means, with special regard being given to the needs of particularly vulnerable persons, and that individuals detained for immigration-related reasons are held in facilities specifically designed for that purpose. Review the  detention policy with regard to children  over the age of 14 years to ensure that children are not deprived of their liberty except as a measure of last resort and for the shortest appropriate period of time. 
C
 
The follow-up report is available here. 

No measures have been taken to guarantee the same  minimum age for marriage for both men and women, and on the steps taken to abolish  polygamy . The Committee asked for more information regarding the review of the Personal and Family Code, including a timeline and whether traditional and religious marriages are covered by this review (3xC). 

Regarding  female genital mutilation and other traditional harmful practices, the Committee noted that new strategies were adopted to raise awareness and to eradicate these practices. More information was asked about the participation of traditional and religious leaders, and the effectivity of the strategies, including statistics (B). 

Another area in which some progress was made, was regarding the increased number of  security officers and capacity-building. More information was required about the steps taken to prevent  vigilante groups to engage in law-enforcement acts, and the results of the national forum on security and community policing (B). Legal proceedings have been brought against perpetrators of ill-treatment, but more details are asked about the sentences imposed on them (B). The State is organizing awareness campaigns about human rights violations, but the Committee asked more details about these campaigns (B). 

Lastly, the recommendation on awareness-raising of  economic and social exploitation of children , was implemented fully (A). However, work remains to be done: the Committee asked more information about the number of cases of child trafficking and exploitation that were reported, investigated and prosecuted, and about the outcomes of the work of the monitoring committees (B). Two recommendations were not implemented at all: to amend the legislation on sex offenses involving children, and to collect disaggregated data on this issue (C).     
 
Reviewed by the Human Rights Committee in July 2016
State replied on implementation measures: July 2017
Assessment of the State reply by the Human Rights Committee: August 2019
Recommendations
Grade
16.1.  Amend the Personal and Family Code so as to guarantee that the same minimum age for marriage applies to men and women and to all marriages, including traditional or religious marriages, and take steps to reduce polygamy with a view to its abolition.
C
16.2. Extend the ban on forced marriages to cover traditional or religious marriages.
C
16.3. Ensure that traditional or religious marriages are officially registered and that the age and consent of the spouses are systematically verified.
C
16.4.  Raise awareness and devise new strategies to eradicate the practice of female genital mutilation.
B
16.5.  Educate and sensitize the public, including traditional and religious leaders, to the need to combat traditional practices that are harmful to women, and ensure the effective application of the legal provisions that guarantee equality in matters of inheritance and access to land.
B
24.1.  Reinforce the presence of national security and defence forces so as to guarantee the security of the population throughout the country and prevent the vigilante groups, including the "Koglweogo", from taking the place of the State and performing law-enforcement tasks.
B
24.2. Conduct investigations, prosecute all alleged perpetrators of human rights violations and, if they are found guilty, sentence them appropriately. 
B
24.3. Organize awareness campaigns on the illegality of summary and mob justice and the criminal responsibility of perpetrators.
B
36.1. Continue efforts to make the general public and those who work in the criminal justice system aware of the problem of trafficking and the risks of economic and sexual exploitation.
A
36.2. Strictly enforce laws and regulations related to child trafficking, child labour and the exploitation of children, with a view to eliminating these practices and strengthening monitoring mechanisms.
B
36.3. Amend Act No. 011-2014/AN so as to ensure that the penalties handed down for sex offences involving children are commensurate with the seriousness of such offences.
C
36.4. Collect disaggregated data on the extent of trafficking for purposes of the sexual and economic exploitation, forced labour and exploitation of children.
C

The follow-up report is available here.
Denmark 
mauritania
The Committee welcomed the legislative and policy measures taken to prevent  and combat domestic violence (A). 

However, the Committee regretted that Denmark neither abolished  solitary confinement for minors, nor reduced the total length of permissible solitary confinement (C). 

Lastly, the Committee graded the implementation of the recommendations regarding  asylum seekers and refugees . Some progress was achieved regarding the respect for the principle of non-refoulement, but the Committee asked more information regarding the legal and procedural standards in place to identify torture victims and the restrictions on so-called "tolerated stay". Only limited information was provided on alternatives to detention (B). 

