West Texas District Church of the Nazarene 

Insurance Brokers Contact Information 

 

Dear Pastor Friends: 

 

In response to several churches across our district experiencing insurance coverage challenges, we are happy to provide the following list of insurance brokers who have provided some assistance to our churches.  We are not endorsing any of these companies but are providing this list so that you have some contact information as a starting point to request quotes for new insurance. 


We acknowledge that some churches are experiencing renewal rates that are double or triple the previous costs.  To minimize this impact, we do recommend that you try to increase the deductibles in order to lower the premiums to a more manageable level. 


Just as we would never drive a car without insurance coverage in place, it is highly inadvisable to hold ministry events in a building without insurance.  

 

Often the property insurance is covered along with liability coverage and therefore, we must not allow the coverage to lapse. 



We are praying for you and with you as we overcome this hurdle together.  If you find another insurance company that would be helpful to share with others, please let us know so that we can add their information to this list. 

 

Respectfully, 

 

West Texas District Office 


Insurance Help 

 

MGT Insurance 

(800) 554-2642 x6076 

Mgtinsurance.com 

 

Zachary Mize (Broker) 

Broker Company: American Church Group 

zmize@americanchurchgroup.com 

844-400-2248 (ext 355) 

http://www.americanchurchgroup-texas.com 

 

Tammy Klontz (Broker) 

Broker Company: Farmers Insurance (Whitney, TX) 

tcallawayins@gmail.com  

(254)- 694-2260 

Sherry Hermann (Broker) 

Broker Company: Sierra Agency 

sierraagency@hotmail.com 

(940)382-3342