ISCA Weekly Chair Post
Red leather chairs in a conference room

December 4, 2025




Birthrates on the Decline


This may not come as a surprise, but having foresight—and engaging in thoughtful board discussion—about the long-term implications of birthrate trends is an essential governance responsibility. In March 2025, the CDC reported that the U.S. birthrate declined by 14% between 1990 and 2023. Even over a much shorter window, from 2018 to 2023, births declined by approximately 5.2%.

After a brief increase during the COVID years, birthrates have resumed their downward trend. What does this mean for independent schools? While these figures reflect national patterns, it is essential to examine birthrates within your own state or region, as variations can be significant. Some areas may experience double-digit declines due to domestic migration, while others may see modest growth.

Boards should be discussing the implications of a shrinking—or expanding—pool of prospective students and how these trends may affect long-term enrollment.


Notably, the births from 2018 to 2023 correspond to kindergarten classes entering schools from 2023 through 2028. A 5.2% decline nationally often manifests as:

  • 6–10% decline in K enrollment in many regions
  • Even sharper declines in rural and suburban markets


Given the potential for a smaller pool of eligible students to enroll in independent schools, boards should be discussing:

A smaller pipeline of future students
Increased competition for student enrollment
Widening geographic variations in birthrates due to domestic migration

Strategic financial planning for decreased revenue


The longer term impact of declining enrollment should prompt boards and administration to do scenario planning exercises that might include options like: 
Consolidating sections

Rethinking class sizes

Repurposing physical spaces

Adjusting faculty hiring

Exploring program sharing or partnerships


Similarly, if you are in an area of the country seeing population growth, your scenario planning should involve expansion capability.

Data is only meaningful when it informs a larger purpose—such as planning to safeguard your school’s future.


For the original CDC report on birthrates Click Here




Upcoming Programs


TODAY!!

Board Level or Not? A New Framework from ISCA for Board Chairs and Heads

December 4, 2025

3:00 - 4:00 pm ET


Navigating the Federal Landscape: Legal Hot Topics for School Governance

December 11, 2025

1:00 - 2:00 pm ET


Strategies for Attracting and Vetting the Right Trustees for Your Board

January 7, 2026

1:00 - 2:00 pm ET




Need to chat with an ISCA Peer Advisor for guidance or support?



Click Here


Weekly Chair Post written and compiled by
Bethany Di Napoli, ISCA Executive Director

Connect with us

287 Gibbs Ave, Newport, RI 02840 | bethany@iscachairs.org | 401-216-8079 | www.iscachairs.org