The maximum period of detention for migrants and asylum seekers awaiting deportation, remained unchanged. The Committee asked whether Denmark is planning to reduce the length of detention, and notes that the detention conditions have improved (B). 

Moreover, the Committee asked how many aliens availed themselves of the right to request judicial review of their detention, since the recommendation to repeal the concerning provision of the Aliens Act, has not been implemented (C). 

The amendment to the Aliens Act relating to the confiscation of asylum seekers' assets, was also not repealed (E). 
 
Reviewed by the Human Rights Committee in July 2016
State replied on implementation measures: July 2017
Assessment of the State reply by the Human Rights Committee: March 2019
Recommendations
Grade
20. Continue efforts to combat domestic violence effectively, in particular violence against women, by ensuring effective reporting on acts of domestic violence, investigations, prosecutions and sanctions of perpetrators. Ensure that guidelines on the application of its legislation are enforced by all police districts in a uniform manner. Continue to provide training to all professionals involved in preventing and combating domestic violence.
A
24. Bring the legislation and practice on solitary confinement into line with international standards as reflected in the United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners (the Nelson Mandela Rules), by abolishing solitary confinement of minors and reducing the total length of permissible solitary confinement. Regularly evaluate the effects of solitary confinement in order to continue to reduce it and to develop alternative measures where necessary.
C
32.1. Ensure that policies and practices related to the return and expulsion of migrants and asylum seekers afford sufficient guarantees of respect for the principle of non-refoulement.
B
32.2.  Ensure that the detention of migrants and asylum seekers is reasonable, necessary and proportionate in the light of the circumstances, and that alternatives to detention are found in practice.
B
32.3. Consider reducing the length of detention for migrants and asylum seekers who are awaiting deportation and improve the detention conditions of such persons, in particular at the detention facility of Vridsløselille.
B
32.4.  Repeal the amendment introduced to the Aliens Act in November 2015 in order to ensure that, in all cases, detained migrants have full access to fundamental legal safeguards, in particular to judicial review of the legality of their detention.
C
32.5.  Repeal the amendment to the Aliens Act relating to the confiscation of asylum seekers' assets.
 E

The follow-up report is available here. 
Ecuador 
mauritania
Ecuador partially implemented all the recommendations it received.  The Committee required information on measures adopted to foster investigations of cases of human rights violations identified within the  Truth Commission , on how the cases that will be prosecuted will be selected, on  trainings given by the Prosecutor's Office to victims, and on progress made on assuring victims access to  full reparation (B).

The Committee also requested information on detention conditions and violence in prisons, in particular prison overpopulation,  trainings to prison personnel, the new "Penitentiary Administration Model", and investigations into complaints of violence within detention facilities (B).

Concerning freedom of speech and freedom of association, the Committee regretted that the State did not provide sufficient information on the measures adopted since the adoption of its recommendations, particularly on investigations of complaints concerning excessive use of force; trainings made to prevent and eliminate all forms of excessive use of force by law enforcement agents; and on the compatibility of Decrees No. 17 and 739 with the Covenant. 

Reviewed by the Human Rights Committee in August 2016
State replied on implementation measures: August 2017
Assessment of the State reply by the Human Rights Committee: August 2019
Recommendations
Grade
20. El Estado parte debe adoptar todas las medidas necesarias para agilizar las investigaciones judiciales relativas a los casos de violaciones de derechos humanos detallados en el informe de la Comisión de la Verdad y garantizar que los presuntos responsables sean juzgados y, de ser declarados culpables, sancionados de conformidad con la gravedad de sus actos. El Estado parte debe también incrementar sus esfuerzos con miras a garantizar que las víctimas y sus familiares tengan pronto acceso a una reparación integral, tomando todas las medidas necesarias, incluida la indemnización.
B
24. Tomando en cuenta las anteriores observaciones finales (CCPR/C/ECU/CO/5, párr. 17), el Estado parte debe incrementar sus esfuerzos con miras a continuar mejorando las condiciones de detención y a eliminar el hacinamiento, en particular asegurando la aplicación efectiva de las normas relativas a medidas alternativas de privación de la libertad. Asimismo, le recomienda que redoble sus esfuerzos para prevenir y poner fin a la violencia en los lugares de privación de libertad y que continúe asegurando que todos los incidentes de violencia entre reclusos, en particular los casos en los que haya habido muertes, sean investigados y los responsables sancionados de conformidad con la gravedad de sus actos.
B
28. El Estado parte debe adoptar medidas apropiadas para garantizar que todas las personas bajo su jurisdicción puedan ejercer en la práctica su derecho a la libertad de reunión pacífica; redoblar sus esfuerzos con miras a prevenir y eliminar efectivamente todas las formas de uso excesivo de la fuerza por miembros de las fuerzas del orden y de seguridad; y adoptar las medidas necesarias para asegurar que todas las alegaciones de uso excesivo de la fuerza sean investigadas de manera pronta, exhaustiva, independiente e imparcial y que los presuntos autores sean llevados ante la justicia y, de ser declarados culpables, sancionados de conformidad con la gravedad de sus actos.

B

The follow-up report is available here (ES).
Kuwait 

The Committee regretted that Kuwait continued to deny the existence of  stateless Bidoon individuals , and treated all of them as illegal residents. No information was provided to the Committee regarding measures taken to progress (E). Also no information was provided regarding the steps taken to guarantee the  right of every child to acquire a nationality (C). Some progress was made on services provided to registered illegal residents, but more information was required regarding the non-discriminatory access to 
social services (B). The Committee also asked more information in relation to whether passports can be used for travelling purposes and about the prohibition of  non-Kuwaitis to participate in public gatherings , and how it is compatible with the freedom of assembly in the Covenant (C). Two more E-grades were adopted: because Kuwait did not abandon its plans to offer Bidoon people "economic citizenship" of another country, and because it refuses to accede to the Convention on Stateless Persons. 

No progress was achieved regarding the restrictions on the freedom of assembly: non-Kuwaitis are still not allowed to participate in public gatherings, and prior authorization of the Ministry of the Interior is required for any assembly. The Committee asked more information on the rules governing assemblies, and the procedures to prevent excessive use of force (C).  Some progress was made on the training of security forces regarding the use of force, but the Committee asked for more details: duration, periodicity, number of persons attending, and whether it is mandatory (B). 

Lastly, no measures have been taken to implement the recommendations of the Committee on the freedom of association (C). A new draft law concerning public welfare associations was adopted, but the Committee asked more information about its content and compatibility with the Covenant (B). 
 
Reviewed by the Human Rights Committee in July 2016
State replied on implementation measures: April 2017
Assessment of the State reply by the Human Rights Committee: March 2019
Recommendations
Grade
11.1. Speed up the process of granting Kuwaiti citizenship to Bidoon people, where appropriate.
E
11.2. Guarantee the right of every child to acquire a nationality.
C
11.3. Register and provide non-discriminatory access to social services to all Bidoon people residing in Kuwait. 
B
11.4. Ensure that Bidoon individuals enjoy their right to freedom of movement, peaceful assembly, opinion and expression.
C
11.5. Set aside plans to offer Bidoon people the "economic citizenship" of another country in exchange for a permanent residence permit in Kuwait.
E
11.6. Consider acceding to the 1954 Convention relating to the Status of Stateless Persons and to the 1961 Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness and having the related obligations implemented through the domestic law.
E
43.1. Ensure that the exercise of the right to peaceful assembly is not subject to restrictions other than the ones permissible under the Covenant.
 C
43.2. I nvestigate all allegations relating to the excessive use of force by security forces and ensure that the perpetrators are prosecuted and the victims adequately compensated.
C
43.3. I ncrease efforts to systematically provide training to all security forces on the use of force, especially in the context of demonstrations, taking due account of the Basic Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials.
B
54.1. Repeal or revise laws restricting the right to freedom of association to bring them into conformity with the Covenant.
C
54.2. clarify the vague, broad and open-ended definition of key terms in those laws and ensure that they are not used as tools to curtail freedom of association beyond the narrow restrictions permitted in article 22 (2) of the Covenant.
C
54.3. Ensure that civil society organizations can operate free of undue government influence and without fear of reprisals or unlawful restrictions on their operations.
B

The follow-up report is available here.
Namibia 
 
The Committee regretted that Namibia denied the existence of  discriminatory racial laws , and that no information was provided regarding the repeal of these laws (C). The State also denied the existence of  discrimination against LGBT persons. No measures have been taken to prohibit discrimination based on sexual orientation, or to adopt hate crime legislation (C). The Committee asked more information about the measures taken to combat  discrimination against persons with disabilities and HIV-positive persons (C). Also, no information was provided on  abolishing the crime of sodomy (C). 

The Committee welcomed the fact that a draft law criminalizing torture is in the process of being adopted, but required more information on its content and conformity with the Covenant (B). Some progress was achieved regarding the Internal Investigation Directorate of the police force, and the oversight mechanism of the Ombudsman, but the Committee required clarification as on whether these bodies operate independently, and on the status of specific cases of torture and ill-treatment (B).  However, no information was provided on measures taken to protect sex workers (C). 

No efforts were taken to implement the recommendation regarding awareness-raising of traditional leaders (C), or to investigate so-called "passion killings" (C). No information was provided regarding measures taken to increase the availability of magistrates in order to ensure access to justice (C), and to expand shelter facilities for domestic violence victims (C). The Committee also asked more information on how victims of rape or violence receive support, and whether a law will be adopted to allow sexual prosecutions to proceed even when victims withdraw their complaint (C).  However, some progress was achieved regarding the legislative measures enacted to  protect witnesses (B). 

Reviewed by the Human Rights Committee in March 2016
State replied on implementation measures: July 2018
Assessment of the State reply by the Human Rights Committee: August 2019
Recommendations
Grade
10.1. Repeal all laws that discriminate on the basis of race and finalize and adopt legislation on intestate succession so as to apply the same rules to all persons without discrimination.
C
10.2. Adopt legislation explicitly prohibiting discrimination based on sexual orientation, including in the Labour Act, and adopt hate crime legislation punishing homophobic and transphobic violence and vigorously enforce it.
C
10.3.  Abolish the common law crime of sodomy and include same-sex relationships in the Combating of Domestic Violence Act (Act No. 4 of 2003) so as to protect same-sex partners.
C
10.4.  Intensify efforts to combat discrimination against persons with disabilities and against persons who are HIV-positive, and ensure their full integration into all spheres of public life.
C
22.1. Ensure that perpetrators of torture and ill-treatment are identified, prosecuted and tried before ordinary courts, and, if found guilty, punished and victims adequately compensated.
B
22.2. Ensure that all cases of torture and ill-treatment are properly investigated by an independent mechanism.
B
22.3. Ensure that sex workers can report crimes without risking being prosecuted for their occupation and that they can participate in opt-out schemes.
C
24.1. Adopt and implement awareness-raising policies and public education programmes involving and targeted at traditional leaders and the public at large, to make gender-based violence socially unacceptable, as well as train traditional leaders on the elimination of gender-based violence.
C
24.2. Systematically undertake prompt, impartial and effective investigations to identify the perpetrators of so-called "passion killings", to prosecute them and, if they are found guilty, to punish them.
C
24.3. Dismantle all legal and practical barriers to prosecuting and punishing perpetrators of domestic violence and to implementing the Combating of Domestic Violence Act (Act No. 4 of 2003) including by increasing the availability of magistrates and other authorities to issue protection orders and ensure access to justice on a 24-hour daily basis.
C
24.4. Fully operationalize and expand shelter facilities for domestic violence victims across the State and ensure that all victims of violence have effective recourse to shelter, as well as to psychosocial counselling and compensation.
C
24.5. Protect victims of violence, including of rape and sexual harassment, from stigmatization as well as from reprisals, and adopt legislation on witness protection.
B
24.6. Ensure that police, prosecutors and judges are adequately trained in addressing issues of gender-based violence, that victims of rape and other such violence receive appropriate support, counselling and compensation, and are protected from stigmatization and reprisals. Adopt pending legislation that would allow sexual violence prosecutions to proceed if the victim withdraws the complaint, to ensure that perpetrators are prosecuted and punished.
C
 
The follow-up report is available here.
South Africa 

Some progress was achieved regarding the implementation of the recommendations of the  Truth and Reconciliation Commission , but the Committee required more information on the number of victims who received reparation and on the status of the investigations into serious human rights violations (B). 

The Committee noted the draft bill on prevention and combating of  hate crimes and hate speech , but required more information about its content and conformity with the Covenant (B). However, the Committee reiterated its recommendations regarding measures to prevent and eradicate  racism and xenophobia (C). 

Some progress was achieved regarding  detention conditions : a review of the legislative and policy framework was initiated in 2016, measures were taken to reduce overcrowding and to abolish arrest quotas by police. More information was required on bail requirements, the prison population in Pollsmoor Remand Detention Facility and the use of solitary confinement (3xB). 

Reviewed by the Human Rights Committee in March 2016
State replied on implementation measures: May 2017
Assessment of the State reply by the Human Rights Committee: March 2019
Recommendations
Grade
13. Increase efforts to implement the recommendations of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, investigate cases of serious human rights violations documented by the Commission, including those involving enforced disappearance, prosecute and punish perpetrators, and provide adequate reparation to all victims.
B
15.1. Redouble efforts to prevent and eradicate all manifestations of racism and xenophobia, protect all communities in South Africa against racist and xenophobic attacks, and improve policing responses to violence against non-nationals. Effective investigations into alleged racist and xenophobic attacks and other hate crimes should be conducted systematically, perpetrators should be prosecuted and, if convicted, punished with appropriate sanctions, and victims should be provided with adequate remedies. 
C
15.2. Pass appropriate legislation explicitly prohibiting hate crimes and hate speech as soon as possible.
B
31.1. Reduce overcrowding, particularly by promoting alternatives to detention, the loosening of bail requirements, revising arrest quotas as indicators of police performance, and by ensuring that bail determinations are made promptly and that persons on remand are not kept in custody for an unreasonable period of time. 
B
31.2. Increase efforts to guarantee the right of detainees to be treated with humanity and dignity and ensure that conditions of detention in all of the country's prisons, including those operated by private contractors, are compatible with the United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners (the Nelson Mandela Rules).
B
31.3. Ensure that de facto solitary confinement measures, including segregation, are used only in the most exceptional circumstances and for strictly limited short periods of time.
B

The follow-up report is available here. 
Sweden 

Sweden fully implemented the recommendations regarding  racism and xenophobia , through awareness-raising, research and training. A national contact point was established to respond to hate crimes, and police regions now have specific hate crime units (A). 

Sweden also made some progress regarding sufficient guarantees for migrants and asylum seekers. However, the legal regime applicable to "security cases" and "qualified security cases" remained unchanged, as well as the application of the principle of non-refoulement (B). 

Lastly, no progress was achieved regarding the detention of migrants and asylum seekers (C).

Reviewed by the Human Rights Committee in March 2016
State replied on implementation measures: April 2017
Assessment of the State reply by the Human Rights Committee: March 2019
Recommendations
Grade
17.1. Redouble efforts to combat hate speech, including on the Internet, racist and xenophobic violence against and negative stereotyping and portrayal of ethnic or religious minorities. Institute new awareness-raising campaigns aimed at promoting respect for human rights and tolerance for diversity and targeted at revisiting and eradicating stereotypes towards different ethnic or religious minorities.
A
17.2. Effectively implement the legal and policy frameworks to counter all manifestations of racism, hatred and xenophobia, including by thoroughly investigating such cases, prosecuting suspected perpetrators where appropriate and, if they are convicted, punishing them and providing victims with adequate remedies.
A
33.1. Ensure that policies and practices related to the return and expulsion of migrants and asylum seekers afford sufficient guarantees of respect for the principle of non-refoulement, in particular for those covered by the new temporary adjustments to the asylum legislation that are currently being drafted, and for those designated as "security cases" or "qualified security cases".
B
33.2. Ensure that the detention of migrants and asylum seekers is a measure of last resort and for the shortest period of time, is necessary and proportionate in the light of the circumstances, and that alternatives to detention are resorted to in practice. 
C

The follow-up report is available here.
Turkmenistan 
 
The Committee regretted that no information was provided on the practice of secret detention and enforced disappearances (C), the measures taken to disclose the fate or whereabouts of forcibly disappeared persons (C) and on investigations into these cases (C). 

The Committee also gave 4 C-grades concerning torture and ill-treatment: no information was provided on the measures taken to ensure that evidence procured by torture is inadmissible in court, on the trainings provided to law enforcement personnel, on the complaint mechanism for prisoners, and on investigations by an independent body. 

Lastly, regarding detention conditions, the Committee regretted the lack of recent information about visits by international delegations to detention institutions (C), about overcrowding and the measures taken to reduce it (C) and the availability of an effective complaint mechanism (C). The only area in which Turkmenistan made (little) progress, is on the purchase of medical equipment for prisons, even though the Committee regretted that no further information was provided (B). 
 
Reviewed by the Human Rights Committee in March 2017
State replied on implementation measures: July 2018
Assessment of the State reply by the Human Rights Committee: August 2019
Recommendations
Grade
17.1. End the practice of secret detention and enforced disappearances.
C
17.2.  Disclose the fate or the whereabouts of forcibly disappeared persons and allow all detained persons visits from their families and confidential access to their lawyers.
C
17.3.  Ensure that all reported cases of enforced disappearance are promptly, thoroughly and impartially investigated, that perpetrators are brought to justice and punished with appropriate sanctions, and that victims and their relatives are informed about the outcome of the investigation and are provided with full reparation.
C
21.1. Ensure that the prohibitions of forced confessions and the inadmissibility of evidence procured by torture are effectively enforced in practice by law enforcement officers and judges.
C
21.2. Provide adequate training on torture prevention and humane treatment to law enforcement personnel.
C
21.3. Implement an accessible and effective complaint mechanism against torture.
C
21.4. Ensure that all allegations of torture and other ill-treatment, hazing and deaths in custody are reported and promptly and thoroughly investigated by an independent and impartial body, that perpetrators are prosecuted and, if convicted, are punished with sanctions consistent with the severity of the crime, and that victims and, where appropriate, their families have both in law and in practice access to full reparation, including rehabilitation and adequate compensation.
C
23.1. Take measures to establish a system of regular and independent monitoring of places of detention without prior notice and create the conditions necessary to facilitate effective monitoring by independent organizations and reinforce its efforts to grant meaningful access to places of detention to the International Committee of the Red Cross.
C
23.2. Take effective measures to eliminate overcrowding in places of detention, including by resorting to non-custodial alternative measures to detention.
C
23.3. Ensure that persons deprived of liberty are treated with humanity and respect for the inherent dignity of the human person and redouble efforts to improve conditions of detention in accordance with the Covenant and the United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners (the Nelson Mandela Rules).
B
23.4. Ensure the availability of an effective complaint mechanism, investigate violations of inmates' rights promptly and thoroughly, bring perpetrators to justice with appropriate penalties, and provide effective remedies and full reparation to victims, including adequate compensation.
C
 
The follow-up report is available here. 
Engaging with the Human Rights Committee 
The   127th session of the Human Rights Committee will take place in Geneva, Palais Wilson, from 14 October to 8 November 2019. It will review the State reports of  Belgium, Cabo Verde, Central African Republic, Czech Republic, Mexico and Senegal.  The Lists of Issues (Prior to Reporting) of Bolivia, Nicaragua, Ukraine, Afghanistan, Croatia and Spain  will be adopted. 

The  deadline  for NGO reports on Lists of Issues is 30 August 2019. 
The  deadline  for NGO reports on State reviews is 16 September 2019. 
The  deadline  to register to attend the session is 4 October 2019. 

For   more information  on engaging with the Human Rights Committee, please visit our   website.